Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High earner query - basically over 100% tax on xmas bonus.

710 replies

NameChangeBonus · 17/11/2023 22:23

My employer has decided to be very generous and give everyone £5k cash bonus this Xmas (in previous years they have given £2k). I have adjusted my salary sacrifice pension contributions so I earn approximately £96k gross. I cannot amend this until April as per my employer policy. I thought there was enough buffer for bonus and benefits.

problem is if I earn over £100k (I have 2 kids aged 1 and 3 in full time nursery)

  • I will pay 60 % tax on my bonus
  • i will become ineligible for tax free childcare - worth £333 per month,£4k per year
  • I will become ineligible for 30 hours childcare for DD1 - worth £600 per month, £7k per year.

basically because I’m getting this bonus we’ll be much worse off financially - is there anything I can do to avoid this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
cocopops · 19/11/2023 10:06

Was going to suggest you direct all of it as a salary sacrifice into your pension- then realised this had already been suggested (as I stopped reading the thread after the inevitable marks comments about diamond shoes). That’s what I’d do.

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 10:03

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/11/2023 09:03

Well you were seriously underestimating in that case. I said approx £35k, you said £25k but now you’re saying it’s actually £33k. Who was closest?! Also, I never mentioned the value of tax free childcare etc. I was talking about people who earn £100k in general.

Are you hard of understanding? OP doesn’t pay tax on £100k, she pays tax on £96k, so that she can also claim additional reductions and benefits. We’re discussing OP, not other people.

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 10:01

LittleBearPad · 19/11/2023 08:56

No, you’re the one making up numbers.

There’s no such thing as Net Income tax.

Of course we have such a thing as net income taxes. OP is due to pay £25,850 in income taxes, and then directly receives £4k reduction in tax from TFC, then receives a benefit worth £7k - making her net contribution £15k. That’s how net figures work.

If you discount the reductions from her actual payments, then you can’t argue she’d be paying more tax if the deductions cease - it can’t work one way and not the other.

Teateaandmoretea · 19/11/2023 10:00

Charlie2121 · 19/11/2023 08:25

To be in the top 1% of earners you need to be earning around 170k+. There are a lot more normal jobs that attract that kind of salary than you would imagine. You don’t need to be a PL footballer. Senior lawyer, plc Board director, senior commercial director, senior finance role etc. All will attract such salaries and will likely be PAYE.

Where I work there are around 25 people on such salaries and every single one is paid via PAYE.

As for the other info, google is your friend. You will see that over half of all households actually receive more cash benefits than they pay income tax. The 70k earnings figure relates to benefit of all services provided not just straightforward cash payments.

Edited

It’s a shame for you only earning 170k. My lifestyle is much more glamorous in the upper echelons of the top 1%.

Come on at least admit you made up the 70k thing/ requoted it from someone else making it up.

VintageTuppence · 19/11/2023 10:00

NameChangeBonus · 17/11/2023 22:51

I know.

we take home approx £7k between us. Over half is nursery fees, and £2k is mortgage and council tax (inside m25 but not an amazing area). That leaves £1500 for all utilities, bills, food, commuting, clothes, for a family of 4…..is that really not ‘quite tight’. I didn’t say ‘very tight’ but it’s not like we have loads of spare cash to go on holiday etc.

In a time when many people are struggling to pay rent and provide food for their children, didn't you consider sharing your income and your bonus could have been considered a little tone deaf?

burnoutbabe · 19/11/2023 09:52

Sofarisoul · 19/11/2023 09:09

Like many others have said the refusal, pension, or charity seem options to consider m.

But what never seems to be acknowledged is that the OP (and anyone else on salary sacrifice) has a salary of 120k, but a ‘pretend’ salary of 98k, already allowing tax and NI savings and access to various schemes.

Salary sacrifice schemes are not compulsory nor promoted tax saving schemes (unlike ISAs before anyone says). Surely if you were to compare an employee on similar salary but the employer doesn’t have salary sacrifice, it would be clear that the OP is already saving tax and getting more out than her counterpart would be.

Happy to be corrected but having salary sacrifice already seems to be quite a benefit to some?

Either person can put the £23k into their pension

If done via salary sacrifice you also save ni (2% but employer saves 13.8% so benefits more)
If done directly you write a cheque for the net amount (20% less) and claim rest via your tax return and get a repayment.

So anyone can do it. Most companies offer salary sacrifice for pensions to save themselves 13.8% ni cost (mine nicely also puts that ni into the pension too)

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 09:52

Christmasaaarrrggghhh · 18/11/2023 10:25

If you didn’t claim child benefit when you could have you are an idiot. You don’t get to lecture others on their finances.

I’m sorry that you think people with principles are idiots. I was vehemently opposed to CB being based on one salary rather than household income, so I put my money where my mouth is and when our household income reached the threshold, we stopped claiming. Also wrote to my local MP asking for it to be reviewed in Parliament.

