Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High earner query - basically over 100% tax on xmas bonus.

710 replies

NameChangeBonus · 17/11/2023 22:23

My employer has decided to be very generous and give everyone £5k cash bonus this Xmas (in previous years they have given £2k). I have adjusted my salary sacrifice pension contributions so I earn approximately £96k gross. I cannot amend this until April as per my employer policy. I thought there was enough buffer for bonus and benefits.

problem is if I earn over £100k (I have 2 kids aged 1 and 3 in full time nursery)

  • I will pay 60 % tax on my bonus
  • i will become ineligible for tax free childcare - worth £333 per month,£4k per year
  • I will become ineligible for 30 hours childcare for DD1 - worth £600 per month, £7k per year.

basically because I’m getting this bonus we’ll be much worse off financially - is there anything I can do to avoid this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Christmasaaarrrggghhh · 18/11/2023 19:12

Princessandthepea0 · 18/11/2023 18:40

It’s been proven that this cliff edge harms tax take. Along with the removal of child benefit at the lower level. People avoid these thresholds for a reason. The 100k anomaly is well publicised in those circles. You can literally be 10s of thousands worse off for earning over 100k by a £1. You lose personal tax allowance, child care hours on top of 40% tax and NI. This gives a marginal rate of close to 70% and over 100% if you have children. Why would you work more to be thousands worse off?

What people forget is that it’s these people paying the most tax. Making them less productive than they could be harms everyone as it lowers tax take. With over half of adults now taking out - we can’t afford that. Other tax systems which are lauded on here - don’t have such a top heavy system of takers. Adults are expected to be productive and everyone is expected to pay a decent amount of tax. In this country, we are classed as low tax because so few people pay tax and those that do - pay low rates. Higher earners already pay their fair share in comparison to other countries - more than in most cases. It’s everyone else who doesn’t.

People become so green with envy about a 6 figure salary. Not stopping to think that it’s irrational to get angry with the very people funding society. All they did was get a good career. Nothing wrong in that - we should celebrate aspiration. The fact we don’t is why the country is fucked. No one wants to do well, happy to take the scraps others are paying for. No anger at why wages are so low in general. Even higher salaries here are really uncompetitive alongside the tax burden. No anger at the person sat on millions paying less tax than those who work for a living. Yet the workers should constantly pay more to fund society. Why? Is over 100% marginal not enough for you?

It takes a special kind of bitterness, envy and stupidity to click on a thread like this. Then offer no advice and just tear a woman down for being successful in her career. What a hole MN is now.

100% this. Agree with every word. Basic rate tax is 20% here. 30% in many other European countries. Then we wonder why their public services are better than ours.

Princessandthepea0 · 18/11/2023 19:08

Meowandthen · 18/11/2023 19:03

Pay for professional advice. You can afford it.

A bunch of people guessing is not to be relied upon.

Edited

It’s really not that deep. That’s why she asked here because people live this situation every day. They can’t help it the thread was taken over by communists.

Pop the extra in a pension and do a self assessment and the end of the tax year.

Meowandthen · 18/11/2023 19:03

Pay for professional advice. You can afford it.

A bunch of people guessing is not to be relied upon.

Princessandthepea0 · 18/11/2023 18:40

It’s been proven that this cliff edge harms tax take. Along with the removal of child benefit at the lower level. People avoid these thresholds for a reason. The 100k anomaly is well publicised in those circles. You can literally be 10s of thousands worse off for earning over 100k by a £1. You lose personal tax allowance, child care hours on top of 40% tax and NI. This gives a marginal rate of close to 70% and over 100% if you have children. Why would you work more to be thousands worse off?

What people forget is that it’s these people paying the most tax. Making them less productive than they could be harms everyone as it lowers tax take. With over half of adults now taking out - we can’t afford that. Other tax systems which are lauded on here - don’t have such a top heavy system of takers. Adults are expected to be productive and everyone is expected to pay a decent amount of tax. In this country, we are classed as low tax because so few people pay tax and those that do - pay low rates. Higher earners already pay their fair share in comparison to other countries - more than in most cases. It’s everyone else who doesn’t.

People become so green with envy about a 6 figure salary. Not stopping to think that it’s irrational to get angry with the very people funding society. All they did was get a good career. Nothing wrong in that - we should celebrate aspiration. The fact we don’t is why the country is fucked. No one wants to do well, happy to take the scraps others are paying for. No anger at why wages are so low in general. Even higher salaries here are really uncompetitive alongside the tax burden. No anger at the person sat on millions paying less tax than those who work for a living. Yet the workers should constantly pay more to fund society. Why? Is over 100% marginal not enough for you?

It takes a special kind of bitterness, envy and stupidity to click on a thread like this. Then offer no advice and just tear a woman down for being successful in her career. What a hole MN is now.

ShadowCipher · 18/11/2023 18:19

Teriyakieverything · 18/11/2023 18:09

Yep, as if that’s not been tried before.

