Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell the school not to punish the child that hit my DD?

92 replies

Whatwouldyoudo24 · 16/11/2023 22:23

Okay so not exactly don’t punish him, but that I think their punishment is ridiculous?

DD is 5 (YR1) and in a mixed YR1/YR2 class. This other child (let’s call him Donald) is in YR2 and he had a lot of settling in issues at the beginning of the year and was often lashing out at the younger children in the class.

My daughter came home and told me what was happening so I had a meeting with her teacher where she mentioned that Donald is being assessed for SEN and has had the same teacher in reception and YR1 so understandably was struggling with the transition. The teacher explained the things they were putting in place to minimise any issues and they all seemed reasonable.

Me and my daughter had a conversation about Donald and I said to stay away from him as much as possible and if there were any issues to let the teacher know, but to also highlight any moments where Donald was kind as the teacher said he responded really well to positive praise.

This was in September and all has been fine since, DD has only mentioned the kind things Donald has done. Today she has come home and said he has hit her in the stomach, ‘not really hard but it’s wasn’t very kind and it made her really sad’, she said this happened on the way into assembly as Donald felt like she was too close to him.

Obviously this is not okay, and I was planning on mentioning it to teacher tomorrow so that they could be aware that moving into assembly is obviously overwhelming for Donald so they could maybe have him slightly ahead of the rest of the class to reduce this issue.

This evening I’ve received a message from her teacher saying that DD has told her Donald has hit her in the stomach and that they are taking away his entire lunch break tomorrow, so they ‘have it in hand’.

Personally I think this is ridiculous, obviously it’s not okay that DD was hit but I can’t see how removing the only portion of the day that allows children to release the energy and frustration that builds after hours in a classroom is going to help? I worry that by the afternoon he will be in a position that is very difficult to regulate his emotions and it could lead to many more issues? I also think it’s just cruel to take away a lunch break for a 6 year old child with possible SEN.

I want to reply and say thank you for letting me know the situation, but please don’t remove Donald’s lunch break over something that didn’t leave a mark and DD had gotten past by bedtime. Would this come across as rude? I worry it’ll sound like I’m telling her how to teach when I really am not, I know I couldn’t teach 20 odd 5/6 year olds.

I’m also not saying Donald shouldn’t face some consequences, only that there must be consequences that would fit the situation better and actually work towards solving the problem?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Imnotabigbeliever · 06/02/2024 20:41

The sanction should be that he has to line up with a teacher, I agree with you taking away his lunch isn’t relevant to the incident and if he is ND it just won’t help the situation.

ilovebreadsauce · 06/02/2024 20:37

You are telling the teacher how to do her job? Wind your neck in !! NOT YOUR BUSINESS

Sugargliderwombat · 18/11/2023 07:59

I think the school are incredibly unprofessional to be telling you all about Donald's needs!

But I do think they know the children best and to leave them to it

Whatwouldyoudo24 · 18/11/2023 07:33

Hello everyone, thank you for so many replies!

Firstly I’m not concerned about whether my DD feels like I protect her, when she told me we had an entire conversation about how it’s never okay to hit, we discussed how she felt about the situation and I explained that I would speak to the teacher first thing in the morning to make sure something is done to make sure it doesn’t happen again.

My plan was to speak to the teacher at drop off, and I hadn’t even considered mentioning consequences because they’re a school, naturally they would have consequences in place. But I wanted to make sure they were aware of the situation and the circumstances surrounding it because otherwise it would happen again, regardless of any consequences. Donald and my DD always walk into assembly together because of where their names are in the register and if they don’t make a change there she will be put in the same position. This would be unfair on my DD and unfair on Donald.

My concern with the message is that it was only mentioning a punishment that could very well make the situation worse for my daughter and mentioned nothing about how they would ensure DD and Donald wouldn’t be put in the same position.

I have decided I am still going to talk to the teacher next week, I still won’t mention the punishment but I want to know DD have told them why it happened so they can make adjustments to keep everyone safe.

Regarding if I should know any of this information, I honestly don’t think I should. But I didn’t ask for the information, from what I can tell I wasn’t the first parent to have concerns about Donald and I think the teacher was just overwhelmed, it doesn’t make it okay and I haven’t passed the information on to any other parent. I also hadn’t even mentioned the incident as I wanted to speak face to face when she messaged to tell me about the punishment.

This will be my final reply about the situation as I am happy viewing this situation differently than a lot of people, and have taken on board that the punishment is not my concern.

Thanks again for so many diverse replies, it’s really appreciated.

