Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High earner query - basically over 100% tax on xmas bonus.

710 replies

NameChangeBonus · 17/11/2023 22:23

My employer has decided to be very generous and give everyone £5k cash bonus this Xmas (in previous years they have given £2k). I have adjusted my salary sacrifice pension contributions so I earn approximately £96k gross. I cannot amend this until April as per my employer policy. I thought there was enough buffer for bonus and benefits.

problem is if I earn over £100k (I have 2 kids aged 1 and 3 in full time nursery)

  • I will pay 60 % tax on my bonus
  • i will become ineligible for tax free childcare - worth £333 per month,£4k per year
  • I will become ineligible for 30 hours childcare for DD1 - worth £600 per month, £7k per year.

basically because I’m getting this bonus we’ll be much worse off financially - is there anything I can do to avoid this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
LittleBearPad · 28/11/2023 00:37

usernamealreadytaken · 23/11/2023 11:08

Don't know of anyone on UC on over £100k.

That’s a really obtuse comment. No one said anyone on a £100k was on UC.

EasterIssland · 23/11/2023 23:15

usernamealreadytaken · 23/11/2023 17:17

So you think it's reasonable for an individual to earn £160k and still claim state support? I really don't swear often, but fucking hell.

Would it be better for them to work 2-3 days a week so they don’t earn as much and get access to childcare ? How would the uk benefit from that ? As it’d be less taxes paid by the employer.

also one person earning 160k shouldn’t get allowance. But 2 people from the same household earning 80k each should they get it?

id love to live in a country where childcare was subsidised like many other countries and access to it is affordable for families. Many women wouldn’t give up their jobs and Hmrc would benefit from it opposite to the current system which penalises you if you are low income (can’t afford) or if you’re high income (no benefits so its better for me to work less).

probably there are things that we spend money on as a country that add less value back to hmrc than incentivising to work

luluw41 · 23/11/2023 19:16

The OP is literally paying for other family’s UC 🙄

Applesaarenttheonlyfruit · 23/11/2023 18:19

usernamealreadytaken · 23/11/2023 17:17

So you think it's reasonable for an individual to earn £160k and still claim state support? I really don't swear often, but fucking hell.

It has NOTHING to do with my views. It’s the law.

TrashedSofa · 23/11/2023 17:49

Charlie2121 · 23/11/2023 17:27

You totally miss the point which is that the system needs to incentivise higher earners to continue to work full time while their children are of nursery age.

If you create a punitive tax regime then higher earners will simply take a step back for a while until their circumstances change. Thats not a good outcome for the Treasury.

Or for those of us who need their services.

Charlie2121 · 23/11/2023 17:27

usernamealreadytaken · 23/11/2023 17:17

So you think it's reasonable for an individual to earn £160k and still claim state support? I really don't swear often, but fucking hell.

You totally miss the point which is that the system needs to incentivise higher earners to continue to work full time while their children are of nursery age.

If you create a punitive tax regime then higher earners will simply take a step back for a while until their circumstances change. Thats not a good outcome for the Treasury.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 23/11/2023 17:20

So you think it's reasonable for an individual to earn £160k and still claim state support? I really don't swear often, but fucking hell

I do think anyone should be able to get tax relief for childcare (for the first two children, ie one per parent), yes. Regardless of income, because higher earners pay it back anyway. I am not sure the current childcare subsidy system works but anyone can get tax relief for anything HMRC says they can, regardless of income so I see no reason why reasonable childcare costs should not count too. Childcare facilitates someone working and earning and paying tax.

Whether a Labour government would introduce it remains to be seen.

I'd get rid of child benefit altogether in the above scenario.

usernamealreadytaken · 23/11/2023 17:17

Applesaarenttheonlyfruit · 23/11/2023 16:52

Well we already know the answer to this don’t we: £60k. That’s what you can do as maximum offset. So £160k is the highest salary that can mitigate this tax. All perfectly legitimate and legal.

If you earn over certain levels, this is then withdrawn again until you can only save £10k into a pension.

So you think it's reasonable for an individual to earn £160k and still claim state support? I really don't swear often, but fucking hell.

