Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask whether a very chatty 13 year old DC in class is 'normal' behaviour?

93 replies

Coldwater12 · 16/11/2023 17:07

Ever since DS was in Year 5, his reports have been a mix of: very bright, able and lovely - but so chatty and easily distracted/distracts others.

We are now in Year 8. The school he's at starts to do GCSES from year 9 and as well as his competence/ability, his attitude to learning will determine what sets he goes into next year.

Just got his progress report through. All except two subjects trots out the standard progress line that covers 'chats too much' or 'gets distracted' which essentially, is the same issue. Not on task. Not focussed.

He's really, really angry and upset with him. He says he tries, and that the report doesn't reflect how he sees himself.

I don't know what to think. There are a few things that might lead me to think he's got ADHD but nothing major. And he's doing well in his work.

I just feel frustrated. Is this normal for his age group? And if so, how can I help him to stay quiet?

OP posts:
WinterDeWinter · 16/11/2023 19:11

By failure I mean - it’s quite common for people with adhd to feel really ashamed of the disjunct between their potential and their actual achievements. My most horrendous sociopath boss once said to me ‘it’s clear you’re very clever, and yet somehow it comes to nothing.’

Coldwater12 · 16/11/2023 19:11

WinterDeWinter · 16/11/2023 19:07

I got the same report. I’ve got ADHD and chatting is the only way not to give in to an unbearable, overwhelming desire to get out of my chair and do something else.

get him assessed- it’s important because he will have accommodations in his exams and it will also make him feel like less of a failure.

I wonder if there's truth in this - if it just stops him realising he can't sit still etc

OP posts:
Coldwater12 · 16/11/2023 19:10

ginnybag · 16/11/2023 19:09

My DD gets frustrated by kids like this, too. And yes, her description for them is getting increasingly blunt.

It's not going to be making him any friends or his teachers.

Why do people feel the need to keep reinforcing this on this thread? I've completely owned this as an issue. It's pointless.

OP posts:
ginnybag · 16/11/2023 19:09

My DD gets frustrated by kids like this, too. And yes, her description for them is getting increasingly blunt.

It's not going to be making him any friends or his teachers.

WinterDeWinter · 16/11/2023 19:07

I got the same report. I’ve got ADHD and chatting is the only way not to give in to an unbearable, overwhelming desire to get out of my chair and do something else.

get him assessed- it’s important because he will have accommodations in his exams and it will also make him feel like less of a failure.

Afteropening · 16/11/2023 19:00

Hazey19 · 16/11/2023 18:56

Totally normal. My son is the same, as are all his friends.

yes, and these are the disruptive ones that are starting to pee off peers who have their eyes focussed on their education

MistressIggi · 16/11/2023 19:00

I tell a lot of students to stop talking but I very rarely go as far as writing it on their reports, that is for serious talkers only!

MistressIggi · 16/11/2023 18:59

There's a difference between your child being chatty sometimes in class, and the teacher deciding to write this on their report
If it's on the reports of several teachers, this is a real problem.

Hazey19 · 16/11/2023 18:56

Totally normal. My son is the same, as are all his friends.

cansu · 16/11/2023 18:54

Matchinglipsandfingertips What would you call the impact of a child who talks over the teacher and interferes with others when they are getting on with a task? How would a child with a hearing impairment deal with this? What about a child with sensory problems who finds noise a trigger for becoming dysregulated? My point which you haven't considered is that there are all kinds of needs in a classroom. The need for someone with SEMH to talk over others does not trump the needs of others for a calm, orderly learning environment.

Lougle · 16/11/2023 18:42

I think it depends really. In my DD's school they have a 2 strike rule for disruption and then the student is hubbed. So some kids learn to knuckle down who would otherwise chat. My personal feeling is that those kids who 'can't' end up in the hub, because who would willingly go to the hub twice. My point is... Apart from the report, what consequence does he face for being over chatty? If they aren't actively tackling it in class, then it's no wonder it isn't changing.

ManateeFair · 16/11/2023 18:38

Namechangedasouting987 · 16/11/2023 17:16

And also being bright, interested and effervescent should be a good thing. Our education system doesn't seem to always agree.

I wouldn't say chatting a lot in class was necessarily an indication of being bright, interested or effervescent, though. It could just as easily mean bored, disruptive and rude. Like the 'chatty' kid I had to sit next to in one of my classes at school. I was interested in the subject. She wasn't. She was a colossal pain-in-the-arse and most of the other kids in the class just wanted her to shut the fuck up. The reason I got put next to her in the first place was, in fact, because the teacher knew I would have no qualms about actually telling her to shut the fuck up.

I'm sure your child is indeed one of the bright and interested ones, but in a classroom setting, he and his desire to chat and 'share knowledge' are not more important than a) the teacher or b) any of the other children. One child shouldn't be making themselves the centre of attention by talking all the time. Obviously there are times when it's totally fine to chat in class - god knows I did plenty of chatting myself; I'm a hell of a talker - but if the teacher is reporting it as a problem, it means they need to learn that there are times when they should have some manners and rein it in.

GreyhpundGirl · 16/11/2023 18:32

I'm a secondary school teacher- yes it is normal, but not ideal as obviously he, and the students he's chatting to should be focusing on their work. My question would be- can he concentrate without distractions at home, and does he respond appropriately (I.e stop talking) when challenged by the teacher?

