Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell the school not to punish the child that hit my DD?

92 replies

Whatwouldyoudo24 · 16/11/2023 22:23

Okay so not exactly don’t punish him, but that I think their punishment is ridiculous?

DD is 5 (YR1) and in a mixed YR1/YR2 class. This other child (let’s call him Donald) is in YR2 and he had a lot of settling in issues at the beginning of the year and was often lashing out at the younger children in the class.

My daughter came home and told me what was happening so I had a meeting with her teacher where she mentioned that Donald is being assessed for SEN and has had the same teacher in reception and YR1 so understandably was struggling with the transition. The teacher explained the things they were putting in place to minimise any issues and they all seemed reasonable.

Me and my daughter had a conversation about Donald and I said to stay away from him as much as possible and if there were any issues to let the teacher know, but to also highlight any moments where Donald was kind as the teacher said he responded really well to positive praise.

This was in September and all has been fine since, DD has only mentioned the kind things Donald has done. Today she has come home and said he has hit her in the stomach, ‘not really hard but it’s wasn’t very kind and it made her really sad’, she said this happened on the way into assembly as Donald felt like she was too close to him.

Obviously this is not okay, and I was planning on mentioning it to teacher tomorrow so that they could be aware that moving into assembly is obviously overwhelming for Donald so they could maybe have him slightly ahead of the rest of the class to reduce this issue.

This evening I’ve received a message from her teacher saying that DD has told her Donald has hit her in the stomach and that they are taking away his entire lunch break tomorrow, so they ‘have it in hand’.

Personally I think this is ridiculous, obviously it’s not okay that DD was hit but I can’t see how removing the only portion of the day that allows children to release the energy and frustration that builds after hours in a classroom is going to help? I worry that by the afternoon he will be in a position that is very difficult to regulate his emotions and it could lead to many more issues? I also think it’s just cruel to take away a lunch break for a 6 year old child with possible SEN.

I want to reply and say thank you for letting me know the situation, but please don’t remove Donald’s lunch break over something that didn’t leave a mark and DD had gotten past by bedtime. Would this come across as rude? I worry it’ll sound like I’m telling her how to teach when I really am not, I know I couldn’t teach 20 odd 5/6 year olds.

I’m also not saying Donald shouldn’t face some consequences, only that there must be consequences that would fit the situation better and actually work towards solving the problem?

OP posts:
curaçao · 17/11/2023 10:12

In the kindest way, who the heck do you think you are to be tellung the teacher how to manage her class?

FlippyFloppyShoe · 17/11/2023 10:02

Tbh I'm surprised the school has told you so much about Donald and his punishment...my dcs school just says 'we are investigating matters and can't tell you the outcomes for data protection reasons'

Ohnoooooooo · 17/11/2023 09:56

SpringboksSocks · 16/11/2023 22:30

I think you’re being very thoughtful. Unfortunately it may be seen as undermining the teacher’s position, and I think there needs to be some consequence, but I agree with you that taking away his lunch break may well be completely counter-productive.

this - it does surprise me how teachers do this to a child with SEN who needs to run out their feelings at lunch. I am not sure what but a different punishment is needed. Do you tell the teacher? Unfort I think not but if you ever speak to them again you can just verbally ask the question would removing lunch play mean they are less settled in the afternoon.

Bellyblueboy · 17/11/2023 09:49

Sorry that was a hit harsh - but I do hate this be kind mantra. It is especially pushed in little girls - be kind to the bigger stronger kid who punches you in the stomach he is having a bad day. Let’s understand why someone is being awful.

I never tell little girls to be kind - I tell them to push back, stand up for themselves.

one day your daughter will encounter a Donald at work - should she fawn and praise him when he is being a decent human being and ‘be kind’ when he steals her ideas and talks over her in meetings?

Bellyblueboy · 17/11/2023 09:46

It’s not up to you to dictate how children are disciplined.

This child clearly has issues that the school has a strategy to address. How arrogant to think you know better. If I was the teacher I Woolf roll my eyes and ignore.

WeeSleekitCowrinTimrousBeastie · 17/11/2023 09:16

You are obviously a kind and thoughtful person.

But you don't know what's going on with Donald. There may be a behaviour plan in place agreed with Donald's family.

The school really shouldn't have told you anything about what will happen with Donald.

Mischance · 17/11/2023 09:16

It is entirely wrong in principle that the teacher told you Donald had SEN.

