Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance tax to be halved

208 replies

WildWhippet · 17/11/2023 10:18

The government intends on having the rate of inheritance tax in the autumn statement.

Is this a good move? Will it encourage you to vote for the Conservative Party?

OP posts:
LifeofBrienne · 17/11/2023 16:48

To fund the inheritance tax cuts they are cutting welfare. Literally taking money away from the sick and disabled, who are already suffering from austerity and rises in the cost of living. People are turning off their fridge because they can’t afford the electricity.

It’s making me feel nauseous when I see Jeremy Hunt’s smug face. I’ve always thought it was hyperbole to say the Tories were waging class war on the poor but FFS.

TitInATrance · 17/11/2023 16:47

It would be so obviously a tax cut for the wealthy ONLY that it would make me determined to vote against them, even if it meant voting tactically. Thankfully in my constituency that’s not the case.

Better to remove an essential product (domestic electricity? Shoes? Cleaning services?) from the scope of VAT.

Cordeliathecat · 17/11/2023 16:45

GasPanic · 17/11/2023 12:42

You can make the claim about being "taxed twice" on just about any tax though.

VAT, you have already paid income tax on the money you use to buy stuff with.
Fuel duty, you have already paid income tax on the money used to buy fuel.
Stamp duty etc etc etc.

It's another one of those nonsense statements, a bit like "we paid in all our lives".

No, the difference is direct vs indirect tax. Direct tax is a tax on your income, indirect tax is a tax on a transaction.

Generally, UK tax policies avoid double taxation which is why we have many tax treaties with other countries. Double taxation is tax being paid twice on the same source of income and is seen as unfair.

For instance, if I were to sell a business for £3m, I would pay £840k capital gains tax. If I then dropped dead the next day my estate would then pay a further £864k IHT on that same £3m income I had received.

That is why is some consider it unfair. The same pot of money is being tax twice directly which is against UK tax principles.

Parker231 · 17/11/2023 16:44

I would increase it so that there is more revenue for social services - hospitals, schools etc.

Shakeylegs · 17/11/2023 16:42

Cordeliathecat · 17/11/2023 16:14

In that scenario, you could look at it like that. But there are other ways people accumulate wealth, not just from a rising property market.

Some people earn it and save their taxed earnings. Some people pour blood, sweat and tears into a business all their lives, pay corporation tax, employment tax whilst working in the business all their lives then sell it and pay capital gains tax.

Of course. But their kids have done none of that so should pay tax when they receive the benefit of all that hard work.

Haydenn · 17/11/2023 16:38

Be better off looking at stamp duty and getting the housing market shifting again

EatMyHead · 17/11/2023 16:33

Inheritance tax should be 100% and impossible to avoid, as a general principle let alone at a time like this when so many are experiencing falling living standards while a small rich minority get even richer on the back of their riches.

But I'm not sure why anybody would be surprised at the Tories doing what they do, and serving who they serve.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 17/11/2023 16:26

Helping out the rich, as per!

Flickersy · 17/11/2023 16:25

IdleAnimations · 17/11/2023 16:18

When people say only 4% pay IHT, I’d love to see figures on how many fell out of the bracket due to funding their own care. This is an important stat I’m yet to find.

I doubt it would be possible to look into that on any real scale to be honest. The data would be too difficult to gather.

IdleAnimations · 17/11/2023 16:19

Callipygion · 17/11/2023 15:42

Old Rees-Moggy can sleep soundly now. I’m so glad for him, it must have been such a worry.

It wouldn’t affect him anyway. I’m under no doubt his money is in art, trusts, offshore accounts etc.

IdleAnimations · 17/11/2023 16:18

Weedoormatnomore · 17/11/2023 16:12

What inheritance! It will be used up paying for social care. So more like 1 or 2 % of people will get it.

When people say only 4% pay IHT, I’d love to see figures on how many fell out of the bracket due to funding their own care. This is an important stat I’m yet to find.

IdleAnimations · 17/11/2023 16:17

CurlewKate · 17/11/2023 14:29

So distasteful the way people with a lot of money scrabble around to find ways not to pay their dues to society...

So distasteful that some think it’s their right to take out of the pockets of others. What constitutes paying their dues?

For example is a high paying speciality Dr (82k average at that point) allowed to keep his money but a lawyer not?

Shall we work off morality points ongoing for who can keep their money? This is a very sketchy place to get to as a society.

Cordeliathecat · 17/11/2023 16:14

Shakeylegs · 17/11/2023 12:38

If you inherit a house worth £2m that your parents bought for £50,000 in 1974, for example, how has that wealth been taxed before?

The double tax thing also ignores the fact that all of our money is taxed multiple times. I earn money and it’s taxed. Then I buy stuff with the remainder and pay VAT. It’s fine. That’s how the economy works.

The only people with a potentially valid complaint against inheritance tax are dead. Anyone benefitting from a will is getting money for nothing, and so moaning about only having 60% of a million pound fortune left is ninja level CF-ery in my view.

In that scenario, you could look at it like that. But there are other ways people accumulate wealth, not just from a rising property market.

Some people earn it and save their taxed earnings. Some people pour blood, sweat and tears into a business all their lives, pay corporation tax, employment tax whilst working in the business all their lives then sell it and pay capital gains tax.

Weedoormatnomore · 17/11/2023 16:12

What inheritance! It will be used up paying for social care. So more like 1 or 2 % of people will get it.

