Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not plate my 10 year old's pizza?

486 replies

Mastmw7g · 17/11/2023 04:05

DH does most of the cooking and tends to cater to DD. I've become concerned that she will not eat when hungry unless he puts food in front of her. He was out and we had pizza. She told me she didn't see her plate. I said to then grab a plate and join me. She said no and went to her room without eating. DH came home and became upset that she hadn't eaten and said I should have put her pizza on a plate for her.

OP posts:
MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 17/11/2023 06:38

No, the pizza next to the oven and slices were already cut. The pizza was next to the plates
Do all she to do was identify how much pizza she wanted and which slices and lift onto the plate next to it? Having seen her brothers already do this? She wasn't singled out as the only one you hadn't served?
She chose not to do this, but then complained about being hungry as soon as daddy got home?

madeinmanc · 17/11/2023 06:38

She's only 10, I think you need to change how you behave with her.

It's part of the ritual of family eating together to have plates and to plate up the food and place it in front of them at the table.

At the age of 10, yes she is capable of putting the pizza on a plate but part of the meal is serving it for the participants which forms a bond between those people. And she is young enough to need your nurturing and caring as a previous poster put it.

The way you are describing it, it sounds like she's just some random person like a student in a shared house at university who happened to drop by and you said to help themselves to pizza, rather than a ten year-old daughter. Very cold and impersonal and I'm sure she picked up on this vibe.

WinedropsOnMoses · 17/11/2023 06:33

ApolloandDaphne · 17/11/2023 06:20

I don't think it's about eating or the ability to get a plate for herself, I think this is about caring. She is looking to her parents to care about her and this is manifesting itself in being offered food on a plate. Food and eating is all about nurture and love rather than merely the ingesting of calories. She is perhaps feeing a little insecure at the moment and needs this little bit of nurturing from you. Look at the behaviour and work out what she is telling you.

I agree with this 100%.

KTSl1964 · 17/11/2023 06:23

How rude saffronsun!!! It would annoy me - it just seems a habit that needs breaking.

LAMPS1 · 17/11/2023 06:22

When you are together, are the meals cooked and served nicely and do you sit down together to eat with a positive spirit to make it a lovely social family time?

You say that your dd eats when her DF makes and serves her a meal.
But that you sit down to eat yourself and refuse to serve her meal, telling her to get the pizza herself if she’s hungry. Where is the love in that ?
Then you wonder why she feels unwanted at the meal table and prefers to go upstairs without. Can you see that not setting her a place as if you don’t expect her to eat with you, is dismissive and does nothing to support good family eating routines. It’s not a question of her being lazy.

There are many aspects to nourishing ourselves. As a parent, I would take the lead and do all I could to prepare and serve a meal with love and good will, making it tempting in terms of the ingredients, cooking, presentation and good loving company around a properly laid table.
Make eating together, even if it’s just a pizza snack, a happy, pleasant experience for your daughter. She’s only ten years old.

WYorkshireRose · 17/11/2023 06:22

SweetFemaleAttitude · 17/11/2023 05:07

Why is the husband being berated for serving his 10yo food on a plate?

This is a weird thread.

Why would you make a pizza, get a plate out for yourself to put pizza on, but not put a slice on a plate for another person in the house, regardless of their age.

It's almost like you were testing her.

Bizarre

This. It's so odd.

PortalooSunset · 17/11/2023 06:20

Why didn't you place a stack of plates next to the pizza? I think it's bizarre everyone had to get their own out.

We eat as a family. Pizza night the cut pizzas are placed in the middle of the table and there's a plate in each place. Each dc has always had a 'dinner job' (eg bring cutlery, make drinks).

Your way sounds very odd to me @Mastmw7g and I can't believe you'd rather your 10 year old went hungry rather than just bung a slice on a plate "because she didn't ask me to".

ApolloandDaphne · 17/11/2023 06:20

I don't think it's about eating or the ability to get a plate for herself, I think this is about caring. She is looking to her parents to care about her and this is manifesting itself in being offered food on a plate. Food and eating is all about nurture and love rather than merely the ingesting of calories. She is perhaps feeing a little insecure at the moment and needs this little bit of nurturing from you. Look at the behaviour and work out what she is telling you.

margotrose · 17/11/2023 06:18

I can't get my head around your behaviour - it's so bizarre to me.

She's ten and she was hungry. Why on earth would you not get her some dinner?

What her brothers do or don't do is irrelevant - you essentially sent your child to bed hungry because of some weird notion that she should have to serve herself Confused

wokbun · 17/11/2023 06:15

There's something going on with her. Your DH isn't picking up on it as he's happy to just get her fed. You've realised there's something up.

Does she cook with you?

EveWinter · 17/11/2023 06:13

I agree @WinedropsOnMoses , it is just a bit of kindness, like when DC make me a cup of tea or stick a slice of bread in the toaster for me as theirs finishes etc..

I don’t get it why you made it such a big deal OP, she is 10.

