Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Changing the law because the current one does not fit your narrative

162 replies

jemenfous37 · 16/11/2023 11:14

How is this allowed to happen? There are quite a few laws that many of us would like to break, either for our own convenience or because they don't suit our world-view, but we cannot.
So why can the Government, after 4 rejected court appeals, dare to ride rough-shod over our laws?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
TangerineNeonLight · 17/11/2023 11:14

EasternStandard · 17/11/2023 08:43

It’s not impossible at all. Hence Aus numbers. They work within the law to achieve it. Not easy but doable

What isn’t possible is limiting by faster processing and keeping same set up. Which is what a fair few people still believe can happen.

That part is not doable so people need to be realistic and decide what kind of numbers they want

But do you think the Rwanda plan would make any difference? Given the small numbers of people they would fly out there, and the refugees we'd receive in return? It's such an immense cost for something that doesn't appear to make any kind of practical difference.

EasternStandard · 17/11/2023 11:00

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2023 10:56

But this is a democracy.

Of sorts. Most MPs were actively rejected by their constituents. So your foundations are ropey to start with. If we had other ways to accommodate that fact (maybe an elected upper house) we would see more representative views and possibly more equitable decision and policy making.

UK democracy such as it is harks back to an age when the masses were excluded and the choice between Whig and Tory was more akin to your favourite Spice Girl. As does US democracy, by the way. Neither is fit for purpose in a pluralistic society with universal suffering.

Now personally, I would look to amend the system rather than the population. However we have been saddled with a whole bunch of folks whose bright idea is to amend the population to fit the system. Something I have seen - and fought against - in many years in IT.

If you ask AI how to go about restoring the UK to the status quo of 1900, you'd get the next Tory manifesto.

If we had other ways to accommodate that fact (maybe an elected upper house) we would see more representative views

As in the US? I see this pushed a lot. On this issue you’d more likely get it through without the HoL and a similar majority to HoC

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2023 10:56

But this is a democracy.

Of sorts. Most MPs were actively rejected by their constituents. So your foundations are ropey to start with. If we had other ways to accommodate that fact (maybe an elected upper house) we would see more representative views and possibly more equitable decision and policy making.

UK democracy such as it is harks back to an age when the masses were excluded and the choice between Whig and Tory was more akin to your favourite Spice Girl. As does US democracy, by the way. Neither is fit for purpose in a pluralistic society with universal suffering.

Now personally, I would look to amend the system rather than the population. However we have been saddled with a whole bunch of folks whose bright idea is to amend the population to fit the system. Something I have seen - and fought against - in many years in IT.

If you ask AI how to go about restoring the UK to the status quo of 1900, you'd get the next Tory manifesto.

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 17/11/2023 10:55

MidnightOnceMore · 17/11/2023 07:54

I see the less deluded Tories are now starting to speak out a bit:

Her proposals were quickly met with criticism, even from her own party, as the Conservatives continue to be divided by her hardline approach.
MP Ashford for Damian Green wrote on X on Thursday evening: “The second test is the most unconservative statement I have ever heard from a Conservative politician. Giving the state the explicit power to override every legal constraint is what Putin and Xi do. We absolutely cannot go there.

^^From The Independent, reporting on response to a wacky article by Braverman in The Telegraph.

Thank you for posting this, I had lost hope of any Conservative MP understanding the limits on the Government's powers.

Also thanks to those posters who have addressed the OP's original issue and avoided diversions into the rights and wrongs of stopping the boats. I am deeply concerned that unconstitutional and undesirable Government behaviours are being slipped through under the smokescreen of a highly emotive issue.

DisquietintheRanks · 17/11/2023 10:48

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2023 10:40

"Understanding concerns" is not a synonym for "agree with fascists"

Also I can "understand" why people believe in a deity. Doesn't mean I do.

Is that not what I said?

But this is a democracy. People will vote based on their concerns no matter how foolish and misguided you think they are. Maybe you should spend some time explaining why housing asylum seekers and refugees doesn't take away from housing their communities, or why providing for them doesn't come at the expense of providing for ourselves. Or why we /they don't have to worry about uncontrolled migration.

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2023 10:40

"Understanding concerns" is not a synonym for "agree with fascists"

Also I can "understand" why people believe in a deity. Doesn't mean I do.

HannibalHeyes · 17/11/2023 10:29

DisquietintheRanks · 17/11/2023 08:37

Your response makes no sense, much like the government's current stance.

If you can't understand the concerns of your fellow citizens (you don't have to share them) then you probably don't have much to offer this debate tbh.

Oh, I can understand why people are gullible enough to believe this shit. It doesn't mean it's the issue they think it is though...

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2023 10:16

I am hoping the government also cannot redefine facts.

Like humans changing sex, for example.

EasternStandard · 17/11/2023 08:43

HannibalHeyes · 16/11/2023 23:59

A cap is impossible not just impractical. We have large numbers arriving on "the boats" despite the fact that the government has closed all legal routes for arriving for most people. So putting an arbitrary "cap" is nonsensical.

