Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I have quite strong views on prostitution

415 replies

Tonight1 · 17/11/2023 04:47

Not at all about the women, just that I would not want to date a habitual user! Or punter as they're called. And yes this came up recently.

This is discussion about how you would feel about it?

AIBU - wouldn't mind
YANBU - would mind

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 18/11/2023 19:34

TangerineNeonLight · 18/11/2023 19:26

And 'legalised regulated countries' @C1N1C - look up Holbeck in Leeds. There was at least one woman who couldn't 'walk away any time' because she was murdered by a punter. The council still went ahead with rolling out their legal red light zone, and they made every woman and child in the area less safe. They couldn't all walk away either.

And I suggest @C1N1C reads #2 on here. nordicmodelnow.org/2021/09/18/the-nordic-model-of-prostitution-a-change-in-perspective-in-protection-of-human-dignity/

I don't suggest anyone else does if they are trauma-impacted at all.

Legalised prostitution isn't nice and safe and a bastion of choice.

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/11/2023 19:28

How is this any different than say organ donation?

Umm I wouldn't support desperate people being offered money for their organs either.

It's not philosophy, or sixth form debate class, it's actually abused women being further abused.

TangerineNeonLight · 18/11/2023 19:26

And 'legalised regulated countries' @C1N1C - look up Holbeck in Leeds. There was at least one woman who couldn't 'walk away any time' because she was murdered by a punter. The council still went ahead with rolling out their legal red light zone, and they made every woman and child in the area less safe. They couldn't all walk away either.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 19:26

TangerineNeonLight · 18/11/2023 18:37

Also on the 'limitless access to sex' point - good sex? Or hair-pulling, spitting, choking, anal, rough sex emulating revolting and abusive pornography? Women might find it easy to find a man willing to have sex with them, not so easy to find one who's offering something enjoyable. Read the threads of women doing OLD and the endless dick pics they endure, the relentless unwelcome sex talk. Read a newspaper today and see that a third of women experience sexual harassment commuting home from work - just getting on the tube at 6pm and getting upskirted or touched inappropriately.

Maybe if men didn't create such a hostile sexual environment for women then they'd find more enthusiastic partners. But that would involve changing men's behaviour, and apparently we should just carry on exploiting and degrading women to 'scratch their itch' instead, right @C1N1C ?

Excellent post @TangerineNeonLight - the concept that men deserve everything that they want, at the expense of women getting a rough deal, props up the patriarchy. Women are supposed to be utterly delighted at the thought of the tiniest scraps of attention from men and if they aren’t there’s a problem with that woman not the men who covet her

TangerineNeonLight · 18/11/2023 19:23

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 18:54

@MrsTerryPratchett
You're not giving women a lot of credit here... you really think that everyone who has had sex with her boss has been coerced, they're naive, and don't know what they're doing? Yes, there will be bosses who make the suggestion, but an equal number of women who do it consciously with an endgame. Same as all these yacht girls... Where is the line between a woman who approaches a (rich) man and having sex 'grudgingly' because they hope they'll get perks, and women who have a genuine interest? How is a man to know?

Are you talking about prostitution in the real world or in some sort of 90s late night Channel 5 soft core erotica full of sexy secretaries in pencil skirts and low cut blouses? Are you trying to imply that all women are essentially prostitutes? Are you saying that because some women are 'yacht girls' and confuse men that others can't be expected to know that prostitutes are frequently trafficked, abused, addicted and traumatised? We know from Epstein and his ilk that plenty of glamourous-seeming young women who might have been considered to be willing hangers-on were in fact groomed, trafficked and coerced into sex acts they didn't consent to with far more powerful men, don't we? And do any of us believe that those men didn't know what was happening?

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 19:22

@TrishIsMySpiritAnimal

Again, I think you're not giving women enough credit... Why is a conscious choice for sex (for money), coercion? A woman who goes on OnlyFans, meeting up with guys etc, because she knows her body can make money is the same as a boxer. Both are decisions to risk your body/health for money.