Mastmw7g · 17/11/2023 06:11

Dixiechickonhols · 17/11/2023 06:04

With the mention of the hairbrush if I’d think something sensory is possibly going on.
Two very different styles of parenting may be confusing. You’d done it as buffet style - pizza and plates on side but dad would serve to table on plates.
Is she says she’s hungry then do you direct eg you can have a yoghurt or fruit. Is she perhaps unsure what she can take.

I can try making suggestions when she says she's hungry. My older son is on the spectrum, so I've had all my kids evaluated and no sensory issues were uncovered, but I've read that it can be harder to detect in girls because they're social chameleons. I'll make more of an effort.

OP posts:
Tiswa · 17/11/2023 06:10

And the thing with refusing she just simply didn’t then eat - she didn’t tantrum or say she wouldn’t she made a choice - but one which led her to not have food.

how does she eat pizza - is it a touching thing?

WinedropsOnMoses · 17/11/2023 06:09

I think the whole scenario is a little odd.

I always plate my 11 and 7 year old's dinner- mainly to make sure everyone has enough (mine are hogs and if it was first come,first served,there would be some left with nothing 🤣), and to make sure plates are balanced, e.g I will whack a bit of salad on the side of a pizza which always gets eaten.

Exception would be for things like buffets on holiday, family bbqs etc where my eldest will sort himself out.

Also though,just because it feels to me like a loving thing to do. Not in a creepy, perfect Insta mum way..it's just nice.

I'd be worried if one of my children skipped dinner and just went to their room. She's only 10,not 16..what's wrong with a bit of encouragement/reminder to eat?

Not sure it's about her skills tbh..She sounds capable,agree with PP that maybe she's not food orientated? Does she seem happy generally?

Afteropening · 17/11/2023 06:09

bloody. hell.

I have just seen your posting history OP

Thread after thread about your “unreasonable” DD. complaint after complaint

she is 10 OP

10

Tiswa · 17/11/2023 06:08

From memory she also has disordered sleep as well based your other thread? How is she at school. It does sound as if something is going on

I would say though given that you know she has a disordered relationship with food and won’t eat unless it is served to her why didn’t you. You set her up to fail knowing she wouldn’t eat dinner.

Thursa · 17/11/2023 06:08

All she had to do was walk into the kitchen, pick up a plate, and put some cooked, sliced pizza on it? At 10 years old? I would not be impressed at a refusal to do that.

Afteropening · 17/11/2023 06:07

are you in the UK Op?

EveWinter · 17/11/2023 06:05

I find this slightly odd. In my house it would have been ‘come and sit down and have some pizza with me’, I would have got up, got a plate and a glass and served food and a drink. Not just for a ten year old but for almost anyone here.

Not because I am a martyr either.

Dixiechickonhols · 17/11/2023 06:04

With the mention of the hairbrush if I’d think something sensory is possibly going on.
Two very different styles of parenting may be confusing. You’d done it as buffet style - pizza and plates on side but dad would serve to table on plates.
Is she says she’s hungry then do you direct eg you can have a yoghurt or fruit. Is she perhaps unsure what she can take.

NLisa · 17/11/2023 06:03

My DS 11 does exactly this if I don’t make him food he will not eat. I prepare all meals during the week but on the weekends he can just have a sandwich during the day when he is hungry. He refuses to eat all day till dinner if I don’t make him anything. He will say he is hungry multiple times a day but will not go in the kitchen to make a sandwich. Which he knows how to do. I have all his favourites in, he is just being lazy/spoiled. We had one that my mum stepped in and made him food so he could eat because we had a stand off again. He is a growing strong tall lad plays football 3 times a week and eats absolutely everything. As long as he does not have to make it. Absolutely bizar

Mastmw7g · 17/11/2023 05:55

MrsTerryPratchett · 17/11/2023 05:48

I don't think I have an odd relationship with food.

I've read the whole thread and you seem to have an odd relationship with relationships. She's 10. She didn't eat dinner. Weren't you a little curious? Didn't you ask? It just seems really strange.

I thought it was insane that she would rather not eat than put forth effort, but let her choose to go to her room. I spent time with her before she went to bed. We didn't talk about food.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 17/11/2023 05:48

I don't think I have an odd relationship with food.

I've read the whole thread and you seem to have an odd relationship with relationships. She's 10. She didn't eat dinner. Weren't you a little curious? Didn't you ask? It just seems really strange.

Mastmw7g · 17/11/2023 05:47

Goldbar · 17/11/2023 04:29

If she says she's hungry, I'd make her get up, come downstairs/into the kitchen with me and physically plate her food herself, rather than just putting it on a plate and taking it to her. Hopefully if there's no more worrying issues around food, she's just being lazy and needs to get used to doing things herself.

Are you eating some meals together as a family or does she tend to eat alone for most of her meals?

No, she eats breakfast with her younger brother. Her older brother eats before them. We have dinner as a family.

OP posts:
RedCoffeeCup · 17/11/2023 05:47

Nearly all 10 year olds would be able to get a plate and put a slice of pizza on it with no problems. The fact that your DD can't and would rather miss dinner altogether seems worrying to me. I feel that this is so unusual for her age that it can't just be because she's lazy / spoilt / DH panders to her and there must be something deeper going on that you need to explore. So I've voted YABU.

Swipe left for the next trending thread