Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High earner query - basically over 100% tax on xmas bonus.

710 replies

NameChangeBonus · 17/11/2023 22:23

My employer has decided to be very generous and give everyone £5k cash bonus this Xmas (in previous years they have given £2k). I have adjusted my salary sacrifice pension contributions so I earn approximately £96k gross. I cannot amend this until April as per my employer policy. I thought there was enough buffer for bonus and benefits.

problem is if I earn over £100k (I have 2 kids aged 1 and 3 in full time nursery)

  • I will pay 60 % tax on my bonus
  • i will become ineligible for tax free childcare - worth £333 per month,£4k per year
  • I will become ineligible for 30 hours childcare for DD1 - worth £600 per month, £7k per year.

basically because I’m getting this bonus we’ll be much worse off financially - is there anything I can do to avoid this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MidnightOnceMore · 19/11/2023 13:09

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/11/2023 11:29

There was a great article in the Times that was shared earlier in the thread. It showed how earning £1 more could mean that some people were £10,000 worse off a year. It’s perverse and there is evidence that it, along with the other crazy tax cliff
edges, are detrimental to the economy. I recommend that you read the article.

I understand the issue.

The Tories have created this issue.

My point is only that factually it is not a 100% tax rate. The issue is the loss of childcare support.

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 13:06

Princessandthepea0 · 19/11/2023 11:10

Ummm it is.

No, it isn’t. OP won’t be paying more tax, she will be losing benefits. On a household income of £130k+.

usernamealreadytaken · 19/11/2023 13:04

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/11/2023 11:09

It’s the cost of childcare in this country that is immoral as it discourages women to work which puts them at greater risk of financial abuse. Do you know how much an average childcare place is in Germany?! About 12 times cheaper than the UK as they pay the same amount a year that we pay in a month. https://www.euronews.com/next/2023/03/06/childcare-puzzle-which-countries-in-europe-have-the-highest-and-lowest-childcare-costs

OP would not only pay higher income tax in Germany, but would also have health, pension and care fund taxes to pay on top. But, yeah, cheaper childcare.

Princessandthepea0 · 19/11/2023 12:51

ilovesooty · 19/11/2023 12:29

No. You pay tax on what you draw down after the tax free lump sum anyway. It's the other things mentioned that rather grate on me, and the concept of the first thought seemingly being how can I pay as little as possible. I acknowledge however that this is a subjective feeling.

Or how to not actively be thousands of pounds worse off for a relatively small pay rise - in op’s case.

ilovesooty · 19/11/2023 12:29

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/11/2023 12:15

Every person who pays into a pension is saving tax. Do you have a problem with that?

No. You pay tax on what you draw down after the tax free lump sum anyway. It's the other things mentioned that rather grate on me, and the concept of the first thought seemingly being how can I pay as little as possible. I acknowledge however that this is a subjective feeling.

TrashedSofa · 19/11/2023 12:22

People really do put a lot of emphasis on their subjective feelings when issues like this come up. We see the same in discussions about people not working more when they're reliant on top up benefits because its not worth it, and there are invariably posters talking about their belief that people should be self-sufficient, benefits not being a choice or whatever. All that changes is the political views of the particular posters centring their own feelings on the matter.

Vanishingly few of us have enough influence for our personal sympathies to matter beyond maybe a few people we know. At best. Really, if one wants to go beyond simply giving advice, the question that actually matters is whether one thinks its a good idea to have a system that incentivises people to lower their incomes or not.

burnoutbabe · 19/11/2023 12:21

the legal ways to avoid tax around the 100k mark mostly involve

Paying into a pension (good to avoid future pension payments by governement under pension credits) or giving to charity (good for charity/society). All things in LAW that are allowed and encouraged by the government

The real issues here are things like footballers/millionairre business people who are paid by off books/in gold/not paid but "given loans". All are using tax laws wording to try and avoid paying any tax and generally get stopped under General Anti avoidance measures.