"They're consenting to sex in exchange for money, otherwise they'd just have sex with a man. That's coercion. "... isn't it their right? It's their body. In legalised and regulated countries, women can walk away any time. How is this any different than say organ donation? It's your body, you can choose to go out and give your body (literally) to someone else in exchange for money. I'm missing the coercion part... A woman waking up and using her own energy to walk to that street corner is consenting.

CurlewKate · 18/11/2023 19:15

"How is a man to know?"

Poor lambs. All those conniving women laying traps for them. They never know how old women are either....

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 18/11/2023 19:00

I would not want to date a habitual user!

I wouldn't describe that as a strong view at all. I'd see it as strangely moderate. Only habitual users? I wouldn't want to go anywhere near any man who had ever in their life used a prostitute. I wouldn't be friends with them, never mind date them.

Carrotcake90 · 18/11/2023 18:59

No it would very much turn me off if they had visited prostitutes in the past , even if they didn't do it any longer. It would be a massive turn off and give me the ick

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/11/2023 18:59

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 18:54

@MrsTerryPratchett
You're not giving women a lot of credit here... you really think that everyone who has had sex with her boss has been coerced, they're naive, and don't know what they're doing? Yes, there will be bosses who make the suggestion, but an equal number of women who do it consciously with an endgame. Same as all these yacht girls... Where is the line between a woman who approaches a (rich) man and having sex 'grudgingly' because they hope they'll get perks, and women who have a genuine interest? How is a man to know?

How is a man to know?

Oh FFS. I can't be bothered. You just don't care about women. Don't bother pretending.

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/11/2023 18:56

@TangerineNeonLight I've known so many women, and a few men, over the course of several decades. The reality is horrifying. And I KNOW the men see that. They just pretend not to, hoping that women not in the trade will be too stupid or uncaring to notice. But most of us actually care about other women.

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 18:54

@MrsTerryPratchett
You're not giving women a lot of credit here... you really think that everyone who has had sex with her boss has been coerced, they're naive, and don't know what they're doing? Yes, there will be bosses who make the suggestion, but an equal number of women who do it consciously with an endgame. Same as all these yacht girls... Where is the line between a woman who approaches a (rich) man and having sex 'grudgingly' because they hope they'll get perks, and women who have a genuine interest? How is a man to know?

TangerineNeonLight · 18/11/2023 18:42

Thank goodness for your post @MrsTerryPratchett to counter the drivel about women making six figure sums and having a grand old time doing 'sex work' when your description is far and away the majority.

In an area of Leeds, the council experimented with making a legal red light zone. A woman was murdered in the trial period; they still went ahead with rolling it out. Schoolgirls in the area would be approached by punters in their uniform on the way home, mums with buggies would be offered money for time with their babies and toddlers. That's the reality of prostitution. Not some ridiculous fantasy of 'high class escorts'.

Disturbia81 · 18/11/2023 18:41

Tonight1 · 17/11/2023 04:47

Not at all about the women, just that I would not want to date a habitual user! Or punter as they're called. And yes this came up recently.

This is discussion about how you would feel about it?

AIBU - wouldn't mind
YANBU - would mind

No wouldn't date a man who even thought it was okay for them to exist. Nevermind use them
Nothing against the women really
Just the men who create the demand.

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/11/2023 18:37

No, it's work. Work means that you agree to do some form of labour you otherwise probably wouldn't do in exchange for an agreed amount of money; I don't do my job out of altruism, and I suspect very few people do regardless of what that job is.

