Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel we get no privacy from adult dc

194 replies

northernroots · 16/11/2023 20:03

We have an ASD son who is 23 and is unlikely to ever move out he's even said so and that's fine with us.
He lives quite independently in that he works, drives and can cook and clean but he doesn't cope well on his own and is mentally more like a teenager.

He has no friends and never goes out except to work when we're all out.
He sits with us all evening on the sofa between us in the middle so if dh and I want to chat it's always around him or he answers for us.

He is always listening to every conversation and chipping in and he doesn't go to bed until we do.
If we go out he comes along and 99% of the time it's absolutely fine, we both know and accept he's only got us and doesn't go out alone.
I just feel frustrated that we have no privacy, no time together to actually be a married couple or a conversation or even a snuggle on the sofa.

He obviously does have his own bedroom but he doesn't go in it unless it's bedtime, he just never has.
He's very oblivious to this of course and just saying go and be in your bedroom would not make sense to him and he'd be very put out.

OP posts:
woollybean · 17/11/2023 18:55

Your son’s interests are exactly the same as my ASD son!! Not in the North West are you 😃

likethislikethat · 17/11/2023 18:39

northernroots · 16/11/2023 20:34

He'd assume he was coming and then feel very rejected and wonder why we didn't want him there.

So fire up Netflix, put out a pizza or something and tell him you'll be back later and not to wait up.

If he does fret then like a child, let him fret and get over it.

Then do it again pretty soon, even if only to the local pub for a few hours.

Keep doing it. He'll soon get the message that its ok, you're going out and he trusts you will be back.

And I guess he did once have a bedtime ? So send him to bed to give yourself time.

zingally · 17/11/2023 16:48

Having read through your follow-up posts, it sounds like, long term, it'll be an assisted living type place for him.

Just out of interest... his driving... How would he cope if he - heaven forbid - had an accident and had to deal with the various roadside dealings?

Stomacharmeleon · 17/11/2023 16:26

Think @ManateeFair has nailed it. Sometimes in our house things need to be spelt out to be understood.

SheIsStuck23 · 17/11/2023 16:15

northernroots · 16/11/2023 21:01

He understands relationships, he often says he fancies this person or that but he doesn't like dh and I kissing, that would create an ewww get a room reaction, little does he know we'd quite like to.

I’d be saying, “That’s a great idea son!”

And then take your husband’s hand and just go upstairs together.

Simple 👍

Verbena17 · 17/11/2023 16:05

ManateeFair · 17/11/2023 14:19

You need to be very direct and clear with him.

"Son, sometimes couples just need some privacy to do things alone. That doesn't mean we don't like your company. I don't know if this is something you've noticed, but most adults your age don't spend all their time with their parents. Their parents love them just as much as we love you, but it's good for adults to do things independently sometimes and it's as important for you as it is for us."

I think you could also try saying "Son, if you had a girlfriend, would you want me or your dad sitting on the sofa between you and her every night?" because I'm guessing the answer would be no. That might help him to understand why you need some privacy.

@ManateeFair this is a really good example.

TheNestedIf · 17/11/2023 14:51

I agree with the posters saying it would be better for him, and you, if you ease him into supported living. My brother is on the spectrum, 43 and still living with my parents. He has no hobbies, no friends and no life. My mother is using him for emotional incest purposes, and cannot be persuaded that it's in his best interests to help him to live independently. I've cut myself off from my family for many reasons, but one of those reasons was to reinforce the point that I will not ever be stepping into my mother's shoes. It hasn't made any difference. My parents are around 80, so this cannot carry on for much longer and my brother, sadly, will one day be dealing with the grief of losing his last parent and his home in one go.

ManateeFair · 17/11/2023 14:19

northernroots · 16/11/2023 20:34

He'd assume he was coming and then feel very rejected and wonder why we didn't want him there.

You need to be very direct and clear with him.

"Son, sometimes couples just need some privacy to do things alone. That doesn't mean we don't like your company. I don't know if this is something you've noticed, but most adults your age don't spend all their time with their parents. Their parents love them just as much as we love you, but it's good for adults to do things independently sometimes and it's as important for you as it is for us."

I think you could also try saying "Son, if you had a girlfriend, would you want me or your dad sitting on the sofa between you and her every night?" because I'm guessing the answer would be no. That might help him to understand why you need some privacy.

WickedSerious · 17/11/2023 14:03

northernroots · 16/11/2023 20:56

I agree, I'm probably making him too comfortable to avoid him feeling uncomfortable.

I've made the same mistake with our son,he's never worked and has no life outside our home.

waterrat · 17/11/2023 13:30

Soemtimes setting boundaries isn't what another person will be happy about - but - if you give your son 80 per cent of your time at home I think you need to just say very clearly - me and your dad need time just us - and decide what you are prepared to set as a boundary.

