Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I have quite strong views on prostitution

415 replies

Tonight1 · 17/11/2023 04:47

Not at all about the women, just that I would not want to date a habitual user! Or punter as they're called. And yes this came up recently.

This is discussion about how you would feel about it?

AIBU - wouldn't mind
YANBU - would mind

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ramalangadingdong · 20/11/2023 12:39

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 19/11/2023 11:05

Just curious what people would think in that situation? Would this guy get any slack for being young and naive?

At the time? No, I8 year-olds aren't babies.Years later, if they were genuinely remorseful and it had been a one-off and they'd treated women respectfully ever since? Maybe.

I agree.

I can barely remember being 18 but I recall not thinking of myself as a child. Of course I felt very young but definitely had very clear beliefs and morals - perhaps more passionately held than now as an older woman because 18 year olds are very passionate about things.

There is no excuse these days for a young man of 18 to be ignorant about issues regarding consent and very many would not allow their dads to coerce them into such an act at that age. Just think, if he could force his son to do that what else could he force him to do - commit murder?

Ramalangadingdong · 20/11/2023 12:30

MasterBeth · 19/11/2023 11:18

Either by

  1. Finding someone who wanted to have sex

or

  1. Not having sex.

Yeah, they can have sex with the “ad libitum” women who have put themselves forward through OLD.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 19/11/2023 18:19

TangerineNeonLight · 19/11/2023 12:27

It's such a simple solution, it boggles the mind the knots some people will tie themselves into to try to make the solution instead 'just rape women, it's the only possible answer to this very perplexing problem'.

Men could masturbate. You know, like I have to anyway, whether I have sex or not, if I actually want to orgasm.

TangerineNeonLight · 19/11/2023 12:27

MasterBeth · 19/11/2023 11:18

Either by

  1. Finding someone who wanted to have sex

or

  1. Not having sex.

It's such a simple solution, it boggles the mind the knots some people will tie themselves into to try to make the solution instead 'just rape women, it's the only possible answer to this very perplexing problem'.

Disturbia81 · 19/11/2023 12:17

The whole thing just makes me sick. The idea that an old man could buy an 18 year old.. God I hate the world.

MasterBeth · 19/11/2023 11:18

C1N1C · 17/11/2023 07:25

I agree with the above thoughts largely, but I'm interested in how people would handle the lack of sex.

To put it into context, literally any girl can go on OLD and be swamped with men after one thing... but your average man could message thousands and not get any interest.

So, while I agree, I am absolutely against prostitution too, what are people's solutions to that itch that women are (largely) able to catch ad libitum, but men cannot?

Either by

  1. Finding someone who wanted to have sex

or

  1. Not having sex.
Masterofhappydays · 19/11/2023 11:06

CurlewKate · 19/11/2023 10:56

I do find some of this thread very depressing. There is no way of knowing whether a prostituted woman or a woman in a porn video is there because she has made an entirely autonomous choice or whether she is coerced, trafficked or in any other way abused. This is an incontrovertible fact. But people are still saying "What about men's needs/wants? What about this individual man-what about him? He has a disability. He was abused by his father. He is damaged. How are his needs going to be met without prostituted women?" Well yes-it's very sad-but the solution is not to exploit women. It's not women's job to fix men!

100%

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 19/11/2023 11:05

Just curious what people would think in that situation? Would this guy get any slack for being young and naive?

At the time? No, I8 year-olds aren't babies.Years later, if they were genuinely remorseful and it had been a one-off and they'd treated women respectfully ever since? Maybe.

CurlewKate · 19/11/2023 10:56

I do find some of this thread very depressing. There is no way of knowing whether a prostituted woman or a woman in a porn video is there because she has made an entirely autonomous choice or whether she is coerced, trafficked or in any other way abused. This is an incontrovertible fact. But people are still saying "What about men's needs/wants? What about this individual man-what about him? He has a disability. He was abused by his father. He is damaged. How are his needs going to be met without prostituted women?" Well yes-it's very sad-but the solution is not to exploit women. It's not women's job to fix men!

heartofglass23 · 19/11/2023 10:45

I would never speak to a man again that had ever paid for sex.

TangerineNeonLight · 19/11/2023 10:07

Famously, Russell Brand's father took him to prostitutes when he was a teenager and no doubt such an upbringing fucked him up and instilled horrendous attitudes within him. He's clearly not a good person to date, as per the OP's question @C1N1C .

Eighteen year olds are very young, but still capable of having empathy for others and seeing women as human. Everyone is a product of the environment in which they were raised, but still has to take responsibility for their choices. And when that choice means dehumanising women and stripping away their choices (even if their own legs took them there as you suggested upthread as the barometer for consent, let's not forget) then that will certainly have an impact on how others view you.

