Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I have quite strong views on prostitution

415 replies

Tonight1 · 17/11/2023 04:47

Not at all about the women, just that I would not want to date a habitual user! Or punter as they're called. And yes this came up recently.

This is discussion about how you would feel about it?

AIBU - wouldn't mind
YANBU - would mind

OP posts:
TangerineNeonLight · 18/11/2023 21:29

You're right about one thing @C1N1C - you are speaking from a position of total ignorance and it shows.

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/11/2023 21:28

I don't really understand how hard it is to believe that some prostitutes do pray on vulnerable men... sex or not. They just see the money.

Yes, the main issue with prostitution is vulnerable male punters. Of course it is.

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 21:27

@TangerineNeonLight

Apologies for the comment. It's easy for people to make assumptions, or the common MN one of an amazing point being made but someone hanging on one word and using it as a weapon.

I have only ever had loving relationships too, and I've never known prostitutes, so I'll admit my opinions are borne from ignorance. I do believe, however, that 'some' women do choose the profession as they see it as an 'easy' way of making money. The high-end escorts for one. It's those minority cases that I'll admit I'm basing a lot of my assumptions on. Many above are saying sex in that position is still coercion, and I am still struggling to see it. Here, we have an often beautiful lady that is being paid (I'm basing this off Secret Diary of a Call Girl) £2000 a night to have sex with a client she herself has vetted. How is this anything other than a planned business transaction for a service like a massage?

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/11/2023 21:27

Still not understanding what point you think you're making about yacht girls.

@TangerineNeonLight yacht girls are a Trojan horse. If he can get us to agree that transactional sex is OK if everyone is cute, or rich, or privileged, then we are condoning transactional sex. In which case it's the same as prostitution. It's just a way to condone sex work.

The fact is that Leo DiCaprio knows the 21 yo model wouldn't shag him if he wasn't rich and famous, just as much as the grubby perv knows the street worker wouldn't shag him if she didn't need money for drugs. All these men are repulsive. None of the women are. It's just worse if the women are being beaten or given drugs or have passports withheld.

XenoBitch · 18/11/2023 21:23

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 21:16

Oh so now he didn’t even have sex with her - sure.

I don’t care if someone is disabled - paying a woman for sex is rape and I have NO sympathy if engaging in rapey behaviour has repercussions.

No, he didn't. I know him quite well and he can't lie at all. He shows me the messages she has been sending him, and I have been blocking them.

I have been in the town centre with my friend, and he pointed out the boyfriend. The boyfriend saw my friend and shouted out "retard" at him.

I don't really understand how hard it is to believe that some prostitutes do pray on vulnerable men... sex or not. They just see the money.

Maybe my town is a cesspit (I believe it is).

TangerineNeonLight · 18/11/2023 21:18

XenoBitch · 18/11/2023 21:13

The prostitute who robbed him. It was with her boyfriend. My friend was threatened with violence (and did go to the police). He never actually had sex with her. He would just pay for her company. In his head, he was helping her financially. She used him as a cash cow to fund her drug habit. He is unable to work and on benefits.

Bu yes, you condone crime against someone who is disabled and vulnerable. His autism meant he did not know he was being taken advantage of. His autism also means that he struggles with social situations, so he felt lonely and turned to paying for company.

Thankfully, he now has a good support network around him.

'You condone crime against someone disabled and vulnerable' - anyone defending prostitution is condoning crime against vulnerable women. Prostitutes are raped, beaten, assaulted and robbed all the time and face being murdered by their clients. Your friend should never have been using prostitutes, regardless of his inability to find a willing sexual partner. This thread is about how revolting men who use prostitutes are; the fact that you have an example of a prostitute who did something terrible back does not negate the fact that men who exploit women are in the wrong.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 21:16

XenoBitch · 18/11/2023 21:13

The prostitute who robbed him. It was with her boyfriend. My friend was threatened with violence (and did go to the police). He never actually had sex with her. He would just pay for her company. In his head, he was helping her financially. She used him as a cash cow to fund her drug habit. He is unable to work and on benefits.

