Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I have quite strong views on prostitution

415 replies

Tonight1 · 17/11/2023 04:47

Not at all about the women, just that I would not want to date a habitual user! Or punter as they're called. And yes this came up recently.

This is discussion about how you would feel about it?

AIBU - wouldn't mind
YANBU - would mind

OP posts:
Waitingfordoggo · 18/11/2023 17:49

C1N1C · 17/11/2023 07:25

I agree with the above thoughts largely, but I'm interested in how people would handle the lack of sex.

To put it into context, literally any girl can go on OLD and be swamped with men after one thing... but your average man could message thousands and not get any interest.

So, while I agree, I am absolutely against prostitution too, what are people's solutions to that itch that women are (largely) able to catch ad libitum, but men cannot?

I’m honestly quite taken aback that you are asking women to provide solutions (in bold text, no less) to a male problem which causes untold suffering to women and girls.

I mean, wtf? They need to sort themselves out.

RosaGallica · 18/11/2023 17:25

@C1N1C I honestly do not care about the poor menz who can’t scratch their itch, as you put it.

Women are worth more than men’s itches.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 17:02

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/11/2023 16:54

Women just aren't important in your world view.

Why is that secretary sleeping with her boss for a promotion, or that actress hoping to get her first big break by sleeping with the producer (uncoerced!), or the sugar daddy idea, any different than consensual prostitution? It is sex for money, or gifts, a job, or a favour. With prostitution, rather than going to your boss, say, you're letting your clients come to you.

In all of those cases, the MEN are in the wrong. Powerless women sleeping with powerful men, having sex they don't want, involves a man fucking an unwilling woman. A woman he knows doesn't actually want to have sex with him.

I always wonder if one of the reasons women don't create a market for male sex workers who have sex with women (this is an almost non-existent market) is because women think about having sex with a man who finds them unattractive, doesn't want to be there, is doing it under sufferance, and is about as turned off as they have ever been. The thought of having sex that is unwanted by the other person is vile. But prostitution, and a vast section of porn, is based on unwilling and unhappy women. It's actually a turn on for many men.

Why don't men see the woman having a good time and enjoying it, wanting them, as an essential part of sex? How can they look at themselves in a mirror when they've just fucked an unwilling woman.

And everyone lying to themselves about most women being OK and most men caring, it's a lie. I've been friends with, worked with, known loads of sex workers. Seen one go out, face all puffy form crying, immediately managed to find a punter. She's dead now, overdose. I saw her sister just afterwards. I'm sure the happy hooker arseholes would be find with that pain as well. Much more typical of sex work than joyful PHD students who just love sex for money with unattractive men, because it's their kink. My eyes can't physically roll back far enough.

EXACTLY @MrsTerryPratchett - powerful scumbags coercing powerless women. And people like @C1N1C spmehow making out they’re equals

So on that note here’s an alternative viewpoint @C1N1C if you’re saying these powerless women are in fact consenting and have power. What about the 18yo adult living with her stepdad putting up with daily sexual harassment because she knows if she doesnt he will deceive her mum and kick you out onto the streets? That’s a woman using her sexuality a weapon to get her way isn’t it?

I ask for personal reasons. I always thought it was fairly despicable a stepdad would do that and never occurred to me to think the 18yo was in fact playing a part somehow.
What’s the difference? Go on, tell me. I beg you

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 16:58

User135644 · 18/11/2023 16:36

I'd say it's more fertile aged women who have the unlimited access to sex.

Young and attractive you mean.

So when someone had the power toots of sex their peers dont deserve the basic treatment of being treated like a human and not raped?

Is paying a 90 year old woman for sex rape then?

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 16:57

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 16:14

@TrishIsMySpiritAnimal @Tonight1

You both raised the same point, so I'm combining answers.

I think people in here are assuming no woman in prostitution is ever consenting to sex.

Why is that secretary sleeping with her boss for a promotion, or that actress hoping to get her first big break by sleeping with the producer (uncoerced!), or the sugar daddy idea, any different than consensual prostitution? It is sex for money, or gifts, a job, or a favour. With prostitution, rather than going to your boss, say, you're letting your clients come to you.

People in here always seem to take the extreme. Every prostitute has a pimp and is coerced. Every porn star is smuggled in from (say) Eastern Europe and drugged/forced into it. OnlyFans girls women are naive and talked into it by pervy men... While that me (often?) be true, there are/will be a large number of women who are models who realise men will pay money to see them... or OnlyFans women who realise men will pay lots of money to see them with fewer clothes... or prostitutes (low and high-end), who realise men will pay thousands for sex.

I'm not arguing for prostitution, I actually think it's really wrong... but definitely don't think every woman has gone into it naively. For many, it is a consensual, conscious choice

It’s honest do unbelievable simple - they aren’t consenting to sex. They’re consenting to sex in exchange for money. Otherwise they’d just have sex with the man. That’s coercion.

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/11/2023 16:54

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 16:14

@TrishIsMySpiritAnimal @Tonight1

You both raised the same point, so I'm combining answers.

I think people in here are assuming no woman in prostitution is ever consenting to sex.

