Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH always takes the best

206 replies

Grumpynan · 16/11/2023 11:17

I know in the grander scheme of things this is mild but it’s really starting to get to me.

my late MIL was a very selfish nasty woman, she got worst over the years eventually when she died she had no friends and her sister didn’t like her. The only people at her funeral was me her son and our 3 children even her other son didn’t attend. I told him last night he is turning into her, her laughed it off and I did back down a little and soften it but I’m really worried he is !

when we were first married, 35 years ago, we shared everything, it was a thing people would comment on, if there was one cake he would cut it in half, if someone gave me chocolate I shared it.

now he always selects the best for him, the nicest chop, the biggest cookie. He’s always first into what ever is available no one else, even the grandkids gets a look in.

last night we had spaghetti bolognaise, I grated the Parmesan and commented that it was the last I had forgotten to get more, never mind he said there looks enough there. I sat down at the table to find he had poured 90% of it on his, about a portion size, when I commented he shrugged and said he didn’t think.

after dinner he called from the kitchen, he had seen the cupcakes I had made to take with me to friends today, oooh he said they look good, I commented that some looked better than others, but I’m getting better at piping and the girls won’t mind, yes he knew why I had made them. But when I went to watch tv later, he was sat there eating one, he had eaten 2 !, ok I had made a dozen and only needed 8, but he had picked the best looking ones leaving the rubbish ones for me to take.

im just getting fed up with it, feel I shouldn’t have to hid away stuff, especially when he knows what they are for

OP posts:
Concannon88 · 16/11/2023 15:26

I think the things you have listed are incredibly tame and you seem nitpicky. You describe your mil as very selfish and nasty, and that hes turning into her. If these are the things you are comparing to her then I think you need to reaccess your morals.

TomatoSandwiches · 16/11/2023 15:16

My brother was like this even from a very young child, there were 4 of us and if there was a treat with four portions he would gobble his up then scream, cry and hang off you and demand everyone else share their portions because his had gone.
Being the eldest I was always made to give over mine.
He was never told no and it shows now he is an adult.

fungibletoken · 16/11/2023 15:14

LusaBatoosa · 16/11/2023 14:51

And the response?

I feel like you’ve come to accept it, so don’t fully realise how insane their behaviour is. It’s shockingly bad. Actually worse than the OP’s (awfully behaved) DH.

Squabbling over whose fault it was 🫣 And nope - I too find his family's behaviour totally alien. And that's precisely why I don't take it to heart that DH still has some of those tendencies but make sure I flag it to him every time in the expectation that he'll drop them. Hence that was my advice to the OP too, provided her DH has other redeeming features. If he's an arse all round then there's a different conversation to be had!

CrushingOnRubies · 16/11/2023 15:08

Yanbu - it's making my blood boil just reading that. I'd have definitely taken Parmesan off his plate or swapped.

As for the cakes I would have made very clear that I was not impressed and it was a shit thing to do.

Especially if it's a recurring thing I would be pulling him up on it every single time

GarlicMaybeNot · 16/11/2023 15:05

44PumpLane · 16/11/2023 11:43

This is really rubbish, especially the cakes example.....the look would have made no difference to the taste so he should have at least taken the "worst" ones and left the most impressive ones for you to take to the girls.

He sounds lacking in manners.

I think the issue is one of complacency, he needs to be told every time.

I agree with others, express hurt and sadness rather than anger.

That's a really good point about the cakes. He purposely took the best-finished ones, knowing OP had made them for a specific purpose (not him) AND that she wanted to show off her better handiwork, which he destroyed.

It isn't greed. He's sending a message. Exactly what it says, I'm not sure, but it sounds something like "You don't matter. I do. Never forget that."

😢

It's a bit of a shocker, OP, especially after the performative sharing of your early days. I quite like the suggestion that he should see a doctor - not because I think there must be some other explanation for his increasingly dominating behaviour, but it's a good way to emphasise that it's a serious issue.

Elastica23 · 16/11/2023 15:02

You'll have to treat him like a kid. He slices the cake, you choose the slice etc.

LusaBatoosa · 16/11/2023 14:51

fungibletoken · 16/11/2023 14:45

"Is there none left? I haven't had any".

And the response?

I feel like you’ve come to accept it, so don’t fully realise how insane their behaviour is. It’s shockingly bad. Actually worse than the OP’s (awfully behaved) DH.

fungibletoken · 16/11/2023 14:45

LylaLee · 16/11/2023 14:20

What did you say to them?

"Is there none left? I haven't had any".

Lilibert456 · 16/11/2023 14:37

Call him out every single time. Selfish greedy pig.

Readingineading · 16/11/2023 14:37

I worked with a man like this. Every buffet, every time food treats were brought in ( weekly, the company were big on food treats ), every time a big birthday was celebrated and a cake was provided. In the end his manager physically stopped him from doing a 2nd round of the buffet table with his Tupperware box when half of the office hadn't had a chance to get anything yet. He was incredulous, the idea of sharing was obviously alien to him.

Bature · 16/11/2023 14:34

PianPianPiano · 16/11/2023 13:27

Because she is not his mother? Why is that poster responsible for the behaviour of her husband?! Its never his fault is it...

So, if your partner behaved like this, you’d say nothing and accept it because you’re not his mother? What?

LusaBatoosa · 16/11/2023 14:30

PianPianPiano · 16/11/2023 13:35

Yes, I said mother because she is (presumably) female and so would therefore play the role of mother rather than father should she have parental responsibilty for him.....
And the point is that your immediate response to that posters tale was to demand to know whether she pulled him up on it and if not, why not. When in fact, his behaviour is not her responsibility, and whether she did or not is irrelevant.

I repeat: So, people should never be pulled up on their poor behaviour because we, collectively, are not their mothers? We should never go ‘why have you done that?’ to our spouses? We should just accept them being shitty? That’s your position?

OhmygodDont · 16/11/2023 14:27

You should have swapped dinner plates on the cheese one. Definitely keep letting him know seriously it’s unacceptable and his turning into his mother.

I couldn’t imagine dh being like that, hell I have to tell him his given me more food than him or practically force feed him anything that’s meant to be “mine” that I want to share with him. He will swap take away chips because I hate soggy ones, always volunteering to be the one who’s dinner gets colder if the children want something it’s a battle of the wills over who is more sharing in our house.

Even the children are told firmly on picky foods that they can’t take all of something or only the best bits it’s for everyone.

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 16/11/2023 14:27

My husband used to be like this.
I always thought it was because of having two overwhelming older sisters growing up. He had to fight to get his share or go.
I called him out on it every single time and he’s a lot better. He can still be a bit selfish but he’s found the easiest way is often to buy two of something so that he knows one is his and that he can have it all.

WowOK · 16/11/2023 14:21

MoltenLasagne · 16/11/2023 11:38

With the parmesan one, I'd have made him swap portions. If he thinks it's acceptable for one of you to miss out, then clearly it's fine if that person is him.

I'd would fo this as well.

LylaLee · 16/11/2023 14:20

fungibletoken · 16/11/2023 13:43

I think it can be really hard to shake off your upbringing. We're now in our 30s and so are his siblings. We had his parents and siblings round for my birthday and I popped inside to find more cutlery for the cake. When I came back a few minutes later they'd already fought over and taken it all. Didn't register that I didn't have any. Just a bizarre attitude to food. Same if they see open food when they visit - e.g. a pack of crisps I've put down whilst doing something else. They'll just help themselves. So alien to me it's a bit hard to engage with but DH is getting better after being pulled up on it. And I've learned to hide any personal treats when the doorbell goes!

What did you say to them?

HiddenLegoOuch · 16/11/2023 14:19

PianPianPiano · 16/11/2023 13:26

I'm one of four. We were ALWAYS taught to make sure we left enough for others - that we should take one of something and then go back for seconds after everyone else had theirs. When there's only one thing left, we were taught to offer it round to others before taking it. So I don't think that's an excuse at all, its just selfish and bad manners.

Exactly the same etiquette taught to my 3 siblings and me, @PianPianPiano .

Although I didn’t realise until too late just how my Ex took advantage of my manners - he’d order whatever he wanted when eating out, and I (being the anxious one regarding our tight finances) would routinely have the cheapest dish and water only to drink. He also knew of our financial situation, but would expect me to select a meal with the remainder of the money after he had chosen.

OP - pull him up every time, and don’t soften the blow. He needs to know just how selfish he is being, and what others actually think about him. If need be, show him what he is doing, and how disrespectful it is towards everyone else.

RedCoffeeCup · 16/11/2023 14:17

YANBU. I'd have made him give me half his Parmesan!

Aquarelles · 16/11/2023 14:16

My ex never even tried to hide when he did this.

I would dish up dinner and call him through to the kitchen to collect his plate. "Which one is mine?" he would say. "Any one." He would then pause for about 5 seconds, eyeing them both up before choosing the one which had more of what he liked on it.

One time he even moaned about it "ooo that one's got more meat but that one has more potatoes hmmm".

Such a turn off.

MarilynSays · 16/11/2023 14:13

I would buy a bar of chocolate and eat it all to myself in front of him when you're watching telly. Do the same with other things, and when he asks for some, "Ah well you don't share with me, so?" He needs to be retrained!! 😂

UnctuousUnicorns · 16/11/2023 14:10

fungibletoken · 16/11/2023 13:43

I think it can be really hard to shake off your upbringing. We're now in our 30s and so are his siblings. We had his parents and siblings round for my birthday and I popped inside to find more cutlery for the cake. When I came back a few minutes later they'd already fought over and taken it all. Didn't register that I didn't have any. Just a bizarre attitude to food. Same if they see open food when they visit - e.g. a pack of crisps I've put down whilst doing something else. They'll just help themselves. So alien to me it's a bit hard to engage with but DH is getting better after being pulled up on it. And I've learned to hide any personal treats when the doorbell goes!

😲 That's just abysmal manners! Your PIL seriously failed on that score!

MummyMumMumMummy · 16/11/2023 14:03

@WhatsThePurposeOfLife i would have agreed with you until I met my DH. He is incredibly unselfish. I do think it can be a rare find though; I’ve met some really selfish horrible bastards in my life.

TryingToMakeSenseOfIt · 16/11/2023 14:00

If you've been married for 35, he certainly won't change now. He sounds very selfish. You could -
Put the dinners on the plates and serve him what you think is a fair amount.

Hide any "nice" food/baking you don't want him to touch.

No, you shouldn't need to do that, but as he's such a greedy, thoughtless, selfish git, I think you'll have to.

EvilElsa · 16/11/2023 13:59

I assume you tell him he's a selfish shit when he does these things? It's such an unattractive trait, I'd be so put off I couldn't just ignore it.

Bobcat246 · 16/11/2023 13:57

Pull him up on it. My husband only did this once. Five of us sat down to dinner with his family. There was a bowl of cauliflower cheese. He helped himself to half of it. I said "Oy, you've taken half the cauliflower cheese and left the four of us with only half between us!". His mum started with "Oh it doesn't matter..." as she's the type to hand people the best bits. I replied "yes it does matter- I love cauli cheese and he's taken way more than his fair share". He was mortified and immediately shared it out fairly. He never did it again.