Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Changing the law because the current one does not fit your narrative

162 replies

jemenfous37 · 16/11/2023 11:14

How is this allowed to happen? There are quite a few laws that many of us would like to break, either for our own convenience or because they don't suit our world-view, but we cannot.
So why can the Government, after 4 rejected court appeals, dare to ride rough-shod over our laws?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
ntmdino · 16/11/2023 16:26

Libertass · 16/11/2023 13:05

That’s not what the government are doing, and to assert that it is shows a complete misunderstanding of what is happening. The government is complying with the law as it currently exists and the rulings of the courts which interprets & apply that law. That’s why aircraft full of illegal immigrants are not taking off for Rwanda today.

If the democratically elected government of the U.K. disagrees with the court’s rulings, and believes current laws are unfit for purpose, then it is completely reasonable for them to try to change those laws by bringing in new legislation and getting it voted through Parliament. That is what governments do. That is how British Parliamentary democracy works.

Edited

This is true, as far as it goes.

The problem that the government has is that, while it can negotiate a new treaty which says Rwanda agrees not to ship these immigrants back to their country of origin and thus comply with the ruling of the Supreme Court, they're making the assumption that it's the only reason their plan is unlawful (not to mention that as soon as Rwanda goes back on any part of its agreement even once, the whole thing gets scrapped).

In reality, it's the only reason amongst the arguments presented at court that their plan is unlawful. It will be relatively trivial for the opposition to continue a dripfeed of arguments and keep this bouncing around the courts until after the General Election, with Sunak and co playing whack-a-mole changing laws to skirt the rulings.

And, let's not forget, there are many in his own party who are not happy with the idea of changing laws to evade adverse court rulings. It's not a given that such a plan will succeed.

LlynTegid · 16/11/2023 16:22

Any of you who voted Conservative in 2019 and fell for the lies of the man who condones sex offenders are partly responsible.

On the specifics of Rwanda, it will end up with yet another court case and appeals. Far better if you think the proposal is reasonable to use UK soil or that of a crown colony/dependency.

cardibach · 16/11/2023 16:18

Libertass · 16/11/2023 13:05

That’s not what the government are doing, and to assert that it is shows a complete misunderstanding of what is happening. The government is complying with the law as it currently exists and the rulings of the courts which interprets & apply that law. That’s why aircraft full of illegal immigrants are not taking off for Rwanda today.

If the democratically elected government of the U.K. disagrees with the court’s rulings, and believes current laws are unfit for purpose, then it is completely reasonable for them to try to change those laws by bringing in new legislation and getting it voted through Parliament. That is what governments do. That is how British Parliamentary democracy works.

Edited

While that’s true, it’s not just British law creating a problem here. It’s international law.
Plus I’m getting very fed up with both the government and the media talking about refugees being sent to other countries ‘to have their claim assessed’. That’s not what’s happening. They can’t come back here even if they are judged to be eligible for asylum.

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 16:07

SerendipityJane · 16/11/2023 16:01

I agreed there was a debate to be had. And part of that would be looking at laws. However there is word "holistic" that should really be a guiding principle.

Don't come to me for a quick answer on that one (I wished I hadn't)...

Whatever happens the set up we currently have will show too much strain, not just here but across EU and elsewhere.

Starting point should be post war systems won’t deal with increase in movement of people.

Whether citizens demand politicians close off or take more people we’ll see.

The status quo won’t stick, and nor will the idea of orderly and limited access using current laws

coldcallerbaiter · 16/11/2023 16:03

I didn’t agree with Rwanda as it was too complicated and costly not because the sentiment was wrong.

Nowhere in the world will accept them unless they are a country that is desperate for the millions of £ it brings.

We could open the borders, then the our standard of living would plummet.

So to the nay sayers, what is your plan?

SerendipityJane · 16/11/2023 16:01

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 15:55

You agreed with this in pp but I do think the laws around asylum need to be changed

Did you have a law / laws in mind?

I agreed there was a debate to be had. And part of that would be looking at laws. However there is word "holistic" that should really be a guiding principle.

Don't come to me for a quick answer on that one (I wished I hadn't)...

Not the Nine O'Clock News - Question Time - Soviet Nuclear Attack

A brilliant Question Time sketch from S01E01 of Not The Nine O'clock News.Rowan Atkinson as Lord Carrington Hugh Thomas as Rudolph Beard, the MP for 'Landsen...

https://youtu.be/ny7nvnshhkg

jemenfous37 · 16/11/2023 15:57

No, but it doesn't make it right to change it becuase you don't like it!

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 15:55

SerendipityJane · 16/11/2023 15:53

If your starting assumption is all it takes is law changes then there really isn't much point is there ?

It's a little like seeing the guy I called to fix my espresso machine walking up the path swinging a sledgehammer.

Actually it's a lot like it.