So - you say, me and your dad have decided to go out once a week just us - if you really really can't face saying that to him - then that's your decision. But I think you can own it, own the need for time on your own.

Carers need time off! You will end up burning out in life if you can't ever say no to your son. He is atusitic so presumably you will just need to spell it out really clearly.

It's really a tough one OP.

Verbena17 · 17/11/2023 13:28

@northernroots it might be worth reposting this in ‘SN teens and young adults’ for a more realistic/supportive set of replies.

Verbena17 · 17/11/2023 13:27

RantyAnty · 17/11/2023 13:24

Why are you assuming I'm non autistic?

I’m really not assuming you’re non autistic. I wrote my reply without referring to you specifically.

RantyAnty · 17/11/2023 13:24

Verbena17 · 17/11/2023 13:20

This is super harsh on the @northernroots OP.
My own DS can speak and write Japanese and play grade 8 piano but it takes him 15 mins to wash up one knife and he cannot speak to his grandparents on the phone! With ASD nothing is as straight forward as ‘just do this’ or ‘just say this’.

Every single autistic person is different & with a massive sliding scale of need.
What’s easy for one person could be extremely difficult for another.

What someone from a non-autistic background might call ‘coddling’, a parent of someone with ASD would see it as reducing their anxiety and making their environment support their need. From the outside, this might seem as though they’re making a rod for their back but to us, it’s reducing the accompanying anxiety in order for them to complete other daily needs. So if for example @northernroots was to make DS sit somewhere else or be left alone overnight, he might then be so super stressed, he wouldn’t make it into work the following day. It really is a difficult balance of supporting for whatever possible needs might crop up hours or days later.

And whilst very small steps towards independence is the ideal scenario, it’s much easier said than done and it’s more often 3 steps forward and 7 back.
it truly is exhausting living like this but that’s what many of our lives as autistic parents are like.

Why are you assuming I'm non autistic?

Verbena17 · 17/11/2023 13:20

RantyAnty · 17/11/2023 11:42

There's support and there's coddling.

You're coddling him.

If he can drive which is everything unpredictable and work a job, then he's capable of doing more for himself besides sitting between you and your H on the sofa every evening.

He's 23, not 5.

You have to ask yourself why you've let this go on for so long and what benefit to you him doing this has because their is some benefit or you wouldn't be doing it.

Is he really incapable is making a few small changes to be more independent or have you just not tried for an easy life and there is a part of his dependency that suits you?

This is super harsh on the @northernroots OP.
My own DS can speak and write Japanese and play grade 8 piano but it takes him 15 mins to wash up one knife and he cannot speak to his grandparents on the phone! With ASD nothing is as straight forward as ‘just do this’ or ‘just say this’.

Every single autistic person is different & with a massive sliding scale of need.
What’s easy for one person could be extremely difficult for another.

What someone from a non-autistic background might call ‘coddling’, a parent of someone with ASD would see it as reducing their anxiety and making their environment support their need. From the outside, this might seem as though they’re making a rod for their back but to us, it’s reducing the accompanying anxiety in order for them to complete other daily needs. So if for example @northernroots was to make DS sit somewhere else or be left alone overnight, he might then be so super stressed, he wouldn’t make it into work the following day. It really is a difficult balance of supporting for whatever possible needs might crop up hours or days later.

And whilst very small steps towards independence is the ideal scenario, it’s much easier said than done and it’s more often 3 steps forward and 7 back.
it truly is exhausting living like this but that’s what many of our lives as autistic parents are like.

Pinkdelight3 · 17/11/2023 11:58

Our 16yo has ASD and could be like this, but one of the good things about ASD is that it really helps to be direct with him and not dwell in that uncomfortable space of hinting etc. I would just tell him that me and his dad are a married couple and need time alone so he needs to go and do his gaming or whatever while we go out or have time in the house without him. He may well have a 'eww mum and dad kissing' reaction, but that's not unhelpful if it makes he want to not be around for it. What you and DH want is totally reasonable and you don't need to worry so much about upsetting him with it. It needs to be normalised in your home so it's not a big deal and not about him. Be direct, clear and logical about it, and it should be better for everyone.

RantyAnty · 17/11/2023 11:42

There's support and there's coddling.

You're coddling him.

If he can drive which is everything unpredictable and work a job, then he's capable of doing more for himself besides sitting between you and your H on the sofa every evening.

He's 23, not 5.

You have to ask yourself why you've let this go on for so long and what benefit to you him doing this has because their is some benefit or you wouldn't be doing it.

Is he really incapable is making a few small changes to be more independent or have you just not tried for an easy life and there is a part of his dependency that suits you?

