Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To complain about teacher's behaviour

665 replies

Ilovechocolate87 · 18/11/2023 14:52

Last night after tea, DD (6) said to younger DD (2) 'Don't you dare do that' (touch her food) in a menacing voice.It isn't something we would say, as I think it's a nasty way to speak to someone, so i asked her where she got it from, to which she replied that her teacher had shouted at a boy in her class (year 1) 'don't you dare interuppt me when I'm talking' and re-inacted it in a thunderous sort of voice.

If she was telling me the teacher was saying such things to her I would be in no doubt to complain, as its clearly threatening behaviour, but as it wasn't at her (and she confirms she has never shouted at her) I'm on the fence whether to say anything or not about it .I've re-iterated to DD not to speak to her little sister like that, explaining that even if the teacher did it, it is still wrong.She told me when I asked that it doesn't scare her when the teacher shouts (she has very sensitive hearing and is often scared if we shout at home) but i'm not really liking that she is seeing someone who should be a professional and a role model behaving in that way towards any child.

OP posts:
WearyAuldWumman · 18/11/2023 18:08

Spidersfreakmeout · 18/11/2023 17:59

Sad to read about the number of teachers who chose to leave after being at the back end of this parent power complaining nonsense.

Just to share…

A good few years ago a complaint was made about me. I won’t go into details but it was absolutely untrue, there wasn’t one word of truth in it. My headteacher at the time sat me down and told me to think really hard because some of the story ‘MUST’ be true, he was very aggressive, very much the customer is always right kind of head. I remember (younger than) crying and saying that it just wasn’t. I started to doubt my own sanity. It was a horrific two weeks with the head not speaking to me and the parent making loud noises on the playground.

Two weeks later the child admitted he’d made it ALL up. Every bit of it. His mum and the head laughed at how kids will be kids. No one apologised to me for the distress I was put under and the head had the nerve to say something on the lines of ‘I knew it wasn’t likely spiders, I know that’s not you’

I loathe this culture where professionals are guilty until proven innocent and parent whatsapp groups are formed to vilify a human being with home lives, children themselves and the stress of trying to teach a class without any support, rapidly rising numbers of challenging pupils and a number of SEND pupils. It’s not the same as the classrooms when you were children. It’s very VERY different and we’ve had to adjust fast and we don’t always get that right.

I am so sorry.

Had a colleague who was suspended after a 15 yr old boy accused him of assault. The boy had punched the teacher.

The teacher was cleared, but left the profession.

Ilovechocolate87 · 18/11/2023 18:08

EstEstEst · 18/11/2023 17:57

It makes you an animal abuser and there are some strong links to animal and child abuse.

Think whatever, but you don't know me, and calling me a child abuser because I had one angry moment and tapped my cat sharply on its bum for weeing on my daughters bed is a massive and grossly unfair stretch.My kids are happy, loving and completely loved.And they know it.

OP posts:
Lovemusic82 · 18/11/2023 18:07

I feel so sorry for teachers. The teacher shouted at a child, a child that was miss behaving, if teachers just sat back and talked in a soft voice all the time the kids would walk all over them. The world has gone crazy, can clearly see why there are so many out of control kids 😬.

Floppyelf · 18/11/2023 18:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Sheraprincessofflower · 18/11/2023 18:03

You are being ridiculous. This teacher has done nothing wrong. What she said was not threatening even if she did shout it. Occasionally as a teacher you need to be very very firm.

Also, consider that your child may be exaggerating (although the teacher is still not in the wrong even if she isn’t exaggerating). I used to be a teacher and was k own for my kind and quiet manner with the class, lots of fun, gentle interactions etc. The class nearly always responded really well to my positive manner. However, one day they were being horrors and I had to stop the lesson, sit them all on the carpet and explain very firmly that this behaviour must stop now and that I was extremely disappointed. I said this in a very quiet but firm voice. Later that day, one of the children came up to me and said “I didn’t like it when you shouted at us.” I hadn’t shouted - I had used a very quiet voice but had been firm and noticably not pleased with them. This child had interpreted any telling off as “shouting” and she hadn’t liked it because it was so rare that I have them a bollocking. This was year 3. Children often interpret somebody being told to stop doing something as “shouting” even if it isn’t.

