Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave toddler playing in the other room for a bit?

289 replies

Frogmarch89 · 16/11/2023 13:43

So 18 month old has a giant playpen full of toys. If somebody is in the room she will only play in it with somebody else, she won't play independently. However if there is nobody else in there she happily plays with her toys and talks to her Teddy bears and dolls.

So sometimes I put her in it, make a cuppa and go in the other room for 20 minutes or so. Both doors are open so I can hear her playing and it is safe in there.

I mentioned doing this to my friend and she says that its not normal to leave a child that young alone. I didn't really think anything of it, it's only now and again and gives me a chance to have a cuppa in peace.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Mamato29192 · 19/11/2023 12:26

wokbun · 19/11/2023 09:41

I think people should read the safe sleep advice from the lullaby trust and decide what they are comfortable with.

And I was comfortable and happy to do what I did. Baba was happy.

TulipinUK · 19/11/2023 12:18

Consent????? Are you serious?

Mamato29192 · 19/11/2023 11:52

BertieBotts · 19/11/2023 09:42

This is not totally correct. They have found a chemical which they think is implicated in SIDS, but it doesn't negate safe sleep advice and it's not THE cause, it's just thought to be one contributing factor. The current medical understanding of SIDS is that it tends to happen with a triad:

Vulnerable baby (which might include this gene or it might include factors like being born premature)
Vulnerable period (2-4 months being the peak risk period)
Environmental factors (separate room, face down, too hot, excess bedding, etc)

OTOH yes SIDS is rare. Guidelines are supposed to tell you best practice so that you can work out what your own comfort level is. The idea that if you don't follow guidelines rigidly to the letter it's "unsafe" or "not fine" or dangerous or something terrible is going to happen is just false and an extreme exaggeration of reality. It's about risk reduction not risk avoidance.

There seems to be this sense especially online that guidelines are some kind of magic talisman and I don't think this is helpful. There is always, even if you follow every single thing, a baseline small risk of SIDS. However, the vast vast majority of SUDI cases are happening for babies who are living in pretty chaotic circumstances - parents with addiction, non stable housing, no proper bed, very little medical care etc.

Quibbling about a healthy infant with well supported parents in a stable, warm household - little things like where they sleep has a very very small effect on the overall risk level. We should be aware of these things and let them inform our decision making, it's not correct to just poo poo it and say it doesn't matter. But at the same time it's also up to an individual family to make an informed choice about what risk level they are comfortable with.

Well yeah stick to the guidelines, wasn't far off it being correct. Not all babies are born with it but if they are its likely to happen. But there's a difference between suffocation and sids.

My son when a bit older got a blanket in his cot. He had 2 teddies from the start. He always got put on his back when I put him down. I made the right decision. Followed my gut and instincts. We slept better when I moved him in to his room then.

He's in a warm and loving home.

BertieBotts · 19/11/2023 09:42

Mamato29192 · 19/11/2023 09:18

Sids is rare. And its a chemical in the brain. Babies are born with it so you can't really prevent it. My son was fine. I did check on him now and again. He was in his own room at 11 weeks. Was better for both of us.

This is not totally correct. They have found a chemical which they think is implicated in SIDS, but it doesn't negate safe sleep advice and it's not THE cause, it's just thought to be one contributing factor. The current medical understanding of SIDS is that it tends to happen with a triad:

Vulnerable baby (which might include this gene or it might include factors like being born premature)
Vulnerable period (2-4 months being the peak risk period)
Environmental factors (separate room, face down, too hot, excess bedding, etc)

OTOH yes SIDS is rare. Guidelines are supposed to tell you best practice so that you can work out what your own comfort level is. The idea that if you don't follow guidelines rigidly to the letter it's "unsafe" or "not fine" or dangerous or something terrible is going to happen is just false and an extreme exaggeration of reality. It's about risk reduction not risk avoidance.

There seems to be this sense especially online that guidelines are some kind of magic talisman and I don't think this is helpful. There is always, even if you follow every single thing, a baseline small risk of SIDS. However, the vast vast majority of SUDI cases are happening for babies who are living in pretty chaotic circumstances - parents with addiction, non stable housing, no proper bed, very little medical care etc.

Quibbling about a healthy infant with well supported parents in a stable, warm household - little things like where they sleep has a very very small effect on the overall risk level. We should be aware of these things and let them inform our decision making, it's not correct to just poo poo it and say it doesn't matter. But at the same time it's also up to an individual family to make an informed choice about what risk level they are comfortable with.

wokbun · 19/11/2023 09:41

Mamato29192 · 19/11/2023 09:18

Sids is rare. And its a chemical in the brain. Babies are born with it so you can't really prevent it. My son was fine. I did check on him now and again. He was in his own room at 11 weeks. Was better for both of us.

I think people should read the safe sleep advice from the lullaby trust and decide what they are comfortable with.

Mimic24 · 19/11/2023 09:39

Definitely ok. It’s good for your mental health to have a break and you will go back with more patience. A play pen is safe so why not?

Mamato29192 · 19/11/2023 09:18

FestiveSandman · 18/11/2023 18:50

No, it’s not fine to do that. Don’t give out dangerous advice.

Baby needs to be in the same space as you when sleeping (day and night) until 6 months because they base their heart rate, breathing and temperature on you. It prevents SIDS.