You agreed with this in pp but I do think the laws around asylum need to be changed

Did you have a law / laws in mind?

SerendipityJane · 16/11/2023 15:53

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 15:47

Which laws around asylum do you want changed?

If your starting assumption is all it takes is law changes then there really isn't much point is there ?

It's a little like seeing the guy I called to fix my espresso machine walking up the path swinging a sledgehammer.

Actually it's a lot like it.

SerendipityJane · 16/11/2023 15:51

Following the Supreme Court’s observation of the patently obvious fact that Rwanda is an unsafe destination for asylum seekers, Rishi Sunak is pushing through legislation to “confirm that Rwanda is safe, and while we’re all playing pretend, I’m six foot six with god-like muscles”.

Rishi Sunak, five foot six, said, “I’m sick and tired of legal battles, and of buying my clothes in the back-to-school sales, and so I’m preparing legislation to solve both problems at once.

“If I change the law to say Rwanda is safe, then observable reality be damned – it IS safe. And I will yell it to the House of Commons as my herculean frame looms over the dispatch box, while for emphasis I rip a phone book in half with my mighty arms and crush a breeze-block to dust between my mighty glutes.
“And coming soon, emergency legislation to say I’m miles ahead in the polls! I alone shall decide what’s real and what’s not! I’m not panicking! I’m not panicking! If you don’t shut up I will pass an emergency law to say I’m not panicking!”

The proposed legislation to reclassify Rwanda as ‘safe’ has already met with fierce opposition from the right wing of the party, who are ideologically opposed to sending asylum seekers anywhere ‘safe’.

The Supreme Court has considered Mr Sunak’s proposition and has ruled that, seriously, of course Rwanda isn’t bloody safe, and that Mr Sunak is actually four-foot eighteen.

Changing the law because the current one does not fit your narrative
EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 15:47

SerendipityJane · 16/11/2023 15:34

But that is a reasonable approach. And as such has no place in this debate.

I am very wary of governments that ride in on the back of "solutions" they have dreamt up, and then try to ram them through regardless.

Which laws around asylum do you want changed?

AgnesX · 16/11/2023 15:47

Par for the course with this bunch of over titled shits. If they can't get what they want one way they'll get it another way.

Bit like the German National Socialist party in the 1930s really.

SerendipityJane · 16/11/2023 15:44

SabrinaThwaite · 16/11/2023 15:43

Well nobody in the electorate could have voted for it, could they? Despite the “it’s what the people voted for” line being trotted out on a regular basis.

It was Patel and Braverman’s stupid idea.

Alternatively, you could just read the nested quotes.

Edited

My point being even if it had been a manifesto pledge ....

https://bylinetimes.com/2022/04/06/boris-johnson-conservative-broken-manifesto-promises-2019/

All the Conservative Manifesto Promises Boris Johnson has Broken – Byline Times

Boris Johnson's broken Conservative Party manifesto pledges from 2019 in full.

https://bylinetimes.com/2022/04/06/boris-johnson-conservative-broken-manifesto-promises-2019

SabrinaThwaite · 16/11/2023 15:43

SerendipityJane · 16/11/2023 15:35

What's that got to do with it ?

Well nobody in the electorate could have voted for it, could they? Despite the “it’s what the people voted for” line being trotted out on a regular basis.

It was Patel and Braverman’s stupid idea.

Alternatively, you could just read the nested quotes.

SerendipityJane · 16/11/2023 15:35

SabrinaThwaite · 16/11/2023 14:47

Not sure that the 2019 manifesto mentioned outsourcing refugees to Rwanda?

What's that got to do with it ?

SerendipityJane · 16/11/2023 15:34

DisquietintheRanks · 16/11/2023 14:06

I don't agree with removing people to Rwanda but I do think the laws around asylum need to be changed (as does the resourcing of the whole system).

But that is a reasonable approach. And as such has no place in this debate.

I am very wary of governments that ride in on the back of "solutions" they have dreamt up, and then try to ram them through regardless.

SabrinaThwaite · 16/11/2023 14:47

MidnightOnceMore · 16/11/2023 13:33

I don't think anyone really considers a minority government - as ours always are in vote share - to be that democratic!

But even so, what they are trying to do by legislating to redefine a country as safe when it has not been found to be safe, extends beyond any manifesto pledge on small boats or immigration.

Not sure that the 2019 manifesto mentioned outsourcing refugees to Rwanda?

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 14:35

HannibalHeyes · 16/11/2023 14:31

The thing is, all this shouting "STOP THE BOATS" at every opportunity is nothing whatsoever about immigration. It's a dog whistle to the racist tendency, as part of their culture wars, because that is the only way they think they can win any seats at the next election (same with the trans debate).