(also, it worked - they were back to normal for the rest of the day).

JudgeJ · 18/11/2023 18:02

Please don't help.nurture princess and prince syndrome where children think no one is allowed to raise their voice to them.

This is the problem, teachers are having to deal with children who have never been told off, they, the children, are the victims of much of the modern way of 'parenting' by parents who have given them the idea that they're the centre of the universe, there have even been fools on here claiming that a baby should be asked to consent to a nappy change! In a school your child is simply one of many and will need to learn to accept discipline even if they don't get any at home.

Spidersfreakmeout · 18/11/2023 17:59

Sad to read about the number of teachers who chose to leave after being at the back end of this parent power complaining nonsense.

Just to share…

A good few years ago a complaint was made about me. I won’t go into details but it was absolutely untrue, there wasn’t one word of truth in it. My headteacher at the time sat me down and told me to think really hard because some of the story ‘MUST’ be true, he was very aggressive, very much the customer is always right kind of head. I remember (younger than) crying and saying that it just wasn’t. I started to doubt my own sanity. It was a horrific two weeks with the head not speaking to me and the parent making loud noises on the playground.

Two weeks later the child admitted he’d made it ALL up. Every bit of it. His mum and the head laughed at how kids will be kids. No one apologised to me for the distress I was put under and the head had the nerve to say something on the lines of ‘I knew it wasn’t likely spiders, I know that’s not you’

I loathe this culture where professionals are guilty until proven innocent and parent whatsapp groups are formed to vilify a human being with home lives, children themselves and the stress of trying to teach a class without any support, rapidly rising numbers of challenging pupils and a number of SEND pupils. It’s not the same as the classrooms when you were children. It’s very VERY different and we’ve had to adjust fast and we don’t always get that right.

EstEstEst · 18/11/2023 17:57

Ilovechocolate87 · 18/11/2023 17:38

Fine, but hitting a cat doesn't make me a bad parent or a child abuser.

It made me a bad pet owner.

It makes you an animal abuser and there are some strong links to animal and child abuse.

AnneValentine · 18/11/2023 17:54

Ilovechocolate87 · 18/11/2023 17:38

Fine, but hitting a cat doesn't make me a bad parent or a child abuser.

It made me a bad pet owner.

You’re a total hypocrit.

PeaceGoodMercutio · 18/11/2023 17:53

What are you trying to suggest?
That the teacher was going to hit the boy if he did "dare" to interrupt her?

Children shouldn't interrupt their teachers.
If I received a complain about that statement I would be writing a strongly worded letter telling you how I value and trust my staff and their decisions within their classrooms.

Differentstarts · 18/11/2023 17:53

It sounds like your daughter is scared of you and doesn't feel safe in her own home so can't be completely honest with you when you asked her why she said what she said. I'm so glad she feels safe at school and doesn't get scared there. You and your partner really need to sort your shit out so that your daughter doesn't have to grow up feeling scared in her own home.

Soontobe60 · 18/11/2023 17:53

Ilovechocolate87 · 18/11/2023 15:14

Its not just the shouting, it's what she said, and I've worked in a nursery for many years so know managing lots of kids is tough at times, but if people can't do the job without getting angry and threatening the kids, they should be in a different career tbh.

You could say the same about parents who shout enough to scare their children though.

TwinkleTwinkleTwinkleTwinkle · 18/11/2023 17:52

Jifmicroliquid · 18/11/2023 17:42

Teachers are leaving the profession in droves.
12.8% of new teachers leave after the first year.
By the end of the fourth year of teaching, a third of teachers have left.
They cannot fill teacher positions in schools and they are struggling to recruit trainees.

