Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance tax to be halved

208 replies

WildWhippet · 17/11/2023 10:18

The government intends on having the rate of inheritance tax in the autumn statement.

Is this a good move? Will it encourage you to vote for the Conservative Party?

OP posts:
Shakeylegs · 17/11/2023 19:14

Cordeliathecat · 17/11/2023 18:38

Being a kid of a small business owner is no piece of cake I can assure you. Rarely any holidays, often having to work in the business from young teens. Often the whole family is involved. All to try and improve the prospects of the family and to leave to your offspring.

IHT was originally created in order to tax the landed gentry whose families never paid tax as the vast wealth just passed down generation to generation.

As the thresholds have not increased in line with general inflation it now captures people it was never intended to.

Sorry but I just don’t see those things as reasons to either scrap or reduce IHT. It doesn’t even kick in before £1m for a couple. Recipients receive all of that first £1m and 60% of everything above that level. That’s extremely generous to the recipients in my view.

If small business owners prioritise their business to the detriment of their children like you describe, that’s not something that the tax system should pay the kids back for when those business owners die.

AnonyMuse · 17/11/2023 19:09

If they abolished IHT and applied CGT as and when assets were sold that would mean that assets handed down from generation to generation would escape tax entirely. Lovely for the landed gentry!

Leftinlimbo · 17/11/2023 19:09

AnonyMuse · 17/11/2023 18:40

Almost everyone, including most of the posters on here, are deeply ignorant about IHT, which is not surprising as it is a highly complicated tax. Until relatively recently it brought in very little revenue, as it is an expensive tax to collect, due not only to its complexity but also the historical info required in some returns and the fact that if assets are not sold following a death valuations have to be obtained by the deceased's executors and agreed by HMRC. The freezing since 2009 of the "ordinary" nil rate band at £325,000 has brought many more estates into charge and the legislation on the "residence" nil rate band is a nightmare. There are also convoluted anti avoidance rules. All that complexity and the need for valuations soaks up a lot of HMRC brainpower and the system is creaking under the strain. There is a good case for saying that that brainpower could be put to better use elsewhere in the tax system.
Yes, it is undoubtedly easier for super wealthy people to avoid IHT by making gifts more than 7 years before death than for those in the merely comfortably off bracket. The former can give away a great deal of wealth whilst being at little risk of running out of funds in their lifetimes, the latter have limited scope for that. But, generally speaking, CGT is paid in connection with a gift, either by the donor selling assets to produce cash to give away or because a gift of an asset other than cash is a CGT disposal, so it is not generally the case that the super rich escape tax entirely on passing down wealth. Indeed if you get it wrong by making a gift shortly before death, you could end up paying a great deal more in IHT and CGT combined than you would have done by holding onto everything until death.
The whole system is a mess and needs a radical overhaul or IHT needs abolishing and CGT needs to be charged on death on gains not taxed in life.

I agree with all of this. I do wonder how much the administration of IHT actually costs.

History has shown that raising taxes often results in lower overall revenue to HMRC as more people seek to avoid them or move themselves or their money and assets abroad. Reducing taxes encourages investment and helps the economy resulting in higher revenues for HMRC.

My hope is that a reduction in the rate will reduce the value of farmland. The current price of land is way in excess of the land's agricultural value, in part due to wealthy people 'land banking' to save IHT. As someone else mentioned, many of these people have no experience of farming and are 'pretending' to farm to gain reliefs. In the south-east, this behaviour has taken thousands of acres out of food production which is an appalling waste of a valuable resource.

DdraigGoch · 17/11/2023 18:49

It could do with proper reform, it's so easily avoided. Abolish the tax entirely, and instead apply CGT as and when the assets are sold. Also revert CGT back to Nigel Lawson's set up where it was set to the same rates as income tax, but with an indexation allowance. That should net the Treasury more money, stop people having to sell granny's house if they don't want to (the tax only applies if/when they do), and it would remove the incentive for multi-millionaires to buy up farmland as a tax dodge.