Applesaarenttheonlyfruit · 23/11/2023 16:52

usernamealreadytaken · 23/11/2023 11:11

But OP's salary isn't £96k, it's already over £100k, but she has already employed legal tax avoidance to bring it down to a level where she can access state support. She's now asking advice on how to keep it even lower so she can earn more and still keep state support - how high should earnings be able to go before we draw a line and say that parents should pay themselves?

Well we already know the answer to this don’t we: £60k. That’s what you can do as maximum offset. So £160k is the highest salary that can mitigate this tax. All perfectly legitimate and legal.

If you earn over certain levels, this is then withdrawn again until you can only save £10k into a pension.

usernamealreadytaken · 23/11/2023 11:11

Christmasaaarrrggghhh · 19/11/2023 15:19

I’d LOVE to know what you’d do in the OP’s situation!

salary £96k, take home £64k. Get a £5k bonus - yay. Take home pay is up to £67k but lose all nursery hours which costs £12k (guess) so my take home pay is down to £55k. Overall, for taking the bonus you lose £9k take home pay, your entire annual food budget. Would you just suck this up, and say ‘oh but society needs the money more’??? Really???

But OP's salary isn't £96k, it's already over £100k, but she has already employed legal tax avoidance to bring it down to a level where she can access state support. She's now asking advice on how to keep it even lower so she can earn more and still keep state support - how high should earnings be able to go before we draw a line and say that parents should pay themselves?

usernamealreadytaken · 23/11/2023 11:08

LittleBearPad · 19/11/2023 15:03

Indeed.

Make it Universal Credit however and all sorts of advice will be given to protect entitlements.

Edited

Don't know of anyone on UC on over £100k.

usernamealreadytaken · 23/11/2023 11:07

NameChangeBonus · 19/11/2023 13:43

If DH earned almost 100k, and I earned £30-35k (in a secure role I loved), would people still be advising I become as SAHP due to short term childcare costs for a few years?

Did you mean to say "If DH earned OVER 100k, and I earned £30-35k (in a secure role I loved), would people still be advising I become as SAHP due to short term childcare costs for a few years?"

I think a large number of people would still look at your £135k+ household income and ask whether your diamond shoes were a too tight too.

Palmasailor · 21/11/2023 18:34

TrashedSofa · 21/11/2023 09:40

Yes, I do wonder whether some of the contributors in this thread have realised that the potential implication of this cliff edge is them not being able to access a service they need.

No. Nobody makes that association, unfortunately they’re mostly waaaay too stupid to come to that realisation.

That, and the govt have basically invented free money for so long that it’s become worthless. Everyone feels entitled to everything free and they’re about to get the mother of all wake up calls.

TrashedSofa · 21/11/2023 09:40

Yes, I do wonder whether some of the contributors in this thread have realised that the potential implication of this cliff edge is them not being able to access a service they need.

laclochette · 21/11/2023 09:07

For those who don't understand why the issue OP is facing is a real problem for all of us, rather than some kind of just deserts for being successful, this article is a good read:

“Like many of my colleagues I have young children and claim funded childcare hours,” says the thirtysomething family doctor. However, the doctor points to the “tax cliff edge at £100,000”, where if a household earns this much or above it loses this funding.

“This is coupled with the loss of the personal allowance from earnings over £100,000, which results in a marginal tax rate of 62% including national insurance. Factor in pension contributions and student loan repayments, and I would only take home 15.5p for every pound earned.

“I did some calculations and realised that, factoring in the loss of childcare hours and the higher tax band, I would need to earn about £120,000 to ‘break even’ with earning just below £100,000.

“As a result, after Christmas I’m reducing my hours to keep my earnings down. This means at the busiest time of the year for the NHS I’ll be sitting at home twiddling my thumbs when I could be at work seeing patients.”
Reducing hours to stay below the £100,000 income threshold was, they added, “a regular topic of discussion” among colleagues. “It’s utter madness. Apologies to patients who can’t get in to see me in February and March. I’ll be back in April.”

