Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband refuses to keep sentimental items for our children

522 replies

Kitkat189 · 16/11/2023 12:37

I recently did a big clear out at home and finally got around to creating little memory boxes for my children, with things like their christening gowns, first haircut, hospital id badges, ultrasound pictures, one or two special outfits - you get the idea. One of my daughters joined in and added a few items which are special to her (leavers shirt from school, acceptance letter to secondary). I laundered, ironed, mended, ordered acid free tissue paper to wrap clothing in, tied with ribbons blah blah. The boxes were purchased from a company which specialises in keepsake boxes. About 45x30 cm so slightly larger than a big shoebox

husband was so annoyed with how much space these boxes took up and wanted them
gone. He doesn’t see any point to keeping any of this. All he had to say was ‘I would never have bought those [boxes]’.

I feel ridiculously hurt by this. We’ve kept an absolute minimum of baby things over the years, husband took everything straight to oxfam as soon as he could and we only kept a few special items. I just wanted some memories for my children for when they leave home. Something tangible to remember their childhood. Husbands parents never did this for him, maybe that’s why he is so unsentimental.

This morning was spent emptying the boxes and putting a few of the things in a small bin bag which can fit under one of the children’s beds. All the carefully wrapped clothes and christening gowns are just lying around now, soon to be disposed of I assume.

Help me get over this. I don’t know why I am so attached to these things and why I feel so upset, he feels differently about these things and I should be able to accept it but I can’t!!

OP posts:
Maatandosiris · 16/11/2023 18:12

Your husband is a controlling cunt. I’d keep the memory boxes over him.

Pigeon31 · 16/11/2023 18:07

I wonder if he's had experience of someone in his family who was a hoarder and has anxiety about stuff building up that isn't going to be used. Obv if it's important to you he should recognise that and make space for it but that's quite a strong reaction.

Crumpleton · 16/11/2023 18:06

He doesn’t see any point to keeping any of this. All he had to say was ‘I would never have bought those [boxes]’.

No, IMO you're wrong here, and this is the only part of your post I'd say that about...and by that I'm meaning you thought all he could/should say was "I would never have bought those boxes"

Infact all he had to say was nothing...just walk by and keep his thoughts to himself.

There's absolutely nothing wrong with you collecting little lifetime memories for your DC and keeping them together in nice boxes, a shoe box isn't going to take up much space.

Honestly this isn't even worth him or you giving a second thought to.
I'd pop it all back in them boxes and let him know that this is one argument that isn't even going to get off the ground cause it's not up for discussion and you don't need his permission to keep a few reminders of your DC growing up.

He may not see any point in keeping the items and that's fine, but his opinion shouldn't outweigh the fact that these things mean alot to you and the DC.

Mumsanetta · 16/11/2023 18:05

slore · 16/11/2023 15:08

  1. Stop being a spineless martyr.
  2. It's no great mystery, your husband is self-referenced. Only his things matter.

Exactly this ^

Makemydaypunk · 16/11/2023 17:58

ErmWhatever · 16/11/2023 15:47

Voted YABU because you're being an absolute wet wipe. Your husband prioritizes his own shit over anyone else's because he is selfish. And you're an enabler.
Put the stuff back in the boxes and tell him to do one.

This with bells on.

AcrossthePond55 · 16/11/2023 17:55

Kitkat189 · 16/11/2023 15:31

I promise this is just one (very odd) piece of the puzzle here - that’s why I am so mystified by it. I totally accept that anyone on this thread won’t believe me but he is a good father, he loves to spend time with them and gives up a lot financially and time wise to support them and their interests. Looking at this particular issue I can see how he would come across as a domineering tyrant who has to have his way but he is normally pretty easygoing. It’s this one topic where be put his foot down. It’s not a high stakes issue so it’s always baffled me

But the thing is, he's not entitled to 'put his foot down'. This is a marriage, not a dictatorship. If you want to keep something precious to you, you should be able to do so. If he wants to keep something precious to him, he should be able to do so. Obviously 'hoarding' is a different matter and you should keep these things in 'your space'. I wouldn't be happy if DH put his 'saved stuff' in my closet or piled it around the house. But if he wants to fill up his side of the closet and his cupboards with his stuff, so be it. No skin off my nose.

