Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High earner query - basically over 100% tax on xmas bonus.

710 replies

NameChangeBonus · 17/11/2023 22:23

My employer has decided to be very generous and give everyone £5k cash bonus this Xmas (in previous years they have given £2k). I have adjusted my salary sacrifice pension contributions so I earn approximately £96k gross. I cannot amend this until April as per my employer policy. I thought there was enough buffer for bonus and benefits.

problem is if I earn over £100k (I have 2 kids aged 1 and 3 in full time nursery)

  • I will pay 60 % tax on my bonus
  • i will become ineligible for tax free childcare - worth £333 per month,£4k per year
  • I will become ineligible for 30 hours childcare for DD1 - worth £600 per month, £7k per year.

basically because I’m getting this bonus we’ll be much worse off financially - is there anything I can do to avoid this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
sep135 · 19/11/2023 07:04

Jobs in eg In the city, finance and senior management often demand specialized skills, education, and experience that may be relatively scarce, fostering a competitive environment that drives higher salaries. In contrast, certain healthcare professions, although critical and demanding, may contend with a broader pool of qualified individuals, potentially affecting wage levels.

Which is essentially supply and demand.

I have a colleague from my investment banking days who earned seven and eight figure bonuses. It was based on a percentage of fees earned (for advisory services not lending before it starts another GFC debate). He saw a new business area, was brilliant at pitching and had the financial expertise to deliver what clients wanted.

Working in investment banking was an eye-opener because, as interesting as it is, the silly hours mean that people do it for the money and there's no pretence otherwise. If you don't get rewarded appropriately, you join a competitor and, if you're senior enough and play the non-competes carefully, you take your clients with you.

99% of fee earners were male and the first thing they told me was never say thank you for your bonuses as it make you look weak. In many way an unforgiving place to work but you realise that men are far less embarrassed about demanding higher salaries than we tend to be.

Princessandthepea0 · 19/11/2023 07:04

AussiUnHomme · 19/11/2023 00:33

It's quite clear the OP has taken salary sacrifice to make their salary 96k to allow for a 3ish k bonus and not go over the 100k threshold.

So, they've played the system and got found out.

The answer easily is to ask for 1k of the latest bonus to go to the pension pot, or just forgo it and explain to the finance people why.

But the fact they've already gamed the system and lost, and decided to tell everyone, is a bit silly

Are you feeling ok? Or is that jealousy blinding you. If it’s the first time op has come across this - then she will need to ask. She is allowed to. Of course people will try and stay below 100k if they will be thousands of pounds worse off. It’s a marginal rate of over 100 percent. This kind of issue makes up an accountant’s work. The government knows it’s harming tax receipts. The government also knows it was causing issues with experienced consultants working less - so as not to break the threshold. Actually paying to work is mad. That’s why they changed the pension allowance. It’s no big secret here. The government know full well they take less tax, the country is less productive and it’s actively harming public services like the NHS.

Frankly, here is a grip for you to get. They have done absolutely nothing wrong.

AussiUnHomme · 19/11/2023 00:33

It's quite clear the OP has taken salary sacrifice to make their salary 96k to allow for a 3ish k bonus and not go over the 100k threshold.

So, they've played the system and got found out.

The answer easily is to ask for 1k of the latest bonus to go to the pension pot, or just forgo it and explain to the finance people why.

But the fact they've already gamed the system and lost, and decided to tell everyone, is a bit silly

ShadowCipher · 19/11/2023 00:21

User123456713 · 18/11/2023 21:49

Its a small % of the income that is taxed so highly, a good employer should realise this and adjust or offer different bonuses.

Its not jealousy, its that people don't quite get why an Oncology nurse for example, working long hours, mega stressed, saving/improving lives, earns so little compared to say a senior manager in the city.

Please don't say "Supply n Demand" we ve huge shortages in Healthcare.

Perhaps also, in a COL crisis, people who are fortunate enough to earn 6 figure salaries should keep their wealth to themselves?

Edited

Jobs in eg In the city, finance and senior management often demand specialized skills, education, and experience that may be relatively scarce, fostering a competitive environment that drives higher salaries. In contrast, certain healthcare professions, although critical and demanding, may contend with a broader pool of qualified individuals, potentially affecting wage levels. The market value of a job may not necessarily align with its social or societal value. Healthcare professionals, exemplified by oncology nurses, make immense contributions to society by saving and improving lives. However, the compensation for such roles is often influenced by budget constraints within the healthcare system.

mauveiscurious · 19/11/2023 00:00

Golly #LeanIn I hope you get sorted, honestly people come on here for genuine advice and they scorned for being a successful woman.