IdleAnimations · 17/11/2023 16:09

tamsinrsmy · 17/11/2023 13:26

This sparked my interest as this week I had the pleasure of paying £200,000 in inheritance tax after my father died in the summer.

And whilst I am slightly annoyed at having to pay it I understand what a fortunate position my sister and I are in - we will still inherit the best part of £2million between us.

It probably could have been avoided if my father had started financial planning 10+ years ago but he felt on some level that he should pay his dues and contribute to society.

If we want to live in a good society we all need to pay taxes and this tax surely is the least offensive -its taking money from the dead who no longer need it.

For many people they have not 'earned' the wealth - it has accumulated because we have failed to build enough housing for the past 30+ years and so house prices have increased more than general inflation. The house my parents bought in 1978 for £30,000 will shortly go on the market for £700,000

I can see there is scope for reform - currently you have to start paying inheritance tax before you can get probate so unless the money is easily available executors may have to take out a loan to pay it before being able to access the estate.

I disagree. Your father probably worked hard to pay off his mortgage and set you and your sister up. We should not look at parents doing this as a negative thing IMO.

I’m really tired of the apologists feeling bad their parents set them up. Parents should want the best for their kids and this ultimately reduces reliance on the state.

It’s a death tax that isn’t affecting the super rich. The limit has not changed since 2009 I believe when prices of homes were vastly different.

In the south you’re having a laugh if you can get a family home under 400k, good luck convincing people to work hard to pay their mortgages off if they know it’ll be taken for care and then IHT if they try and pass it on. We already have abysmal productivity and stagnation in terms of spending and saving.

I get there’s a lot of envy and I get it as I come from a rubbish background myself and will inherit nothing. However; my children will inherit as much as I can give and how dare anyone tell me it’s not fair that I’ve busted my rump to make sure they’re set up unlike I was. They shouldn’t apologise for their working class mother hoping to set them up from beyond the grave after a lot of sacrifice.

Callipygion · 17/11/2023 15:42

Old Rees-Moggy can sleep soundly now. I’m so glad for him, it must have been such a worry.

Ginmonkeyagain · 17/11/2023 15:15

That is like people who don't understand tax thresholds.

I personally would tax inheritance (with some carve outs for spouses and dependent children, people inheriting all or part of their primary residence and some busenisses) as income.

WelshNerd · 17/11/2023 15:04

There won't be anyone affected by inheritance tax who will switch to vote conservative solely because of a reduction in the rate.

The narrative is relying on people being too thick to understand it doesn't apply to them. A friend told me the other day her mum wanted to put the house in her name now to avoid inheritance tax. She lives in a 3bed ex council house in South Wales. Tories don't have policies anymore - only propaganda.

80sMum · 17/11/2023 15:03

Personally I think Inheritance Tax should be abolished altogether. Very few people pay it anyway. Wealthy people who would likely be the highest payers jump through hoops to avoid paying it.

Edit. I forgot to add that it would take quite a bit more than a reduction in inheritance tax to convince me to vote for the Conservatives!

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 17/11/2023 15:01

Ginmonkeyagain · 17/11/2023 14:54

I find generally people are in favour of cutting taxes they think they will have to pay and increasing taxes they dont think will apply to them. Regardless of political affiliation.

Nope. Not true here.

I stand to benefit personally from the cuts to inheritance tax. I am not in favour of the cuts at all.

AlltheFs · 17/11/2023 14:59

It’s personally good news as my divorced parents were contemplating remarrying to help IHT as would only be payable once or something then (they have quite a lot between them).

But no, wouldn’t influence my vote.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 17/11/2023 14:57

Ginmonkeyagain · 17/11/2023 14:49

@Lemonyfuckit It is the same for CGT that is levied on properties that are not principal private residences. you may well have bought a property using post tax income, paid stamp duty and then pay tax when you sell it.

The basic issue is we need taxes to fund public services and as the population ages getting most of the tax revenue we need from taxes on income is going to be more challenging. Taxing the estates of the dead a reasonable amount seems to me like one of the less regressive ways to do it, especially since much of that wealth is from unearned gains in housing equity.

Edited

Exactly - for most 'normal' earners, their estates on death consist of their house, the gain on which as never been taxed, their ISAs, the gain on which has never been taxed, and for those with DC pensions, their pension funds, the gains on which have never been taxed. I have no issue with IHT, but I don't think it should discrimnate between those with and without children. Everyone should get the same allowance. Transfers between spouses should be exempt but that's it!

Ginmonkeyagain · 17/11/2023 14:54

I find generally people are in favour of cutting taxes they think they will have to pay and increasing taxes they dont think will apply to them. Regardless of political affiliation.

coldcallerbaiter · 17/11/2023 14:53

@tamsinrsmy how did you pay 200k tax on 2 mill? Would it not be 40% of the non exempt part which is 1 mill and you get charged 400k tax!?

Flickersy · 17/11/2023 14:51

coldcallerbaiter · 17/11/2023 14:47

@Flickersy
How do HNW do it now? What sort of fees are there? So many loopholes have closed.

Trusts are still popular as the IHT is spread, and it allows them to lay money away for future generations which can't be meddled with by the family - tax is not the only reason to set up a trust.

But mostly it's just sensible planning ahead, making sure you give away assets which are liable to IHT in good time, weighing up the CGT vs IHT payable on those, and insofar as possible trying to make sure you only retain those assets in your estate which can be relieved. And taking out life insurance which would cover potential IHT should you pass away (mainly only beneficial if you're young and very wealthy).

Swipe left for the next trending thread