Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Educate Yourself it May Save Your Life

57 replies

Onthepage · 17/11/2023 17:04

Please read the following link, this is the governments very questionable and dangerous solution to lack of medically qualified staff. These people are NOT medically qualified, please make sure you know who is treating you or your loved ones it could just save your or your loved ones life!
it is your right to know who is treating you and to make that choice.
This is the governments attempt to pull the wool over your eyes by spinning PA’s and AA’s as something they most definitely are not. They even get paid nearly twice as much as a qualified junior doctor who is responsible for them. Do you think that is reasonable, if you agree with me it’s YANBU!
https://www.bma.org.uk/bma-media-centre/bma-calls-for-immediate-pause-on-recruitment-of-physician-associates

Illustration of doctors and a map of the UK

BMA calls for immediate pause on recruitment of physician associates - BMA media centre - BMA

Press release from the BMA

https://www.bma.org.uk/bma-media-centre/bma-calls-for-immediate-pause-on-recruitment-of-physician-associates

OP posts:
Catza · 17/11/2023 21:43

therealcookiemonster · 17/11/2023 21:40

@Catza have you read about the recent patient deaths due to mismanagement by PAs who introduced themselves as doctors?!

where AHPs can play a vital role in providing certain services, it is very important for patient safety that roles are clearly defined and competencies established. I have worked with excellent PAs, but the degree to which the government is planning on using PAs to fill the physicia shortages is nothing less than criminal. patients will be harmed and are being harmed. there is no short-cut to becoming a clinician. ps nhs medic since 2010 so have had plenty of experience

I have zero issues with more regulations and defined boundaries. In fact the linked statement by the BMC is very sensible. Unfortunately, the OPs posts aren’t and appear to vilify anyone who isn’t “medically trained”. As a result, patients refuse to work with anyone who isn’t a medic which impacts on quality of their care. It’s become fashionable to bash the NHS though so I’ll just leave it at that.

Changedforthetoday · 17/11/2023 21:43

Papillon23 · 17/11/2023 21:39

PAs, if effectively regulated and well managed, could be a great asset to the health service.

The ones I know are dedicated, well trained, clear about their role and extremely trustworthy.

Yes, we need to make sure we have enough doctors, and increased numbers of trainee doctors would be something I would absolutely support.

But we have plenty of clinical staff who aren't doctors who do great jobs and there's absolutely no need to suggest they are dangerous because the public don't have a full awareness of them. Loads of roles that exist now either didn't exist or have a wider scope than they did before.

That doesn't mean that there aren't risks, that they won't make errors (no one can be guaranteed not to make errors) or that they don't need to be regulated, monitored and with suitable planned roles.

But the NHS is in a state and we need more clinicians and to create a sustainable service. Physicians associates, alongside other clinicians and hopefully and expanded number of trainee doctors seem to me like a great and sensible way to do this.

I am of this opinion too.

what currently sits uncomfortably with me
is the way the PAs are being targeted as dangerous - this seems like almost whole scale bullying.

i feel there is room for all here in an NHS that has huge staffing gaps and massive waiting lists it needs to be pulling together to pulling itself apart.

Papillon23 · 17/11/2023 21:43

nocoolnamesleft · 17/11/2023 21:39

I got asked to teach student PAs safe prescribing (something I routinely do with medical students, doctors in training, nurse practitioners etc) and I agreed that I would do it as soon as they could clarify who was their regulatory body, so I could ensure that it was consistent with their recommendations, as I always do for other staff groups. Only they don't have a regulatory body. They are accountable to no one. Which is terrifying. (Obviously I knew this when I asked)

That's not really the PAs' fault though is it?

