Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To complain about teacher's behaviour

665 replies

Ilovechocolate87 · 18/11/2023 14:52

Last night after tea, DD (6) said to younger DD (2) 'Don't you dare do that' (touch her food) in a menacing voice.It isn't something we would say, as I think it's a nasty way to speak to someone, so i asked her where she got it from, to which she replied that her teacher had shouted at a boy in her class (year 1) 'don't you dare interuppt me when I'm talking' and re-inacted it in a thunderous sort of voice.

If she was telling me the teacher was saying such things to her I would be in no doubt to complain, as its clearly threatening behaviour, but as it wasn't at her (and she confirms she has never shouted at her) I'm on the fence whether to say anything or not about it .I've re-iterated to DD not to speak to her little sister like that, explaining that even if the teacher did it, it is still wrong.She told me when I asked that it doesn't scare her when the teacher shouts (she has very sensitive hearing and is often scared if we shout at home) but i'm not really liking that she is seeing someone who should be a professional and a role model behaving in that way towards any child.

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 19/11/2023 12:31

Sherrystrull · 19/11/2023 12:15

What a horrific and offensive post. You clearly have a chip on your shoulder about teachers.

She evidently does.

moptophairshop · 19/11/2023 12:31

There is evidence of posters saying they have left the teaching profession because they could not cope with parents' comments, yes. There is no evidence they were or are capable teachers though.

Just to be crystal clear, are you suggesting that teachers like myself are leaving simply because we can't cope with a couple of comments? I've been called a 'fucking disgrace' in front of my class and parents for letting a child out with their coat unzipped at the end of the day (child was 7 and had been told to zip their coat up), I've had to sit in a meeting and justify why I had reprimanded a child for snapping all the pencils on their table. Parents have free reign to say whatever they like, sometimes loudly, in the playground but teachers are not able to say anything.

I'm not going to dignify the second part of your unpleasant comment with a response, but thanks for showing others an example of the casual disrespect we have to deal with.

greengreengrass25 · 19/11/2023 12:29

Yes it's really unhelpful and unnecessary

Cloud cuckoo land

Sherrystrull · 19/11/2023 12:15

Repurposing · 19/11/2023 11:12

There is evidence of posters saying they have left the teaching profession because they could not cope with parents' comments, yes. There is no evidence they were or are capable teachers though.

Teaching is just one of many professions that are accountable to families for their work. Good organisations welcome questions and reflect on feedback and are dynamic, they seek to reassure families and don't blame the children and families for failings in their profession. Imagine if the NHS and Social Services did that ! Attacking parents who just want some support and reassurance and using their past struggles against them is bullying, and it reflects badly on the posters, not the OP. Everyone knows this is true.

What a horrific and offensive post. You clearly have a chip on your shoulder about teachers.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 19/11/2023 12:07

It's almost as if some parents instantly forget what school and school children are like as soon as they have a child, even though they went to school themselves and knew perfectly well at the time that a) children quite often misbehave, lie and exaggerate b) it is not always possible to get them to behave themselves by saying sweetly 'Now everybody, let's all use our indoor voices and be kind, shall we?'

They also seem to be bizarrely unaware that their child will benefit from being in a class where the teacher has good classroom control. But they are often the first to complain when the behaviour of other children is not controlled. And yet also when the behaviour of their child is controlled.

viques · 19/11/2023 11:57

Ilovechocolate87 · 18/11/2023 16:29

I would never complain about something like that....you didn't do anything wrong.

The point of the story is not that @TwinkleTwinkleTwinkleTwinkle did anything wrong, because she didn’t. The point that you seem to have missed is that a child went home, reported the story in their own words and the immediate parental knee jerk response was to send a three paragraph email to the head teacher which was so unpleasant that Twinkle had to be talked down from resigning. And in the end chose not to continue at that school.

