Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave toddler playing in the other room for a bit?

289 replies

Frogmarch89 · 16/11/2023 13:43

So 18 month old has a giant playpen full of toys. If somebody is in the room she will only play in it with somebody else, she won't play independently. However if there is nobody else in there she happily plays with her toys and talks to her Teddy bears and dolls.

So sometimes I put her in it, make a cuppa and go in the other room for 20 minutes or so. Both doors are open so I can hear her playing and it is safe in there.

I mentioned doing this to my friend and she says that its not normal to leave a child that young alone. I didn't really think anything of it, it's only now and again and gives me a chance to have a cuppa in peace.

AIBU?

OP posts:
AprilFools2015 · 18/11/2023 00:47

Jk987 · 16/11/2023 14:21

Omg you don't need a camera! What exactly is going to happen? You can hear her play and you'll know if gets upset. Enjoy the break OP!

Exactly this. And props to person who called out the total idiot who says a camera is violating an 18 month olds rights...seriously get some perspective! Are my rights being violated because my 70 odd year old parents still have the only photographs of my 1980s layering that looked like a perm, etc.? Erm no, I will survive (I wish they had been burned defo, but I will survive). Stop talking utter drivel, there's precedence here...that Nirvana baby dude lost his case.

Mel2023 · 17/11/2023 23:28

TiredMummma · 17/11/2023 23:15

Oh gosh, I am surprised your health visitor didn't tell you that SIDS risk doubles if you are not in the room for long periods - it's not just about room sharing at night - until 6 months. I just would never have taken this risk with any of my children, it's just not worth it for a 20 minute shower and the stress of them crying and not immediately responding is not something I could do either.

Sorry I should I clarified I always had the monitor on them. I carried it round the house with me/ propped it up by the shower etc and then checked on them often. My child was, and still is, a heavy breather/ snorer. If they went quite boy did I go and see. But they’ve always napped in their room/upstairs. Or if they were asleep in Moses basket in the living room I’d leave them be, put the monitor on and close the door. Of course I know the risks of SIDS and they are as always regularly checked on along with the monitor. I asked my midwife when I was pregnant as my friend as scared me by saying I had to be round baby 24/7 even when they napped, honestly felt quite overwhelmed by that. She actually laughed and said no of course not, as long as they’re in a safe space like a Moses basket, checked on and monitored you’re fine.

Mel2023 · 17/11/2023 23:24

Sorry I should I clarified I always had the monitor on them. I carried it round the house with me/ propped it up by the shower etc and then checked on them often. My child was, and still is, a heavy breather/ snorer. If they went quite boy did I go and see. But they’ve always napped in their room/upstairs. Or if they were asleep in Moses basket in the living room I’d leave them be, put the monitor on and close the door. Of course I know the risks of SIDS and they are as always regularly checked on along with the monitor. I asked my midwife when I was pregnant as my friend as scared me by saying I had to be round baby 24/7 even when they napped, honestly felt quite overwhelmed by that. She actually laughed and said no of course not, as long as they’re in a safe space like a Moses basket, checked on and monitored you’re fine.

Koalasparkles · 17/11/2023 23:15

PinkRoses1245 · 16/11/2023 13:51

of course it's fine? They and you need space. and don't use a camera, it's total violation of their rights, they can't consent.

Sorry, what? 😅

TiredMummma · 17/11/2023 23:15

Mel2023 · 17/11/2023 23:07

Jeez absolutely not lax parenting. Everyone parent’s differently. I’m the type of parent who from day 1 home from the hospital put baby in Moses basket in the bedroom while I took a shower/got dressed/did housework etc for 20 mins/ half an hour. My health visitor and midwife always emphasised that if baby is in a safe space and checked on then it’s ok, get yourself a short break. This translates to toddler age surely. I didn’t think anything of it until a friend mentioned to me she thought it strange, and carried her baby everywhere, to the extent of lying them on the bathroom floor when in there! I often go out to run on our treadmill (and have done from about 10wks pp) which is in the garden summer house while LO naps and just take the baby monitor. You do you. Your child is obviously fine. If you’re concerned put a baby monitor in there.

Oh gosh, I am surprised your health visitor didn't tell you that SIDS risk doubles if you are not in the room for long periods - it's not just about room sharing at night - until 6 months. I just would never have taken this risk with any of my children, it's just not worth it for a 20 minute shower and the stress of them crying and not immediately responding is not something I could do either.

SleepingStandingUp · 17/11/2023 23:10

PinkRoses1245 · 16/11/2023 13:51

of course it's fine? They and you need space. and don't use a camera, it's total violation of their rights, they can't consent.

So it's ok for op to strip her off, wipe her bum, stare at her 16 hours a day all without consent but a video camera is crossing a line? Does that mean you're never taken a single photo of your child until they could give informed consent??

saythatagaintome · 17/11/2023 23:09

i don’t see the problem?
my toddler also plays independently if I’m in the other room, and she’s not even in a playpen, however my home is child safe.

Mel2023 · 17/11/2023 23:07

Jeez absolutely not lax parenting. Everyone parent’s differently. I’m the type of parent who from day 1 home from the hospital put baby in Moses basket in the bedroom while I took a shower/got dressed/did housework etc for 20 mins/ half an hour. My health visitor and midwife always emphasised that if baby is in a safe space and checked on then it’s ok, get yourself a short break. This translates to toddler age surely. I didn’t think anything of it until a friend mentioned to me she thought it strange, and carried her baby everywhere, to the extent of lying them on the bathroom floor when in there! I often go out to run on our treadmill (and have done from about 10wks pp) which is in the garden summer house while LO naps and just take the baby monitor. You do you. Your child is obviously fine. If you’re concerned put a baby monitor in there.