The school are clearly dealing with it and have chosen a punishment that fits in with their plan for him. You do not know what other incidents have occurred with other children and the punishment could be entirely appropriate in context. He may have been on last warning over other other incidents.

It is not your place to come back on them about this. Your job is to make sure they know when incidents happen that involve your DD.

IsleofDen · 17/11/2023 09:12

This is a 6 y/o with well known additional needs. I wouldn’t get involved in the punishment (although I do agree that removing lunchtime is counterproductive) but I would be asking them how this happened and how they propose to keep your daughter safe.

This is 100% a failure by the school, they are not supporting him correctly, not recognising that he is disregulated and failing to respond quickly enough to keep everyone safe. You cannot get involved in the actions they take, but you can hold them as a school accountable for their failure that led to your daughter getting punched.

Gerrataere · 17/11/2023 09:08

Im glad to see you’re leaving it up to the school op. If Donald’s parent feels this is an inappropriate way to punish him, that’s up to them to discuss with the school. As a parent of autistic children, I would and have fully accepted that (whilst there needs to be accommodations for their needs) it’s never excusable to hit out at other child. All children should be safe at school.

I am concerned about how much ‘Be Kind’ you’re putting on your daughter. Her welfare comes first, and that’s the most important lesson you could ever teacher her. Of course she should be understanding of others to a point, but never to her own detriment.

MariaVT65 · 17/11/2023 08:59

TheOccupier · 17/11/2023 08:47

Something similar happened to me at school and I've never forgotten the feeling of my mum not being on my side.

Support your DD! Donald isn't your problem.

Absolutely this. Forget Donald and show full support for your DD.

dancingdec · 17/11/2023 08:48

If the child has a gut response to hit out at others he feels too close, taking away a break won't manage it effectively as in the moment he'd react exactly the same. He needs working with specifically to de-sensitise that feeling. I think this needs to be more focused, specific behaviour management based on that rather than some ill-informed punitive retribution.

I agree that your dd should not get the message this is okay. However, the school's response is lacking in informed judgement.

TheOccupier · 17/11/2023 08:47

Something similar happened to me at school and I've never forgotten the feeling of my mum not being on my side.

Support your DD! Donald isn't your problem.

Shayisgreat · 17/11/2023 08:42

Like I think the school need to be putting in appropriate measures to ensure that Donald feels safe and able to learn without lashing out but it's not OP's role to tell them this!

Shayisgreat · 17/11/2023 08:40

You are responsible for ensuring your daughter is OK and supporting her to navigate relationships and friendships. If you focus on ensuring that the person who punched your daughter is not punished too harshly what message do you think your daughter will pick up? Might she start to think that her comfort and safety come second to the "troubled" child? What could this lead to in her future?

I'd be very wary of getting involved in how the school manage the other child - he has his own parents who can advocate for him. You concentrate on your child and her wellbeing.

Gymrabbit · 17/11/2023 08:36

itsmyp4rty

Since you are such an expert can you explain why the student only punches children who are smaller and younger than him?
And how he will ever learn that this is unacceptable behaviour if he is not punished?

itsmyp4rty · 17/11/2023 08:30

I'm with you OP, Donald lashed out because his needs weren't being met. School should know that he can't cope with children getting too close and make sure that doesn't happen for everyone's sake. They failed him and failed your daughter - and now he's being punished.

What I would want put in place is something to prevent this happening again. There's a good chance Donald may not even understand that this is a punishment for something that happened on a different day when he was overwhelmed. It is to make you feel that 'something is being done' as it is probably what other parents have insisted on 'Donald needs to be punished for this' - you can see it from all the replies on here.

I would contact the school because if they think this is the way to handle it then you do know how to handle it better than them - so why should you pretend you don't? If the school doesn't like you knowing better then they need to get their teachers trained up in handling children with ASD, ADHD etc. They can't punish Donald into being able to cope with things that he can't cope with, it just won't work.

If Donald can't cope with break times outside due to the noise and number of children then keeping him in at lunchtime might well be much better for him and everyone else - but then lets not pretend that that is his punishment. It is to enable him to cope in the school environment.

All in all the chances are that Donald would be much better off somewhere for children with SEN which has much smaller classes and much more support. He shouldn't be being 'punished' because that is not available to him.

Totaly · 17/11/2023 08:12

I agree with you that playtime being taken away will likely cause more problems later that day, I don't think the teacher will like being called out on that

Rubbish. Some children with ASD in ‘that’ mood will take his aggression out on others in the playground. He’s best kept away save others a punch.