Bu yes, you condone crime against someone who is disabled and vulnerable. His autism meant he did not know he was being taken advantage of. His autism also means that he struggles with social situations, so he felt lonely and turned to paying for company.

Thankfully, he now has a good support network around him.

Oh so now he didn’t even have sex with her - sure.

I don’t care if someone is disabled - paying a woman for sex is rape and I have NO sympathy if engaging in rapey behaviour has repercussions.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 21:15

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 21:11

You're misconstruing my point on this one. You're mixing up coercion with strategy. The 18 year old is being coerced into sex, or is being made to believe that sex will save the roof over her head. The point I was making about the secretary or yacht girl is more based on 'ambition'. A willing offer of sex for a step up (in a job or society). The woman has not been coerced but has chosen to do it in the belief she will attain benefits. I do admit there is a fine line, as you could argue that the yacht girl might believe the only way she could get those Gucci handbags is by doing it, but you would like to hope that hard work would likewise get her there too.

What am I missing? As I said, I'm open to be educated, but I see the above points as very different. One is a submission in fear, the other is a tool at her disposal.

Yes the 18yo is being coerced - so is the employee who will only get ahead if she has sex with her boss.

But interesting you draw the line at ‘ambition’. so women who want to gain something - money, a job - don’t deserve the same respect as the 18yo? AKA the attentions of an unwanted predator

TangerineNeonLight · 18/11/2023 21:13

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 21:11

You're misconstruing my point on this one. You're mixing up coercion with strategy. The 18 year old is being coerced into sex, or is being made to believe that sex will save the roof over her head. The point I was making about the secretary or yacht girl is more based on 'ambition'. A willing offer of sex for a step up (in a job or society). The woman has not been coerced but has chosen to do it in the belief she will attain benefits. I do admit there is a fine line, as you could argue that the yacht girl might believe the only way she could get those Gucci handbags is by doing it, but you would like to hope that hard work would likewise get her there too.

What am I missing? As I said, I'm open to be educated, but I see the above points as very different. One is a submission in fear, the other is a tool at her disposal.

Well why don't you have a think about why there aren't 'yacht boys' and what that tells you about the power dynamics in society, for a start.

XenoBitch · 18/11/2023 21:13

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 13:52

He was also robbed by one of them to the tune of £100s, and they would take advantage of his vulnerability

Good

Rapists don’t deserve respect

The prostitute who robbed him. It was with her boyfriend. My friend was threatened with violence (and did go to the police). He never actually had sex with her. He would just pay for her company. In his head, he was helping her financially. She used him as a cash cow to fund her drug habit. He is unable to work and on benefits.

Bu yes, you condone crime against someone who is disabled and vulnerable. His autism meant he did not know he was being taken advantage of. His autism also means that he struggles with social situations, so he felt lonely and turned to paying for company.

Thankfully, he now has a good support network around him.

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 21:11

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 20:52

So you get that demanding sex from a woman in exchange for something beneficial to her is wrong….but not when it comes to men only giving women a promotion if she sleeps with him?

You're misconstruing my point on this one. You're mixing up coercion with strategy. The 18 year old is being coerced into sex, or is being made to believe that sex will save the roof over her head. The point I was making about the secretary or yacht girl is more based on 'ambition'. A willing offer of sex for a step up (in a job or society). The woman has not been coerced but has chosen to do it in the belief she will attain benefits. I do admit there is a fine line, as you could argue that the yacht girl might believe the only way she could get those Gucci handbags is by doing it, but you would like to hope that hard work would likewise get her there too.

What am I missing? As I said, I'm open to be educated, but I see the above points as very different. One is a submission in fear, the other is a tool at her disposal.