Why is that secretary sleeping with her boss for a promotion, or that actress hoping to get her first big break by sleeping with the producer (uncoerced!), or the sugar daddy idea, any different than consensual prostitution? It is sex for money, or gifts, a job, or a favour. With prostitution, rather than going to your boss, say, you're letting your clients come to you.

People in here always seem to take the extreme. Every prostitute has a pimp and is coerced. Every porn star is smuggled in from (say) Eastern Europe and drugged/forced into it. OnlyFans girls women are naive and talked into it by pervy men... While that me (often?) be true, there are/will be a large number of women who are models who realise men will pay money to see them... or OnlyFans women who realise men will pay lots of money to see them with fewer clothes... or prostitutes (low and high-end), who realise men will pay thousands for sex.

I'm not arguing for prostitution, I actually think it's really wrong... but definitely don't think every woman has gone into it naively. For many, it is a consensual, conscious choice

Women just aren't important in your world view.

Why is that secretary sleeping with her boss for a promotion, or that actress hoping to get her first big break by sleeping with the producer (uncoerced!), or the sugar daddy idea, any different than consensual prostitution? It is sex for money, or gifts, a job, or a favour. With prostitution, rather than going to your boss, say, you're letting your clients come to you.

In all of those cases, the MEN are in the wrong. Powerless women sleeping with powerful men, having sex they don't want, involves a man fucking an unwilling woman. A woman he knows doesn't actually want to have sex with him.

I always wonder if one of the reasons women don't create a market for male sex workers who have sex with women (this is an almost non-existent market) is because women think about having sex with a man who finds them unattractive, doesn't want to be there, is doing it under sufferance, and is about as turned off as they have ever been. The thought of having sex that is unwanted by the other person is vile. But prostitution, and a vast section of porn, is based on unwilling and unhappy women. It's actually a turn on for many men.

Why don't men see the woman having a good time and enjoying it, wanting them, as an essential part of sex? How can they look at themselves in a mirror when they've just fucked an unwilling woman.

And everyone lying to themselves about most women being OK and most men caring, it's a lie. I've been friends with, worked with, known loads of sex workers. Seen one go out, face all puffy form crying, immediately managed to find a punter. She's dead now, overdose. I saw her sister just afterwards. I'm sure the happy hooker arseholes would be find with that pain as well. Much more typical of sex work than joyful PHD students who just love sex for money with unattractive men, because it's their kink. My eyes can't physically roll back far enough.

User135644 · 18/11/2023 16:36

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 14:26

Exactly!

In the same breath this ‘women have unlimited access to sex’ shows that the only valid women are the young gorgeous ones. Pretty sure my overweight 70yo neighbour isn’t at it like rabbits with any man.

I'd say it's more fertile aged women who have the unlimited access to sex.

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 16:14

@TrishIsMySpiritAnimal @Tonight1

You both raised the same point, so I'm combining answers.

I think people in here are assuming no woman in prostitution is ever consenting to sex.

Why is that secretary sleeping with her boss for a promotion, or that actress hoping to get her first big break by sleeping with the producer (uncoerced!), or the sugar daddy idea, any different than consensual prostitution? It is sex for money, or gifts, a job, or a favour. With prostitution, rather than going to your boss, say, you're letting your clients come to you.

People in here always seem to take the extreme. Every prostitute has a pimp and is coerced. Every porn star is smuggled in from (say) Eastern Europe and drugged/forced into it. OnlyFans girls women are naive and talked into it by pervy men... While that me (often?) be true, there are/will be a large number of women who are models who realise men will pay money to see them... or OnlyFans women who realise men will pay lots of money to see them with fewer clothes... or prostitutes (low and high-end), who realise men will pay thousands for sex.

I'm not arguing for prostitution, I actually think it's really wrong... but definitely don't think every woman has gone into it naively. For many, it is a consensual, conscious choice

Whatthefnow · 18/11/2023 16:04

@Tonight1 not contradicting myself at all. I was being paid for sex so in that sense I was being used but the men didn't make me feel like that.

It wasn't a bad experience to be honest. I did it purely for the money.

I'm fully aware it's very different for the majority of women.

Tonight1 · 18/11/2023 14:53

Whatthefnow · 18/11/2023 14:22

I escorted in my early twenties. I was happy to have sex for money and saw it as a transaction. My body was being used for sex but I never felt used. Did the deed, took the money and left.

You did slightly contradict yourself there...so you knew you were being used for sex. But at the same time didn't feel used after having said you were being used. So you did feel used but didn't care.

Glad you didn't come to any harm however.

OP posts:
bonzaitree · 18/11/2023 14:43

I would never date a man who had used sex workers. I understand why the women do it (money) but I don’t get why (WHY?) anyone would pay for sex.

You JUST PAID her. She DOESNT WANT to fuck you! What could be less sexy than having to pay someone so that they consent to sex?? It’s so fucked up!

Isheabastard · 18/11/2023 14:29

There is a website called UKPunting.com, where men rate the prostitutes.

Most of them just see the women as a variety of orifices and a paid for service that they can expect good service like rating a restaurant, or a product.

The men are not shy about their kinks and misogyny. The language and comments are utterly crude and vile. I’m female and older and I was shocked at how degenerate it was.