LimePi · 19/11/2023 09:47

@TheIndecisiveElf

the cost quoted is BEFORE free hours and tax free childcare

Tombero · 19/11/2023 09:33

Aprilx · 19/11/2023 07:33

The charitable donation is not a good idea as it is not true. It is the charity that benefits from the tax credit not the individual making the donation.

There’s a section on the tax return for any giving you’ve done which was gift aided. You then get a tax credit yourself for it.

LittleBearPad · 19/11/2023 09:32

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 09:11

You mean people who minimise the tax they pay, like OP does? I guess the difference is that they probably don’t claim additional benefits on top. We don’t know how much DH earns, but even on min wage their household income is over £130k - and we’re arguing that OP is being hard done by if people on £25k aren’t contributing to her childcare costs? FGS.

People on £25k aren’t net contributors. They won’t be funding the OP.

TrashedSofa · 19/11/2023 09:29

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 09:13

Where’s the cut off then? How much should a person be able to earn and still get taxpayer funded childcare? £150k, £250k, £500k? Wherever the cutoff is, there will be a massive marginal tax jump. We’re arguing here about a household with an income of maybe over £130k, getting something funded by families who will never get close to that level of income.

Alternatively, there doesn't actually have to be a cutoff. As there isn't for the 15 free hours at 3. We provide any number of things to people who are entitled to them regardless of their income, and avoid the cutoff problem. Statutory maternity pay, state pensions, bus passes. Clearly it's a principle that we as a society accept. As we should, since it's a good idea to keep the highest earners who pay the most into the pot feeling that they have a stake. Our crumbling public services increasingly aren't cutting it.

Princessandthepea0 · 19/11/2023 09:20

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 08:50

So where’s the cut off? Do will still give those on £200k free childcare and tax breaks? Those on £500k? I thought we wanted better public services which need to be funded via tax, yet someone earning over £100k is able to pay only £20k net income taxes.

What? Explain to me why you think a marginal rate of over 100% is acceptable or going to boost tax take. Better still, don’t click on a thread you don’t understand just to tear a woman down. It’s a very bad look.

Princessandthepea0 · 19/11/2023 09:18

Teateaandmoretea · 19/11/2023 08:12

😂😂😂👍🏻. Me too, I play upfront for Man U.

I’m still waiting for that link.

Here’s an idea - go find it yourself, it’s well documented. The poster is correct. Or do you like spending your Sunday logging onto a thread you can offer no advice on - to tear down a woman who earns a hood wage out of jealousy and spite. The behaviour in here is vile.

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 09:13

Princessandthepea0 · 18/11/2023 13:32

Do you not get it? This is a prime example of a tax system which the chancellor has been told reduces tax take. Why would you take a pay rise to be worse off? It all goes in a pension. The shortsightedness of people in this country is mind boggling. Why would anyone pay a marginal tax rate of over 100%.

Where’s the cut off then? How much should a person be able to earn and still get taxpayer funded childcare? £150k, £250k, £500k? Wherever the cutoff is, there will be a massive marginal tax jump. We’re arguing here about a household with an income of maybe over £130k, getting something funded by families who will never get close to that level of income.

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 09:11

ShadowCipher · 18/11/2023 13:37

And if all the so-called 'rich' decided to use, for example, offshore tax havens, then who covers the tax? The rich can only provide so much before they resort to other measures. Instead, why not have an across-the-board policy where everyone earns the same amount, regardless of the role?

You mean people who minimise the tax they pay, like OP does? I guess the difference is that they probably don’t claim additional benefits on top. We don’t know how much DH earns, but even on min wage their household income is over £130k - and we’re arguing that OP is being hard done by if people on £25k aren’t contributing to her childcare costs? FGS.

Sofarisoul · 19/11/2023 09:09

Like many others have said the refusal, pension, or charity seem options to consider m.

But what never seems to be acknowledged is that the OP (and anyone else on salary sacrifice) has a salary of 120k, but a ‘pretend’ salary of 98k, already allowing tax and NI savings and access to various schemes.

Salary sacrifice schemes are not compulsory nor promoted tax saving schemes (unlike ISAs before anyone says). Surely if you were to compare an employee on similar salary but the employer doesn’t have salary sacrifice, it would be clear that the OP is already saving tax and getting more out than her counterpart would be.

Happy to be corrected but having salary sacrifice already seems to be quite a benefit to some?

uhOhOP · 19/11/2023 09:07

sherloc · 18/11/2023 20:52

@Christmasaaarrrggghhh Basic rate tax is 20% here. 30% in many other European countries. Then we wonder why their public services are better than ours.

Up to £12,570, you pay income tax at 0% and National Insurance at 0%

From £12,571 to £50,270 tax is at 20% AS WELL AS National Insurance at 12%

That's 32% and that NI isn't put into a pot in your name. Some (£20 billion+) is diverted to NHS England, the remainder goes into the general taxation pot and is spent on Suella's payoff, subsidising Parliamentary food and drink or running schools or the Fire Brigade.