School isn’t Fightclub (what happens in fightclub stays in fightclub) , and it shouldn’t be, but it is a place where perceptions and reports to parents by children of what happens in a classroom is often tempered by the age of the reporters, their limited vocabulary, their specific viewpoint, their misreading of a situation, their unwillingness to accept responsibility for their behaviour, or to recognise that their behaviour has sequentially contributed to an event. You might not like that, but it is true,

Not all teachers are wonderful and professional, though the vast majority are, and by the same token not all children are angels, though the vast majority have the capability of being delightful. All need to be held accountable for their actions, but as in any situation both sides need a voice to be heard.

zingally · 19/11/2023 11:57

You're being way too over-sensitive.

Imagine you had 30 kids that age to control. Someone needs to be the authority figure, and sometimes, with that many people (with all sorts of baggage and differences to consider), sometimes a bit more force is required. Imagine if all 30 of those people rebelled at once? It would be carnage. The person at the front needs to be fairly authoritarian to prevent that happening. And if that means being a bit loud and scary occasionally, then so be it.

Your DD said herself, she wasn't scared.

I'd be sitting with the knowledge that she finds the shouting in her own home more scary.

Spidersfreakmeout · 19/11/2023 11:27

I agree @WinterWaffle its crazy that she just wasn’t willing to listen. She described the teacher as ‘guilty’ of threatening a child (from a commentary from her 6 year old). She was told she was wrong. I’ve seen many MANY of these threads and the simple fact of AIBU is about the possibility your thinking maybe challenged. I’ve seen many accept the outcome of the poll and move on. But she continued to argue and become very verbally angry when it wasn’t going her way which led to more people trying to get her to see sense. 95% have sent a clear message. I’d argue as nearly one and a half thousand people voted the vast majority of those are parents and not teachers, who are aware of what might happen if this complaint culture is allowed to go out of check and aware there is no complaint to be made here.

ilovesooty · 19/11/2023 11:27

because they could not cope with parents' comments

Nice bit of victim blaming there. And your disbelief in their capability and effectively accusing those teachers of lying is hugely insulting.

WinterWaffle · 19/11/2023 11:24

moptophairshop · 19/11/2023 11:10

I am a very capable teacher with a proven track record over many years. I love working with children and am especially passionate about supporting children with SEND in mainstream. However, I am leaving directly as a result of the abuse and aggression I have received from parents over the last year. My mental health is in tatters and I'm not going to stay in a role that leaves you so vulnerable to abuse.

Dismiss this evidence all you like, but there's already several of us on here saying the same thing and I know more and more of my colleagues are close to breaking point.

It’s a shame there can’t be a two-tier system in schools - parents choose if they want a teacher who will tell their children off when needed and won’t stand for any nonsense or one who will do the ‘gentle’ teaching. It would also be interesting to see the kids’ outcomes at the end of it all.

Pussycat22 · 19/11/2023 11:24

For God's sake !!! And then they wonder whyt today's kids think they can do as they like!!!

EstEstEst · 19/11/2023 11:20

Repurposing · 19/11/2023 11:12

There is evidence of posters saying they have left the teaching profession because they could not cope with parents' comments, yes. There is no evidence they were or are capable teachers though.

Teaching is just one of many professions that are accountable to families for their work. Good organisations welcome questions and reflect on feedback and are dynamic, they seek to reassure families and don't blame the children and families for failings in their profession. Imagine if the NHS and Social Services did that ! Attacking parents who just want some support and reassurance and using their past struggles against them is bullying, and it reflects badly on the posters, not the OP. Everyone knows this is true.

Are you actually intimating that teachers on this thread who have left the profession or that are thinking of leaving are not capable? Seriously? You’re even more deluded than @Ilovechocolate87

PatsyStonesBeehive · 19/11/2023 11:18

Funnily enough, the other day I sternly said "Don't you dare even think about doing that" to my 5 year old, who I could see was stealthily getting ready to push one of our cats off the sofa so that he could lie down. He then got a 5 minute lecture on how precious the cats are, we never hurt them and they are to be left in peace!