The PAs I know all WANT to be regulated. But they can't compel someone to regulate them.

therealcookiemonster · 17/11/2023 21:42

@Papillon23 I agree with you, but they in no way can replace physicians themselves. they are simply not qualified enough. as it is we are severely understaffed (in all the roles, not just doctors) and the easy fix of getting staff from the EU is gone.

therealcookiemonster · 17/11/2023 21:40

@Catza have you read about the recent patient deaths due to mismanagement by PAs who introduced themselves as doctors?!

where AHPs can play a vital role in providing certain services, it is very important for patient safety that roles are clearly defined and competencies established. I have worked with excellent PAs, but the degree to which the government is planning on using PAs to fill the physicia shortages is nothing less than criminal. patients will be harmed and are being harmed. there is no short-cut to becoming a clinician. ps nhs medic since 2010 so have had plenty of experience

nocoolnamesleft · 17/11/2023 21:39

I got asked to teach student PAs safe prescribing (something I routinely do with medical students, doctors in training, nurse practitioners etc) and I agreed that I would do it as soon as they could clarify who was their regulatory body, so I could ensure that it was consistent with their recommendations, as I always do for other staff groups. Only they don't have a regulatory body. They are accountable to no one. Which is terrifying. (Obviously I knew this when I asked)

Papillon23 · 17/11/2023 21:39

PAs, if effectively regulated and well managed, could be a great asset to the health service.

The ones I know are dedicated, well trained, clear about their role and extremely trustworthy.

Yes, we need to make sure we have enough doctors, and increased numbers of trainee doctors would be something I would absolutely support.

But we have plenty of clinical staff who aren't doctors who do great jobs and there's absolutely no need to suggest they are dangerous because the public don't have a full awareness of them. Loads of roles that exist now either didn't exist or have a wider scope than they did before.

That doesn't mean that there aren't risks, that they won't make errors (no one can be guaranteed not to make errors) or that they don't need to be regulated, monitored and with suitable planned roles.

But the NHS is in a state and we need more clinicians and to create a sustainable service. Physicians associates, alongside other clinicians and hopefully and expanded number of trainee doctors seem to me like a great and sensible way to do this.

Onthepage · 17/11/2023 21:38

Therealcookiemonster, Totally agree thank you 😊

OP posts:
Catza · 17/11/2023 21:37

Onthepage · 17/11/2023 21:26

Summermeadowflowers, well said. I’m not saying that all PAs are terrible, but their role is limited and the public generally don’t know what they are or what they actually do! It is also another reason why junior doctors have been striking. Why do these PAs get almost double the pay junior doctors do? Doctors 5 years at uni, PAs 2. Doctors medically qualified, PAs not. Doctors can do surgeries and prescribe, guess what PAs can’t do either unless repeat prescription! Doctors responsible for PAs!

No, PAs do 3 years of clinical science, then two year masters in PA = 5 years in total.

therealcookiemonster · 17/11/2023 21:35

LakeTiticaca · 17/11/2023 21:30

They are not actually "medically unqualified "
My niece is a PA and she spent 5 years at university

the definition of medically qualified is having completed a degree (followed by an internship in medicine) and being continually assessed for competence and being under the jurisdiction of the relevant professional regulatory bodies.

let's not conflate matters for the sake of the argument.

Onthepage · 17/11/2023 21:35

Changedfortheday, Yes I have worked in the NHS for many years as have many family members. It has been dumbed down and dumbed down. I don’t presume to tell people how they should vote, or who they should vote for, that is a private and personal decision. I just want to raise awareness of what is happening in the NHS. People need to be aware of who is treating them and whether they are properly qualified to do so.

OP posts:
Badatthis · 17/11/2023 21:35

nocoolnamesleft · 17/11/2023 21:27

When our local university starting training PAs, they came to us to ask us to help train physician assistants. Then suddenly, they started calling them physician associates. Presumably because it's more confusing to the public.

Physician assistant is also very close to magician assistant and conjures (see what I did there) an image of someone in a sparkly outfit gesturing at a box they're about to step into.

Catza · 17/11/2023 21:33

Summermeadowflowers · 17/11/2023 21:10

@Catza we have a really good PA at my surgery but those sorts of posts are so annoying.

First of all, you always know who treats you because every consultations starts with "Hello, my name is XYZ, I am one of the physician associates in X service".