Teenagehorrorbag · 17/11/2023 23:05

MY DTs were often left in playpens and similar while I got on with jobs. When very small I would put them in a Moses basket and take them outside while I did gardening jobs. When they were mobile I absolutely used playpens. I remember leaving DS in a wheely chair aged about 8 mths, and I went outside to do a few jobs. I kept looking through the window to check on them both.

After a bit I looked through the window and the chair was empty! I nearly had a heart attack! Ran indoors and found DS lying on his back next to the chair, happily playing with his fingers. He'd obviously put his foot against the crossbar under the seat, and levered himself out. Scary....

Sorry - I'm not trying to put you off. I was obviously a bit slack but as long as you child is somewhere safe then you're absolutely fine!

CaspianPlover · 17/11/2023 22:56

How times have changed. I put my babies well wrapped up, in their pram, in the garden. I would listen every 10 mins or so to see if they were awake, no child has ever come to harm from crying for a while - we used to say it exercised their lungs 😅 perhaps it would be good for children and mums to do as their mums used to do rather than then the smothering and dare I say stifling over care that seems to prevail today. As long as your child cant come to harm a few minutes of crying is not going to harm them. Let them exercise those lungs 🥰

itsmylife7 · 17/11/2023 22:48

Playpens were very commonly used years ago. She's safe and enjoys it so carry on.

Your friend needs to keep her opinions to herself and stop judging you.

JMAngel1 · 17/11/2023 22:46

PinkRoses1245 · 16/11/2023 13:51

of course it's fine? They and you need space. and don't use a camera, it's total violation of their rights, they can't consent.

Ok, so the world has officially gone mad.

Nbobun · 17/11/2023 22:43

@Moglet4 I'm Chinese and I often left my baby to nap outside in the pram or rocker, being winter or summer, as long as he was wrapped up or protected from the sun.
My parents also left me outside in the pram when I was a baby. If I were screaming, my dad would say it was good to release some energy 🤣. The others were mortified 🤣

WimbyAce · 17/11/2023 22:36

Sounds fine to me. I totally get what you mean though, if I am in the room mine will want me to play. If I'm in the kitchen I just hear her chatting away to her toys quite happily.

stichguru · 17/11/2023 22:35

This is fine. It's what playpens are for. Your friend is like crazy! Does she always take her child to the loo, or just make sure she doesn't need a number 2 when there is no other adult present?!

AmazingSnakeHead · 17/11/2023 22:29

Your friend is mad, does she really have no time where her child is alone? How will they learn to play by themselves without attention? At that age children are mobile, do you just follow them from room to room no matter what you're doing? My Ds used to play in his room alone for 15/20 minutes, with me checking in and all doors open (in a flat so I could hear him perfectly and get to him instantly if needed).

Frogmarch89 · 17/11/2023 22:29

I'm glad to see I'm not alone in my thinking.

Interesting to read that some feel it's a no no. She really is very close by and I peak in but fair enough if its not something you would do.

To answer some questions, I can't just have a cuppa in the same room as her without her wanting it/trying to get it 😆. She's a funny one my DD if you're in the room she's obsessed with you but very much out of sight out of mind. If you're away from her she will play happily. So thays why.

I wouldn't agree it's lax parenting, it's 20 minutes maybe twice a week 🤣

OP posts:
Elaina87 · 17/11/2023 22:26

PinkRoses1245 · 16/11/2023 13:51

of course it's fine? They and you need space. and don't use a camera, it's total violation of their rights, they can't consent.

Consent? Why are you banding that around? She's not recording her and putting her all over the internet. It would be a monitor to check she is safe while she has a cuppa in peace.

Firebird83 · 17/11/2023 22:26

I’m jealous! I also have an 18 month old who I can’t leave for more than a minute without her crying or coming to find me.

CuteCillian · 17/11/2023 22:21

As soon as a day time nap was dropped I substituted it with solo play. Good for them and me. I can see it really has helped each child to be happy in their own company now they are young adults. Some of their contemporaries still struggle.

Scottishskifun · 17/11/2023 22:19

TheBerry · 17/11/2023 15:39

I honestly thought everyone did this???

I’m amazed to hear your friend doesn’t think it’s ok.

Nope but DS1 was a koala til well over 2. DS2 will sit happily or play with his brother whilst I make food etc. But I can see them easily.

I would probably set up a camera just incase OP

Spottydogtoo · 17/11/2023 22:12

Should the consent be in writing? And does it need to be witnessed? 😂

Maybe87 · 17/11/2023 22:02

She is in a room that you feel she is safe and she stays there for 20 mins playing happily.. I have done it and I would do it again! Those who say they wouldn’t do it, what are they doing when they go for a number 2??

Winnipeggy · 17/11/2023 21:48

FestiveSandman · 17/11/2023 19:51

I think that’s way too young and very lackadaisical parenting. I wouldn’t entertain that until 2/2.5.

Seriously? 🙄

Moglet4 · 17/11/2023 21:48

Lifeomars · 17/11/2023 21:29

My mum used to put me outside in my pram (I was a summer baby) to nap, she said she parked the pram under the washing line and I would lie there watching my nappies fluttering in the breeze!

They sleep so much better outside!

Swipe left for the next trending thread