All of this is explained in gov.uk, webpages but generally in opaque ways that require a degree of prior knowledge to fully appreciate. Then, some accounting sleights of hand reduce transparency further, so all of the funds destined for NHS England are deemed to be spent in full - before any other funding - to ensure that underspends by the Department for Health and Social Care don't give the impression that NI should be reduced.

It's dry stuff, that few live for, but the history of why the government accounts for things as it does, what we are being taxed for and how the money is used would make for a fascinating TV programme or a series of podcasts - and that would really inform the next general election.

You seem to know what you're talking about. Make the podcast series! I'd definitely listen to it 😁

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/11/2023 09:03

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 08:39

Not sure where you get your figures from, but you’re overestimating.

Someone on £100k pays £27,432.00 tax and £5,518.60 NI, or just under £33k total.

OP has already said she reduces her taxable salary to £96k via salary sacrifice, so she pays £25,832.00 tax and £5,438.60 NI. Once you deduct the equivalent value of TFC and free hours (£11k), OP pays less than £15k income tax plus NI taking her contribution to just over £20k. You seem to think she pays about 40% more…

Well you were seriously underestimating in that case. I said approx £35k, you said £25k but now you’re saying it’s actually £33k. Who was closest?! Also, I never mentioned the value of tax free childcare etc. I was talking about people who earn £100k in general.

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 09:00

Princessandthepea0 · 18/11/2023 13:44

Give as much? These are the people funding 54.2% of the population to take. They don’t have a personal allowance, they pay 40-45% headline tax rates and marginals of over 100%. These people aren’t the rich. They are mugged at every turn. They are funding everyone else and it’s never enough. Hated just for doing well. The actual rich with millions in assets are not paying much tax.

And there we have it, the politics of envy. The actual rich have assets; no matter that many of them worked for those assets, and indeed OP will also have a very valuable asset given that she’s buying a property in London. Is there a figure you have in mind for the worth of the “actual” rich? Do you just mean those with “old” money, or do you include new money, people like Jamie Oliver, the Beckhams, James Dyson? They worked and invested and reaped the benefits and are now stupidly wealthy - how much more of their money should we be able to take?

LittleBearPad · 19/11/2023 08:56

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 08:53

Her NI is around £5.5k, so her net income taxes are just over £20k. You’re overestimating by about 50% - you made up the £40k figure.

No, you’re the one making up numbers.

There’s no such thing as Net Income tax.

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 08:53

LittleBearPad · 18/11/2023 14:54

Wrong.

You’ve forgotten National Insurance payments (tax by another name) and student loan repayments which are a graduate tax.

I didn’t make up the £40k I quoted

Her NI is around £5.5k, so her net income taxes are just over £20k. You’re overestimating by about 50% - you made up the £40k figure.

LittleBearPad · 19/11/2023 08:52

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 08:39

Not sure where you get your figures from, but you’re overestimating.

Someone on £100k pays £27,432.00 tax and £5,518.60 NI, or just under £33k total.

OP has already said she reduces her taxable salary to £96k via salary sacrifice, so she pays £25,832.00 tax and £5,438.60 NI. Once you deduct the equivalent value of TFC and free hours (£11k), OP pays less than £15k income tax plus NI taking her contribution to just over £20k. You seem to think she pays about 40% more…

You don’t get the £11k refunded - the OP’s nursery costs are simply reduced by that amount.
You've also forgotten student loan payments which are a tax on graduates - 9% or so.

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 08:50

Princessandthepea0 · 18/11/2023 13:32

Do you not get it? This is a prime example of a tax system which the chancellor has been told reduces tax take. Why would you take a pay rise to be worse off? It all goes in a pension. The shortsightedness of people in this country is mind boggling. Why would anyone pay a marginal tax rate of over 100%.

So where’s the cut off? Do will still give those on £200k free childcare and tax breaks? Those on £500k? I thought we wanted better public services which need to be funded via tax, yet someone earning over £100k is able to pay only £20k net income taxes.

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 08:39

Dibblydoodahdah · 18/11/2023 16:13

Someone on £100k pays around £35k in tax and national insurance.

Not sure where you get your figures from, but you’re overestimating.

Someone on £100k pays £27,432.00 tax and £5,518.60 NI, or just under £33k total.

OP has already said she reduces her taxable salary to £96k via salary sacrifice, so she pays £25,832.00 tax and £5,438.60 NI. Once you deduct the equivalent value of TFC and free hours (£11k), OP pays less than £15k income tax plus NI taking her contribution to just over £20k. You seem to think she pays about 40% more…

ACynicalDad · 19/11/2023 08:34

ssd · 19/11/2023 08:28

What i can never understand from these threads is how someone so smart to earn the amount op gets is so clueless with money.

That’s harsh, they’ve already done some financial planning to keep below the threshold, this was just more than they expected.