You might not do your job out of altruism. That's fair. But do you do your job out of trauma? Because if you removed from sex work, anyone who:

Was pimped
Was trafficked
Is addicted
Is mentally unwell
Has a PD
Was abused as a child
Has any other avenue to feed themselves and their children
Doesn't have a safe home
Was trauma-impacted
Is in an abusive relationship

You'd be left with almost no one. And those women would be paid extortionate amounts of money, eye-watering amounts. The ONLY reason you can get a blow job for a few quid is addiction. Some men are paying a lot but most aren't. And the reason is adverse childhood experiences, abuse and addiction.

Neatly, what that means is that abusive men are paving the way for more abusive men. Some men abuse children, some of those children go on to be abused by other men. The truth is that happy, healthy women, with no abuse in their pasts, and other options, typically don't take up sex work.

And men don't ask BTW. Men will tell you they 'check' but they don't. They don't know if the woman they are fucking has her passport, has to do it for the next fix, is beaten if she doesn't. They simply don't care. And if you gave them the option, statistically, to be treated in the same way as the woman they are doing it to, would they risk it? If you said, "scratch your itch, but if the woman is coerced, a man will come in after and coerce you. If she is addicted, someone will inject you with heroin. If she is trafficked, someone will come in and take you to Romania or Somalia and take your passport away. If she is raped, a man will come in and do the same to you." Would any man scratch his itch then? Of course not. And what that means is that they don't see the women as truly human.

TangerineNeonLight · 18/11/2023 18:37

Also on the 'limitless access to sex' point - good sex? Or hair-pulling, spitting, choking, anal, rough sex emulating revolting and abusive pornography? Women might find it easy to find a man willing to have sex with them, not so easy to find one who's offering something enjoyable. Read the threads of women doing OLD and the endless dick pics they endure, the relentless unwelcome sex talk. Read a newspaper today and see that a third of women experience sexual harassment commuting home from work - just getting on the tube at 6pm and getting upskirted or touched inappropriately.

Maybe if men didn't create such a hostile sexual environment for women then they'd find more enthusiastic partners. But that would involve changing men's behaviour, and apparently we should just carry on exploiting and degrading women to 'scratch their itch' instead, right @C1N1C ?

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 18:34

It's not a resource that women are hoarding and refusing to share out fairly.

THIS!!

Someone upthread even used the term ‘unfair’. But as another PP pointed out - if a man can’t get sex or even a date he’s doing something VERY wrong and it’s probably to do with coming across to women like a POS who should be avoided at all costs. On the school run, in the supermarket and in public in general about 85% of men with their female OH have a face like a dropped pie. Lots of married men have the personality of a wet mop. Ugly men clearly are getting laid left right and centre - if you’re ugly/attractive/boring AND not getting sex it’s because you have something wrong with YOU and it’s certainly not up to sexually active women to solve that problem for you.

I wonder if these poor menz not getting laid have actually, I dunno, tried having a conversation, or tried to be nice or charming, or just make an effort not to be creepy weirdos? Doubt it.

TangerineNeonLight · 18/11/2023 18:28

User135644 · 18/11/2023 18:16

Prostitution is wrong and inexcusable. Fertile aged women, at least, have limitless access to sex in most cases. Both can be true.

There is something so dehumanising about this phrasing 'fertile aged women have limitless access to sex'. It gives me the shudders. It's the way incels and misogynists talk about women.

It's also such an irrelevant point. If women don't want to have sex with some men, it's not up to women to make that right for those men. It's not a resource that women are hoarding and refusing to share out fairly. I know a lot of men view it that way, but it's a grotesque viewpoint. And that doesn't become less true if some of the men who can't find a woman to consensually sleep with them are disabled. They still aren't entitled to use women's bodies.

I also hate the 'I do my job for money, what's the difference' argument - I have done some shitty jobs, but none that put me at hugely increased risk of rape and assault. No one wants their own mother, sister, wife, daughter or any woman they care about to become a prostitute. It's always for 'other women'.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 18:22

I also think the ‘sex work positive’ people who bleat on about ‘women can say no to anyone they like and choose their clients’ are deluded if they think this makes their ‘job’ less dangerous.

