Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High earner query - basically over 100% tax on xmas bonus.

710 replies

NameChangeBonus · 17/11/2023 22:23

My employer has decided to be very generous and give everyone £5k cash bonus this Xmas (in previous years they have given £2k). I have adjusted my salary sacrifice pension contributions so I earn approximately £96k gross. I cannot amend this until April as per my employer policy. I thought there was enough buffer for bonus and benefits.

problem is if I earn over £100k (I have 2 kids aged 1 and 3 in full time nursery)

  • I will pay 60 % tax on my bonus
  • i will become ineligible for tax free childcare - worth £333 per month,£4k per year
  • I will become ineligible for 30 hours childcare for DD1 - worth £600 per month, £7k per year.

basically because I’m getting this bonus we’ll be much worse off financially - is there anything I can do to avoid this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ShenleyWillow · 18/11/2023 07:44

You have to laugh at the jealousy displayed from those who have no idea about your journey and possible sacrifices to get to your position.

Agree with others, ask for some/all of it contributed towards your pension.

Ireolu · 18/11/2023 07:44

I read the title of the thread and thought to myself I hope OP has her hard hat handy for the responses she will get. And MN did not disappoint. Some mean spirited and nasty comments.

OP on the basis of what has been posted here by those responding solely to the problem you have I am sure you will be able to sort it out. Goodluck!

ginandtonicwithlimes · 18/11/2023 07:43

Sounds like you are struggling to afford the choice to have two children close together. As that was a choice you will have to suck it up

Why no savings? Surely you could have been able to stick a little in?

SunshineHello · 18/11/2023 07:41

I don’t think people quite understand how expensive life is in the South East for families with young children.

£100k is 5.5k a month.

£3,800 on nursery.

£400k mortgage is about £2,500.

That’s £6,300. You’re already £800 in the red.

User890976 · 18/11/2023 07:41

Definitely set up a private pension (SIPP, whatever you want call it) to add in the excess over £100k and get you below the threshold. You can then do this in future years anytime you encounter this problem (which will presumably become more likely with inflation pay rises, promotions etc) - it’s a bit more faf than using the employer scheme for everything as you need to claim the additional 20pc via your tax return (the basic rate 20% is added on automatically) but it gives you so much more flexibility to manage these unknowns like your bonus at the end of the tax year.

I did it to great effect for several years to manage my personal tax free allowance.

you can just use one of the investment firms like vanguard (very low fees) or hargreaves lansdowne or whoever and it’s is really very simple to set up.

I do find it interesting that your childcare costs more than your husbands salary and wonder how many women have been made to give up work in similar circumstances for the good of the family pot 🤔 however I agree working through high childcare costs is an investment in the future and obviously your husband needs to be happy day to day with what he’s doing.

hope you get it sorted OP

EasterIssland · 18/11/2023 07:40

Mikimoto · 18/11/2023 07:34

96K AND partner's salary AND STILL seeking free childcare?
Speechless.

Speechless that you’ve not understood how the system works at all but try to lecture others

babbygabby · 18/11/2023 07:37

@Mikimoto its not free childcare it’s subsidised. Why shouldn’t higher earners receive some benefits? The old child benefit used to be universal & we don’t means test winter fuel allowances. Also ignores the fact that a couple earning 96k each will get “free childcare” but the OP loses out by going over the threshold.

AgnesX · 18/11/2023 07:36

The only option is to put in your pension is you can.

Is paying to your student loan an option ( I can't remember).

Mikimoto · 18/11/2023 07:34

96K AND partner's salary AND STILL seeking free childcare?
Speechless.

WinchSparkle80 · 18/11/2023 07:32

Easiest option put in your pension via employer, they get tax relief too.

Next option open a personal pension (SIPP) put it in there, handy for one offs, you don’t have to regularly pay in from memory - but please check. Don’t forget you have it.

Another option would be to donate £2-3K to charity, this can reduce your tax liabilities when calculated in a tax return.