OP posts:
Sdpbody · 18/11/2023 07:27

YABU for not going straight in to school and demanding information on what provisions they are putting in place to keep your child safe. If all parents complain about this child, more will be done. SEN or not, he can't be allowed to get away with this terrible behaviour!

Madamlulu · 18/11/2023 07:18

MoMandaS · 16/11/2023 22:36

I think this is the first time on here I've seen such a sensible and empathetic view, from a parent, of a school situation involving a child with additional needs. If only the teacher concerned had your level of understanding! I do think you should put your view across to them, yes. You're right that what they propose will be counter productive and they need to support him better in order to safeguard your daughter and his other peers.

This!

Couldn't put it any better.

IAmAnIdiot123 · 18/11/2023 07:04

AmyDudley · 16/11/2023 22:42

I think that the way Donald's behaviour is handled is a matter for his teacher and his parents and nothing whatsoever to do with you.. If I was Donald's mother I would be pretty irritated to find another parent was discussing my child's problems with the teacher and taking it upon herself to interfere in strategies to regulate his behaviour, giving opinions on what may trigger his behaviour etc - do you honestly think experienced teachers who know this child much better than you do have no clue ? - massive crossing of boundaries on your part.

How would you feel if a random parent went into school and discussed with the teacher how your DD should be disciplined ? Donald isn't a free for all, everyone stick their oar in just because he may have SEN. He is as entitled to his privacy as much as any other child in the class.
You may think you are being thoughtful but it comes over as very patronising.

And reassure your DD that she doesn't have to put up with being hit by anyone.

This! I would be really annoyed to find out another parent was discussing what sort of punishment was appropriate for my child with the teacher.

Honestly I'm amazed they even told you the punishment, I thought they were just meant to notify you of the situation and advise it was being handled.

pilates · 18/11/2023 07:03

I am glad you’re going to let the school deal with it. Hope your DD is ok.

Chipsahoyagain · 18/11/2023 06:59

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 16/11/2023 22:31

YABU. It's not your place to tell the school how to deal with the behaviour of its pupils, even when the incident involved your child.

This. You've spent your entire post on showing how kind you are towards Donald but not acknowledging that it's your dd who you advocate for? What message are you sending to your dd? It's ok because it didn't leave a mark, think about that for a second.

user1492757084 · 18/11/2023 06:56

Thank the teacher but also question whether taking away the whole of his lunch is reasonable.

They may have very good reasons for doing it this way and ultimately it is their call.

VashtaNerada · 18/11/2023 04:24

Regular teachers don't have any of trainings to understand neurodiverse children - we do, but arguably not enough.
Yet again, this all comes down to funding. There are too many children with SEN without appropriate support and too many classmates getting hurt on a daily basis. It is currently the saddest part of my job that I can’t guarantee children’s safety in my classroom, it’s absolutely appalling.

TizerorFizz · 17/11/2023 18:32

We need special schools. Too
many were closed on the mantra of “inclusion” in mainstream schools. It’s not acceptable for all the Dc in mainstream school to have Dc there who simply cannot cope. It’s not safe for the majority. Primary schools do exclude and there are primary prus. There’s not enough training for school staff either but some dc really should not be in mainstream schools.

PocketSand · 17/11/2023 17:24

The OP demonstrates that it is very easy to see trigger points for SEN DC (like standing too close when lining up) and very easy to come up with a solution that will prevent the SEN DC becoming overwhelmed and behave in a manner that impacts on the safety and well being of non-SEN classmates.

The real question is why that doesn't happen. The answer is funding and the length of time it takes to procure it. Realistically the SEN should be well understood at this point and 1:1 and social skills, social stories be in place. We are told mainstream can meet needs. Unfortunately the SEN budget is likely to be used for catch up learning to improve school stats. It is passing the buck and cheaper to use ineffective punishment of SEN DC and fail to safeguard their classmates. It sows division where the SEN DC are branded as violent little shits but fails to support them or provide access to alternative education such as special schools where more appropriate or safeguard classmates.

It is soul destroying for parents and damaging for DC when support is not put in place with inevitable results. Sometimes this happens deliberately so that the school can document need for additional funding. This is especially the case when DC are being 'assessed' ...

catphone · 17/11/2023 16:31

punishments dont work on SEN children. A mainstream school isn't a suitable environment which is why they're acting out, regular teachers don't have any of trainings to understand neurodiverse children

MrsMarzetti · 17/11/2023 11:34

Maybe you need to have your daughters back here. Where will you draw the line? How may times and how bad the injury before you expect to stand up for your daughter?

misssunshine4040 · 17/11/2023 11:30

@AtrociousCircumstance spot on

notahappybunny7 · 17/11/2023 11:03

YABU unless you’re also Donald’s mother show some loyalty to your kid and don’t teach her to put up and shut up cause some kid has “needs”

AtrociousCircumstance · 17/11/2023 11:00

Do your job: protect your daughter. Prioritise your daughter.