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/nov/21/im-reducing-my-hours-fiscal-drags-impact-in-the-cost-of-living-crisis

‘I’m reducing my hours’: fiscal drag’s impact in the cost of living crisis

Guardian readers share how frozen income tax thresholds have tipped them into higher brackets, affecting household budgets

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/nov/21/im-reducing-my-hours-fiscal-drags-impact-in-the-cost-of-living-crisis

Scrumbleton · 19/11/2023 22:25

some nasty people on this thread!
if your employer doesn't permit additional voluntary contribution to your pension you can very easily (on line) oper a self invested pension (SIPP). government will add a 40% tax refund to anything added to Sipp and you can judge your contribution to take you below the 100k threshold at which your personal allowance starts to taper away. you can do it any time before the tax year ends. DH and i opened SIPPs with AJ Bell. V easy - you can keep the money in cash or invest on something with a very wide risk spread like a global shares etf. i recently removed my 25% tax free lump sum as i retired. Was also pretty easy.

5thCommandment · 19/11/2023 20:58

As someone posted yesterday in this thread before Mumsnet got all woke sensitive - broke bitches be jealous 😂
We need to encourage high earning and see high pay as a positive. Who's tax do you think pays for all the public services...

RadioTop · 19/11/2023 20:42

Why such vitriol towards a successful woman? Well done

PurpleBugz · 19/11/2023 18:41

You are not taxed on charitable donations. Give it to the poor

Princessandthepea0 · 19/11/2023 17:29

MidnightOnceMore · 19/11/2023 16:40

'people' may have done that, but I did not.

As I said before, I hope you feel better soon. It can't be fun being so cross with randoms on the internet.

Still waiting for your sage advice. I’m not the one clicking on threads just to wind myself up.

MidnightOnceMore · 19/11/2023 16:40

Princessandthepea0 · 19/11/2023 14:07

Well quite. You didn’t come here to offer advice because there isn’t any. There was no argument here. Just a simple post asking for tax advice. People fell over themselves to offer nothing constructive but their hatred for higher earners.

'people' may have done that, but I did not.

As I said before, I hope you feel better soon. It can't be fun being so cross with randoms on the internet.

rainbowunicorn · 19/11/2023 16:32

Pottedpalm · 19/11/2023 11:54

I agree @rainbowunicorn
’tone deaf’, ‘read the room’, ‘check your privilege’… we can have a discussion around different scenarios surely.

Yes, there are far too many posters who try to shut down any discussion by telling people to read the room, that their post is tone deaf etc. You can't mention someone's age in a post or you get them all shouting about ageism. You can't talk about diet without the fear of someone telling you that it is fat shaming.
There are posters on here that seem incapable of having a discussion and just start throwing out the same old nonsense to shut down anything they don't like. Other posters get fed up and just don't contribute to the threads. Then there are always a couple of posters on threads like these that have their own little argument that goes on for several pages and derails the entire thread.

Christmasaaarrrggghhh · 19/11/2023 15:19

ilovesooty · 19/11/2023 12:13

So it is legal then - thanks for explaining. I just find it dispiriting that there are so many perfectly legal ways for people to avoid paying tax they owe. Having said that it's even more dispiriting that people feel their first option is to look what avoidance tactics they can employ.

I’d LOVE to know what you’d do in the OP’s situation!

salary £96k, take home £64k. Get a £5k bonus - yay. Take home pay is up to £67k but lose all nursery hours which costs £12k (guess) so my take home pay is down to £55k. Overall, for taking the bonus you lose £9k take home pay, your entire annual food budget. Would you just suck this up, and say ‘oh but society needs the money more’??? Really???

Charlie2121 · 19/11/2023 15:10

Topofthemountain · 19/11/2023 15:03

Childcare assistance should be universal, the numbers accessing childcare over 100k is probably fairly minimal anyway.

There are more than you might think. If like me you have no free grandparent childcare available you will think twice about having children until you are on a decent salary as the costs are immense.

I’ll have paid around 60k in nursery fees for 1 child whereas friends of mine with 2/3 children paid nothing as grandparents did it all for free.

If I’d had 3 children like some of them did it would have cost me close to 200k in nursery fees. You won’t get near to being able to afford that without a big 6 figure salary.

Topofthemountain · 19/11/2023 15:03

Childcare assistance should be universal, the numbers accessing childcare over 100k is probably fairly minimal anyway.