SENDhelp2023 · 17/11/2023 11:38

I also have a son with asd, hes only 11 though. What about a flat of his own with your support si he can try and make hus own way in the wotld.

forrestgreen · 17/11/2023 11:32

If you start thinking about when you're getting old, if you don't change anything now nothing will be different then. And you'll be worrying about dying and leaving him (sorry) so it's better to make changes now, that def will make him uncomfortable, but will give everyone a better quality of life long term.

defineme · 17/11/2023 09:26

I also wanted to add that supported living is not really available for hfa people with jobs and able to do housework or drive. In my area they'd possibly be given direct payments to pay for a personal assistant to help them with life skills sort of stuff if they were struggling.
One of my jobs is as a self employed pa and I help support people in their own homes with anything like cleaning, healthy eating, paying bills, socialising, personal care.

defineme · 17/11/2023 09:21

Good luck op.
Baby steps, absolutely no need to rush him into supported living at 23!
He is doing far better than some neurotypical 23 year olds with his job and driving.

Start with the immediate sofa issue by taking some time just the 2 of you and work towards social groups etc. You've just got into a habitual way of living and it needs a bit of adjustment.

I feel no need to rush my son towards supported living. But we're all reasonably happy with our set up. My son goes out several nights a week, has a job, goes out with us, but also friends, his brother, his grandparents and a befriender.
My mother also lives with me in an annexe,so maybe I'm more used to an extended family living setting. I anticipate my neurotypical dc living back with us after university for a little while or as long as they need. I have nearly 2 decades of working life ahead of me, I don't think it's unreasonable to think I can look after my son for a bit longer, I have friends the same age as me with children under 10! He might end up in supported living at some point, he might end up being with his brother or he might be able to live with me until I'm 95..like my grandad who lived independently until then. I have a nice dream of me and him in the same care home..there's one near us that has elderly clients and younger clients with ld and it works so well.

Onelifeonly · 17/11/2023 09:07

I don't think you necessarily need to look at assisted living yet given your age (though things can happen at any age ...) but I do think he needs some gentle scaffolding towards independence. You say he is like a teenager but actually he's behaving more like a much younger child, since most teens like to get away from their parents and love having their own room to escape to.

He needs to learn to be alone for periods of time with or without you being in the house. What does he have to entertain him in his own room? TV, computer? Getting him into online gaming could be a good way to get him to interact with others. Yes, I know it can become an addiction and unhealthy, but it is also a less threatening way of being alongside others doing something they enjoy.

What about a sport? I don't mean a team sport which he may find too daunting but running, cycling, hiking etc? If you could start him off, he might get interested in doing it alone.

I also think you need to explain that couples do need time alone together. You could plan short outings - walk in park, or cafe visit or whatever - where he knows how long you'll be and when you'll be back.

To be honest, its part of normal parenting to do / encourage these things, you're just starting at a much older age.

CocoPlum · 17/11/2023 08:51

I don't think you've mentioned if you have other children ... but for everyone's sake please take some of the advice to get your son used to being alone/living more independently. I am close to someone whose sibling is like your DS (though much older). Their parent passed away, and they have struggled with loneliness, not wanted to get out, and it's basically up to their sibling to do everything remotely tricky for them - which is difficult as the person with ASD was used to being the focus of their parent and getting their own way. It's sad for the person with ASD and a heavy burden for their sibling. If you take action now you are lessening the load on any other DC, and setting up your son for when you will no longer be around.

Foodieasfuck · 17/11/2023 07:34

It sounds like you may have to wean him off you a little. Start with really small things like, your dad and I need to chat so we are going for a walk. Back in 20 mins etc… from what you are saying, it looks like you have fallen into a pattern and of course, you dont want him to feel rejected. Someone once said to me, if you want something to be different you have to stop doing the same thing. Which i found really helpful.
You sound like a really lovely and caring Mum. I hope you can find a way.

Pythonesque · 17/11/2023 07:22

I think it is important that you continue to expect him to be growing and learning - as you acknowledge, he is in many ways like a younger teenager still, and just because he is over 18 doesn't mean he is an adult with no further capacity for learning! But if you continue to expect and model small changes and progressions towards more independence, that process in itself will be part of his familiar routine. Each day/week/month/whatever, what are we going to do new or different this time?

Perhaps you need to discuss with your husband what you'd like life to look like for him and you in 5 / 10 / many years time. Create a vision of something, and then think what the steps to get there might be. Then find the first tiny steps that you could actually be taking now.

Good luck!

NowNumber5 · 17/11/2023 07:15

Good morning OP,
Try implementing a couple of very minor changes to start things off - how about you or your DH always sit in the middle seat of the sofa first (obviously talk to DH about this plan, when your son is at work) so your son has to sit on the side of that parent.

Then try phrasing things in his favour. For example, if you and DH want to go out for a walk, tell your son “We are going out for 20 minutes to give you some time to yourself”.

I think small baby steps are the key here.