There are lots of reasons for this, but children’s behaviour and lack of parental support on the whole is a definitely a contributing factor.

You only have to come on here to see one or two posts a day where a parent is slating a teacher.
Perhaps if teachers are so dreadful at their jobs, you’d like to home school your little angels instead? Or maybe you could put your money where your mouth is and join the profession and show all these mean and awful teachers just how it should be done?
How about you stand at the front of a class and keep the attention of 32 children, when 7 of them have SEN and you have no TA. How about you see how you deal with constant disruptive behaviour, knowing that if you say anything too ‘harsh’, or dole out a fitting punishment, the little cherub’s parent (or perhaps a random parent whose child was nothing to do with it!) is going to put a complaint in against you.

I have no regrets in leaving the profession and you couldn’t pay me enough money to go back.
It’s not teachers failing children, it’s parents.

I think for me, you COULD pay me enough.

I see threads on here daily of people earning over 100k. I earned £28k, leaving after ten years qualified, five years ago. (The school had no payscale as such).

I would go back tomorrow for £100k.

CharingX976 · 18/11/2023 17:51

Even if the teacher was a bit "menacing" in their tone, it'll do the children good to learn that there are a variety of personalities they're going to have to come up against in the world. Everyone has different ways of asserting their authority. Being more domineering might be wrong in your eyes, but it's just fact that that's how some people in authority behave so they need to get used to it. I was never shouted at as a child and as a result I am so sensitive and cannot cope when anyone is angry or raises their voice. I wish my parents had been less gentle with me.

WearyAuldWumman · 18/11/2023 17:50

TwinkleTwinkleTwinkleTwinkle · 18/11/2023 16:07

When I was a teacher, and pregnant, I had a sudden wave of nausea. I had to run out of the room blurting a quick - and garbled- , "sorry kids back in a min" to go and be sick.

The parent of the most disruptive kid in the class (adjective not strictly relevant, sorry) sent a three paragraph email to the head, which I have tried to block out, but I do remember it containing phrases like "what sort of flakey teachers are you employing?!"

I received a copy of the email one evening at 11pm. I didn't sleep that night, was in floods of tears, was a wreck the next day, and resigned. Only because the head talked me down did I stay. But I didn't go back at the end of mat leave. That was because of a parent. Overreaction maybe, but I think it was the fact that I could make very little complaint about the behaviour of that kid, yet I was under such scrutiny.

Pretty outing, but it needs to be said.

Had a parent complain about my absence. I was organising my mum's funeral. (I'm an only child.) Including the day of the funeral, I had 5 days' compassionate leave and I'd organised work for my classes.

Blackandwhitemakesgrey · 18/11/2023 17:50

Its been my experience (to date) that most teachers shout. I suppose they have to at times but agree there is a difference between being loud and being menacing. My own child had a teacher who shouted a lot last year. It was a daily occurrence. However in other ways, the teacher was amazing. She was very good at explaining/teaching (not all teachers are) and was very encouraging and motivating.

However the year before the same child had a teacher who was quite plainly a mean adult who spoke menacingly to the kids and stared straight into their faces. My child hated that teacher and was frightened of her. On one occasion, the children made Christmas cards for the teacher and in front of them, she balled them up and threw them into the bin without reading the cards.

When it came to the end of the year, the kids didn't make her cards or bring in kids like they had previously done.

The very sad thing was that she was a young teacher (24/25 at most) and she was plainly not cut out for the job. I dread to think what she will be like in another ten years and can only hope she recognises that teaching is not for her and quits.

Shouting, while not great isn't as bad as being frightening. Kids cannot learn in that atmosphere and definitely keep an eye on it and ask to meet with the school if necessary. My child's end of year results were far below what was previously achieved but thankfully went back to being an A student the following year with another teacher.

neverbeenskiing · 18/11/2023 17:49

But I would expect a teacher to have more patience and emotional regulation than a frazzled parent rushing around at the end of their tether.If they don't maybe they should be in a different career.