And this may be 'one topic' but I'm sure it's not one isolated incident. There have probably been other, even minor, things that you tossed when you'd rather have held on to it, simply to avoid his being angry/upset.

It could be that he has a 'fear' of hoarding, but I doubt it since he keeps his own shit. It seems to me that he is 'making a point' (even if only to himself) that he is 'in control' or can make you do what he wants, even if only in this one issue.

jannier · 16/11/2023 17:47

AffIt · 16/11/2023 13:01

I don't know if this makes things better or worse, but we recently cleared out my mother's house in advance of her moving into sheltered accommodation and it took WEEKS: it was incredibly stressful and time-consuming.

I'm in my 40s, I'm here, I'm fine: I don't need first teeth or ID bands or whatever.

If it doesn't fit in an A4 envelope, it goes.

But that's your choice would you throw out something your partner cherished?

Shinyrain · 16/11/2023 17:42

Quickly re-pack those special items back in their boxes. This is not about your husband - it's about your children! He sounds mean spirited but don't let him rule the roost on this - even your daughter was excited by this and was adding to her box - it's a special thing to do. I imagine that one day your children will be so grateful that you did this for them and will cherish the thought and care that went into making up theses boxes of special memories but even if they don't , well ... that's for them to decide and recycle the contents. Please go with your own instincts on this. It's a lovely thing to do - don't let him decide. x

L0bstersLass · 16/11/2023 17:40

Kitkat189 · 16/11/2023 14:54

@MargotBamborough True. But I’m still upset that he looks at all of this like it’s rubbish. We can’t agree on everything in this marriage but for some reason this was so hurtful.

For now I put all the little mementoes in a small bin bag and put it away. The clothing I guess will have to go in the name of compromise

@Kitkat189 - I believe you when you say that he's not normally controlling.
I also understand when you mention that it's tarnished the memory of this lovely activity you did with the children.

However, you should genuinely recreate them now.
Do not throw things away.
Do not put things in a bin bag.
Do not capitulate.

Recreate the beautiful boxes.
You will change how you feel about them. In years to come you will be devastated that you backed down on this.
Stand your ground.
Set a great example to your children that some things are worth fighting for.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 16/11/2023 17:40

Oh, for crying out loud. Tell him to stop being such a prick. Put everything back together for dc. If your "dh" protests tell him to get therapy for his obvious childhood issues and not to bring it up or interfere again.

Mistymountain · 16/11/2023 17:38

Kitkat189 · 16/11/2023 15:31

I promise this is just one (very odd) piece of the puzzle here - that’s why I am so mystified by it. I totally accept that anyone on this thread won’t believe me but he is a good father, he loves to spend time with them and gives up a lot financially and time wise to support them and their interests. Looking at this particular issue I can see how he would come across as a domineering tyrant who has to have his way but he is normally pretty easygoing. It’s this one topic where be put his foot down. It’s not a high stakes issue so it’s always baffled me

Perhaps he hates the reminder that they're growing up? I always feel a pang when I look at photos, I don't take them myself, and just keep a small number of the ones people send me. I feel tied down by reminders of the past and then it's really upsetting if you do lose the things you've kept, so it's better not to keep them at all.

Darhon · 16/11/2023 17:37

I’m a chucker and not a hoarder, I hate having lots of stuff. But even I’ve got 3 boxes of kids stuff - 1 for each kid. First shoes, little clothes I loved them in, a few bits from school when they were little. I also kept some books they loved having read to them so they can read them to any kids they have. I merrily chucked everything else.

He’s a dick. Put them back in the boxes you bought now. Or get a friend to save them

DisappearingGirl · 16/11/2023 17:34

That's really mean of him. I agree you need to just say "I'm doing it anyway as it's important to me and the kids".

In terms of why he's doing it (not as an excuse): Were/are his family hoarders? Does he have a fear of becoming a hoarder and overwhelmed with stuff? Just wondering.

MCOut · 16/11/2023 17:27

He’s an ass OP. DP is hugely sentimental and I’m not at all but I’d never go out my way to kill his buzz like that. We just have an agreement that he keeps his stuff contained.