TangerineNeonLight · 18/11/2023 21:10

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 20:20

@MrsTerryPratchett
No mask... not sure why that's reportable either. Just relating it to the yacht girl comment that a woman can voluntarily go on the boat, willingly consent to sex and it somehow be his fault as she's being somehow 'coerced'.I was actually seeking an explanation, as the comment seemed to have an agenda.

I appreciate everyone has different views, but I'm happy to be educated... I realise it's a touchy subject.

Still not understanding what point you think you're making about yacht girls.

For the record, I don't hate men. Just the ones who think they have a right to women's bodies, or that their lack of sex is an injustice women have to take responsibility for, or who use ridiculous examples perpetuating a false 'happy hooker' myth to prop up an industry based on torture, abuse and rape.

If you think hating people with those views equates to 'man-hating' then I'd suggest you have a lower opinion of your sex than I do. A lot of men don't think that way at all. And my life is full of good, decent men who I love.

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 18/11/2023 20:56

I could never be with a man that has used one, not even a one time thing.
It would be a deal breaker for me, no matter how much I loved the man in question.

Masterofhappydays · 18/11/2023 20:56

@C1N1C are you in a sexless relationship by any chance? Couldn’t possibly understand why 🙄

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 20:52

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 20:46

@TrishIsMySpiritAnimal

And apologies for missing that... I've probably missed a lot of comments (I have about ten people replying!)

I'm not trying to be a dick/troll (promise), the questions/comments are (you might have noticed), more out of a naivety but also genuine curiosity, and I AM happy to be educated if I'm wrong.

As for your comment about the step dad, absolutely wrong, (for those who missed it, a girl willingly engaging in sex with a stepdad to secure a roof over her head)... I would absolutely call that coercion. I would liken this to Epstein, as those women's careers depended on providing sex.

So you get that demanding sex from a woman in exchange for something beneficial to her is wrong….but not when it comes to men only giving women a promotion if she sleeps with him?

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 20:46

@TrishIsMySpiritAnimal

And apologies for missing that... I've probably missed a lot of comments (I have about ten people replying!)

I'm not trying to be a dick/troll (promise), the questions/comments are (you might have noticed), more out of a naivety but also genuine curiosity, and I AM happy to be educated if I'm wrong.

As for your comment about the step dad, absolutely wrong, (for those who missed it, a girl willingly engaging in sex with a stepdad to secure a roof over her head)... I would absolutely call that coercion. I would liken this to Epstein, as those women's careers depended on providing sex.

CurlewKate · 18/11/2023 20:46

"Man haters" is such a "tell". Anybody who is unhappy with the way some men relate to women is called a "man hater" in an attempt to minimise and silence her concerns.

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 20:20

@MrsTerryPratchett
No mask... not sure why that's reportable either. Just relating it to the yacht girl comment that a woman can voluntarily go on the boat, willingly consent to sex and it somehow be his fault as she's being somehow 'coerced'.I was actually seeking an explanation, as the comment seemed to have an agenda.

I appreciate everyone has different views, but I'm happy to be educated... I realise it's a touchy subject.

TangerineNeonLight · 18/11/2023 20:05

I don't really know why you brought yacht girls into the conversation, @C1N1C , but it feels like it comes from a woman-hating perspective.

Out of interest, do you think Epstein's victims were there of their own free will?

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 19:58

@C1N1C not going to answer the stepdad question then.

Youve tripped yourself up - women aren’t ‘doing what they want with their bodies’ re prostitution - MEN are doing what they want with her body

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/11/2023 19:55

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 19:53

I think people are misrepresenting what I'm saying. I've said above numerous times that I'm against prostitution. Trafficking, rape, violence... all wrong. BUT I do think women (everyone) should have the right over their own body. If a man with big biceps wants to make money by punching others, go for it. If someone with a nice voice wants to become a singer, fine. If a woman (or man!) thinks people will pay good money for sex with them, they should have that right. It's their body. I actually think people should have the right to suicide too... it's crazy how you don't have the ultimate right over your own body, but that's another conversation!
But I become against prostitution, porn and OnlyFans etc when there IS coercion of any kind, absolutely.