Teachers are not robots. They have good days and bad days, they experience stress and they make mistakes just like everyone else.

I have a child with SEND who is upset by shouting. She also can't read social cues so in the past if a Teacher has shouted anywhere near her, she has assumed they were shouting at her.

I would never go running to the HT to complain about a Teacher raising their voice unless they said something genuinely offensive or inappropriate. Instead, I explain to my DD that adults have big emotions too and sometimes this means they might shout, just like she sometimes shouts when she's overwhelmed or frustrated. I have also explained that sometimes Teachers have to shout to get children's attention when there are 30 children in a class and its getting a bit loud. She understands this, because we've helped her to understand it, and she is now more able to rationalise that unless the Teacher uses her name or is looking directly at her, it's unlikely they are shouting at her.

OhDeniseReally · 18/11/2023 17:47

Dear me! I imagine you would possibly be one of the first parents to complain if your child's learning is hampered by the behaviour of another student in the class. Also, working in a nursery is not the same as teaching a class of 30 students, all of whom have challenging targets to meet..

porridgeisbae · 18/11/2023 17:46

The maths teacher used to throw the board rubber at me :) Well, my desk.

VickyEadieofThigh · 18/11/2023 17:45

creditdraper · 18/11/2023 17:43

OP
You just don’t get it do you? You sound so entitled.
It’s parents like you who can ruin a perfectly decent teacher’s career.

Correct. A ridiculous parental complaint like this might be just the thing to drive an overworked, underappreciated teacher to resign.

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 18/11/2023 17:45

Hitting a cat made you an animal abuser. Reading that honestly made me feel ill. Abusing animals is as gross as abusing children.

My ds has never been scared of me. He has complex special needs and used to regularly attack me.

i have gotten frustrated at times, but never scared him. Never screamed at him. I am his safe place.

I don't think having your kids be scared of you is ever a good thing.

He is also really polite and well behaved with others and at school ( although school refusal is a thing ), I have never had to scare him.

And " don't you dare " is not threatening language. Why do you think it is?

sensationalsally · 18/11/2023 17:45

"She masks a lot at school" - this is known as social behaviour. You should be glad that a) she is learning to get on in a social environment in an acceptable way b) she is comfortable enough at home to let go and relax into her "family" self.

creditdraper · 18/11/2023 17:43

OP
You just don’t get it do you? You sound so entitled.
It’s parents like you who can ruin a perfectly decent teacher’s career.

laclochette · 18/11/2023 17:43

I would see this as a good opportunity for your child to learn that whether things are ok or not depends on context.

When a teacher, who has a disciplinary role, a position of authority etc, says something, it's different from if we say it to our friends and family. That's a very important element of socialisation - for a child to learn that the exact same thing, said in the exact same way, can be ok in one context but not ok in another.

So I'd just say something like, we don't speak to each other here the way our teachers speak to us because when we're at home with our family, it's different to being at school.

Jifmicroliquid · 18/11/2023 17:42

Teachers are leaving the profession in droves.
12.8% of new teachers leave after the first year.
By the end of the fourth year of teaching, a third of teachers have left.
They cannot fill teacher positions in schools and they are struggling to recruit trainees.

There are lots of reasons for this, but children’s behaviour and lack of parental support on the whole is a definitely a contributing factor.

You only have to come on here to see one or two posts a day where a parent is slating a teacher.
Perhaps if teachers are so dreadful at their jobs, you’d like to home school your little angels instead? Or maybe you could put your money where your mouth is and join the profession and show all these mean and awful teachers just how it should be done?
How about you stand at the front of a class and keep the attention of 32 children, when 7 of them have SEN and you have no TA. How about you see how you deal with constant disruptive behaviour, knowing that if you say anything too ‘harsh’, or dole out a fitting punishment, the little cherub’s parent (or perhaps a random parent whose child was nothing to do with it!) is going to put a complaint in against you.

I have no regrets in leaving the profession and you couldn’t pay me enough money to go back.
It’s not teachers failing children, it’s parents.