Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help choosing a dog breed

65 replies

holeymoleymacaroli · 17/11/2023 18:21

As a family we have decided to get a dog. DH has always had dogs and is desperate for one again, it's also going to be for our eldest DC to help with her anxiety/ self confidence. This isn't a post for people to persuade us not to get one so please don't comment if that's what you think.

Now the problem is we are stuck on a breed. Ideally we would like a small dog, something that is obviously good with children, easy to train and doesn't mind being left alone for short periods of time.

Any suggestions welcome!

OP posts:
Verv · 17/11/2023 19:21

Bichon or any of its cross breeds - bichon x Maltese, bichon x shit-tzu etc.

Theyre such amiable sunny little individuals.

AWanderingMinstrel · 17/11/2023 19:19

Experienced dog owner here. Son and DIL are vets. Mixed breed every time unless you intend to breed them.

Missingmyusername · 17/11/2023 19:17

Staffy or Lab.
It really does depend on what you can offer a dog. Exercise, costs, grooming, how often dog will be left, some of the dogs being suggested suffer with separation anxiety- meaning they can poo everywhere or self harm, some aren’t fond of cuddles either.

Wanttobeok · 17/11/2023 19:16

People really need to read the OP!

They are looking for a small dog and already have had a border collie and a rottie suggested 🙄

Also asking for suggestions of breeds happy to be left alone for short periods and someone comes on to suggest their breed but then says it doesn't like being left alone!

OP I would agree with those who have suggested a Border Terrier or a Miniature Schnauzer.
My mum has a cocker and he's only young but great with kids. However I'm not sure about him as a therapy dog...I need therapy after two hours of continually being stared at until I throw his ball!

Dee1224 · 17/11/2023 19:15

Hi, we looked into getting a miniature schnauzer from a breeder before getting our first dog, (we eventually ended up with a totally different breed).

I spoke to two lovely KC miniature schnauzer breeders who both said that they wouldn’t recommend them to first time dog owners due to their behavioural traits. Once I thought about it, I agreed, (the one we know is very clingy, yappy and has a tendency to snap when agitated).

I know a few cockapoos and small labradoodles -(some, I know, can be huge!) Their owners swear by them for providing emotional support, being friendly and relatively easy to train.

As with any dog - make sure you meet the breeder, see the dogs’ living conditions and the mother if going for a puppy, before purchase.

MrsWhites · 17/11/2023 19:14

Cocker Spaniel.

Ours is a working one, he has his moments when he’s a little bit nuts but he’s easy to train, amazing with kids, very gentle, doesn’t mind being alone for a few hours and low maintenance- needs brushing and that’s about it!

Weegieunicorn · 17/11/2023 19:14

Whippet or staffie. Loving and gentle dogs.

Dogknowsbest · 17/11/2023 19:13

King Charles Cavaliers are also fabulous - so friendly and super cute.

Cheesecakefiend · 17/11/2023 19:11

Think about how your family operates. Do you enjoy long walks regularly ? If so a terrier could be for you. Do you work from home ? If not do not get a dog prone to separation anxiety like a poodle. If you hate hoovering consider a low shedding breed. Do you want a simple dog like a labrador or an intelligent one like a collie. If the latter you need to be prepared to give it lots of brain game training etc.

Ohwhatfuckeryisthis · 17/11/2023 19:10

Whippet! (Whippet real good!) We actually have a Wire Haired Fox Terrier and she’s lovely but a stubborn little cuss at times, all love and cuddles on her terms. But due to sad family circumstances we had to take on a whippet and she is the sweetest natured dog ever, cuddly full of love never heard her growl ever. Short mental bursts of running, then sleeps. Will love your daughter unconditionally, minimal grooming, incredibly tactile.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 17/11/2023 19:10

Just got a rescue pug and she is the easiest dog ever - great with children. small enough to pick up but robust to be able to play with kids, get on well with people and other animals. But if I were getting a puppy, I would not get a pure breed - they are ridiculously inbred. I would absolutely get a pug cross - they usually really resemble pugs in looks and temperament but have noses!