There is a lot of acrobatic reaching for some way to make men the real victims on this thread and it's extremely informative.

C1N1C · 19/11/2023 09:57

@TangerineNeonLight

That was not my intent. We're not going to cover every prostitution topic in one thread, but what I raised was a true account, and one I felt was relevant to the OP's original question of could you overlook someone who had been to a prostitute. In his situation, him being also (in my perception) a victim does not diminish her situation at all. Both sides can be traumatised.

As I said, truthfully, I have no idea whether this was inherently in his nature too...he might have enjoyed it, he might have asked for it, but I'd like to think positively and assume this was his father's doing, and as such, consider it a form of inflicted abuse. I'm not trying to shift the attention away from the trauma these women suffer, merely getting back onto the original question.

Planesmistakenforstars · 19/11/2023 09:44

It is completely impossible to know if a sex worker is trafficked, threatened, or otherwise under duress. In which case any man who buys sex is okay with there being a chance of raping someone, and can get aroused and go through with it knowing that could be the case. Just so they can wank into that person's body. I wouldn't date anyone who remotely thought it was okay.

TangerineNeonLight · 19/11/2023 09:15

I feel, @C1N1C , that you've gone away desperate to conjure up a gotcha scenario to open the door to 'oh it's ok if...'

I'm sure plenty of misogynist rapists learned it from the misogynist rapists who went before them. It doesn't make a difference to the amount of harm done to women so please stop searching for a hypothetical scene in which you can make it all about men's feelings.

C1N1C · 19/11/2023 08:52

When I was 18 on sixth form (is that the age? It's been so long!), one of my friends was 'bought' a prostitute by his father to, I guess, get him started/familiar etc... which I think is abhorrent. It's instilling a belief that women are just objects.

Just curious what people would think in that situation? Would this guy get any slack for being young and naive? Is the damage done? I didn't respect him after that, and if I were an interested female party, the ick factor would put me right off. However, upon reflection, there's a part of me that sees it as parental abuse. He was coerced by his father. I know we can't see inside his head, and people will argue men can't 'perform' without desire, which is largely true... but if he was egged on to follow through with it under duress, is there not a rape parallel here? Sadly, I know this is not uncommon in some societies...

I'm definitely not in any way saying it is comparable, or as serious as true rape (apologies if it came out that way)... but it is forced sex without desire/approval.

KimberleyClark · 19/11/2023 07:43

I agree. Wouldn’t be interested in a man who thought going to strip/lap dancing clubs was ok either. Decent men don’t.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 19/11/2023 07:37

XenoBitch · 19/11/2023 01:52

You see me?
He never had sex with anyone... he wanted company. I have said that several times.
The lady he saw exploited him, and threatened with violence with her boyfriend and my friend made that known to the police.
Like I said, I am still helping him shut down messages from social media.

Why on earth can you not seen that there are prostitutes out there that are prey on vulnerable people?
My friend is one, and I see them out and about with men that have profound learning disabilities. Theses men most likely can not consent at all, because they just don't understand.

The men who pay to put their dicks into these women don't care whether the women are trafficked, pimped, battered, deliberately made dependent on drugs, groomed into it as a child, etc. And you expect a woman who has at least one of the above done to her to a) have a sufficiently-undistorted concept of "consent" to recognise someone who lacks capacity, and b) to have the luxury of being able to care about that in a situation where turning down punters' money means being battered, going cold turkey, or going hungry.

Tonight1 · 19/11/2023 07:33

I mean that I want them to be loved and taken care of

OP posts:
Tonight1 · 19/11/2023 07:31

I think @XenoBitch is coming from a good place, even if a little misguided about the wider impacts.

This really made me think about my female friends though, if anyone went into prostitution I wouldn't lock them into a cupboard or such, but I would be very hissy and impatient and want to vet the men. No chance a weirdo would hurt them if I had anything to do with it.

OP posts:
VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 19/11/2023 07:23

XenoBitch · 19/11/2023 04:08

Yeah, I am pretty upset by some of the comments about my friend here TBH.
But funnily enough, no comments about my other friend who slept with a prostitute to get back at his wife. Why is that?
I am stepping away now, because my autistic friend has been a rock to me, and is a beautiful person... at one time was very lonely and lacking the skills in what to do. I do not hold it against him.

But funnily enough, no comments about my other friend who slept with a prostitute to get back at his wife. Why is that?

Because you are not defending the cheat, so no comment is required.

I am concerned for you about your choice of friends. Two men who have used prostituted women, one to hurt his wife, these are not people I'd choose to be around.

