Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell the school not to punish the child that hit my DD?

92 replies

Whatwouldyoudo24 · 16/11/2023 22:23

Okay so not exactly don’t punish him, but that I think their punishment is ridiculous?

DD is 5 (YR1) and in a mixed YR1/YR2 class. This other child (let’s call him Donald) is in YR2 and he had a lot of settling in issues at the beginning of the year and was often lashing out at the younger children in the class.

My daughter came home and told me what was happening so I had a meeting with her teacher where she mentioned that Donald is being assessed for SEN and has had the same teacher in reception and YR1 so understandably was struggling with the transition. The teacher explained the things they were putting in place to minimise any issues and they all seemed reasonable.

Me and my daughter had a conversation about Donald and I said to stay away from him as much as possible and if there were any issues to let the teacher know, but to also highlight any moments where Donald was kind as the teacher said he responded really well to positive praise.

This was in September and all has been fine since, DD has only mentioned the kind things Donald has done. Today she has come home and said he has hit her in the stomach, ‘not really hard but it’s wasn’t very kind and it made her really sad’, she said this happened on the way into assembly as Donald felt like she was too close to him.

Obviously this is not okay, and I was planning on mentioning it to teacher tomorrow so that they could be aware that moving into assembly is obviously overwhelming for Donald so they could maybe have him slightly ahead of the rest of the class to reduce this issue.

This evening I’ve received a message from her teacher saying that DD has told her Donald has hit her in the stomach and that they are taking away his entire lunch break tomorrow, so they ‘have it in hand’.

Personally I think this is ridiculous, obviously it’s not okay that DD was hit but I can’t see how removing the only portion of the day that allows children to release the energy and frustration that builds after hours in a classroom is going to help? I worry that by the afternoon he will be in a position that is very difficult to regulate his emotions and it could lead to many more issues? I also think it’s just cruel to take away a lunch break for a 6 year old child with possible SEN.

I want to reply and say thank you for letting me know the situation, but please don’t remove Donald’s lunch break over something that didn’t leave a mark and DD had gotten past by bedtime. Would this come across as rude? I worry it’ll sound like I’m telling her how to teach when I really am not, I know I couldn’t teach 20 odd 5/6 year olds.

I’m also not saying Donald shouldn’t face some consequences, only that there must be consequences that would fit the situation better and actually work towards solving the problem?

OP posts:
Djimm · 17/11/2023 01:20

OP I think you have made the right decision not to mention that.

I don't think the teacher should have shared those details so if it comes up in conversation you could do a "honestly you didn't need to give me the details of the punishment, it's none of my business" but I don't think you can put that in an email.

Well done to your daughter for speaking up and seeing the big picture with Donald. She's lucky to have such an insightful mum.

SaySomethingMan · 17/11/2023 01:10

i don’t hu school continue to use this stupid punishment. Everyone suffers then because the child is even less likely to self regulate.
Your DD should be protected by all means but school need to find an appropriate consequence. It’s so lazy

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 17/11/2023 01:08

supernoodletrain · 17/11/2023 01:03

Bit harsh, he's what, 6? Not an excuse for hitting but adults labelling him as a violent little shit at such a young age is hardly setting him on a path to become anything other than that

Agree. The violent behaviour absolutely needs to be addressed but it's disgusting to describe a 6yo child as a "little shit". It tells you more about the adult that's saying that than it does about the child.

egowise · 17/11/2023 01:08

While I think you seem compassionate and caring for Donald, I agree with the consensus on the thread.

I agree with you that playtime being taken away will likely cause more problems later that day, I don't think the teacher will like being called out on that.

I'm glad your little one okay.

supernoodletrain · 17/11/2023 01:03

Gymrabbit · 16/11/2023 23:09

Why are you pandering to the needs of a violent little bully?
you said yourself that he was ‘lashing out at the younger kids in the class’, how strange that he wasn’t lashing out at the ones who were bigger than him. No, it’s clearly just smaller kids and little girls in the year below that he likes to thump.

little shits like him grow up to be big shits who abuse women and people smaller than themselves if they are not firmly taught that this sort of behaviour is unacceptable. Your daughter needs to be taught that kids like him must never be allowed to bully her or other vulnerable children not encouraged to be nice to him.