That said it’s likely a TA will take him for a run to burn off some energy.

wesurecouldstandgladioli · 17/11/2023 08:12

Gymrabbit · 17/11/2023 08:07

Very telling that so many of you are so concerned about this child that the OP freely states only picks on and abuses children younger than him. If he genuinely had SEN he would be punching anyone who annoyed him. I work with children with ASD and they will square up to sixth formers if they are in that frame of mind because they are genuinely dysregulated and not bullies.

children’s behaviour is becoming more and more violent the softer and more pandering the systems are. If all the mindfulness and be kind bullshit actually worked we would be seeing improvements by now.

A fellow teacher who is an NQT summed it up very clearly yesterday ‘I’ve tried to be kind and nice and understanding when they misbehave and are rude and aggressive and they just do it more because they see they can get away with it.’

If you RTFT, you’ll see everyone is telling OP to focus on her own child and not worry about the wellbeing of the child who hit her.

You seem to be reading a different thread to everyone else.

Gymrabbit · 17/11/2023 08:07

Very telling that so many of you are so concerned about this child that the OP freely states only picks on and abuses children younger than him. If he genuinely had SEN he would be punching anyone who annoyed him. I work with children with ASD and they will square up to sixth formers if they are in that frame of mind because they are genuinely dysregulated and not bullies.

children’s behaviour is becoming more and more violent the softer and more pandering the systems are. If all the mindfulness and be kind bullshit actually worked we would be seeing improvements by now.

A fellow teacher who is an NQT summed it up very clearly yesterday ‘I’ve tried to be kind and nice and understanding when they misbehave and are rude and aggressive and they just do it more because they see they can get away with it.’

dhworry · 17/11/2023 05:40

What happens to the other child isn't your fight that's for his parents.

If the child has asd or adhd losing the lunch break won't matter jot in the long term. next time a child is too close he won't think oh last time I hit someone I lost my lunch break. He will react because he is overwhelmed.

He needs to either be taken separately or stand at the back and be supervised for signs he is struggling. The staff are currently setting him up to fail unless they alter the situation.

Impact of losing the break will depend on how it's managed, if he loses the opportunity to exercise/let off steam he will likely struggle more in the afternoon. If he is fixated on routine he will likely struggle more because he will be disregulated .

Going forward I would tell your dd to be kind to everyone in the class but to give him space unless he asks to play.

Noicant · 17/11/2023 05:07

Your DD doesn’t need to be telling the teacher when he’s being kind. You will be sending the message that she’s a support human.

He hit her, even if he has a SEN she needs to learn that it’s fine for her to have boundaries and she doesn’t have to run around trying to make his life better at her own expense.

This really isn’t the message you should be sending your DD for her own wellbeing. Stop making her feel like she’s responsible for him and stop acting like it’s not a big deal if a boy hits your DD because she will internalise that.

junbean · 17/11/2023 04:42

Exclusion is cruel, especially at this age and with his issues. Your idea of easing transitions is spot on. Honestly you have a better grip of the situation than the teacher! She must be overwhelmed. No harm in your suggestion, especially if it helps everyone involved.

VashtaNerada · 17/11/2023 04:27

God I wish more parents were like you! I’ve taught children who hit and it can be a nightmare to resolve when it’s outside the child’s control due to their particular SEN. I wouldn’t worry too much about the ‘punishment’. He may well be having a nice calm time playing with an adult indoors to help him regulate himself. The child’s behaviour is wrong but that doesn’t make him a bad child. I’m surprised they told you he was being assessed for SEN though - definitely not appropriate to share that with another parent! It’s made me wonder if the teacher is new.

Pumpkinspicelattetime · 17/11/2023 02:11

I agree with you that missing a break the next day may not be the best punishment but schools are rather limited in what they can do. But it is for Donald's parents to take that up with the school if they disagree with it.

Your job is to stand up for your daughter. You can do this by not minimising what happened to her and shrugging it off just because this time it didn't leave a bruise. That doesn't matter, she was still attacked a school. She shouldn't have to put up with it just because her attacker has SEN.

The fact Donald is only targeting the younger kids from the year below suggests he has some element of control here.

momonpurpose · 17/11/2023 01:40

I get you are trying to be kind however your child needs to see that it was wrong she was hit and he is punished.