Hope it works out. There is a weird earnings scale in the UK where between £100-£150K you get absolutely dinged fir tax.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 18/11/2023 07:30

Howdoesitworkagain · 17/11/2023 23:02

@UsingChangeofName and @egowise you’ve showed yourselves up a bit.

Do you not think the problem lies in childcare costs of £3.8k per month for two children? Another area that’s underfunded and yet here you are being spiteful and jealous about a woman having a decent paying job. How embarrassing.

To be fair they have chosen to have two children quite close together rather than space it like most couples do in order to get the funding. That is a choice is it not?

Lili132 · 18/11/2023 07:30

MusicAndPassionWereAlwaysTheFashion · 18/11/2023 07:06

Tall poppy syndrome is rife in this country. Don't get ahead of yourself now OP. Don't have any ambition, or get any better qualifications to get ahead and earn more to help you and your kids. Don't be talented, or invent something. Let's make sure we are all on the same level, not overly educated and working too hard so that no one else will get uppity.

OP, I would talk to an accountant. It might be good to do that anyway to make sure you are maximising the money you earn.

As for donating it to charity, OP is already contributing loads of money into the pot which no doubt many of you benefit from. She is doing her fair share of paying for others already.

I completely agree. It almost became "fashionable" to be "poor" and to complain. And while there are definitely people who genuinely struggle majority of those who I see complaining never mention how lucky they are to be in council housing or how much they get in childcare support and universal credit on top of their wages.
But if you worked hard and have a high salary then god forbid you say anything even if you were left on a bread line after paying for your mortgage and childcare. You're still be classed as privileged and deserving of suffering.

The whole point of getting into high paying jobs (which is very hard to do and requires a lot of sacrifice!) is to have a better lifestyle and security. The way tax and childcare support works makes it other way round which just doesn't make any sense.
People shouldn't be worse off by earning more. The whole point of getting a pay rise is to have more money not less. The system is totally illogical and awkward.

CyclingMumKent · 18/11/2023 07:25

Do a manual payment into a private SIPP in March

gormin · 18/11/2023 07:23

This happened to us a couple of years ago. DH works in sales and his commission can vary a lot. One year he 'accidentally' earned over 100k (about 102k I think). Obviously I didn't declare this to HMRC in advance because I didn't know it was going to happen. But they did freeze our 30 hours and TFC once they found out after the tax year finished. I called them and explained what had happened and that it was a one off, and they just unfroze it all. Like you, we really relied on it as we had two kids full time in nursery in London and a big mortgage.

I'm not suggesting you try this, just sharing a story! I actually like the idea of asking for some of it as holiday or asking them to reallocate it to another member of staff.

And please ignore the people saying nasty things, money threads bring out the worst in people!

rwalker · 18/11/2023 07:17

justabigdisco · 17/11/2023 22:28

Maybe spend it on having your diamond shoes re-sized?

Obviously just jealous and bitter

think people needs to remember
someone who earns this type of money contributes more to the public purse than the average person earns in a year

sep135 · 18/11/2023 07:13

someone who earns £120k pays 60% on their top 20k….and I’m actually have less money by being given a bonus….surely that doesn’t make sense.!

I'm embarrassed to say that I'm a chartered accountant and don't quite understand how you get from the 40% higher rate (up to £125%) to your marginal tax rate of 60%.

Although having looked at it, are you in Scotland where the personal allowance tapers? In which case you end up in the 47% band plus lose your PA?

Lili132 · 18/11/2023 07:08

Redwineislife · 18/11/2023 07:02

To those who are commenting on the high nursery costs. I have two children in nursery, 3.5 days per week and it costs £1,500 per month. 30 hours free is calculated over the school year so in effect it’s less than 2 days per week ‘funded’ and still a lot to pay for. Plus meals for the unfunded days. Believe me, it was a shock to me too when I had been banking on ‘free’ nursery for my twins when they turned 3!!!