If you're wanting to have a word with someone...try a therapist.

WinterWaffle · 19/11/2023 11:16

The thing is there wouldn’t have been so many ‘negative’ replies had OP agreed that she was in the wrong in the first few pages.

”Am I wrong to complain about what a teacher may have said to a child that isn’t my child and I wasn’t there?”
”yes you are wrong, teachers have enough on their plates and you don’t know what happened anyway as you weren’t there”

The end.

But OP would not admit she is wrong even thought 95% disagreed with her. She dug her heels in further and further and then all her past posts cropped up about the poor cat and her child being frightened in her own house etc etc. and her not being such a perfect parent.

Now she’s flounced because she didn’t like the truth. Oh well, never mind.

Repurposing · 19/11/2023 11:12

There is evidence of posters saying they have left the teaching profession because they could not cope with parents' comments, yes. There is no evidence they were or are capable teachers though.

Teaching is just one of many professions that are accountable to families for their work. Good organisations welcome questions and reflect on feedback and are dynamic, they seek to reassure families and don't blame the children and families for failings in their profession. Imagine if the NHS and Social Services did that ! Attacking parents who just want some support and reassurance and using their past struggles against them is bullying, and it reflects badly on the posters, not the OP. Everyone knows this is true.

moptophairshop · 19/11/2023 11:10

Repurposing · 19/11/2023 10:29

ilovesnooty - I have no evidence that capable teachers are leaving the profession because of parents comments. What I do have evidence of is defensive behaviour and horrid bullying right here on this thread, some of it from teachers.

What do you think that tells people?

I am a very capable teacher with a proven track record over many years. I love working with children and am especially passionate about supporting children with SEND in mainstream. However, I am leaving directly as a result of the abuse and aggression I have received from parents over the last year. My mental health is in tatters and I'm not going to stay in a role that leaves you so vulnerable to abuse.

Dismiss this evidence all you like, but there's already several of us on here saying the same thing and I know more and more of my colleagues are close to breaking point.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 19/11/2023 11:05

Ilovechocolate87 · 19/11/2023 06:59

Thanks @Repurposing for all the support...I have said all i can to defend myself and explain, but even though i'm not in denial about my own mistakes and flaws, some people will clearly never be convinced that I am not all the awful things I've been called on this thread, and like you say it's only going to make me feel worse and worse reading it all, plus the more I respond the more active this thread will remain.

Time to all move on to bullying the next unsuspecting poster now please!!

I am leaving this thread and deleting my account now, to escape the unnecessary nastiness which seems so rife on here, and focus on parenting my lovely children in the real world, which most of the time I do pretty bloody well.
I don't need an online forum trying to tell me otherwise.

Ah a good old flounce and storm off!

One of my posts before was actually semi agreeing with you and being sympathetic with the pile on, but after this, it really seems like you’ve not learned much apart from, no, you probably aren’t going to complain about this teacher.

Interesting you worked in a nursery. From my interactions with nursery staff, nursery children can be different (maybe not!) to school aged children. I also know that children over exaggerate, copy, lie about things which they see or hear.

JMSA · 19/11/2023 11:02

You're ridiculous. Hope that helps.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 19/11/2023 11:01

ilovesnooty - I have no evidence that capable teachers are leaving the profession because of parents comments.

Vexatious parental complaints, as well as parents backing up their child in spite of clear evidence of wrongdoing, and refusing to cooperate with perfectly reasonable school sanction policies, are part of what is driving teachers out of the profession. Do you honestly doubt that?

As far as teachers being driven out by individual complaints goes... that happens a lot too. A child maliciously and falsely complains about a teacher,or at least wildly exaggerates (usually to get themselves out of trouble, or just because they bear a grudge about something). Parents believe the child. School has to suspend the teacher while an investigation is made. The teacher is eventually found not to have done anything wrong, but the stress of the process, along with the knowledge that the students all know and will never stop spreading lies about it, makes it impossible for the teacher to stay in the school, or possibly in teaching.