HOW can you know how every PA begins their consultation? Confused

Because I worked in the nhs long enough with enough colleagues in various roles to know that people introduce themselves and their profession when they first meet a patient. I have to say that the only time I am not seeing people introducing themselves is in GP surgeries but since PAs work in other settings too, I am not prepared to generalise this behaviour to thousands of other professionals across the NHS

LakeTiticaca · 17/11/2023 21:30

They are not actually "medically unqualified "
My niece is a PA and she spent 5 years at university

nocoolnamesleft · 17/11/2023 21:27

When our local university starting training PAs, they came to us to ask us to help train physician assistants. Then suddenly, they started calling them physician associates. Presumably because it's more confusing to the public.

Changedforthetoday · 17/11/2023 21:27

@onthepage I’ve been seen by a number of PAs in my surgery and have never had a problem with the service I get from them. In fact they’ve always emphasised their role definition to me very clearly and have never felt lied to or that someone was masquerading.

I have to admit to feeling a huge amount of sympathy for many in the PA role with all the bad press recently as I feel they have entered the service of the NHS with genuine reasons and now they are getting vilified and undermined in the press.

Make no mistake I believe Junior doctors deserve pay equality - and maybe people will finally wake up and stop voting Tory - but I feel there needs to be some protection in the current climate for staff in the PA role as it is becoming unpleasant.

Do you work in the NHS? How do you feel about the attacks on PAs?

Onthepage · 17/11/2023 21:26

Summermeadowflowers, well said. I’m not saying that all PAs are terrible, but their role is limited and the public generally don’t know what they are or what they actually do! It is also another reason why junior doctors have been striking. Why do these PAs get almost double the pay junior doctors do? Doctors 5 years at uni, PAs 2. Doctors medically qualified, PAs not. Doctors can do surgeries and prescribe, guess what PAs can’t do either unless repeat prescription! Doctors responsible for PAs!

OP posts:
lostinthoughts · 17/11/2023 21:24

I work in secondary care and work alongside PA's as part of an MDT. I would agree with you that often they are supervised by consultants. They in no way trying to dupe anyone into believing the are doctors. You keep referring to the fact they 'aren't medically trained' - what exactly do you mean by this? Yes we now they haven't done a degree in medicine, rather they have done a vocational medical degree which has a large overlap. They don't prescribe medications as part of the degree and therefore cannot make any medication changes or prescribe new medications. They carry out the jobs that the ward doctors would do to assist and lighten the junior doctors workload.

I'm the same vein there are some incredibly senior nurses/physiotherapists and paramedics who are considered advanced clinical practitioners who can carry out medical assessments and prescribe once they have completed necessary training. They don't have degrees in medicine, do you also feel like these people are duping the public too?

Pippu · 17/11/2023 21:21

"Hello, my name is XYZ, I am one of the physician associates in X service".
Nope. The one I saw introduced himself as a "physician". That would probably fool most patients into thinking he was a doctor. I knew what he was though I didn't comment as was feeling very unwell.

Long thread on the subject here.
www.mumsnet.com/talk/general_health/4940978-physician-associates-missing-diagnoses?reply=130754811

Echobelly · 17/11/2023 21:18

Not heard of this - thank you.

I can imagine that even if a physician associate introduced themselves, most people wouldn't know what that meant, so it's worth spreading the word.

DisquietintheRanks · 17/11/2023 21:16

I don't think YABU @Onthepage . After a disastrous appointment when what turned out to be whooping cough was misdiagnosed by a practice nurse I refuse to see anyone but a qualified doctor unless I'm there for blood to be taken or about ear wax.

Incey · 17/11/2023 21:16

Thanks for raising it @Onthepage , I feel strongly about this too!

Onthepage · 17/11/2023 21:13

I am so sorry to hear that you had to go through that Incey. I am just trying to raise awareness that we the public are being duped! Just want people to have the knowledge because it all seems to have been put into place under the radar!

OP posts:
ssd · 17/11/2023 21:11

Will this not be happening with private insurance then?

Summermeadowflowers · 17/11/2023 21:10

@Catza we have a really good PA at my surgery but those sorts of posts are so annoying.

First of all, you always know who treats you because every consultations starts with "Hello, my name is XYZ, I am one of the physician associates in X service".

HOW can you know how every PA begins their consultation? Confused

Swipe left for the next trending thread