Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help choosing a dog breed

65 replies

holeymoleymacaroli · 17/11/2023 18:21

As a family we have decided to get a dog. DH has always had dogs and is desperate for one again, it's also going to be for our eldest DC to help with her anxiety/ self confidence. This isn't a post for people to persuade us not to get one so please don't comment if that's what you think.

Now the problem is we are stuck on a breed. Ideally we would like a small dog, something that is obviously good with children, easy to train and doesn't mind being left alone for short periods of time.

Any suggestions welcome!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mustardfan · 17/11/2023 20:51

I have a cavapoo. She’s a cross between a Cavalier King Charles Spaniel and a poodle. She is loving, friendly, just wants to be cuddled. She’s fine to be left for periods at home. She’s small, and doesn’t need a lot of exercise, but has been on long walks with us too (to the top of Snowden). I think that the breeder that you pick is as important as the breed. Our dog came from a loving home, she stayed with her mother and the whole litter until we collected her, and she settled instantly into our home, sleeping through the night.

Burgerexplosion · 17/11/2023 20:16

SisterHyster · 17/11/2023 18:56

Not sure what you are smoking to suggest a border collie as a dog for an inexperienced dog owner with young children.

This.

Border Collies are highly intelligent dogs which require large doses of mental stimulation and physical exercise.

PieonaBarm · 17/11/2023 20:11

Border Terrier. Mine was an absolute clown, he was brilliant. He was fairly biddable in the end but it did take some strict training. He did have his moments (was positively racist to Labradors and Golden Retrievers as he was beaten up by one as a small puppy and he NEVER forgave the entire breeds and definitely NEVER forgot!)

He would go for as long or as short a walk as you wanted. DH would run with him until he got to about 9 and just sat down about a mile in and refused to go any further 😂. Absolutely LOVED fetch and would drop his ball for our 3 year old niece. He was such a brilliant little dog, always happy and helped me through some horrendous times, he lived until he was 13 which can be considered young for a Border.

We have a Miniature Schnauzer in the family and me and DH say to each other that she's nice but she's "not a dog" like our Border was.

anarchicparadise · 17/11/2023 19:59

long haired chow chow

AWanderingMinstrel · 17/11/2023 19:57

Paradeofrain · 17/11/2023 19:41

Not true. See my response above. Some mixes are healthy but not all

I agree that combinations of breeds matter- I certainly wouldn’t recommend a chihuahua with a Bernese mountain dog 😂My point was only to highlight that as all pure breeds carry inherited conditions which can be life limiting, choosing to choose a mixed breed might offset these genetics.

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/11/2023 19:52

Ahhhhhh... this is basically my job!

Small breeds are either companion breeds or terriers - either way they're generally sharp, need lots of exercise and mental stimulation, and may struggle without a person around. However whatever breed you get, bank on it being 2 years to go from puppy to reliable adult, and near that before you can routinely leave them for useful time frames without worrying about it or having to do lengthy set ups to ensure they're ok. You may well get there faster, but it is better to err on teh side of caution.

If you DO NOT LIKE fast clever loud yappy demanding dogs - do not get a poodle x. Just don't. Particularly, do not get a poodle x working cocker spaniel (as many cockerpoos are).

I would say half my day job is talking down people at their absolute limit with a cockerpoo.

Border terriers - neat, clean, tidy, one of the most trainable and biddable terriers, still a terrier though so fi you want unquestioning obedience without a seconds thought, not the dog for you. If you're happy to prove its worth doing as you ask almost every time you ask, fine, not a bother.

Whippets - lovely, typically very cuddly too, clever but less demanding than terriers on the whole. May have a high prey drive (so would a terrier) but they are a big fan of a comfy snooze too and typically not keen on going ou tin ALL weathers, just the nicer weather thanks.

Other ideas..

Grand Basset Griffon Vendeen (or the Petit version) - scent hound, so they can be a bit dodgy off lead but I've met plenty trained well enough to go off lead in places you already know.

VERY cuddly and affectionate, yet independent enough not to be super needy either. Food driven so easy to train, and their general attitude is that everyones lovely, but they don't HAVE to greet everyone, only those who acknowledge them (unlike some of the friendly breeds who can be a bit thuggish when young).

Cirneco D'ell Etna - whippety but more exotic.

Fauve de Bretagne - smaller than the GBGV and gingery.

Clumber spaniel - a big dog really on short legs but very steady, loving and patient unlike pretty much all the other spaniels!

Paradeofrain · 17/11/2023 19:50

Honestly it really depends what you want in a dog. What you'll get is people describing their favourite dog breed which might not fit for you

Border terrier for example are fiesty! They aren't usually suitable around small pets, need a fair amount of exercise (more comparable with larger dogs than toy dogs), need hand stripping so factor in a couple of groomers visits a year, can be selective with other dogs as they don't back down from a fight.

It's not to day they aren't a good dog, but no breed comes without its considerations or is perfect for every home

defi · 17/11/2023 19:47

My vet said they rarely see border terriers so she recommends them.