Yellowdaysaregood · 17/11/2023 19:08

Don't necessarily be hung up on having a smaller breed they're all dogs in the end 😁, what I would say, as an experienced dog owner on my sixth now. I have had everything from a cavalier king Charles and a mongrel rescue to two highly strung chocolate Labradors, if you have them from puppy's be prepared for that ,...puppyhood is hard. they piss and shit and chew EVERYWHERE, Get you up in the middle of the night and generally piss you off , but once you get past that you get the rewards , good luck

wetotter · 17/11/2023 19:06

Chewings · 17/11/2023 18:43

Greyhound 100% would be ideal for you.

No it wouldn't - they want a small dog!

I know greyhounds fold up smaller than their size would suggest, but by no stretch are they small dogs. Whippet or small lurcher might work though - but recall can be harder to train in sight hounds

wetotter · 17/11/2023 19:03

Lakeland terriers can be tricky (usually very high prey drive) so I'm not sure that they're one for a first time owner.

All terriers are fairly independent minded harking back to their old role as ratters, where they would go round the farm and do their job with minimal human input (and often described as stubborn/obstinate when that trait is inconvenient!) They're not naturally biddable (like eg labradors) but are of course trainable.

But the best "entry level" terriers are the Border, the Norfolk (an "at watch" breed), the Norwich (vulnerable native breed) and the Cairns. They're cracking little dogs - can go all day but would be fine on a couple of short walks on the days you can't fit longer ones in, friendly temperament, low maintenance coat, no drool

SisterHyster · 17/11/2023 18:56

Purpleraiin · 17/11/2023 18:36

I've had so many different breeds from childhood to adult and by far the best one is my current dog and she's a border collie. Obviously not as small as a terrier but she's not exactly big either.
She has been the easiest to train, very placid and such a gentle temperament. I'd honestly never have another breed now I've had her 🙂
Oh and she is brilliant with kids of all ages!

Edited

Not sure what you are smoking to suggest a border collie as a dog for an inexperienced dog owner with young children.

Wishitsnows · 17/11/2023 18:56

Cavalier King Charles spaniel’s are rated as good emotional support dogs. Small and very affectionate.

DiaryofWimpy · 17/11/2023 18:54

My mum and dad have a cross between shitzu and terrier she is a delight so loving and loyal. The only downside is she doesn't like being left alone.

Iateallthechocolate · 17/11/2023 18:51

Cocker spaniel. Good with children, easy to train, happy disposition, not too big, don't care about rain or fireworks.
Need clipping every 3 months ( not really a con as they also bath them and it makes them easy to brush)

DanceMumTaxi · 17/11/2023 18:50

Close family member has a schnoodle (miniature schnauzer poodle cross). He’s big enough to have a decent walk if you want one but small enough not to take over the living room. He’s fantastic with my kids and loves cuddles. He just wants to be near you, but he can be left especially if he’s had a good walk first. Most days he has 2 30-40 minutes walks a day, with one being off lead. He loves to sniff so this quite important. Another plus is that he doesn’t shed hair, however he does need to go to the groomers fairly regularly. He’s very chilled around other dogs, never barks at them. He can be a bit stubborn though and he won’t play games like fetch.

Chewings · 17/11/2023 18:43

Greyhound 100% would be ideal for you.

justheretoread111 · 17/11/2023 18:42

Whippets! Perfect breed for a family and such sweet little low maintenance dogs.

GlitteryUnicornSparkles · 17/11/2023 18:40

When I worked at a vets they all swore by Corgi’s for the best temperaments. The ones I got to meet were all lovely. Small, don’t require too much exercise, fairly robust.

SouthernBel · 17/11/2023 18:38

Border Terrier! Ours is an absolute dream girl, incredible with the children, easy as pie around the house, will snuggle up with me on the sofa and let me squeeze her extra hard on bad days. We've had loads of dogs through the years (DH and I always grown up with dogs) but this is the first Border we've had - we'll honestly never look at another breed again! She brings us so much joy every day.

ScroogeMcDuckling · 17/11/2023 18:38

i love Rottweilers, but they are big dogs, they are small Labrador size, they are so family oriented and they are definitely house dogs and part of the family, but they do need a good walk or two daily.

if I was wanting a smaller dog, I really love cocker spaniels because they seem beautiful and friendly, and they go to the hairdressers every few weeks because they don’t malt!!

I also am finding myself loving small bulldogs, either French or English

thistimelastweek · 17/11/2023 18:37

Cairn terrier.
Norfolk terrier.
I've had both and both were fab.