Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not plate my 10 year old's pizza?

486 replies

Mastmw7g · 17/11/2023 04:05

DH does most of the cooking and tends to cater to DD. I've become concerned that she will not eat when hungry unless he puts food in front of her. He was out and we had pizza. She told me she didn't see her plate. I said to then grab a plate and join me. She said no and went to her room without eating. DH came home and became upset that she hadn't eaten and said I should have put her pizza on a plate for her.

OP posts:
Heronwatcher · 17/11/2023 13:39

Sorry I think YABU. If we were eating pizza as a family we’d either all be sitting around the table with plates and the pizza in front of us so we’d be helping ourselves (and helping the younger kids if necessary), or I would plate it up (say if we were eating in the other room) and give a plate of food to everyone. That’s not mollycoddling.

If I knew my kids hadn’t eaten dinner I’d give them the option for a slice of toast or something.

Kids of 10 don’t always see consequences to their actions.

If my kids say they’re hungry I ask them to suggest something they would like to eat, and if sensible I will help them with it, like direct them to the right place or say whether we’ve got it or not.

LittleBearPad · 17/11/2023 13:29

HoppingPavlova · 17/11/2023 11:22

@LittleBearPad Thats really depressing

How so? How the hell would he know how many of them were home, and wanting dinner (not going out for it). You seriously want him to go all around the house, see how many are home and take a survey on who is staying in for the night and wanting dinner, as some may have had it before getting home. Then warm up plates (apparently that’s a standard), and plate up? Hilarious. Hilarious. But sure, depressing ………..

Do I know who’s eating dinner in my house, yes. It’s mad, I know, but I talk to my family.

Do I call everyone down to dinner and then serve and all eat together around a table, also yes.

FourStringsNoWaiting · 17/11/2023 13:20

Just seen your comment that you didn't do it for her because she "didn't even ask" you to

Ok, I won't wash school uniform or make packed lunches or pay the mortgage until my DD asks me to 🙄

You're the parent, your DD - who is TEN - should not have to ask you to parent her ffs

jlpth · 17/11/2023 13:03

YABU

The reason for her not getting a plate and putting the pizza on it is not relevant. She's a child and she needs to eat. You're her mum and you need to ensure that happens.

There could be anything going on from ASD/anxiety to an attitude problem to simply having had a bad day and feeling tired. Doesn't matter. You need to be the parent and make sure she's eaten. Your dh was right.

Night409 · 17/11/2023 13:02

followmyflow · 17/11/2023 11:28

everyone please. however you eat dinner is fine. plated up warm plates, everyone serves themselves whatever. some people do it one way some the other some a mix. the problem is that OP, knowing her daughter is struggling with this, purposefully made some kind of power play over dinner instead of ensuring her 10 year old child is fed and not hungry. this one single dinner is not so important that OP had to go so far to prove a point. if her daughter genuinely has issues and OP and her husband need to work through them then that should be tackled. but not like this. OP is being so heavy handed and nasty trying to wrestle with her daughter over this one meal. the daughter can obviously sense this which is why she, regardless of being hungry, took herself to her room instead when she saw what OP was doing.

I completely agree!

Night409 · 17/11/2023 13:00

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 17/11/2023 12:32

My reply to you got deleted. Do an Advanced Search for this poster's threads and see what she has said about her daughters before. This prior posting gives important context.

I agree.

At the very least this poster struggles to parent.

The fact that the issues are always with the daughters and never the sons is quite concerning.

Night409 · 17/11/2023 12:58

HoppingPavlova · 17/11/2023 12:23

@Night409 I would give her step by step instructions and take over if she needed me to.
E.g pick up a plate. Which slice do you want. Use your hands/the spatula to pick it up

At 10yo? That’s normal for 5yo but at 10yo? I have one who has ASD/ADHD/GAD/OCD and every other letter under the sun. Even then that would have been REALLY unusual for 10yo.

Yes a 10yo.

I work with kids older than her and many need step by step instructions.

She is struggling for a reason.

Giving her step by step instructions will allow OP to see where she starts hesitating and help figure out the issue.

But it also helps if DD gets overwhelmed with it all, just to break it down into steps.

Some people can just learn things easily and pick them up without being taught.
Some people need a bit of extra support and need to be actually taught how to do things in a very basic way.

porridgeisbae · 17/11/2023 12:48

Many people's dining conventions here sound odd to me but that's by the by. We always had a family meal and of course we'd check who was in before it was made.