Those who mocked her, you all need to grow up.

sherloc · 18/11/2023 23:39

ClareBlue · 18/11/2023 23:19

Are you still permitted to have some gold bars tax free. Def used to be able to.

Not sure, but I believe one of the London football clubs blew this one.
Paid the players in bags of one pound coins, in the next room, a bullion dealer would convert the gold sovereigns into paper money.
Unsurprisingly, the Inland Revenue noticed that the club was collecting far less employee tax than its peers. Slowed them down for a bit, but other tax scams have been tried since. They get caught, but sadly, nobody seems terribly bothered.

Bellsbeachwaves · 18/11/2023 23:19

A couple of things may not helping your case on this thread:

I think you're giving childcare figures without deducting the contributions from the govt.

I'm so skint I've got a £2000 mortgage. Yes and a mortgage on a house inside the M25 that you have the capacity to pay off

Similar attitude from someone else who said not well off we have four children in private school. Yes. You are well off. You have four children in private school.

It's like having a fridge full of champagne and saying omg I'm skint and living pay cheque to pay cheque. Yes because you have a fridge full of champagne 🤣

ClareBlue · 18/11/2023 23:19

Are you still permitted to have some gold bars tax free. Def used to be able to.

BackAgainstWall · 18/11/2023 23:01

YANBU
Refuse the bonus.
Your employer will totally understand.

sherloc · 18/11/2023 22:54

@User123456713 people don't quite get why an Oncology nurse for example, working long hours, mega stressed, saving/improving lives, earns so little compared to say a senior manager in the city.

The two largest elements to this difference are:

  1. When any trade/profession has more women than men in it, the perception (or maybe reality) of women happy to accept 40% pay for 60% hours to accommodate childcare drives down wages in that trade/profession. Expected to apply to an increasing number of roles for doctors as there are no more female trainees than male.
  2. The vocational penalty, whereby junior workers in voluntary and public sector jobs are motivated by altruism and therefore need not be paid their true worth. Nobody thinks a middle-manager in a bank finds motivation from the goodness of their heart. Interestingly, the senior management in the voluntary and public sector are rewarded as though they are as avaricious as their private sector counterparts.
sleepwouldbenice · 18/11/2023 22:52

justabigdisco · 17/11/2023 22:28

Maybe spend it on having your diamond shoes re-sized?

Crass and pathetic comment

Princessandthepea0 · 18/11/2023 22:42

User123456713 · 18/11/2023 21:49

Its a small % of the income that is taxed so highly, a good employer should realise this and adjust or offer different bonuses.

Its not jealousy, its that people don't quite get why an Oncology nurse for example, working long hours, mega stressed, saving/improving lives, earns so little compared to say a senior manager in the city.

Please don't say "Supply n Demand" we ve huge shortages in Healthcare.

Perhaps also, in a COL crisis, people who are fortunate enough to earn 6 figure salaries should keep their wealth to themselves?

Edited

You are able to read - why click on a thread where you’re going to be offended and have no wisdom to answer the question.

Last time I checked - this site was called Mumsnet. Not minimum wage net or UC claimants net. Although you’d not know it. You have zero right to police what advice people come here for.

EasterIssland · 18/11/2023 21:53

User123456713 · 18/11/2023 21:49

Its a small % of the income that is taxed so highly, a good employer should realise this and adjust or offer different bonuses.

Its not jealousy, its that people don't quite get why an Oncology nurse for example, working long hours, mega stressed, saving/improving lives, earns so little compared to say a senior manager in the city.

Please don't say "Supply n Demand" we ve huge shortages in Healthcare.

Perhaps also, in a COL crisis, people who are fortunate enough to earn 6 figure salaries should keep their wealth to themselves?

Edited

why an Oncology nurse for example, working long hours, mega stressed, saving/improving lives, earns so little compared to say a senior manager in the city.

what makes you think a senior manager is jot mega stresses and their work has an impact on improving other people’s lives ? My previous role was developing software for nhs , whilst I wasn’t directly saving the live I was supporting those that were saving lives , making their work easier and as such saving lives. Not only those earning minimum wage have got a difficult role

User123456713 · 18/11/2023 21:49

Princessandthepea0 · 18/11/2023 18:40

It’s been proven that this cliff edge harms tax take. Along with the removal of child benefit at the lower level. People avoid these thresholds for a reason. The 100k anomaly is well publicised in those circles. You can literally be 10s of thousands worse off for earning over 100k by a £1. You lose personal tax allowance, child care hours on top of 40% tax and NI. This gives a marginal rate of close to 70% and over 100% if you have children. Why would you work more to be thousands worse off?