AnonyMuse · 17/11/2023 18:40

Almost everyone, including most of the posters on here, are deeply ignorant about IHT, which is not surprising as it is a highly complicated tax. Until relatively recently it brought in very little revenue, as it is an expensive tax to collect, due not only to its complexity but also the historical info required in some returns and the fact that if assets are not sold following a death valuations have to be obtained by the deceased's executors and agreed by HMRC. The freezing since 2009 of the "ordinary" nil rate band at £325,000 has brought many more estates into charge and the legislation on the "residence" nil rate band is a nightmare. There are also convoluted anti avoidance rules. All that complexity and the need for valuations soaks up a lot of HMRC brainpower and the system is creaking under the strain. There is a good case for saying that that brainpower could be put to better use elsewhere in the tax system.
Yes, it is undoubtedly easier for super wealthy people to avoid IHT by making gifts more than 7 years before death than for those in the merely comfortably off bracket. The former can give away a great deal of wealth whilst being at little risk of running out of funds in their lifetimes, the latter have limited scope for that. But, generally speaking, CGT is paid in connection with a gift, either by the donor selling assets to produce cash to give away or because a gift of an asset other than cash is a CGT disposal, so it is not generally the case that the super rich escape tax entirely on passing down wealth. Indeed if you get it wrong by making a gift shortly before death, you could end up paying a great deal more in IHT and CGT combined than you would have done by holding onto everything until death.
The whole system is a mess and needs a radical overhaul or IHT needs abolishing and CGT needs to be charged on death on gains not taxed in life.

Cordeliathecat · 17/11/2023 18:38

Shakeylegs · 17/11/2023 16:42

Of course. But their kids have done none of that so should pay tax when they receive the benefit of all that hard work.

Being a kid of a small business owner is no piece of cake I can assure you. Rarely any holidays, often having to work in the business from young teens. Often the whole family is involved. All to try and improve the prospects of the family and to leave to your offspring.

IHT was originally created in order to tax the landed gentry whose families never paid tax as the vast wealth just passed down generation to generation.

As the thresholds have not increased in line with general inflation it now captures people it was never intended to.

headcheffer · 17/11/2023 18:38

Seeing as there's now no maximum pension holding limit, surely the best way to avoid IHT is to make yourself as liquid as possible and then put it in a pension wrapper and name whoever you want to inherit as your beneficiary anyway?

Fluffypuppy1 · 17/11/2023 18:17

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 17/11/2023 17:43

I'm all in favour of getting rid of IHT altogether, along with SDLT (an irritating tax if ever there was one).

People are living in cloud cuckoo land if they seriously believe in this utopia where everyone will be equally rich one day.

This.

Inheritance tax is expected to raise £7.2 billion for 2023-24. Which is 0.7 percent of tax receipts.

The NHS costs £181 billion per year so only a tiny amount of that.

My neighbours gifted their £2 million plus house to their DC in 2015 to avoid inheritance tax. If IHT was around 10% the vast majority of people wouldn’t bother to try to avoid it.

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2023 18:15

kingtamponthefurred · 17/11/2023 18:11

I wouldn't vote Conservative if they guaranteed me life tenancy at the Ritz while hooked up to a perpetual orgasm machine.

Now that deserves a "promised" v "reality" poster ....

kingtamponthefurred · 17/11/2023 18:11

I wouldn't vote Conservative if they guaranteed me life tenancy at the Ritz while hooked up to a perpetual orgasm machine.

ruby1957 · 17/11/2023 18:06

ditalini · 17/11/2023 17:06

£500,000 on a property left to children/grandchildren (on estates under 2mil).

Remember, spousal inheritence is tax free and the allowance is also transferable, so potentially up to £1million on the house.

This is so often overlooked by those being disgusted that the government takes 40% when in reality a couple can pass over IHT allowance to each other, plus pass their property on so with a £1m allowance and only paying 40% of the amount left after that - they really are not hard done by.
Suppose a couple leave £1.5m in total - the IHT on that would be 40% of £500K. The beneficiaries would receive £1m + £300K - IHT paid £200k
As a singleton with a house worth £600k I feel it is a tad unfair that I would have to pay IHT of 40% on £100K even if I leave the house to a family member.

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2023 17:56

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 17/11/2023 17:43

I'm all in favour of getting rid of IHT altogether, along with SDLT (an irritating tax if ever there was one).

People are living in cloud cuckoo land if they seriously believe in this utopia where everyone will be equally rich one day.

It's a little like the idea of making everyone above average intelligence

updownleftrightstart · 17/11/2023 17:50

I'd be much more likely to vote for them if they doubled it

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 17/11/2023 17:48

If I died tomorrow my estate almost certainly would be subject to IHT and frankly that's fine with me. It seems only fair that my nieces - who would inherit - have a pay tax on a lump sum they've never worked for and that most other people will never get

If I died tomorrow, my estate would definitely be subject to IHT and frankly is is not fine with me. It seems grossly unfair that my children - who would inherit - have to pay tax on a lump sum which has accrued thanks in part to various members of my family working their socks off and never asking for anything in return. NFW would I want that money to go to HMRC.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 17/11/2023 17:45

FWIW, I was 100% determined never to vote Conservative again after Brexit and Lockdown. However, given that the Labour party was equally in favour of both of those completely shitty policies and the Lib Dems are a woke joke, I am going to revert to the Conservatives as they are the best of a crap lot.