I'm not even talking about very serious complaints like physical assault. This happened to someone I know well. The accusation by the (large, confident, robust, bullying) 16 year-old was that the teacher had made them 'feel unsafe in school' by shouting at them on one occasion. 5 years of tellings-off, occasional shouting, detentions etc had had no effect on this student or their behaviour. Teacher suspended for months while the school faffed around. The complaint was eventually not upheld, by which time the teacher had got another job (not in teaching). This was an effective, popular teacher (both with staff and students).

This kind of thing happens all the time. And yes, I know malicious complaints happen in other jobs too, but rarely on the say-so of children, on the basis of no initial evidence.

RedToothBrush · 19/11/2023 10:46

Repurposing · 19/11/2023 10:29

ilovesnooty - I have no evidence that capable teachers are leaving the profession because of parents comments. What I do have evidence of is defensive behaviour and horrid bullying right here on this thread, some of it from teachers.

What do you think that tells people?

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

Aside from that...

There are posters on this thread who have literally said that parents were the reason they left the profession and others have said that's one of the main reasons they are considering it.

...is that not evidence enough for you?

electriclight · 19/11/2023 10:44

Repurposing · 19/11/2023 10:29

ilovesnooty - I have no evidence that capable teachers are leaving the profession because of parents comments. What I do have evidence of is defensive behaviour and horrid bullying right here on this thread, some of it from teachers.

What do you think that tells people?

It's not bullying if op asks for opinions and gets them. On AIBU people know they'll get unvarnished, honest opinion - that's the point. It's also easy to escape any perceived bullying by logging off or hiding the thread.

Unlike teachers who are available to angry parents throughout the school day and particularly at the classroom door at drop off or pick up. Unlike other professionals, everyone thinks they can do our job, that it's ok to comment on how we do our job, that we must provide immediate responses and solutions, that we are not allowed to be human or make mistakes. Try turning up in your dentist's or doctor's surgery, or your solicitor's office, or anywhere else and demanding instant access or an immediate resolution to a perceived problem. I remember the push to involve parents in their children's education but now they think they run schools.

Spidersfreakmeout · 19/11/2023 10:41

No evidence, despite the number of teachers on here telling you they’ve left or leaving? The evidence is HERE, just like the evidence you cited for your side of the argument.

Also just a quick Google search and you’ll find the evidence. The Guardian ran an article on it recently. The DfE have raised concerns about it (they recognise that this is an issue) after the case of the teacher who was taken to the Teacher Regulation Authority this year over an incident that hit the Sun newspaper. Parent had complained to the Sun before she’d even contacted the school.

Seaglass7 · 19/11/2023 10:41

No you shouldn’t complain, there are no grounds for doing so.

IMO I’d be more worried about the fact that you’ve been cruel to an animal, you’ve had anger issues, and work in a nursery environment. I certainly wouldn’t want someone like you looking after a baby/toddler.

There is NEVER any excuse for being cruel to an animal, shame on you!

unique78 · 19/11/2023 10:41

Well, OP says she's gone and will delete, so this post is probably pointless. However, when her DD potentially flunks her exams due to uncontrollable behaviour in the class hindering her learning, or potentially becomes one of the uncontrollable kids due to ineffective parenting/teaching, she may question her choices. And if her DD has kids, and a similar situation arises, she may hand her DD a grip. We can live in hope.

EstEstEst · 19/11/2023 10:35

Repurposing · 19/11/2023 10:29

ilovesnooty - I have no evidence that capable teachers are leaving the profession because of parents comments. What I do have evidence of is defensive behaviour and horrid bullying right here on this thread, some of it from teachers.

What do you think that tells people?

You have evidence now, I’m one that left education and there are many more posts on this thread from others that have left. You have absolutely no idea of the bullying teachers endure from parents and a lot of the time from SLT who are too scared to stand up to parents.