What people forget is that it’s these people paying the most tax. Making them less productive than they could be harms everyone as it lowers tax take. With over half of adults now taking out - we can’t afford that. Other tax systems which are lauded on here - don’t have such a top heavy system of takers. Adults are expected to be productive and everyone is expected to pay a decent amount of tax. In this country, we are classed as low tax because so few people pay tax and those that do - pay low rates. Higher earners already pay their fair share in comparison to other countries - more than in most cases. It’s everyone else who doesn’t.

People become so green with envy about a 6 figure salary. Not stopping to think that it’s irrational to get angry with the very people funding society. All they did was get a good career. Nothing wrong in that - we should celebrate aspiration. The fact we don’t is why the country is fucked. No one wants to do well, happy to take the scraps others are paying for. No anger at why wages are so low in general. Even higher salaries here are really uncompetitive alongside the tax burden. No anger at the person sat on millions paying less tax than those who work for a living. Yet the workers should constantly pay more to fund society. Why? Is over 100% marginal not enough for you?

It takes a special kind of bitterness, envy and stupidity to click on a thread like this. Then offer no advice and just tear a woman down for being successful in her career. What a hole MN is now.

Its a small % of the income that is taxed so highly, a good employer should realise this and adjust or offer different bonuses.

Its not jealousy, its that people don't quite get why an Oncology nurse for example, working long hours, mega stressed, saving/improving lives, earns so little compared to say a senior manager in the city.

Please don't say "Supply n Demand" we ve huge shortages in Healthcare.

Perhaps also, in a COL crisis, people who are fortunate enough to earn 6 figure salaries should keep their wealth to themselves?

Charlie2121 · 18/11/2023 21:34

5thCommandment · 18/11/2023 21:29

Damn @Charlie2121 what do you do? I'm hitting 135k with bonuses and thought that was decent lol. Very impressive 👍 keep the tax coming it's needed 🤣

Legal profession in quite a niche, heavily regulated industry where experienced peer competition is sparse hence the high salary.

135k is very decent. I earned well below that for much of my career.

TheCave · 18/11/2023 21:33

I haven't read all threads of this, but have you asked if it's possible to divert 100% of the bonus to your pension as a one-off payment? My employer does this. It actually saves them money somehow (I think on National Insurance payments) and they give us some of the saving. It means that if you divert all the bonus to your pension, you actually get slightly more than the amount of the bonus stuck into your pension pot. It's a no brainer for me, but annoyingly means I won't enjoy any bonuses until I'm retired. Not massively complaining, I'm fortunate to get a bonus and it's entirely my choice to stick it in the pension pot (I don't do it to avoid the £100k threshold).

Also, I haven't done it personally but I understand you could get the money and then add it to your pension pot as a one-off payment yourself and somehow claim the income tax back. I think that would mean that you keep your income below £100k. Worth considering.

5thCommandment · 18/11/2023 21:29

Damn @Charlie2121 what do you do? I'm hitting 135k with bonuses and thought that was decent lol. Very impressive 👍 keep the tax coming it's needed 🤣

Palmasailor · 18/11/2023 21:27

Charlie2121 · 18/11/2023 21:14

That's basic economics. I earn 200k after pension contributions and pay around 80k in deductions every year.

If the top rate taxes were lower I'd probably stay in work for longer. As it is I'll retire earlier. Even if it is 6 years earlier than I intended this equates to half a million in lost receipts for the Treasury.

People struggle to accept that higher earners need incentives however once you reach the point where you don't really need to work any more you soon start assessing whether it is worth it or not.

With the top 1% paying 30% of all income tax the government needs to be careful not to upset this group of people.

I know. I work a lot less than I could because I don’t need to. I’m not working any harder or longer to pay more tax.

Charlie2121 · 18/11/2023 21:14

Palmasailor · 18/11/2023 20:12

Margaret Thatcher reduced the higher tax rates and the overall tax take increased.

Just sayin 🤷‍♂️

Donns hard hat.. lol..

That's basic economics. I earn 200k after pension contributions and pay around 80k in deductions every year.