Bit harsh, he's what, 6? Not an excuse for hitting but adults labelling him as a violent little shit at such a young age is hardly setting him on a path to become anything other than that

anonimoxyz · 17/11/2023 00:24

I still remember my mum telling me to be kind to a kid with Down syndrome who used to batter me and a girl whose parents were divorcing who was going after me mentally every day. We're talking early 90s and schools weren't great with any type of difficulty but I never felt listened to or protected by my mum (and life got worse and she still couldn't help me) just a different perspective

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 17/11/2023 00:19

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 16/11/2023 22:31

YABU. It's not your place to tell the school how to deal with the behaviour of its pupils, even when the incident involved your child.

I disagree - if parents have opinions about behaviour policies they should question them

Op is right that removing break times mean that children aren't able to regulate - any teacher can tell you of the hell that is their classroom after a wet play

TizerorFizz · 17/11/2023 00:11

@Whatwouldyoudo24 You do perhaps need to be better informed about the school’s Behaviour and Sanctions policy. This often covers bullying too. Read about what the school will do when behaviour is unacceptable.

Donald probably is not easy to manage but it’s not up to you to get involved. I would strongly suggest you understand the encouragement DC are given to behave well, as articulated in the policy, and that there are consequences if there’s no improvement. The school is responsible for meeting Donald’s needs though. How they do it, is down to them but always advocate for your own child. Donald’s parents will advocate for him. He may well be assessed for SEN.

Mousexat · 16/11/2023 23:55

You’re worried your daughter was being bullied by this boy and now you want to intervene and stop behavioural punishments? Have a hard think about what you’re teaching your daughter here.

Mousexat · 16/11/2023 23:51

It’s not for you to worry about Donald. Worry about your own daughter and stop making excuses for aggressive boys/ men

lanthanum · 16/11/2023 23:49

If the normal consequence for hitting someone is not followed, that may send the wrong messages to Donald.
I knew a child with ASD who did something wrong at school, but genuinely didn't realise it was wrong because the teacher hadn't moved his name to the sad cloud (or whatever it was). In his eyes, because that hadn't happened, what he did must have been okay!
Consistency can be important.

Lesleyknopeswaffleiron · 16/11/2023 23:47

@Doveyouknow surely the only people who have the right information and access to know what is or isn’t likely to be counterproductive are the school and Donald’s parents.

We don’t know Donald’s EHCP, we don’t know his history with other children (except that it’s happened before to younger and smaller kids). We don’t know what other interventions have been tried before this sanction, we don’t know whether he has supportive parents or whether the school are battling on multiple fronts.

There’s empathy, yes, and I think it’s right to feel sadness for Donald and to hope that he’s getting the help he needs. But it’s not OP’s place, or yours, to suggest that we know what is or isn’t right for Donald

1AngelicFruitCake · 16/11/2023 23:46

Do not do this! Im an experienced primary school teacher and mother to a kind girl who would be hurt by others at school sometimes

  1. Dont come across like you know more than them
  2. Don’t let your daughter think it’s ok to be hurt and the punishment not to be too bad because x, y and z. It’s not ok, sad it’s missing his break but you need to leave it. Your daughter needs to know even a little bit is not ok.
  3. Explain to your daughter it must be hard that he herds more help with his learning BUT hurting others, with words or physically is never ok, there is no excuse ever
PestilencialCrisis · 16/11/2023 23:35

Why is the teacher telling you about another child's punishment?

Doveyouknow · 16/11/2023 23:15

I think some posters are being a bit harsh here. I think your post is very thoughtful. I think that you are right that the punishment is likely to be counterproductive. Whether the teacher will appreciate your input I am not sure. I am also surprised she contacted you to tell you about another child's punishment. Our school would never do that.

BerriesCones · 16/11/2023 23:15

Your job is to advocate for your dd, not to tell her to be kind to people who hit her or to advise the teachers on how he's disciplined.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 16/11/2023 23:14

You don't have the full picture. Leave the school to deal with it.

It's good to show compassion and understanding towards "Donald". He is just a little boy and he is still learning. But SEN or no SEN, he does have to learn that he can't behave in that way. The school is trying to help him learn that.