I got to it when I got into a rabbit hole when I was reading about a niche porn site that coerced young college girls (in the US) into porn. It ended up as a criminal case and the main perpetrators went on the run from US justice.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 14:26

CurlewKate · 18/11/2023 14:24

@TrishIsMySpiritAnimal "Women generally have unlimited access to sex if they wish to have it,"
So would men if they didn't want to only have it with beautiful women under 25....

Exactly!

In the same breath this ‘women have unlimited access to sex’ shows that the only valid women are the young gorgeous ones. Pretty sure my overweight 70yo neighbour isn’t at it like rabbits with any man.

CurlewKate · 18/11/2023 14:24

@TrishIsMySpiritAnimal "Women generally have unlimited access to sex if they wish to have it,"
So would men if they didn't want to only have it with beautiful women under 25....

Whatthefnow · 18/11/2023 14:22

I escorted in my early twenties. I was happy to have sex for money and saw it as a transaction. My body was being used for sex but I never felt used. Did the deed, took the money and left.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 14:19

User135644 · 18/11/2023 13:53

Most homeless are men. Sex work is often a lifeline for women.

being raped every day is a lifeline just because more men are homes less? What horse shit. there are services in this country for homeless people and particularly homeless women.

toddlermam · 18/11/2023 14:15

I would never, ever get with a man who's ever used prostitution in their life.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 14:13

User135644 · 17/11/2023 23:20

I think a lot of men nowadays are just expected to go without sex in reality, but then as you say MN forbids porn as well. They'd probably prefer it if men could just get their knackers done like dogs.

I'm very much against prostitution but male sexuality in general is frowned upon here. Women generally have unlimited access to sex if they wish to have it, so it's not a level playing field in that sense.

Edited

And that’s women’s problem how exactly?

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 14:12

XenoBitch · 17/11/2023 23:17

Same as some people I know. I mentioned one in a PP... and despite not seeing her in person for well over a year, she has been trying to get in touch on his various social media platforms. He was a clear mark, she exploited him for money, and now wants more.

I hope she succeeds. Serves him right

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 14:11

XenoBitch · 17/11/2023 23:14

And take advantage of vulnerable men...?

It goes both ways.

But the ‘vulnerable men’ are taking advantage of them first through coercing them into sex. But it’s unacceptable the other way round?

The fact you value a man’s wallet more than women’s bodies tells me everything I need to know about you

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 14:10

cariadlet · 17/11/2023 22:59

For fucks sake, did you never stop to think how desperate for money that poor woman must have been?

Did you wonder how many of the men who paid her assaulted her or refused to pay her or refused to wear a condom or pressurised her into performing acts which she found painful or degrading?

Did you wonder if she disassociated during sex to cope with what was happening?

Did you wonder would happen to her kid(s) if their friends found out what she was forced to do to make ends meet?

Did you wonder if she suffered from PTSD?

Or did none of that matter as long as you family member found someone he could pay to fuck?

well said

Women are so fucking dehumanised it depresses me

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 14:06

C1N1C · 17/11/2023 22:16

@cariadlet @AntonFeckoff

I appreciate both your views, but the average person does not want to live without sex.

In places like Australia, prostitution is legal and actually regulated, so in this situation, is it still considered 'rape' in your view? The women are there voluntarily and get paid good money for a service they willingly provide.

I remember a blogger saying that the average woman has the same access to sex as an A-list celebrity... this is certainly not true for even good-looking men. An average woman could ask 100 men and be reasonably successful... an average man would fail miserably.

Saying 'I can have sex any time I want, but f you, men, you have to rely on your right hand because those are the cards you were dealt' is a bit insensitive... akin to a man saying women have to sit on the sidelines at sport because f you, women, those are the cards you were dealt'. The ability to succeed (more) in each case is simply a 'perk' of each respective gender. Women biologically have greater access to sex, and men biologically are stronger and thus will outperform women at sport.

I'm asking the question, but honestly, I don't think there is an answer. OLD means that women can be very picky about who they bed, and as a result, there will be a lot of men without a sexual future. Prostitution has been used for centuries but is now being shamed. Porn would be a 'second best' but is equally derided (on MN).

@C1N1C so because women can get sex easier than men it means men can rape women if they have the money to?

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 14:05

I appreciate both your views, but the average person does not want to live without sex.

Boo hoo- doesn’t excuse rape

In places like Australia, prostitution is legal and actually regulated, so in this situation, is it still considered 'rape' in your view?

Yes

Tonight1 · 18/11/2023 14:02

@User135644 I've been homeless. Not street homeless but staying with a friend for a few months. Just cut back my expenditure.

I really didn't want this to be a critism of women who do this for money.

It has really helped me though as quite a few posters understood I was unhappy being sexually harassed by someone who goes to prostitutes frequently.

OP posts:
TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 14:01

Janeandme · 17/11/2023 22:00

This is unacceptable to me, and derides rape. As much as I am not supportive of men who use prostitution, it is not rape. By any definition. I do not support this sort of hysterical response. Nor do I accept it.

But these women are being coerced into sex they would otherwise have. How is that not rape?