If the top rate taxes were lower I'd probably stay in work for longer. As it is I'll retire earlier. Even if it is 6 years earlier than I intended this equates to half a million in lost receipts for the Treasury.

People struggle to accept that higher earners need incentives however once you reach the point where you don't really need to work any more you soon start assessing whether it is worth it or not.

With the top 1% paying 30% of all income tax the government needs to be careful not to upset this group of people.

sherloc · 18/11/2023 20:52

@Christmasaaarrrggghhh Basic rate tax is 20% here. 30% in many other European countries. Then we wonder why their public services are better than ours.

Up to £12,570, you pay income tax at 0% and National Insurance at 0%

From £12,571 to £50,270 tax is at 20% AS WELL AS National Insurance at 12%

That's 32% and that NI isn't put into a pot in your name. Some (£20 billion+) is diverted to NHS England, the remainder goes into the general taxation pot and is spent on Suella's payoff, subsidising Parliamentary food and drink or running schools or the Fire Brigade.

All of this is explained in gov.uk, webpages but generally in opaque ways that require a degree of prior knowledge to fully appreciate. Then, some accounting sleights of hand reduce transparency further, so all of the funds destined for NHS England are deemed to be spent in full - before any other funding - to ensure that underspends by the Department for Health and Social Care don't give the impression that NI should be reduced.

It's dry stuff, that few live for, but the history of why the government accounts for things as it does, what we are being taxed for and how the money is used would make for a fascinating TV programme or a series of podcasts - and that would really inform the next general election.

Palmasailor · 18/11/2023 20:12

Princessandthepea0 · 18/11/2023 18:40

It’s been proven that this cliff edge harms tax take. Along with the removal of child benefit at the lower level. People avoid these thresholds for a reason. The 100k anomaly is well publicised in those circles. You can literally be 10s of thousands worse off for earning over 100k by a £1. You lose personal tax allowance, child care hours on top of 40% tax and NI. This gives a marginal rate of close to 70% and over 100% if you have children. Why would you work more to be thousands worse off?

What people forget is that it’s these people paying the most tax. Making them less productive than they could be harms everyone as it lowers tax take. With over half of adults now taking out - we can’t afford that. Other tax systems which are lauded on here - don’t have such a top heavy system of takers. Adults are expected to be productive and everyone is expected to pay a decent amount of tax. In this country, we are classed as low tax because so few people pay tax and those that do - pay low rates. Higher earners already pay their fair share in comparison to other countries - more than in most cases. It’s everyone else who doesn’t.

People become so green with envy about a 6 figure salary. Not stopping to think that it’s irrational to get angry with the very people funding society. All they did was get a good career. Nothing wrong in that - we should celebrate aspiration. The fact we don’t is why the country is fucked. No one wants to do well, happy to take the scraps others are paying for. No anger at why wages are so low in general. Even higher salaries here are really uncompetitive alongside the tax burden. No anger at the person sat on millions paying less tax than those who work for a living. Yet the workers should constantly pay more to fund society. Why? Is over 100% marginal not enough for you?

It takes a special kind of bitterness, envy and stupidity to click on a thread like this. Then offer no advice and just tear a woman down for being successful in her career. What a hole MN is now.

Margaret Thatcher reduced the higher tax rates and the overall tax take increased.

Just sayin 🤷‍♂️

Donns hard hat.. lol..

ginandtonicwithlimes · 18/11/2023 20:03

Nanaof1 · 18/11/2023 16:03

Oh yippee skippy! Now the reproduction police have shown up to impart their "wisdom". It's about as useful as six toes on one foot and about as wanted, but, here we are.

She can have as many kids as she wants but she can't complain about the cost of childcare if she chooses to have them close together. 🤦 Why do you think many get a new sibling after three or when starting school?

burnoutbabe · 18/11/2023 19:31

I am a finance professional and have given free advice. And countered the wrong bits.

Princessandthepea0 · 18/11/2023 19:30

Meowandthen · 18/11/2023 19:27

Communists. 😂

I’m a finance professional and the vast majority of “advice” isn’t right. And no, I am not giving free advice.

The vast majority from those in that position is.

Meowandthen · 18/11/2023 19:27

Princessandthepea0 · 18/11/2023 19:08

It’s really not that deep. That’s why she asked here because people live this situation every day. They can’t help it the thread was taken over by communists.

Pop the extra in a pension and do a self assessment and the end of the tax year.

Communists. 😂

I’m a finance professional and the vast majority of “advice” isn’t right. And no, I am not giving free advice.

Swipe left for the next trending thread