(and i in fact use the same pension laws and pay half my (part time) salary into the pension (via salary sacrifice) to save myself 20% tax/12% NI and my taxable salary is just above the PAYE threshold - My employer also pays the 13.8% NI they save into the pension - so i get around 45% boost to my pension for every £100 not taken as salary.

so the benefit is there for EVERYONE to take advantage of if they wish - at higher levels you avoid 40% and 2% NI or the £100k cliff edge)

Jeremysirons · 19/11/2023 12:17

Do not take a lower amount or decline the bonus.

Open a SIPP (you can do this in 30 mins with vanguard or AJ bell) and put the full 5k bonus in there.

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/11/2023 12:15

ilovesooty · 19/11/2023 12:13

So it is legal then - thanks for explaining. I just find it dispiriting that there are so many perfectly legal ways for people to avoid paying tax they owe. Having said that it's even more dispiriting that people feel their first option is to look what avoidance tactics they can employ.

Every person who pays into a pension is saving tax. Do you have a problem with that?

DonnaBanana · 19/11/2023 12:14

And people wonder why the newer generation is having children in far fewer numbers than ever before! It’s a sensible thing to avoid having kids if you’re not either heavily subsidised by the state or in the top 5% of earners, thus creating a next generation more divided than ever. It’s a huge moral failing of this country to not support families and it’ll bite us all in the bum when our population goes down and no one is left to pay for our state pensions

ilovesooty · 19/11/2023 12:13

burnoutbabe · 19/11/2023 12:08

i can;t see how spreading a bonus over a longer period could really be caught be tax laws?

Isn't it just saying - give me a pay rise every month rather than a one off payment?

the taxpayer is taking a risk anyway - cash NOW or waiting a while for cash, with the possibolity that the company goes bust etc.

many companies will agree to delay a bonus into the April payroll rather than March payroll. All perfectly legal. (of course if you get similar bonuse's each year you have same issue every year but i avoided that by going part time, others could retire, take a break between jobs to have a "low" tax year.

And of course if its your own company, you pay dividends or salary exactly when its most tax efficient to do so.

So it is legal then - thanks for explaining. I just find it dispiriting that there are so many perfectly legal ways for people to avoid paying tax they owe. Having said that it's even more dispiriting that people feel their first option is to look what avoidance tactics they can employ.

Sofarisoul · 19/11/2023 12:10

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/11/2023 11:34

If childcare was a reasonable cost the OP wouldn’t have to make additional salary sacrifice payments into her pension so I don’t see that there is anything immoral in what she is doing. There’s also evidence that the crazy tax cliff edges that we have in the UK are detrimental to the economy. There was a good article on the Times about this that was shared earlier in the thread.

Quite. Childcare needs to be affordable for everyone. I’m all for that! I didn’t say the OP was immoral, rather I am questioning a system that allows use of artificial salaries upon which a variety of things can then be based. I said I didn’t blame anyone for doing it but the moralitiy, or perhaps better word is ethics, of a system that allows it can be questioned.

And I also agree re the tax cliff edges. It’s also wrong that employers pay low wages knowing that staff will be topped up by the government, thus subsidising employer profits. I totally agree that this country isn’t run well!

burnoutbabe · 19/11/2023 12:08

ilovesooty · 19/11/2023 12:00

If that's tax avoidance and thus legal it's one of the loopholes that needs closing. If it's tax evasion it shouldn't happen.

And before I get accused again of knocking women down I'd say the same if it were a man doing it.

i can;t see how spreading a bonus over a longer period could really be caught be tax laws?

Isn't it just saying - give me a pay rise every month rather than a one off payment?

the taxpayer is taking a risk anyway - cash NOW or waiting a while for cash, with the possibolity that the company goes bust etc.

many companies will agree to delay a bonus into the April payroll rather than March payroll. All perfectly legal. (of course if you get similar bonuse's each year you have same issue every year but i avoided that by going part time, others could retire, take a break between jobs to have a "low" tax year.

And of course if its your own company, you pay dividends or salary exactly when its most tax efficient to do so.

VintageTuppence · 19/11/2023 12:02

rainbowunicorn · 19/11/2023 11:47

There are many more people not struggling than there are struggling. If you are going down the route of something being tone deaf because of how a section of society is doing we might as well just close mumsnet and all other discussion forums.
It's not a race to the bottom.
OP has the right to ask a question based on her circumstances.