Pinkitydrinkity0 · 17/11/2023 17:44

IdleAnimations · 17/11/2023 16:53

But are the truly wealthy paying IHT?

Thats the real question as they frankly aren’t. They’ve got loopholes they can access.

Yes, the truly wealthy are paying a lot of IHT.

If by “loopholes” you mean legislation, it applies to everyone regardless of wealth.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 17/11/2023 17:43

I'm all in favour of getting rid of IHT altogether, along with SDLT (an irritating tax if ever there was one).

People are living in cloud cuckoo land if they seriously believe in this utopia where everyone will be equally rich one day.

luckylavender · 17/11/2023 17:33

coldcallerbaiter · 17/11/2023 10:34

Good move. We are one of the higher IHT country’s in the developed world. 20% would still be high in comparison but is more reasonable. I see lots of threads on here about inheritance helping children and grandchildren get on the ladder or else they would not be able to, and rent forever or long term, so at least the money goes to the family of the people that earned it.

And wealth can never be distributed. The rich get richer. From the Party of 'levelling up'

Starsalign · 17/11/2023 17:12

Tories I am sure assume everyone will recieve an inheritance when that couldn't be further from the truth. Its weird it's always one of the more controversial ones when it doesn't affect many people at all; I wonder if it's because it's one that affects influential people more than others so they're more vocal (why would they bother advocating for others after all).

I think inheritance tax is fair in that many people who bought houses decades ago have amassed a really healthy rise in value- that chunk has effectively never been taxed and it should be when passed on.

Finteq · 17/11/2023 17:09

I would much rather cuts elsewhere.

IHT won't affect me anyway.

ditalini · 17/11/2023 17:06

purser25 · 17/11/2023 16:55

I understood that inheritance tax kicks in after about £350 000 most properties in the South East are more than that

£500,000 on a property left to children/grandchildren (on estates under 2mil).

Remember, spousal inheritence is tax free and the allowance is also transferable, so potentially up to £1million on the house.

purser25 · 17/11/2023 16:55

I understood that inheritance tax kicks in after about £350 000 most properties in the South East are more than that

IdleAnimations · 17/11/2023 16:53

Flatulence · 17/11/2023 16:52

It's ridiculous.
Only a tiny percentage of estates ever pay IHT but it does bring in much-needed money to the exchequer to pay for things that benefit society: schools, hospitals, roads, rail etc.
This move is simply a bribe to the "worried affluent" - who are almost certainly going to vote Tory anyway.
If I died tomorrow my estate almost certainly would be subject to IHT and frankly that's fine with me. It seems only fair that my nieces - who would inherit - have a pay tax on a lump sum they've never worked for and that most other people will never get.
If the Government wanted to help ordinary people by reducing any tax then cut the rate of VAT; that's a tax that massively disproportionately affects the least well off.
And I'd rather gouge my own eyes out with spoons than vote Tory; never have and can't imagine I ever would.

But are the truly wealthy paying IHT?

Thats the real question as they frankly aren’t. They’ve got loopholes they can access.

Flatulence · 17/11/2023 16:52

It's ridiculous.
Only a tiny percentage of estates ever pay IHT but it does bring in much-needed money to the exchequer to pay for things that benefit society: schools, hospitals, roads, rail etc.
This move is simply a bribe to the "worried affluent" - who are almost certainly going to vote Tory anyway.
If I died tomorrow my estate almost certainly would be subject to IHT and frankly that's fine with me. It seems only fair that my nieces - who would inherit - have a pay tax on a lump sum they've never worked for and that most other people will never get.
If the Government wanted to help ordinary people by reducing any tax then cut the rate of VAT; that's a tax that massively disproportionately affects the least well off.
And I'd rather gouge my own eyes out with spoons than vote Tory; never have and can't imagine I ever would.

IdleAnimations · 17/11/2023 16:51

Flickersy · 17/11/2023 16:25

I doubt it would be possible to look into that on any real scale to be honest. The data would be too difficult to gather.

It’d be fascinating though wouldn’t it? I do wonder what will happen when elder Millenials like myself don’t have the property or savings needed to pay for our care like our grandparents and parents are currently. It’s going to be pretty turbulent when that day comes.

This is why it sounds like I’m pandering to the rich (although I’d question what rich is to some) in my comments, but I’m concerned that we’re all already so up against it that stifling any further ambition to save or earn more money will lead us to issues further down the road.