@Mastmw7g But it seems like you're playing some sort of games with your DD. Stop that unless you want to encourage her to have a complex. Kids and adolescents can be weird but you should've tried to get her to come down and have some food IMHO after she went off, rather than just ignoring it.

Wolvesart · 17/11/2023 12:43

The concept of family meal would always apply in this house even if it’s the DC and I having a cheeky Deliveroo in front of the telly. I’d usually order the food and therefore be the one answering the door. I might ask DC to get the plates out or I might - but there’s no dinner scenario in which individuals get their own plates out but not anyone else’s.

After reading this thread I’m picturing houses across the country with queues at the cupboard, queues at the pizza box and last in the queue moaning cos some hollow legged teenager has taken nearly all the food.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 17/11/2023 12:32

SaltedPies · 17/11/2023 10:03

What is she saying about her dds? 😔

@MrsSkylerWhite I somehow doubt the op makes roast dinner and lovingly gathers her family round the table.

Shame on the posters validating a neglectful and possibly abusive parent.

Edited

My reply to you got deleted. Do an Advanced Search for this poster's threads and see what she has said about her daughters before. This prior posting gives important context.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 17/11/2023 12:28

Highlighting a poster's thread history for context gets a deletion? That's daft, anyone can carry out an Advanced Search.

HoppingPavlova · 17/11/2023 12:23

@Night409 I would give her step by step instructions and take over if she needed me to.
E.g pick up a plate. Which slice do you want. Use your hands/the spatula to pick it up

At 10yo? That’s normal for 5yo but at 10yo? I have one who has ASD/ADHD/GAD/OCD and every other letter under the sun. Even then that would have been REALLY unusual for 10yo.

HoppingPavlova · 17/11/2023 12:20

How dare a little girl want to sleep?

Think you are missing a plum piece of info there. It was after 10am and the kid was cracking it that their siblings noise was keeping them from sleeping. Not 5am, not even 7am, but the kid felt genuinely entitled not to have sleep disturbed by household noise at 10am. That’s not a normal requirement for a child to dictate.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 17/11/2023 12:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Night409 · 17/11/2023 11:52

If this was me I would stand by the pizza and watch and assist everyone taking a slice.

I would then watch my DD and see which part she’s struggling with.
I would assume that the youngest may sometimes need help too.

I would give her step by step instructions and take over if she needed me to.
E.g pick up a plate. Which slice do you want. Use your hands/the spatula to pick it up.

If any of those steps she starts hesitating, then remind her how to do it and then ask if she wants you to do it instead.

A PP said it sounds distant and I have to agree.

You know that for whatever reason she chooses to go hungry rather than plate her food up and so instead of trying to help her or do it for her, you let her go hungry.

Next time do it for her but have her there with you to watch how you do it.
Get her involved - ask her to pass you a plate and point to which slice she wants.

Don’t get frustrated with her and see how she gets on.
Keep doing this until she is confident at passing you her plate and pointing at which slice and then do the opposite, you get the plate and she puts the slice on it.

lt does sound like you struggle with parenting (we all do) so keep making threads and we can all try and help each other.

JudgeJ · 17/11/2023 11:51

HappyHolidai · 17/11/2023 04:47

If my Mum offered me food and refused to put it on a plate I would wonder if she was losing her marbles (and I'm an adult perfectly capable of getting my own plate).

This OP seems to have said the daughter couldn't have any dinner unless she got her own plate. This is crazy, bonkers, bizarre behaviour and I'm not surprised the daughter was confused and ran away.

I suppose you would expect Mummy to cut it up for you too! We're talking about a pizza not meat, two veg and gravy!

saffronsoup · 17/11/2023 11:48

ItsADoggieDogWorld · 17/11/2023 11:40

You're not very nice are you.

Most of your posts on here are critical of other people. Not sure why it bothers you to read my post when it doesn’t bother you to write similar or worse about others.

jelly79 · 17/11/2023 11:47

This feels really strange and like you are having a stand off with your DH

I can't imagine not wanting to plate up my kids food and having them join me to eat. It's a pleasure. Doesn't mean they are spoiled

ItsADoggieDogWorld · 17/11/2023 11:40

saffronsoup · 17/11/2023 05:18

Given you don’t cook, ordered take out when DH wasn’t home to cook, and then only served yourself, laziness seems to run in the family.

You're not very nice are you.

Peacheroo · 17/11/2023 11:39

@HoppingPavlova just seen you're the poster that said about rainbows flying out of arses. We're very much on the same page and you've made me laugh twice today 😀 thank you for that.