People just don't get it! It's such an ignorance. And costs are so different across the country.
Also people with kids on lower salaries get other benefits. If you count how much better off a family can be by receiving universal credit, living in council housing, getting 30 free hours childcare etc it's actually a lot of money.

Mumsanetta · 18/11/2023 07:07

Oh don’t get me started on the tax free childcare system! It should be based on household income not individual incomes to make it fairer as atm a couple each earning ££99k would get but a couple with a household income that is much lower wouldn’t get it if one of them earns over £100k.

MusicAndPassionWereAlwaysTheFashion · 18/11/2023 07:06

Tall poppy syndrome is rife in this country. Don't get ahead of yourself now OP. Don't have any ambition, or get any better qualifications to get ahead and earn more to help you and your kids. Don't be talented, or invent something. Let's make sure we are all on the same level, not overly educated and working too hard so that no one else will get uppity.

OP, I would talk to an accountant. It might be good to do that anyway to make sure you are maximising the money you earn.

As for donating it to charity, OP is already contributing loads of money into the pot which no doubt many of you benefit from. She is doing her fair share of paying for others already.

SamanthaVimes · 18/11/2023 07:04

If you do go the pension route ring them to ask because we were advised when we recently rectified that it needed to be a different private pension that the extra cash went in (DH is in a similar bracket, over £100k but not so far over that losing tax free childcare doesn’t make us worse off than earning £99k)
He’s opening a new private pension to contribute to before April and according to the person we spoke to that’s ok.
I’m not sure why it makes a difference and the woman we spoke to didn’t really seem to know either but that’s where it was left

MikeRafone · 18/11/2023 07:03

Ask not to have the bonus
ask they redirect the bonus to the lowest paid staff member instead
put the money in a SIPP

Redwineislife · 18/11/2023 07:02

To those who are commenting on the high nursery costs. I have two children in nursery, 3.5 days per week and it costs £1,500 per month. 30 hours free is calculated over the school year so in effect it’s less than 2 days per week ‘funded’ and still a lot to pay for. Plus meals for the unfunded days. Believe me, it was a shock to me too when I had been banking on ‘free’ nursery for my twins when they turned 3!!!

Lili132 · 18/11/2023 07:01

NameChangeBonus · 17/11/2023 22:51

I know.

we take home approx £7k between us. Over half is nursery fees, and £2k is mortgage and council tax (inside m25 but not an amazing area). That leaves £1500 for all utilities, bills, food, commuting, clothes, for a family of 4…..is that really not ‘quite tight’. I didn’t say ‘very tight’ but it’s not like we have loads of spare cash to go on holiday etc.

OP we rent, we have 2 children and both earn much less then you and your husband but with help of universal credit we have more available income then you do.
Unfortunately in this country having higher salary can leave you worse off if you have to pay for childcare, mortgage etc. But some people are too ignorant and jealous to understand that.
Childcare for 2 children can cost almost £4000 and £2000 mortgage is considered cheap in South East so again people who live in more affordable areas have no idea how expensive it is and majority of women on here didn't pay full time childcare for 2 children so often don't think about it.

It is really unfair when someone works extremely hard, go into debt to study and then suddenly is much worse off for getting a little pay rise. The system is really broken and I think childcare support should be lowered gradually once you go over threshold but here you go.

Pooooochi · 18/11/2023 06:59

If things are quite tight on your salary, you need to have a look at your finances

Ignore the people saying this crap who simply don't understand what it costs to live in/near london and don't realise lower earners in london often only manage it because they are depending on social housing and UC top ups, or don't have kids to pay for.

That said, 3800 is a stupid amount of money on nursery when you have tax free childcare and 30 free hours for one. That suggests that the cost pre those is well over £2k per child a month - that will be a very swanky nursery and you can easily find cheaper options.

CeilingWacks · 18/11/2023 06:58

How is nursery costing 3.5k/month when one of the children is receiving 30 hours free?