TangerineNeonLight · 19/11/2023 07:15

XenoBitch · 19/11/2023 04:08

Yeah, I am pretty upset by some of the comments about my friend here TBH.
But funnily enough, no comments about my other friend who slept with a prostitute to get back at his wife. Why is that?
I am stepping away now, because my autistic friend has been a rock to me, and is a beautiful person... at one time was very lonely and lacking the skills in what to do. I do not hold it against him.

The thread has been enormously derailed by endless discussion about this one man. His disabilities and vulnerability do not give him the right to buy women. The harm that prostitution does to women - vulnerable women - far outweighs the harm it does to men. That doesn't mean there is no harm to men - you have given us one, extremely torturous and ever-changing, story about an evil prostitute and her poor innocent male victim. Fine. But for every man like your friend (and if a woman's choice is to be raped for money or to steal money from someone vulnerable I think we can at least agree that's not a great choice and we can empathise with the decision to do the latter!) there are hundreds of thousands of women suffering far more.

The thread is about dating a man with a history of paying for sex. It's a no - to your friend who did it out of revenge, to your autistic friend, to any other men who think for whatever reason that they are more entitled to sex than women are entitled to bodily autonomy.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 19/11/2023 07:15

XenoBitch · 19/11/2023 00:33

Are you an autistic woman who managed to have a normal relationship?
Women of all types, autistic or not, find it so much easier to find a partner.
An autistic man, and someone who also had physical disabilities, not so much at all.

Women of all types, autistic or not, find it so much easier to find an abuser. FTFY. It's far harder for a woman to find a decent safe-to-be-around man than it is for a man to find a decent safe-to-be-around woman because so many men use porn or use prostituted women.

I wouldn't call my relationships "normal". I can think of exactly one that didn't involve the man lying to me, emotionally blackmailing me, cheating on me, or manipulating me. Because I'm autistic, I'm vulnerable to mistreatment.

There are men out there who prey on vulnerable women, actively seek us out. There are men out there who fetishise disabilities. Believe me when I say that women are not in any way privileged through being preyed on by these men.

In any case, I still don't care what someone's excuse is, they don't get a licence to pay to rape.

XenoBitch · 19/11/2023 04:08

FourteenTog · 19/11/2023 03:58

Maybe @XenoBitch could make a different thread about this person, maybe on a different site? He did whatever he did. He suffers however he suffers. Buying women is WRONG and this thread is about that, not about how some vulnerable people exploit other vulnerable people. The OP was not suggesting she was considering becoming a carer, and does not sound like an enabler. She was thinking through a RELATIONSHIP. And the point stands. The fuckuppery of punters makes them undesirable partners, whether they are Jack the Ripper or a poor lamb.

Edited

Yeah, I am pretty upset by some of the comments about my friend here TBH.
But funnily enough, no comments about my other friend who slept with a prostitute to get back at his wife. Why is that?
I am stepping away now, because my autistic friend has been a rock to me, and is a beautiful person... at one time was very lonely and lacking the skills in what to do. I do not hold it against him.

FourteenTog · 19/11/2023 03:58

Maybe @XenoBitch could make a different thread about this person, maybe on a different site? He did whatever he did. He suffers however he suffers. Buying women is WRONG and this thread is about that, not about how some vulnerable people exploit other vulnerable people. The OP was not suggesting she was considering becoming a carer, and does not sound like an enabler. She was thinking through a RELATIONSHIP. And the point stands. The fuckuppery of punters makes them undesirable partners, whether they are Jack the Ripper or a poor lamb.

XenoBitch · 19/11/2023 02:42

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 19/11/2023 02:34

Again, with the making things up - when did I say that was ok? Why are you trying to make me out to be ableist?

You say he doesn’t know the normal way to get a relationship but yet something told him to go and coerce women into sex. He has been able to do that with no problem. How convenient that of all the things he was able to do (a man supposedly incapable of forming connections) using prostitutes was his the one thing he has done again and again.

I feel awful for telling his story here, but I am defending him.
He was approached in the street. I see it all the time.. the prostitutes here are rather forward.
Bless him, he told me he was awful at sex because he had no idea what he was doing (in his 40s). He did it once, considered it awful and was not into it again. However, he wanted female company.. hugs and chat. He ended up with a prostitute who he did not sleep with, but he spent a lot of time with. She ended up robbing him (along with her boyfriend) to the tune of £100s.
That was a year ago, and she is now trying to get back in touch (to get money). I have been helping block her and learn that she is toxic and trying to take advantage of him.
I have seen the same lady in town (yes, Swindon), with people with profound LD, and disabilities.