Did you bother to look at the quote history? The OP agreed that ‘there were so many jealous and bitter people here’. My comment was in response to that.

Also ‘Money matters’ would have been a more appropriate place to ask the question.

ilovesooty · 19/11/2023 12:00

Sconehenge · 19/11/2023 11:47

Don’t ask for a lower amount, ask for them to give it to you spread out into next tax year.

If that's tax avoidance and thus legal it's one of the loopholes that needs closing. If it's tax evasion it shouldn't happen.

And before I get accused again of knocking women down I'd say the same if it were a man doing it.

Pottedpalm · 19/11/2023 11:54

rainbowunicorn · 19/11/2023 11:47

There are many more people not struggling than there are struggling. If you are going down the route of something being tone deaf because of how a section of society is doing we might as well just close mumsnet and all other discussion forums.
It's not a race to the bottom.
OP has the right to ask a question based on her circumstances.

I agree @rainbowunicorn
’tone deaf’, ‘read the room’, ‘check your privilege’… we can have a discussion around different scenarios surely.

Sconehenge · 19/11/2023 11:47

Don’t ask for a lower amount, ask for them to give it to you spread out into next tax year.

rainbowunicorn · 19/11/2023 11:47

VintageTuppence · 19/11/2023 10:00

In a time when many people are struggling to pay rent and provide food for their children, didn't you consider sharing your income and your bonus could have been considered a little tone deaf?

There are many more people not struggling than there are struggling. If you are going down the route of something being tone deaf because of how a section of society is doing we might as well just close mumsnet and all other discussion forums.
It's not a race to the bottom.
OP has the right to ask a question based on her circumstances.

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/11/2023 11:34

Sofarisoul · 19/11/2023 11:15

I do agree that childcare costs are completely immoral yes! I’m all for massive childcare subsidies for parents, and I’m child free.

If childcare was a reasonable cost the OP wouldn’t have to make additional salary sacrifice payments into her pension so I don’t see that there is anything immoral in what she is doing. There’s also evidence that the crazy tax cliff edges that we have in the UK are detrimental to the economy. There was a good article on the Times about this that was shared earlier in the thread.

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/11/2023 11:29

MidnightOnceMore · 19/11/2023 11:15

No it isn't.

The additional £4k tips op over a threshold affecting entitlement to childcare subsidy, resulting in a net cost, but the overall tax rate is - obviously - not over 100% is it?

There was a great article in the Times that was shared earlier in the thread. It showed how earning £1 more could mean that some people were £10,000 worse off a year. It’s perverse and there is evidence that it, along with the other crazy tax cliff
edges, are detrimental to the economy. I recommend that you read the article.

Robott · 19/11/2023 11:27

Didn’t know that either, maybe that should change.

TrashedSofa · 19/11/2023 11:25

Robott · 19/11/2023 11:23

@TrashedSofa yeah I knew about that one and that doesn’t seem right.

In OP situation I’d have to look at alternative child care, almost £5000 a month for 2 kids is absurd! surely a childminder or nanny would be cheaper.

I think you can't use the 30 free hours with a nanny?

Robott · 19/11/2023 11:23

@TrashedSofa yeah I knew about that one and that doesn’t seem right.

In OP situation I’d have to look at alternative child care, almost £5000 a month for 2 kids is absurd! surely a childminder or nanny would be cheaper.

Princessandthepea0 · 19/11/2023 11:23

Robott · 19/11/2023 11:17

Oh right, just assumed it was joint income. Does seem a bit crazy. So 2 parents could be earning 90 odd grand a year each and still be entitled to 30 hours tax free?

Yes. Which again is the issue. It penalises women, especially single mothers. Other women seem happy with this status quo which is perverse.

Princessandthepea0 · 19/11/2023 11:21

MidnightOnceMore · 19/11/2023 11:15

No it isn't.

The additional £4k tips op over a threshold affecting entitlement to childcare subsidy, resulting in a net cost, but the overall tax rate is - obviously - not over 100% is it?

Marginal tax rate. At 100k you’ll lose personal allowance. That then puts you at about 70%. For someone with children they then lose any entitlement to child care which will puts them over 100% effectively. You’re thousands worse off for earning £1 more. If you don’t understand this, there is no explaining it to you.