^ yes like jack Russell terriers they live forever running on spite

AWanderingMinstrel · 17/11/2023 19:46

Labrador everytime- saw a silver Lab the other day - gosh what a beautiful dog!

Tinysoxxx · 17/11/2023 19:43

My vet said they rarely see border terriers so she recommends them.

Scottishskifun · 17/11/2023 19:43

I think it depends on how active you are as a family and is that activity going to focus around a dog.

Cocker Spaniels and collies need shed loads of exercise and mental stimulation.

Terriers have a stubborn streak which needs training from day dot but small. Would not get a jack Russell though bit insane small dog syndrome too.

I'm a sight hound lover for easy going family pet (they like to sleep....a lot!) But they can be skittish and some can have high prey drive so recall can be difficult (ours does have recall).

Also suggest going for a reacue not a brand new puppy! But using a rescue charity ideally who Foster first they will know more about the dog and they will go for right fit.

SisterHyster · 17/11/2023 19:41

Wanttobeok · 17/11/2023 19:16

People really need to read the OP!

They are looking for a small dog and already have had a border collie and a rottie suggested 🙄

Also asking for suggestions of breeds happy to be left alone for short periods and someone comes on to suggest their breed but then says it doesn't like being left alone!

OP I would agree with those who have suggested a Border Terrier or a Miniature Schnauzer.
My mum has a cocker and he's only young but great with kids. However I'm not sure about him as a therapy dog...I need therapy after two hours of continually being stared at until I throw his ball!

To be fair, working collies are pretty small - mine is 10kg!

Paradeofrain · 17/11/2023 19:41

AWanderingMinstrel · 17/11/2023 19:39

Of course but mixed breed avoids many of the inherited conditions of a pure breed.

Not true. See my response above. Some mixes are healthy but not all

AWanderingMinstrel · 17/11/2023 19:39

Of course but mixed breed avoids many of the inherited conditions of a pure breed.

Paradeofrain · 17/11/2023 19:39

The mix thing is such a myth. Theres no generic mix personality, a collie mix is going to be very different to a pug mix

2 bracy breeds bred together eg a pug and a bulldog will have the same health issues as their parents. 4 breeds prone to hip issues will create a dog with the same propensity for hip issues as a lab. It depends on what the parents are prone to

You have no idea what a mix can turn out like. It will have some traits of both parents in any ratio. It can develop the things you were hoping to avoid anyway eg. You can breed a labradoodle that comes with a lab coat, lab hips but a poodles sensitivity

ShatteredPeace · 17/11/2023 19:38

Border terrier all day long. Excellent family dogs, and extremely cute.

myotherkidisacassowary · 17/11/2023 19:37

YoDood · 17/11/2023 18:24

The answer is always a border terrier.

They are wonderful family friendly little dogs. Ours has done wonders for our eldest’s anxiety. He just finds her so cheering and happy - she jolts him from his negative thoughts and stops him spiralling.

She’s also been an attraction for people coming to see us on play dates, which has enhanced our kids’ popularity a bit.

Edited

Was going to suggest a border! Absolutely lovely little dogs

Cherrysoup · 17/11/2023 19:36

Toy poodle, border terrier, any of the vulnerable British breeds. Cocker is a good shout, but maybe avoid the working bred ones, they’ll be lively!

Paradeofrain · 17/11/2023 19:34

What does your perfect dog look like? Some people's perfect dogs are other nightmares!

What level of energy are you looking for? A couch potato that can miss a few walks when it's hammering it down or a get up and go dog that will play with the kids

What are your pet hates/any thing you really need to avoid? Food scrounging? Good with cats? How happy are you to have a talkative dog like some of the terriers above known for being noisy?

What level of shedding can you cope with? Are you happy to head off to the groomers every 6 weeks, a few times a year or rather a wash and go dog? (Bare in mind that groomers cost a fair amount!)

nameychanger5678 · 17/11/2023 19:30

Labrador. Loving and gorgeous. Beautiful looking. Border terriers are such ugly dogs (puts on flak jacket)

wetotter · 17/11/2023 19:30

AWanderingMinstrel · 17/11/2023 19:19

Experienced dog owner here. Son and DIL are vets. Mixed breed every time unless you intend to breed them.

Surely that depends what's in the mix?

Neverknewidfindmyselfonhere · 17/11/2023 19:27

We have a jug and she's a wonderful dog. (Jack Russell cross Pug) Small, doesn't need hours of waking, happy to sleep when you go out, great with other dogs and children, loving and none of the issues true pugs have. Can be a little bit yappy at the birds but a great family dog.

Playdoughcaterpillar · 17/11/2023 19:26

I have a border terrier/ jack Russell Cross. He's been easy to house train. Never woken me in the night. Never chewed any furniture etc. Loves to be with you and reasonably cuddly but happy to be left alone for up to 4h or so. Recall training was harder due to prey drive. Still not 100% at 2.5y

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 17/11/2023 19:24

Does it have to be a small dog? I would highly recommend a golden retriever but they are obviously not very small!

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 17/11/2023 19:24

We have a Westie. Lovely little chap.