Parker231 · 16/11/2023 17:27

Kitkat189 · 16/11/2023 14:54

@MargotBamborough True. But I’m still upset that he looks at all of this like it’s rubbish. We can’t agree on everything in this marriage but for some reason this was so hurtful.

For now I put all the little mementoes in a small bin bag and put it away. The clothing I guess will have to go in the name of compromise

Nothing has to be got rid unless you want it to. Make the boxes and keep them safe for your DC’s.

Quartz2208 · 16/11/2023 17:25

@Kitkat189 has he actually said he doesn’t want you to keep them or that you should do this or are you simply react8ng to him not liking them. Because the first is wrong and definitely on him. The second (which I think is the truth) is your issue.

the fact he doesn’t like them doesn’t mean you can’t or shouldn’t. Surely this is the onky th8ng one of you likes and the other doesnt

TheClitterati · 16/11/2023 17:24

"DH I understand that you do not want to keep sentimental items for our children, but I ery much do. I am making keepsake boxes for them and they will stay here."

If he's as decent as you say he is absolutely none of the above will be a problem

GoingDownLikeBHS · 16/11/2023 17:23

Now you’ve started on the “but he’s a good father!!” I’m out. Why would you allow your kids to be treated like this?

CareConundrum · 16/11/2023 17:20

I agree you need to keep the boxes and contents together if they make you and your children happy and you'd like them for the future.

I would reinstate everything without telling him and ask another family member (from your side, not his) to store them in their loft or spare room. Otherwise it's too big a risk - he's likely to throw everything on another occasion, maybe without telling you.

Sorry if this isn’t possible for some reason. I haven't RTFT as the situation made me so cross on your behalf - and eager to reply!

OKt · 16/11/2023 17:20

You made such a lovely gift for your children and your husband should respect that. I would have loved that, as it is I keep everything I want to from my childhood.

SequinsandStiIettos · 16/11/2023 17:18

Ah sorry, your eldest is 13. Teenager. Therefore old enough to have and keep the box somewhere in her room or wardrobe. Job done.

Artwork - photos/digital frame - pick out one you love above all else to frame. Or you do a washing line on kitchen wall/ peg the artwork up as it comes back then do the one in - one out rule.

Justanothercatlady · 16/11/2023 17:18

Your question of why he’s like this will only come from him. And only if you’re prepared to ask and hear his response. What if you ask him: 1. what’s the difference between how you feel about your mum’s stuff and how me and the children feel about their stuff? 2. what do you think is important to me/the children? 3. Why do you want to be rid of my / the children’s stuff? Give him space to explain it. Will be interesting to understand if it’s all about priorities (his), inability to see other’s perspective or simply he doesn’t care.

Dramatic · 16/11/2023 17:16

InTheCheapSeats · 16/11/2023 17:10

I have a memory box for each of my kids, containing their first outfits, christening gowns, first lock of hair etc.
I also have a memory box of my own containing stuff that is sentimental and memorable to me. It's a bloody big box too.
My husband wouldn't dream of interfering with them, he knows how important they are to me.
That's called being respectful of my wishes and possessions.
Your husband is being neither towards yours or you.
Box them all back up and put them in the loft.
Then get him told straight!

I have similar for myself and all the kids (we have 5 so it's a fair amount) my DH rolls his eyes a bit because he's much less sentimental than me but he wouldn't dream of trying to make me throw it away. It would actually make me reconsider our relationship if he did.

Dramatic · 16/11/2023 17:14

Kitkat189 · 16/11/2023 15:23

I should pack everything back up again and find a place to store them - but something which was meant to be lovely and positive feels tarnished now. That’s my problem I guess. I need to think about the children and just do it for them

Definitely do this. Just because your husband feels a certain way about it doesn't mean your kids won't appreciate it when they're adults, or even after you're gone. It's a connection to you as much as anything else for them.

Do not throw the clothes out as a compromise, keep everything you wanted to including the boxes, it's hardly like you're filling the house up with crap, it's one box each. He can suck it up

sistersled · 16/11/2023 17:13

Please don’t throw any of it out. You’ve already gone through some of it with your DD and she’s obviously happy with what’s in there so as long as you have the space then it should all be kept.