MrsHarrisAParis · 16/11/2023 18:28

We had a chatty DC. Tbh if it's been going on for 3 years for you - what have you tried so far? We engaged with the school when we got the first report saying they were chatty eg told school and DC that we were happy if the teacher moved their seat; told the school we were supporting them at home by telling DC to be quiet in school - explaining different techniques; going to a mindfulness class; playing games where you had to be quiet, etc.
DC still loves to chat but is now a year older than your DC and report card consistently says they're great in class, attentive, contributes well, etc. Maybe puberty brought a little bit more awareness. Maybe all the steps we've put in place since the first report helped. I don't know.
But I'd say you don't need to worry about them losing their personality just because they quieten down in school.

Mariposista · 16/11/2023 18:26

OP some kids are more talkative than others. Personally, I'd be more concerned about a withdrawn, disengaged kid. Your boy sounds great! As long s he is getting his work done, and not disturbing the others and stopping them learning, don't worry about him.

Please don't slap a SN on him. Plenty of talkative people are just that - talkative and sociable. There is nothing wrong with them.

And FWIW and said kindly, nobody was calling your son a dick. The PP intimated that other kids may think 'heck what a dick he won't shut up'. That is not the same as saying 'I (the PP)think he is being a dick as he talks too much'. Please don't be so defensive. Some may indeed think that. You don't and nor do his true friends, which is what's important.

Matchinglipsandfingertips · 16/11/2023 18:26

For those who have no knowledge of neuro diverse children this is a ridiculous post. Disruption of others? We have few special schools anymore. We have little or no SEMH network. Camhs is so over subscribed any child struggling will wait 18 months for help. A chatty child is an inconvenience but better than a silent one. This post makes me very angry. Be kind people. Read NFIS Facebook if you want to understand real barriers to learning. Fu*king middle class shit.

ManateeFair · 16/11/2023 18:22

I'm sure being overly chatty in class is a behaviour that's seen in a lot of kids with ADHD, but it's also a behaviour that's seen in a lot of kids without ADHD, so I don't that alone would be a warning sign; it would likely have to be accompanied by other signs and symptoms.

cansu · 16/11/2023 18:18

Matchinglipsandfingertips. How on earth do you know this child is interested and engaging?? I would imagine if you are trying to concentrate on the teacher's explanation and someone is turning round and talking to you or someone se this is annoying and disruptive. I am fed up of people shouting this kind of rubbish. Being neurodiverse does not mean others with differing needs don't matter. By the way I have two neurodiverse children. Their needs don't trump the needs of other children.

Pooooochi · 16/11/2023 18:17

ADHD is not a deficiency in attention; it’s a difficulty in regulating your attention to matters you find unstimulating.

Is this really the case? Most people are much worse at paying attention to stuff they find boring, what is the distinction between the normal range of inability to apply oneself to things you aren't interested in, and ADHD? Ive never heard it described in that way before. Surely it can't reach a level of clinical diagnosis unless it really impairs you.

Pooooochi · 16/11/2023 18:15

Oh and if he's doing well, his own ability to focus probably isn't an issue.

Lots of teachers don't like bright chatty kids primarily because:

  • they can disturb others
  • talkative kids can mean quiet kids get less chance to speak/contribute
  • sometimes they are poorer listeners and will do things like interrupt

So maybe focus on these aspects of it when talking to your DC about how they need to change their behaviour. Its not about them not trying etc its the impact on others.

Younghearts · 16/11/2023 18:14

I think you’re best giving the school a call and asking to meet with them or have a phone call to chat about the report. Rather than spend the next few days wondering what it means or why they’ve wrote it xx

TheRulerofThings · 16/11/2023 18:14

Parent to an ADHD child here. It’s not a label, it’s a medical diagnosis which is bloody hard to get, despite what some people here seem to believe.

OP there are definitely a few flags here which would suggest it’s worth looking into. As another poster said - look closely at how your child manages things he is not interested in. ADHD is not a deficiency in attention; it’s a difficulty in regulating your attention to matters you find unstimulating. Many people with ADHD excel in areas which match their interests as they hyperfocus on them - which is why it is possible for some to do very well in school and yet also have ADHD. In your shoes I would keep an open mind - have a look at the online questionnaires, even if just to set your mind at ease.

BurbageBrook · 16/11/2023 18:13

You've had lots of good advice on your son's behaviour but I just wanted to chip in as someone who is an ex teacher that it is completely wrong that behaviour determines setting, if that is really the case at this school. Setting should never be based on behaviour as that makes it utterly unfair on hard working pupils in the lower sets.

Jifmicroliquid · 16/11/2023 18:12

Chatty kids are disruptive in lessons. Some of them are bright enough that their chatting doesn’t impact their learning particularly, but it has an impact on the rest of the class because they distract others or the teacher has to stop everything to tell them to stop.
A chatty kid who doesn’t cause any issues, I never mentioned on reports. A chatty kid who is disruptive in class I would mention.

Matchinglipsandfingertips · 16/11/2023 18:12

Really? I was trying to help you. I gave you statistics, clever people need support too. Chatting is not always a ND pointer. People have attacked your child. Please don't bother to reply.

Swipe left for the next trending thread