A man who lays woman for sex is always and forever, treating a woman as an object rather than the human she is. That poses a potential risk for EVERY ‘client’. She may well think she’s ‘chosen’ a safe man who won’t harm her - but unless a bodyguard watches over their sex how do you know until it’s too late that he won’t pull the condom off, rape her, go too far etc? You do t

CurlewKate · 18/11/2023 18:22

"who adults fuck and why is nobody else's fucking business."

Up to a point, Lord Copper.

User135644 · 18/11/2023 18:16

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 16:58

Young and attractive you mean.

So when someone had the power toots of sex their peers dont deserve the basic treatment of being treated like a human and not raped?

Is paying a 90 year old woman for sex rape then?

Prostitution is wrong and inexcusable. Fertile aged women, at least, have limitless access to sex in most cases. Both can be true.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 18:08

Waitingfordoggo · 18/11/2023 17:49

I’m honestly quite taken aback that you are asking women to provide solutions (in bold text, no less) to a male problem which causes untold suffering to women and girls.

I mean, wtf? They need to sort themselves out.

@C1N1C and other hate women. Men’s ‘itches’ matter more than women’s bodies. To @XenoBitch men’s wallets matter more.

Its terrifying

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 18:07

RosaGallica · 18/11/2023 17:25

@C1N1C I honestly do not care about the poor menz who can’t scratch their itch, as you put it.

Women are worth more than men’s itches.

Exactly

This thread shows people for who they really are - women’s bodies are no different to money or a chocolate bar you can buy in a shop.

Fucking grim

woMeN CAn fUCk WhOEvEr tHEy LiKe

Yeah - except they aren’t are they Einstein - they’re fucking people they wouldn’t normally fuck because they’re being paid.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 18:06

SocksAndTheCity · 18/11/2023 18:00

No, it's work. Work means that you agree to do some form of labour you otherwise probably wouldn't do in exchange for an agreed amount of money; I don't do my job out of altruism, and I suspect very few people do regardless of what that job is.

There will be people here who do jobs I wouldn't choose, but I don't claim that they're not able to decide to do them. I don't expect anybody would want to pay me for a shag, but if they did and I decided to take their money I am not going to be told by some random who's appointed themselves the sex police I'm not allowed to choose who I fuck and why.

Rape, kidnap, pimping and exploitation are illegal. Prostitution is not, because who adults fuck and why is nobody else's fucking business.

Saying ‘it’s just work’ like any other job is so fucking diminishing to women’s bodies.

A job shouldn’t involve the danger of rape and sexual assault. If it was then unions would be all over it.

A job shouldn’t involve having to give up your physical agency to someone who can overpower you.

You can fuck whoever you like - but let’s not pretend that ‘sex work’ isn’t coercion into sex through the medium of money.

The ‘adults choosing to fuck’ are often trafficked or in that position because they have no option for various reasons. How totally finishing of the many victims, and of women’s bodies to treat them like they’re transactional.

This woke agenda is so unbelievably anti-women I’m genuinely embarrassed for whoever buys into it

SocksAndTheCity · 18/11/2023 18:00

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 16:57

It’s honest do unbelievable simple - they aren’t consenting to sex. They’re consenting to sex in exchange for money. Otherwise they’d just have sex with the man. That’s coercion.

No, it's work. Work means that you agree to do some form of labour you otherwise probably wouldn't do in exchange for an agreed amount of money; I don't do my job out of altruism, and I suspect very few people do regardless of what that job is.

There will be people here who do jobs I wouldn't choose, but I don't claim that they're not able to decide to do them. I don't expect anybody would want to pay me for a shag, but if they did and I decided to take their money I am not going to be told by some random who's appointed themselves the sex police I'm not allowed to choose who I fuck and why.

Rape, kidnap, pimping and exploitation are illegal. Prostitution is not, because who adults fuck and why is nobody else's fucking business.