Peacheroo · 17/11/2023 11:34

HoppingPavlova · 17/11/2023 11:10

This is just bizarre. Just pizza for dinner, no salad (or anything else). No-one lays the table. Presumably cold plates. Children expected to come and put a slice of pizza on a plate and eat it with their hands

Thanks. Best thing ever. Gold.

I have just alerted those of my (now adult) kids who are home tonight to the abuse they suffered as kids, and still do I guess. One literally has tears running down their face and can’t speak. They want to know what other pearls this site contains. Many, I assure them.

Not sure how social services missed our family tbh. Pizza without salad. Plates directly from the cupboard without being warmed up. Latecomers forced to use the empty boxes as plates to save on washing up/dishwasher🤣. Eating pizza with their hands🥺. IN FRONT OF A TV🤯. No love🫣. How they went on to be successful degree educated professionals (as children of successful degree educated professionals), who knew their parents loved them - how? For the love of God, how😱.

I don’t feel I can reveal the extent of abuse that was suffered on taco or fajita nights. Cold plates. Serve yourself the bits you want. There were both hard AND soft taco’s. Does that count?

This abuse has continued into adulthood. Tonight, DH made a pasta bake. On finishing and getting out of the oven, he yelled out ‘pasta bake’, served only himself and expected anyone else who wanted some to come get theirs. He is a bastard. I’m obviously planning on leaving him. And taking (now adult) kids.

Kids are absolutely howling. At 10yo they were well able to whack however many slices of pizza they wanted (albeit without a loving salad - but with garlic bread - bonus surely????), onto a non-warmed plate and eating it, safe in the knowledge we still loved them, without an international incident requiring a website discussion.

I've never heated my plates. I didn't realise I was such an awful person. Please send thoughts and prayers.

Theydontknowthatweknowthattheyknow · 17/11/2023 11:32

I understand you wanting to encourage dd to serve herself OP but the whole dynamic between you and your child just sounds really off.

I find it odd that you didn't just ask dd why she's choosing to go hungry. Is she woried about it being too hot? (quite possible if she hasn't done it before) or is she afraid of serving herself too much and getting into trouble? Was she overwhelmed by the choice? I would have at least asked. If this isn't something you typically do or she's used to her dad serving it up for her then it might well be a much bigger deal for her than you or other posters on here realise, especially if there's an element of ND there. Why not just ask 'is something putting you off picking some?' And then reassure her 'oh it's ok there's plenty take what you want' 'no I promise it isn't too hot' 'do you want me to talk you through what everything is?' This is gently encouraging independence without turning food into a big deal.

Whatever the reason she doesn't have the skills yet to manage this situation independently and nor will she next time this happens. All she's learning from how it was dealt with is to surpress her concerns and that her needs won't be met. Just talk to her she's your daughter

aSofaNearYou · 17/11/2023 11:28

LittleBearPad · 17/11/2023 11:17

Tonight, DH made a pasta bake. On finishing and getting out of the oven, he yelled out ‘pasta bake’, served only himself and expected anyone else who wanted some to come get theirs.

Thats really depressing.

Is it? The poster in question was talking about a household of adults, I can't remember the last time my parents dished up the food for me as an adult. It's perfectly normal to just put the food out in the kitchen and everyone help themselves - because people can then choose what they want and how much.

I initially agreed that in OPs position I'd just put her plate out rather than let a 10 year old not eat, but bloody hell, the responses here are increasingly ridiculous and not very helpful. It's tough to have a constructive conversation when you have people saying adults being invited to serve themselves, or people eating pizza with their hands on a non heated plate is shocking and depressing.

followmyflow · 17/11/2023 11:28

everyone please. however you eat dinner is fine. plated up warm plates, everyone serves themselves whatever. some people do it one way some the other some a mix. the problem is that OP, knowing her daughter is struggling with this, purposefully made some kind of power play over dinner instead of ensuring her 10 year old child is fed and not hungry. this one single dinner is not so important that OP had to go so far to prove a point. if her daughter genuinely has issues and OP and her husband need to work through them then that should be tackled. but not like this. OP is being so heavy handed and nasty trying to wrestle with her daughter over this one meal. the daughter can obviously sense this which is why she, regardless of being hungry, took herself to her room instead when she saw what OP was doing.

HoppingPavlova · 17/11/2023 11:22

@LittleBearPad Thats really depressing

How so? How the hell would he know how many of them were home, and wanting dinner (not going out for it). You seriously want him to go all around the house, see how many are home and take a survey on who is staying in for the night and wanting dinner, as some may have had it before getting home. Then warm up plates (apparently that’s a standard), and plate up? Hilarious. Hilarious. But sure, depressing ………..