Your dd also needs to learn that it's never ok for someone to be violent towards her...even if they have SEN or some other extenuating circumstances. It is important for her to know that.

Totaly · 16/11/2023 23:14

it’s just hard not to feel empathy for other students

No it really isn’t - protect your daughter - that’s your job - if she sees you siding with others when she’s clearly the victim, how are you going to react when she really has a problem? Do you think she would tell you about it? You are undermining her confidence in you as her protector.

Gymrabbit · 16/11/2023 23:09

Why are you pandering to the needs of a violent little bully?
you said yourself that he was ‘lashing out at the younger kids in the class’, how strange that he wasn’t lashing out at the ones who were bigger than him. No, it’s clearly just smaller kids and little girls in the year below that he likes to thump.

little shits like him grow up to be big shits who abuse women and people smaller than themselves if they are not firmly taught that this sort of behaviour is unacceptable. Your daughter needs to be taught that kids like him must never be allowed to bully her or other vulnerable children not encouraged to be nice to him.

Lesleyknopeswaffleiron · 16/11/2023 23:06

Hi OP,
Agree with previous posters - the school have got this and in the kindest possible way, it’s nothing to do with you.

Three things are on my mind:

  1. reinforcing expectations that young girls should make adjustments for the poor behaviour of boys. Previous posters have articulated this better than me but I wanted to add my voice to the mix. There’s a difference between explaining to your DD the reason behind poor behaviour (SEN and unmet need) and reducing/diminishing the sanction.

  2. undermining the teachers. You don’t know what’s been going on with Donald other than the interaction with your own child. The school has likely worked with Donald’s parents on a plan; your intervention reeks of interference. I’d be cross if I was trying hard to teach my child a boundary and someone else undermined it.

  3. we do some children with additional needs a disservice when we have lower expectations of them. We project confidence in them when we say ‘I think you are worthy and capable of adhering to rules and boundaries and I think you can do it, so I’m going to show you what that looks like’. Taking boundaries and sanctions away from some children with SEN is often more cruel, not less cruel. (Of course that’s not always true in all cases, but nor is the reverse. When we say that SEN is a free pass to behave inappropriately we rob people of the opportunity to learn)

I think teaching empathy is a great skill, and I think it’s brilliant that you are doing this with your DD but would advise not to let the pendulum swing too far the other way

youcandanceifyouwanna · 16/11/2023 23:03

You only know about the situation with your daughter, how many other kids has he hit? Stay out of it.

Mintesso · 16/11/2023 22:59

Indoorcatmum · 16/11/2023 22:29

I personally believe that it is important for your daughter to see a boy being punished for physically harming her.

This will set her up for later in life, knowing that this is unacceptable.

I understand feeling sympathy for the boy and what he is going through, but in my opinion you are not actively showing that you are on your daughters side and her safety (emotional and physical) is your priority.

It doesn't matter what someone has going on, at any age. There should be consequences for these actions.

Otherwise you raise girls who think it's okay to be hit and boys who are unable to control their anger.
If he can't control it due to additional needs, then the teachers need to control it and supervise more closely.

So yes, I think you are bring very unreasonable to interfere with the punishment the teacher deems appropriate.

This.

Mariposista · 16/11/2023 22:57

Your daughter is there to learn, not to be in fear of being hit in the stomach (she was fine this time, may not be next).
Donald is there to learn also, not to be thumping people.
Not sure how effective punishing him the next day will be, but at least they aren't brushing it under the carpet.

caringcarer · 16/11/2023 22:55

The class teacher will know how Donald has been with all other DC in his class. He might have had many warnings. You only know about how he has hit your DD in the stomach so the teacher has a better overall picture to decide what is an appropriate punishment.

Whatwouldyoudo24 · 16/11/2023 22:53

Thank you for all the replies! I’m going to leave it.

For those worried I’m too involved, this is only the second time I’ve ever had contact with the school regarding this child and the first was a meeting set up because I was worried DD was being bullied. I haven’t even replied to the teacher for this one, I think sometimes it’s just hard not to feel empathy for other students.

But I’ll just let DD know that the teacher has contacted me and well done for telling the teacher, it was something she struggled with at the beginning so she always just told me!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread