Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave toddler playing in the other room for a bit?

289 replies

Frogmarch89 · 16/11/2023 13:43

So 18 month old has a giant playpen full of toys. If somebody is in the room she will only play in it with somebody else, she won't play independently. However if there is nobody else in there she happily plays with her toys and talks to her Teddy bears and dolls.

So sometimes I put her in it, make a cuppa and go in the other room for 20 minutes or so. Both doors are open so I can hear her playing and it is safe in there.

I mentioned doing this to my friend and she says that its not normal to leave a child that young alone. I didn't really think anything of it, it's only now and again and gives me a chance to have a cuppa in peace.

AIBU?

OP posts:
FestiveSandman · 18/11/2023 18:50

Mamato29192 · 18/11/2023 18:44

I put my son in the cot at 6 weeks so he got used to it with a monitor whilst I was downstairs. It's fine to do that

No, it’s not fine to do that. Don’t give out dangerous advice.

Baby needs to be in the same space as you when sleeping (day and night) until 6 months because they base their heart rate, breathing and temperature on you. It prevents SIDS.

A baby monitor doesn’t help with any of that.

BertieBotts · 18/11/2023 18:46

Oh I did miss the playpen part - I would be happy to leave them playing indefinitely, if they can come and find me if they want to. In a playpen is different. Sorry I'm tired and must have skim read.

But yes it's totally fine to leave them to it for a while if they are happy.

Mamato29192 · 18/11/2023 18:44

Brilliantlydone · 18/11/2023 06:43

The advice now is to be with your baby in the same room when they are sleeping, day or night, to reduce the risk of sids. Monitor makes no difference to this. Of course everyone in reality weighs up risks and makes the choice that fits best for them, but just in case anyone with a little baby is reading this and thinks they might be over the top for being in the same room as their baby when they nap!

Op yanbu. I leave my 12 month old to play by himself from time to time so I can cook/ put a wash on etc etc..i pop in and out.

I put my son in the cot at 6 weeks so he got used to it with a monitor whilst I was downstairs. It's fine to do that

BertieBotts · 18/11/2023 18:43

It's a completely normal thing to do!

And what does it matter if it DOES stretch to an hour? What terrible thing is going to happen if they are playing happily for an hour? (Very unlikely for an 18mo to self entertain for that long anyway).

Make sure you can hear them and are checking in in case of accidents.

threatmatrix · 18/11/2023 18:42

MaryShelley1818 · 16/11/2023 13:45

I wouldn't leave an 18month old playing unsupervised in another room but I'm a bit over cautious and as you've described it sounds relatively safe. Could you put a camera in?

In a playpen?

saffy2 · 18/11/2023 18:31

I’ve never used a playpen and always left my
children to play if they are happy while I do stuff. At any age really! My youngest often played in the garden on her own before she could walk 😂 things were risk assessed and made as safe as possible for her.

Soulou · 18/11/2023 18:28

Absolutely fine, would make sure no water cup in with her. It does everyone good to have downtime and she sounds perfectly safe. It can be a good thing, as it can help with separation issues later on.

FestiveSandman · 18/11/2023 18:23

Manthide · 18/11/2023 17:15

I'm an older generation and I don't really like the idea of video monitors in the bedroom. We had a baby monitor that let us know if dc were crying, in distress etc but it's a bit like trackers on phones it just seems a step too far. Dd2 does have a video baby monitor but I'm glad they weren't around when mine were young.

You’re glad you weren’t able to safely watch your child?

Are you also glad you weren’t able to have safe sleep advice or safe car seats too?

Survivor bias is rife with “your generation”, but unfortunately you can’t tell your bullshit we were fine mantra to the ones who died.

IncreasinglyGrumpy · 18/11/2023 18:22

If its nice and safe then I would say it shows your little one already has a healthy sense of attachment and knows you'll come back - good for you both

Manthide · 18/11/2023 17:15

I'm an older generation and I don't really like the idea of video monitors in the bedroom. We had a baby monitor that let us know if dc were crying, in distress etc but it's a bit like trackers on phones it just seems a step too far. Dd2 does have a video baby monitor but I'm glad they weren't around when mine were young.

Radioshark · 18/11/2023 10:12

That is the beauty of a playpen. You can leave them playing safely while hanging out clothes, answering the door, going to the toilet etc.

MrsB74 · 18/11/2023 10:06

Notmetoo · 16/11/2023 13:49

I wouldn't do it but I would never use a playpen either. But if it works for you and she's happy then it's fine.

What an odd comment! It was the only way I could go to the toilet (I have twins)

Georgyporky · 18/11/2023 09:50

Babyboomtastic · 16/11/2023 15:11

😂😂😂

Funniest post I've read for a long time.

Singleandproud · 18/11/2023 09:40

@Whiteday where did I say she was on the floor when I used hot things? Ofcourse that would be a ridiculous thing to do, that's why she would be sat in her high chair playing with playdoh or similar - not so when I was washing up or making a sandwich when it was fine to be on the floor

Whiteday · 18/11/2023 09:22

Singleandproud · 18/11/2023 08:42

@JLou08 you take them with you, they sit in their high chair/ at the table/ play with pots and pans on the floor and play whilst you get the meal ready and tidy up.

When you do the chores they come along with you, they love to help.

Nipping to the loo is very different to leaving them for 20 minutes. But she would just play in the hallway at the top of the stairs with the door open if home alone. Sleepwise we co-slept and breast fed till she was 3 so we went to bed at the same time and I'd just read/ listen to music/ watch TV on a tablet until she was asleep

How utterly ridiculous to have a child playing on the floor in the kitchen, whilst you cook.

Hot liquids, dropped items etc, much more of a hazard than being in a play pen.

Mumoftrois · 18/11/2023 08:58

My 12 month old twins have one- they are always in there on their own whilst I cook, nip to the loo have a quick shower etc. the only way I can get anything done!! More hazardous being in there together too as they climb on each other 😂😂 she will be perfectly fine just keep checking on her!

Singleandproud · 18/11/2023 08:42

@JLou08 you take them with you, they sit in their high chair/ at the table/ play with pots and pans on the floor and play whilst you get the meal ready and tidy up.

When you do the chores they come along with you, they love to help.

Nipping to the loo is very different to leaving them for 20 minutes. But she would just play in the hallway at the top of the stairs with the door open if home alone. Sleepwise we co-slept and breast fed till she was 3 so we went to bed at the same time and I'd just read/ listen to music/ watch TV on a tablet until she was asleep

JLou08 · 18/11/2023 06:53

I'm interested in how people who say they wouldn't do this get anything done. Like how do you make the toddlers meals and clean up afterwards? Do they need to sit in the bathroom with you when you need the toilet? If you wouldn't leave them in a playpen in the day do you not leave them alone in their cot/bed at night?

Brilliantlydone · 18/11/2023 06:43

Mel2023 · 17/11/2023 23:24

Sorry I should I clarified I always had the monitor on them. I carried it round the house with me/ propped it up by the shower etc and then checked on them often. My child was, and still is, a heavy breather/ snorer. If they went quite boy did I go and see. But they’ve always napped in their room/upstairs. Or if they were asleep in Moses basket in the living room I’d leave them be, put the monitor on and close the door. Of course I know the risks of SIDS and they are as always regularly checked on along with the monitor. I asked my midwife when I was pregnant as my friend as scared me by saying I had to be round baby 24/7 even when they napped, honestly felt quite overwhelmed by that. She actually laughed and said no of course not, as long as they’re in a safe space like a Moses basket, checked on and monitored you’re fine.

Edited

The advice now is to be with your baby in the same room when they are sleeping, day or night, to reduce the risk of sids. Monitor makes no difference to this. Of course everyone in reality weighs up risks and makes the choice that fits best for them, but just in case anyone with a little baby is reading this and thinks they might be over the top for being in the same room as their baby when they nap!

Op yanbu. I leave my 12 month old to play by himself from time to time so I can cook/ put a wash on etc etc..i pop in and out.

GaggleTheGoose · 18/11/2023 06:00

PinkRoses1245 · 16/11/2023 13:51

of course it's fine? They and you need space. and don't use a camera, it's total violation of their rights, they can't consent.

I have no words. None. Zero. Zilch. 😂😂

GaggleTheGoose · 18/11/2023 05:55

Of course it's fine. It's character building too because they're less clingy if they're left alone to play in their playpen etc.
Your friend is being a drama llama.

Whiteday · 18/11/2023 05:51

PinkRoses1245 · 16/11/2023 13:51

of course it's fine? They and you need space. and don't use a camera, it's total violation of their rights, they can't consent.

Oh dear god! WTAF!

Sarasara1983 · 18/11/2023 02:32

its fine!

BeckiBoBecki · 18/11/2023 01:31

Are you insane? Watching a baby in person or via a camera in another room is utterly normal. Should mum turn off the baby monitor too?

Should she ask permission before changing her nappy?

I hope to god you’re baiting.

AprilFools2015 · 18/11/2023 01:05

Mel2023 · 17/11/2023 23:28

Sorry I should I clarified I always had the monitor on them. I carried it round the house with me/ propped it up by the shower etc and then checked on them often. My child was, and still is, a heavy breather/ snorer. If they went quite boy did I go and see. But they’ve always napped in their room/upstairs. Or if they were asleep in Moses basket in the living room I’d leave them be, put the monitor on and close the door. Of course I know the risks of SIDS and they are as always regularly checked on along with the monitor. I asked my midwife when I was pregnant as my friend as scared me by saying I had to be round baby 24/7 even when they napped, honestly felt quite overwhelmed by that. She actually laughed and said no of course not, as long as they’re in a safe space like a Moses basket, checked on and monitored you’re fine.

Good grief the world is losing its marbles!!! Well done Mel2023 for calling out this utter cudswallop!! First OPs tyke is 1.5 years old not 6months or under, 2nd my tyke slept in his own cot in own room from round 4 months & it improved our sanity no end!! 3. there are ways to keep an eye (baby monitors, camera monitors, listen for your child, etc.) 4. Are women/parents supposed to just never sleep again?? 5. tyke sat in his bouncy chair while I showered from similar age, he was in bathroom with me & safe and I could have a blinkin' wash! (he also sat in high chair, sleepy head etc. while I made a cuppa, baked the odd cake, hoovered, etc., he also napped for 3 hrs a day until he was 4 - bliss - and came out in travel system / buggy for walks/baby classes for hours at a time, with planes overhead as it was Windsor...we both adored this Mat Leave time a bunch!) 6. I went back 2 work 3 days a week when he was 8.5 months old, he went to nursery...cried every day, but loved it. Please, please trust me...yes there is SIDS, but you will not be helping them by constantly panicking & never getting any sort of break!!! Tyke is 8 now and fine...he has autism & adhd but that's genetic, not because I didn't stay with him 24/7 until he went to school.