A baby monitor doesn’t help with any of that.

Sids is rare. And its a chemical in the brain. Babies are born with it so you can't really prevent it. My son was fine. I did check on him now and again. He was in his own room at 11 weeks. Was better for both of us.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 19/11/2023 07:45

Of course it’s ok. Especially in a playpen! No different to playing alone in the cot when they wake at night.

catattacks · 19/11/2023 07:34

Totally fine

its good to encourage some independent playing

Elisi · 19/11/2023 01:49

Why do you think playpens were invented? There are numerous occasions where a mum needs to know that their toddler is safe while they're doing things. Mopping the floor? Playpen. Cooking dinner for when hubby and eldest son get in from work and school? Your chirpy lil angel crawling around your feet when you're cooking? Playpen in the kitchen. Need a poo? Pop you in the playpen, mummy needs a poo. Playpens aren't for dumping children in when you can't be arsed, they are a necessary bit of equipment to keep your child safe, and also to give them a bit of space that they can call their own. She'll be climbing out of it before long, she will let you know if she's unhappy 😁 xx

MarvellousMonsters · 19/11/2023 00:43

PinkRoses1245 · 16/11/2023 13:51

of course it's fine? They and you need space. and don't use a camera, it's total violation of their rights, they can't consent.

A violation of their rights? Hmm Best get rid of those baby monitors too!

JustMe262 · 18/11/2023 22:52

She’s 18 months not 18 years! Nothing wrong with a camera so she can make sure the baby is safe.

Whiteday · 18/11/2023 21:05

restingbitchface30 · 18/11/2023 20:10

Nothing wrong with that! I have 16 mo twins and I leave them playing for close to an hour every night to cook. Obviously I pop in to make sure they’re ok every few minutes but we cannot have our babies glued to us constantly!

Sensible parenting IMO!

Elpaso42 · 18/11/2023 21:02

People are very obsessed with cameras, I would wager that anyone on here will have made it to adulthood without them!
It's fine if you want them but playpens were invented for precisely this reason. I think you're getting your dc into a good habit of entertaining herself, you don't to be attached to her 24/7.

Jeannie88 · 18/11/2023 20:32

Fine to have some time out but you also need to keep an eye out, they are able to find the slightest thing to do that is dangerous! Maybe a camera there so you can actually see what she's doing or frequent popping head round door. Would leave mine in small playpen while just going to loo or hoovering but would have visual contact most of the time. Listening out isn't enough at that age really, hearing a worrying noise and not knowing what happened 😐

restingbitchface30 · 18/11/2023 20:10

Nothing wrong with that! I have 16 mo twins and I leave them playing for close to an hour every night to cook. Obviously I pop in to make sure they’re ok every few minutes but we cannot have our babies glued to us constantly!

Snippit · 18/11/2023 20:02

If you can see her I don’t see a problem. Some people are so overprotective and pretty much anal. If you’re comfortable with it and your child is happy where’s the harm.

Lollipop81 · 18/11/2023 19:51

I used to leave mine in a travel cot with toys and watching tv whilst I had a quick shower, so I guess it’s the same. Different strokes

BooBooDoodle · 18/11/2023 19:44

I left both of mine playing in a play pen when they were little. I had washing to take upstairs or a quick chance to make a bed and tidy up etc. I don’t agree with kids being stuck to their parents all the time, they need to learn to independently play and occupy themselves. You’re talking 20 odd minutes at a time, you can hear them should they need you. It’s healthy for you as a mother to grab a break when you see fit and recharge a little.

Ilovecleaning · 18/11/2023 19:34

This sounds absolutely fine. I laughed at one poster who asked can you install a camera! So you can watch her grow wings and fly out of her playpen? 🤣🤣🤣

ambr · 18/11/2023 19:31

What you’re doing is perfectly normal. The comment from your friend about it not being normal sounds harsh, uncalled for and really not supportive. I’d say it wasn’t a normal reaction from a friend.

CantFindMyMarbles · 18/11/2023 19:31

your child is safe, well engaged and happy.
your friend is utterly bizarre.

Manthide · 18/11/2023 19:20

Why would I need to watch my child while it slept when I could hear them? Also I had my eldest just after the back to sleep campaign so I obviously followed that advice (she hated it) and we also had car seats which we used - and seatbelts. I have 4dc and was always within hearing distance. The elder two were about 16 when they had their first mobile phone and they weren't smart so no option to track - and I wouldn't track my 15 year old unless they asked.

SouthLondonMum22 · 18/11/2023 19:11

FestiveSandman · 18/11/2023 18:50

No, it’s not fine to do that. Don’t give out dangerous advice.

Baby needs to be in the same space as you when sleeping (day and night) until 6 months because they base their heart rate, breathing and temperature on you. It prevents SIDS.

A baby monitor doesn’t help with any of that.

Actually, no one truly knows why it reduces the risk of SIDS, they just know that it does. It's nothing but a guess that it may be something to do with mimicking breathing of the adults in the room.

SIDS is also rare and there are other things that are more likely to help prevent SIDS with much more solid research and evidence behind it such as putting them on their backs to sleep.

It's really a risk assessment that each and every parent needs to make for themselves.

TerrysNeapolitan · 18/11/2023 18:56

That is what a playpen is for. Not an issue at all.