But then, why do some posters not understand (or do they) that a person receives different wages depending on the role they perform, etc.? Instead, they seem to prefer the mantra of just taxing the rich?

Teriyakieverything · 18/11/2023 18:09

Howdoesitworkagain · 18/11/2023 18:08

Same income regardless of role 😂

Yep, as if that’s not been tried before.

Howdoesitworkagain · 18/11/2023 18:08

Same income regardless of role 😂

Teriyakieverything · 18/11/2023 18:08

I think you are right there, there is an underlying Marxist/communist current in the thread that’s fuelled by envy but cloaked in ‘fairness’.

ShadowCipher · 18/11/2023 18:05

Teriyakieverything · 18/11/2023 17:38

Gosh, ‘same income regardless of role’…you speak as if that s a new idea / alternative that no one has thought of before……or I’m misunderstanding your post.

Edited

There's some backstory to this on this thread. Some posters have commented on the thread that the OP, suggesting that they should be grateful and accept their current wages. Others question why the OP is seeking advice, while some argue that the wealthy should be taxed more. Additionally, there are those who believe that if a person studies, achieves promotions, etc., they earn the wage they receive, a perspective I understand and agree with.

My point was to address those who weren't impressed with the OP seeking help. I proposed that if individuals were dissatisfied with the disparity in wages due to roles, promotions, private companies, etc., why not advocate for everyone to be paid the same amount regardless of their role?

This suggestion aims to test whether the critics would still argue that the OP earns too much.

Teriyakieverything · 18/11/2023 17:38

Gosh, ‘same income regardless of role’…you speak as if that s a new idea / alternative that no one has thought of before……or I’m misunderstanding your post.

ShadowCipher · 18/11/2023 17:13

Nanaof1 · 18/11/2023 15:28

LOL! I can't tell if you are being serious or not. But the fact that you even thought of this makes people like Putin proud. smdh

Yeah, people would be lining up to be doctors, nurses and other stressful roles if they were going to get paid as much as the person who only has to say, "Do you want fries like that?"

Sometimes, TOO often anymore, it's just mind-boggling to read the posts on these threads. I truly despair for the human race.

I was making a point for the posters who seem exasperated about the OP earning the amount they do and asking for advice. I needed to add more, but I was essentially offering an alternative to higher earners. Everyone would be on a basic rate of income, regardless of the role. Although as a societal experiment, it would be intriguing for those who think the OP should not earn as much as they do to try everyone on the same level wage, regardless of their role. This could help them reassess their views on the matter.

Merryoldgoat · 18/11/2023 16:54

@burnoutbabe

that’s my point.

The bonus would be accrued in the accounts but might not be finalised until the financial year end - eg there might be an agreement of x% of profits so you’d accrue a certain amount, say £10k for the YE 31/3 accounts, but the actual amount when finalised might be £8.5k owing to various adjustments.

So it’s EARNED in the (say) 23/24 tax year but not paid until 24/25 tax year.

But according to DWhat that could be considered fraudulent which is what I was querying.

stillplentyofjunkinthetrunk · 18/11/2023 16:51

I agree @sherloc I think the same problem exists for people on in work benefits at other earnings levels and I think it's a problem there too.

If you're going to lose 2p or 3p for every 1p you earn it feels awful, and incentivises you to earn less to try to avoid crossing that barrier. The people who lose out from a simpler tax system are tax accountants.

sherloc · 18/11/2023 16:26

@NameChangeBonus Whatever you feel about the responses, well done for starting the thread - it has certainly stirred up emotions.
Contentious though threads like this one are, they should be the basis for Mumsnetters telling the major parties what their priorities are - particularly as the GE is not far away.
Personally, I think that no part of one's wages/salary should give the earner less than 50p in any pound earned, others would like to see a return to the Beatle tax (95%, or 'one for you, nineteen for me' to quote George).
If the personal tax allowance had kept pace with the purchase price of my house (decades ago) it would now be equal to the Minimum Living Wage - should it be?
Flat rates of tax, where everyone pays a fixed rate of maybe 30% of all their income over the personal allowance would make it worth earning an extra hours wages and boost productivity - a sensible idea or a nightmare?
Those coming up to a delayed state pension were told they would not pay National Insurance past pension age, is that fair because they've been told that, or do we think the WASPI women got their just deserts for not training as pensions experts?
A record number of businesses appear to be failing, is it fair that newly formed Limited Companies get over a year to file their first accounts and many are dissolved owing taxpayers money? Should start-ups and loss-making/low margin businesses instead pay 1% or 2% of each sale as tax (as they do with VAT) to reflect the risk borne by the taxpayer? It would be one way to get money from Facebook and Amazon, but is it fair on Jane the painter and decorator?
Like the supermarkets that continually tell us that they are just responding to customer demands when they discontinue lines, eliminate staffed checkouts and so on, if we can articulate our thoughts, perhaps we should be telling those organisations which have a major bearing on our health, wealth and happiness what our priorities are.