There are two simple ways they could actually "stop the boats". The first is having an efficient processing centre in France (which has been repeatedly offered, but turned down by the government because they want to fuel this "crisis").

The second would be to rejoin the EU, and the Dublin convention. But they don't want to do this as they would have to declare all their offshore investments to HMRC.

It's patently obvious that this crisis has been created by the government when you see how they have drastically reduced the resources of those processing asylum claims. If they were processed efficiently, then they wouldn't have to be housed long term in hotels, or fucking floating disease pits, and they could either be returned, or (as 90% of cases are approved after appeal) join society and work.

If you're falling for this nonsense you need to take a long, hard look at yourself...

These won’t work.

And you’ll find migration an increasing political pressure across the EU

HannibalHeyes · 16/11/2023 14:31

The thing is, all this shouting "STOP THE BOATS" at every opportunity is nothing whatsoever about immigration. It's a dog whistle to the racist tendency, as part of their culture wars, because that is the only way they think they can win any seats at the next election (same with the trans debate).

There are two simple ways they could actually "stop the boats". The first is having an efficient processing centre in France (which has been repeatedly offered, but turned down by the government because they want to fuel this "crisis").

The second would be to rejoin the EU, and the Dublin convention. But they don't want to do this as they would have to declare all their offshore investments to HMRC.

It's patently obvious that this crisis has been created by the government when you see how they have drastically reduced the resources of those processing asylum claims. If they were processed efficiently, then they wouldn't have to be housed long term in hotels, or fucking floating disease pits, and they could either be returned, or (as 90% of cases are approved after appeal) join society and work.

If you're falling for this nonsense you need to take a long, hard look at yourself...

DisquietintheRanks · 16/11/2023 14:06

I don't agree with removing people to Rwanda but I do think the laws around asylum need to be changed (as does the resourcing of the whole system).

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 16/11/2023 14:02

I agree that this is the most worrying aspect of the whole debacle.

There's a big difference between the Government initiating a balanced, reasoned debate on a law that might need reviewing, and the PM stating that they WILL change the law by special emergency procedures. The first is what Parliament is for. The second is scary.

To those saying they have a mandate to reduce immigration by any means necessary - no, they have a mandate to reduce immigration by any legal means. If those legal means are not sufficient, then follow normal democratic process to change the law. Do not invoke special emergency procedures to create loopholes. We are not at war here.

This is no longer about whether controlling immigration is right or wrong. It is about whether the current government considers it is above the law.

therealcookiemonster · 16/11/2023 14:00

I vote for a change in the law that makes it illegal to charge for cookies.

Neriah · 16/11/2023 13:46

Sapphire387 · 16/11/2023 12:01

Yeah but government is supposed to make laws for the benefit of the citizens, not to fuel its own racist agenda and cynically distract us from the real issues this country faces.

Before I say this I am going to preface what I say because I know a lot of people will hate it. No matter what this government do to try to change the law on this matter I will actively oppose the change. Full stop, and no negotiation. On a wider basis I despise this government and everything they stand for.

But there are regrettably very many citizens - and not all of them Tory voters either - who agree with the government on the "small boats", so arguing that such a move doesn't benefit citizens doesn't hold very much water. Many, many citizens would disagree with you that they get no benefit, and (living in a very racially diverse area) I can tell you that many of those citizens are the children and grandchildren of immigrants. I don't agree with them. I also see much of this debate as a way of distracting people from their real life issues. But regrettably this debate has been far from won in the general population, and it is not just the "right wing" who think like this.

I do agree with others that I think this is a dead horse - there is very little chance that this particular "strategy" will work even if they change the law, because there are other hurdles they will not easily overcome, and which not even their own backbenchers will support. Certainly, even with a change in the law tomorrow, they won't clear those hurdles and send anyone anywhere before a general election. So this is mostly about undermining Suella's remaining support before an election....

But the bigger picture is what we do to change hearts and minds about decency and compassion in relation to asylum, and fair and safe routes to asylum. After all, just a quick scurry around threads here will tell you that thse small boats are full of young foreign men who will rape the first white woman they see (or imply that if they don't outright say it). Then there's the complaints about how none of them work (they aren't allowed to - why not let them?). Etc. Etc. There is a broad failure to understand anything about this agenda. Just the very fact that we threw open our doors at a moments notice to welcome those nice (white) Ukrainian people, but I don't notice anyone screaming they would like to "adopt" a Palestinian family.....thousands and thousands of posts about Gaza with opinions of every shade, but oddly no suggestion we should help people by giving them sanctuary in the UK should they want to come.

HannibalHeyes · 16/11/2023 13:39

It's beyond stupid. And even if they succeed it's still a load of nonsense.

Rwanda have agreed to take around 200 asylum seekers a year. It won’t scratch the surface of the real problem which is a useless processing system. They just want that plane to take off as it will give racists a semi and win a few votes...