Anything else is you putting your need to feel ‘kind’ and ‘evolved’ above your child’s needs. Work that stuff out in your own adult relationships - don’t project it onto her.

Ikeatears · 17/11/2023 10:57

@Whatwouldyoudo24 I wouldn't question the school on this occasion as it isn't your child who is being punished.
Perhaps in your reply you could tell them about the kind things that your daughter mentioned that Donald has done as a small way of advocating for him but without undermining the school or not supporting your daughter?

wednamenov · 17/11/2023 10:39

Don't do this. Seriously. Do NOT do this.

I'm impressed the school are responding as they are. A child with SEN at our school has been hurting children for years, starting from when he was tiny. Now he's stronger, whole classes have to be evacuated when he's throwing tables around, and it's been getting worse and more dangerous as he gets older and much stronger. I feel quite strongly that if the school had taken a clearer line in early days, got more support for him etc, things would be better now - for him and other children.

My child was punched hard enough to be winded and fell to the ground. When he was on the ground he was kicked hard in the head. And attacked further times after that in quick succession. Very very dangerous.

I don't care what kind of SEN any child has, it is NEVER acceptable for other small children to have to absorb the negative consequences of their life circumstances. And that includes your DD.

My child didn't sign up to be a physical support aid for helping a child with SEN to learn to manage his emotions. Keep in mind too that being on the receiving end of these kinds of attacks can give rise to additional needs too: my child stopped wanting to go to school and became very anxious.

Adults need to do the right thing by both children: include kids with SEN and other issues AND ensure every single child is protected and safe. Every child has a right to safety. There are no exceptions and should be no tolerance for reduced safety. And parents of both sets of children should insist on this.

There is different primary school local to me where a child (one who very sadly grew up witnessing horrific domestic abuse) viciously fixates on a class member and will attack relentlessly. The school has had to occasionally lock him out the classroom to prevent him from returning and attacking again. A teacher there told me they're just dreading the day he brings in a knife. They can do virtually nothing because parents don't want to complain because they know his story and feel desperately sorry for him.

I look at both these kids and think, all the sympathy they're getting now, and tolerance, instead of hard focussed work in the form of all the support they need to help them, will vanish when they're adults.

The day the child in my school grows up and, as an adult, kicks another adult in the head, will be the day they go to jail. The day the kid at the other school stabs someone he'll be seen as a psychopath, and not a damaged child, overnight. He'll be written about in the local newspaper. Surely we want to avert that for these kids? And that means responding rationally (not emotionally) to behaviour now.

LakeTiticaca · 17/11/2023 10:31

It's not your concern. Protect your daughter instead of offering her up as another child's punch bag

ConflictofInterest · 17/11/2023 10:27

I agree with everyone else YABU. I've worked with severely disabled children in special schools and they still need consequences when they hurt others because otherwise how will they learn it's not ok? Also how else do you protect others? The teacher will decide what's the appropriate consequence, perhaps he is overwhelmed at lunch time and prefers spending it indoors anyway or it may just be a safer way to keep an eye on him.

fuckityfuckityfuckfuck · 17/11/2023 10:25

In several schools I've taught in, missing play for a child where playtime is vital for regulation, usually meant missing the main playtime with friends, but still having a run around in another area with an adult or (if they have a 1:1) taken outside during the afternoon for a run around.

Leah5678 · 17/11/2023 10:20

Bellyblueboy · 17/11/2023 09:49

Sorry that was a hit harsh - but I do hate this be kind mantra. It is especially pushed in little girls - be kind to the bigger stronger kid who punches you in the stomach he is having a bad day. Let’s understand why someone is being awful.

I never tell little girls to be kind - I tell them to push back, stand up for themselves.

one day your daughter will encounter a Donald at work - should she fawn and praise him when he is being a decent human being and ‘be kind’ when he steals her ideas and talks over her in meetings?

This 👏👏 could also be related to relationships so many girls make excuses for their abusive partners. No one should be punched in the stomach because someone else is having a bad day

Leah5678 · 17/11/2023 10:16

YABU. Your daughter should not have to put up with another kid thumping her in the stomach. Excuses for the boy are irrelevant your daughter is your priority. Good that the school are punishing him many people have to put up with their child being bullied and the school doing nothing about it

Swipe left for the next trending thread