Dibblydoodahdah · 18/11/2023 16:18

Christmasaaarrrggghhh · 18/11/2023 16:17

And go over 100k nd the government suddenly removes any childcare help which can cost tens of thousands. That’s the whole point of this post

Yes, I know that. I was just pointing out to the previous poster that they were £10k out on their tax calculations!

Christmasaaarrrggghhh · 18/11/2023 16:17

Dibblydoodahdah · 18/11/2023 16:13

Someone on £100k pays around £35k in tax and national insurance.

And go over 100k nd the government suddenly removes any childcare help which can cost tens of thousands. That’s the whole point of this post

Dibblydoodahdah · 18/11/2023 16:13

usernamealreadytaken · 18/11/2023 13:32

OP pays about £25k income tax, and gets £11k back, so around £14k net. About 14% income tax.

Someone on £100k pays around £35k in tax and national insurance.

Nanaof1 · 18/11/2023 16:13

EasterIssland · 18/11/2023 08:35

How does your comment answer the op with her question ?

It doesn't, but it helps feed @Blanc4 's false sense of self-righteous indignation and pretend superiority.

Of course, whether anyone believes that prattle is a topic for another day. 😉

Nanaof1 · 18/11/2023 16:03

ginandtonicwithlimes · 18/11/2023 07:43

Sounds like you are struggling to afford the choice to have two children close together. As that was a choice you will have to suck it up

Why no savings? Surely you could have been able to stick a little in?

Oh yippee skippy! Now the reproduction police have shown up to impart their "wisdom". It's about as useful as six toes on one foot and about as wanted, but, here we are.

Nanaof1 · 18/11/2023 15:42

Covetthee · 18/11/2023 06:32

We Women really are our own worse enemies.

who needs Men to put us down when we do it so freely! 🤦🏽‍♀️

ffs if you’re unhappy with your life and what you earn maybe instead of commenting on a topic which obviously triggers you, sit down and have a look at yourself and better yourself if not financially then mentally.

jealousy is an ugly trait and you wont get far in life like that or by putting people down, you made your comment, you got yout little dopamine hit by putting down someone yet what have you achieved? The OP still earning £100k and you look like a twat.

op- sorry no advice as I earn no where near that lol but the nasty comments you have recieved are disgusting.

I love to see other women in successful positions with higher salaries so well done and i hope you sort it out.

I bow to your great way with words!

Take A Bow Thank You GIF by Iliza
Nanaof1 · 18/11/2023 15:28

ShadowCipher · 18/11/2023 13:37

And if all the so-called 'rich' decided to use, for example, offshore tax havens, then who covers the tax? The rich can only provide so much before they resort to other measures. Instead, why not have an across-the-board policy where everyone earns the same amount, regardless of the role?

LOL! I can't tell if you are being serious or not. But the fact that you even thought of this makes people like Putin proud. smdh

Yeah, people would be lining up to be doctors, nurses and other stressful roles if they were going to get paid as much as the person who only has to say, "Do you want fries like that?"

Sometimes, TOO often anymore, it's just mind-boggling to read the posts on these threads. I truly despair for the human race.

jlpth · 18/11/2023 15:12

AussiUnHomme · 18/11/2023 13:44

Ha ha sucks to be you

I guess it sucks to be you as well with that attitude

LittleBearPad · 18/11/2023 14:56

burnoutbabe · 18/11/2023 14:06

the nil band withdrawl at £100k just isn't generally well known and catches people out at my work often when they get with a demand for an extra £2k when they said BUT i pay via PAYE.

I used to always send a reminder each tax year to all staff (small co) about tax returns and who should do one (per HMRC guidance which includes anyone over £100k). and a reminder about pension payments to reduce salary and save
NI. But its not usual for companies to advise on staff tax arrangements and people only chatted to me about it as i was payroll person and knew what they earned.

this sort of conversation just doesn't happen in real life unless you KNOW everyone there is earning over £100k or around that.

Very true - did my SA this morning. I have very simple tax affairs and am paid via PAYE but I owe the tax man another £4k which annoyingly can’t be dealt with via PAYE over the next year as it’s over the £3k threshold.

LittleBearPad · 18/11/2023 14:54

usernamealreadytaken · 18/11/2023 13:32

OP pays about £25k income tax, and gets £11k back, so around £14k net. About 14% income tax.

Wrong.

You’ve forgotten National Insurance payments (tax by another name) and student loan repayments which are a graduate tax.

I didn’t make up the £40k I quoted

burnoutbabe · 18/11/2023 14:06

the nil band withdrawl at £100k just isn't generally well known and catches people out at my work often when they get with a demand for an extra £2k when they said BUT i pay via PAYE.

I used to always send a reminder each tax year to all staff (small co) about tax returns and who should do one (per HMRC guidance which includes anyone over £100k). and a reminder about pension payments to reduce salary and save
NI. But its not usual for companies to advise on staff tax arrangements and people only chatted to me about it as i was payroll person and knew what they earned.

this sort of conversation just doesn't happen in real life unless you KNOW everyone there is earning over £100k or around that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread