Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Changing the law because the current one does not fit your narrative

162 replies

jemenfous37 · 16/11/2023 11:14

How is this allowed to happen? There are quite a few laws that many of us would like to break, either for our own convenience or because they don't suit our world-view, but we cannot.
So why can the Government, after 4 rejected court appeals, dare to ride rough-shod over our laws?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
MidnightOnceMore · 16/11/2023 13:33

FloatingLog · 16/11/2023 13:27

The idea is that the public has elected a government with certain agenda and leanings, so politicians are legislating in representation of the voters. It's supposed to be democracy.

I don't think anyone really considers a minority government - as ours always are in vote share - to be that democratic!

But even so, what they are trying to do by legislating to redefine a country as safe when it has not been found to be safe, extends beyond any manifesto pledge on small boats or immigration.

FloatingLog · 16/11/2023 13:27

The idea is that the public has elected a government with certain agenda and leanings, so politicians are legislating in representation of the voters. It's supposed to be democracy.

MidnightOnceMore · 16/11/2023 13:23

There were 2 ways the government could scrap this ludicrous idea.

More money getting poured down the drain while the government pretend they have a plan.

What will the Lords do with the legislation? Kick it out presumably. Tick, tick, tick the parliamentary clock keeps running.

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 13:19

SerendipityJane · 16/11/2023 13:17

There were 2 ways the government could scrap this ludicrous idea. They've just chosen the one the dim won't twig it's happened.

‘The dim’

That old chestnut worked with Brexit, not

Try again I suppose

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 13:17

Dotjones · 16/11/2023 13:16

"Changing the law because the current one does not fit your narrative."

Well, yeah, obviously? Why do you think laws get changed - it's because politicians decided that the current ones are wrong, or out of date, or don't cover something that needs to be legislated.

The gun laws have repeatedly changed over the last century because they didn't fit with the "narrative" of the time. People often complain that the laws which ban begging and sleeping rough are outdated and should be revised.

It's nothing unusual for a government to want to change laws. It's part of their job.

Exactly. Otherwise we’d be stuck with the same laws. Obviously not though

SerendipityJane · 16/11/2023 13:17

There were 2 ways the government could scrap this ludicrous idea. They've just chosen the one the dim won't twig it's happened.

Dotjones · 16/11/2023 13:16

"Changing the law because the current one does not fit your narrative."

Well, yeah, obviously? Why do you think laws get changed - it's because politicians decided that the current ones are wrong, or out of date, or don't cover something that needs to be legislated.

The gun laws have repeatedly changed over the last century because they didn't fit with the "narrative" of the time. People often complain that the laws which ban begging and sleeping rough are outdated and should be revised.

It's nothing unusual for a government to want to change laws. It's part of their job.

MidnightOnceMore · 16/11/2023 13:14

I see that many Tories and legal experts think the idea that parliament can just vote to declare Rwanda 'safe' is a nonsense.

We shall see what the legislation comes out looking like.

Then organisations can take the legislation itself through the courts.

I can't see anything happening quickly.

SerendipityJane · 16/11/2023 13:12

Libertass · 16/11/2023 13:05

That’s not what the government are doing, and to assert that it is shows a complete misunderstanding of what is happening. The government is complying with the law as it currently exists and the rulings of the courts which interprets & apply that law. That’s why aircraft full of illegal immigrants are not taking off for Rwanda today.

If the democratically elected government of the U.K. disagrees with the court’s rulings, and believes current laws are unfit for purpose, then it is completely reasonable for them to try to change those laws by bringing in new legislation and getting it voted through Parliament. That is what governments do. That is how British Parliamentary democracy works.

Edited

However the underlying facts of the case are that - regardless of any "treaty" (and if the UK is quite prepared to abandon treaties, then so are the Rwandans) - SCOTUK found Rwanda to be unsafe.

We are in danger of straying in to redefining pi to be a round 3 because decimals are (as well know) a pinko plot. You are of course free to call pu whatever you want. But if you like your buildings standing, and your electricity flowing, 3.141572 is probably a better bet.

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 13:11

Libertass · 16/11/2023 13:05

That’s not what the government are doing, and to assert that it is shows a complete misunderstanding of what is happening. The government is complying with the law as it currently exists and the rulings of the courts which interprets & apply that law. That’s why aircraft full of illegal immigrants are not taking off for Rwanda today.

If the democratically elected government of the U.K. disagrees with the court’s rulings, and believes current laws are unfit for purpose, then it is completely reasonable for them to try to change those laws by bringing in new legislation and getting it voted through Parliament. That is what governments do. That is how British Parliamentary democracy works.

Edited

This

SabrinaThwaite · 16/11/2023 13:10

LadyMacB · 16/11/2023 13:08

Whatever your view of the Rwanda plan, the government are just flogging a dead horse. How much time and expense is being expended on this bullshit?

£140 million just on the Rwanda treaty so far.

MidnightOnceMore · 16/11/2023 13:09

Libertass · 16/11/2023 13:05

That’s not what the government are doing, and to assert that it is shows a complete misunderstanding of what is happening. The government is complying with the law as it currently exists and the rulings of the courts which interprets & apply that law. That’s why aircraft full of illegal immigrants are not taking off for Rwanda today.

If the democratically elected government of the U.K. disagrees with the court’s rulings, and believes current laws are unfit for purpose, then it is completely reasonable for them to try to change those laws by bringing in new legislation and getting it voted through Parliament. That is what governments do. That is how British Parliamentary democracy works.

Edited

The government wants to legislate that Rwanda is safe, when the courts have judged it not safe.

The issue is not the law, but the third country under consideration.

You can pretend the government is behaving normally, but it is not.

LadyMacB · 16/11/2023 13:08

Whatever your view of the Rwanda plan, the government are just flogging a dead horse. How much time and expense is being expended on this bullshit?

Smileycup · 16/11/2023 13:07

MrsMattMurdock · 16/11/2023 11:40

You can't just create a law that says "Rwanda is safe" though if that isn't the objective reality. I can draw a few extra zeroes on my bank balance but that doesn't make me a millionaire.

Agree

Libertass · 16/11/2023 13:05

That’s not what the government are doing, and to assert that it is shows a complete misunderstanding of what is happening. The government is complying with the law as it currently exists and the rulings of the courts which interprets & apply that law. That’s why aircraft full of illegal immigrants are not taking off for Rwanda today.

If the democratically elected government of the U.K. disagrees with the court’s rulings, and believes current laws are unfit for purpose, then it is completely reasonable for them to try to change those laws by bringing in new legislation and getting it voted through Parliament. That is what governments do. That is how British Parliamentary democracy works.

SerendipityJane · 16/11/2023 12:47

This is what you get when you forget what fascism looks like

“The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.”

https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/8205321-the-party-told-you-to-reject-the-evidence-of-your

and in the US "abortion" is being redefined if the GOP gets it's way.

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/02/opinion/abortion-bans-republicans.html

E2A: Also remember the government rushing to change the law to deny compensation to Workfare victims ? If you put up with that then you really greased the slope for this one.

MidnightOnceMore · 16/11/2023 12:44

We could pass a law redefining zero as an ever increasing number?

Throwhandsupintheair · 16/11/2023 12:25

Maybe the next judgement will be that we’ve achieved net zero targets. I put nothing past this charlatan of a PM.

MidnightOnceMore · 16/11/2023 12:11

It'll be interesting to see what format this legislation will take.

There's a whole heap of scepticism within the Tory party as to whether it is possible to legislate in the way Sunak was proposing yesterday.

If he has to use the Parliament Act to force it through the Lord's it'll take a year. He hasnt got a year.

Sapphire387 · 16/11/2023 12:01

bonkersAlice · 16/11/2023 11:50

Precisely !.

Yeah but government is supposed to make laws for the benefit of the citizens, not to fuel its own racist agenda and cynically distract us from the real issues this country faces.

bonkersAlice · 16/11/2023 11:50

ShenleyWillow · 16/11/2023 11:20

Without getting into the politics of this particular ruling, that's what Parliament does week in week out - review, debate, amend and create law.

Precisely !.

QuickDraining · 16/11/2023 11:44

Not wanting to go too off message. But it's totally irksome when they suggest they can fast track new laws for something like this. When things that feel more seemingly urgent, like environment pollution seems to go on unabashed.

I initially thought they never had any intention of ever enacting such a scheme. Due to totally foreseeable challenges. Suggesting they are tackling the 'problem' without actually doing anything. 13 years, and barely any progress on a topic they were dog whistling about before they gained power.

When we were members of the EU, it seemed only fair to come up with an EU solution.

Alas, my Mum expects that when Rishi stops the boats, all the eastern Europeans will exit Bognor Regis. I hear stuff like why can't France have them etc etc. Would be great to have a sensible debate about immigration/migration/asylum.

MidnightOnceMore · 16/11/2023 11:42

TryAgainWithFeeling · 16/11/2023 11:32

Creating, amending, removing laws is literally parliament’s job though? It’s not riding roughshod over the law if what they’re proposing is to change the law.

I’m totally against the Rwanda policy, but not for this reason.

Saying 'Rwanda is safe' is not a law, it is a judgement.

MrsMattMurdock · 16/11/2023 11:40

You can't just create a law that says "Rwanda is safe" though if that isn't the objective reality. I can draw a few extra zeroes on my bank balance but that doesn't make me a millionaire.

TryAgainWithFeeling · 16/11/2023 11:32

Creating, amending, removing laws is literally parliament’s job though? It’s not riding roughshod over the law if what they’re proposing is to change the law.

I’m totally against the Rwanda policy, but not for this reason.