But truth be told, the bit i don't get are the man-haters above who think the 'yacht girls' are being coerced and that it's the man's fault. I'm open to the explanation there... A woman chooses to get on that yacht. She's often dressed provocatively and knows full-well the man will probably be attracted to her and will probably be interested in sex. If the man traps her on the yacht, he's a rapist, but if she engages in sex with that man with the hope he might keep her around and buy her stuff (consensual aex for downstream money)... I fail to see why he is at fault.

man-haters?

Reported. You let the mask slip just a little too much.

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 19:53

I think people are misrepresenting what I'm saying. I've said above numerous times that I'm against prostitution. Trafficking, rape, violence... all wrong. BUT I do think women (everyone) should have the right over their own body. If a man with big biceps wants to make money by punching others, go for it. If someone with a nice voice wants to become a singer, fine. If a woman (or man!) thinks people will pay good money for sex with them, they should have that right. It's their body. I actually think people should have the right to suicide too... it's crazy how you don't have the ultimate right over your own body, but that's another conversation!
But I become against prostitution, porn and OnlyFans etc when there IS coercion of any kind, absolutely.

But truth be told, the bit i don't get are the man-haters above who think the 'yacht girls' are being coerced and that it's the man's fault. I'm open to the explanation there... A woman chooses to get on that yacht. She's often dressed provocatively and knows full-well the man will probably be attracted to her and will probably be interested in sex. If the man traps her on the yacht, he's a rapist, but if she engages in sex with that man with the hope he might keep her around and buy her stuff (consensual aex for downstream money)... I fail to see why he is at fault.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 19:47

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 19:22

@TrishIsMySpiritAnimal

Again, I think you're not giving women enough credit... Why is a conscious choice for sex (for money), coercion? A woman who goes on OnlyFans, meeting up with guys etc, because she knows her body can make money is the same as a boxer. Both are decisions to risk your body/health for money.

"They're consenting to sex in exchange for money, otherwise they'd just have sex with a man. That's coercion. "... isn't it their right? It's their body. In legalised and regulated countries, women can walk away any time. How is this any different than say organ donation? It's your body, you can choose to go out and give your body (literally) to someone else in exchange for money. I'm missing the coercion part... A woman waking up and using her own energy to walk to that street corner is consenting.

No, the ones not giving women enough credit is men. By coercing them into sex using money they are treating them like a body part not a human. I want women to be treated as humans.

Can you tell me when a boxer ever risks being brutally raped or murdered when they step into the ring?

Organ donation for money is illegal. Why do you think that is? Have a long hard think.

A woman waking up and using her own energy to walk to that street corner is consenting.

What about trafficked women? Do you really think using your own legs to go somewhere = consenting to a dangerous misogynistic profession?

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/11/2023 19:44

C1N1C · 18/11/2023 18:54

@MrsTerryPratchett
You're not giving women a lot of credit here... you really think that everyone who has had sex with her boss has been coerced, they're naive, and don't know what they're doing? Yes, there will be bosses who make the suggestion, but an equal number of women who do it consciously with an endgame. Same as all these yacht girls... Where is the line between a woman who approaches a (rich) man and having sex 'grudgingly' because they hope they'll get perks, and women who have a genuine interest? How is a man to know?

If a woman is sleeping with her boss because it’s the ONLY way she will get ahead in the organisation - as opposed to a male colleague he doesn’t want to sleep with - that’s coercion 100%. And coercion is not consensual.

Id really like you to answer the question about the stepdad that I asked. The 18yo stepdaughter had an endgame of not being kicked out the house. It’s the same right? That’s ok for the stepdad to do because she’s willing to tolerate it for her own gains? Right?

Wotsitfappe · 18/11/2023 19:39

I haven't read the thread I will do. But my first instinct is that your views are totally normal and very uncontroversial.