There is so much nonsensical about all these arguments. The idiocy and cruelty of those proposing them is beyond my understanding...

Edited

It’s not impossible at all. Hence Aus numbers. They work within the law to achieve it. Not easy but doable

What isn’t possible is limiting by faster processing and keeping same set up. Which is what a fair few people still believe can happen.

That part is not doable so people need to be realistic and decide what kind of numbers they want

DisquietintheRanks · 17/11/2023 08:37

HannibalHeyes · 16/11/2023 23:59

A cap is impossible not just impractical. We have large numbers arriving on "the boats" despite the fact that the government has closed all legal routes for arriving for most people. So putting an arbitrary "cap" is nonsensical.

There is so much nonsensical about all these arguments. The idiocy and cruelty of those proposing them is beyond my understanding...

Edited

Your response makes no sense, much like the government's current stance.

If you can't understand the concerns of your fellow citizens (you don't have to share them) then you probably don't have much to offer this debate tbh.

MidnightOnceMore · 17/11/2023 07:54

I see the less deluded Tories are now starting to speak out a bit:

Her proposals were quickly met with criticism, even from her own party, as the Conservatives continue to be divided by her hardline approach.
MP Ashford for Damian Green wrote on X on Thursday evening: “The second test is the most unconservative statement I have ever heard from a Conservative politician. Giving the state the explicit power to override every legal constraint is what Putin and Xi do. We absolutely cannot go there.

^^From The Independent, reporting on response to a wacky article by Braverman in The Telegraph.

Yellownotblue · 17/11/2023 00:48

jemenfous37 · 16/11/2023 20:05

Of course i understand how the law works @penjil . Please don't be so patronising

Do you? The government is constrained by the constitution. Even though it is unwritten, it exists and the SC is in charge of applying it. The government cannot just make any law that passes through their head on a given day. They cannot make arbitrary laws, or mislead the sovereign (as BJ did when he sought to prorogue parliament).

I am hoping the government also cannot redefine facts. A country that isn’t safe shouldn’t be legislated into a safe country. That’s absurd.

Yellownotblue · 17/11/2023 00:42

Malarandras · 16/11/2023 16:37

Making law is what parliament does though. Literally. The government is the government because that party has a parliamentary majority. A future government can reverse those laws, they frequently do. Governments tend to legislate to support their narrative, thats democracy for you!

Can you give an example of the government legislating to alter facts?

The SC has ruled, having pored over hundreds of pages of evidence, that Rwanda is not a safe country. That is a finding of fact. Rishi is introducing a bill to have it declared that Rwanda is a safe country.

It is not the job of parliament to seek to alter reality. It is in fact the very premise of 1984, and should be a worry to us all. Ministry of Truth, anyone?

HannibalHeyes · 16/11/2023 23:59

A cap is impossible not just impractical. We have large numbers arriving on "the boats" despite the fact that the government has closed all legal routes for arriving for most people. So putting an arbitrary "cap" is nonsensical.

There is so much nonsensical about all these arguments. The idiocy and cruelty of those proposing them is beyond my understanding...

DisquietintheRanks · 16/11/2023 22:56

Why is a cap impractical?

cardibach · 16/11/2023 22:27

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 22:22

To add to last post in relation to fast processing it is possible if a cap is applied. But that’s not currently possible under international law. Well unless another location is used and then safe routes are added separately with a limit

If any country speeds up processing and makes it easier they won’t be able to deal with the numbers

So what’s your solution? A cap is impractical for many reasons.

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 22:22

cardibach · 16/11/2023 22:08

I don’t disagree. But processing efficiently is essential to any solution. People languishing in limbo helps nobody.
There is an increasing population of migrants with valid asylum claims. It needs a global solution. But pretending we are ‘full’ isn’t helpful.

To add to last post in relation to fast processing it is possible if a cap is applied. But that’s not currently possible under international law. Well unless another location is used and then safe routes are added separately with a limit

If any country speeds up processing and makes it easier they won’t be able to deal with the numbers

cardibach · 16/11/2023 22:08

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 21:41

It’s a really tough one. I think people are underestimating what is happening already and will continue to increase

All the fast processing type answers won’t work

We’ll either see clamping down but eventually that may be destabilising

Or countries will hugely struggle with influx which will also be destabilising

I don’t mind if there’s discussion to build consensus but the ‘easily fixed’ and ‘just process faster’ answers just aren’t feasible at all

I don’t disagree. But processing efficiently is essential to any solution. People languishing in limbo helps nobody.
There is an increasing population of migrants with valid asylum claims. It needs a global solution. But pretending we are ‘full’ isn’t helpful.

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 21:41

cardibach · 16/11/2023 21:18

Like I’ve said - I don’t know. Do you?
What’s your solution for the growing number of genuine asylum seekers in the world?

It’s a really tough one. I think people are underestimating what is happening already and will continue to increase

All the fast processing type answers won’t work

We’ll either see clamping down but eventually that may be destabilising

Or countries will hugely struggle with influx which will also be destabilising

I don’t mind if there’s discussion to build consensus but the ‘easily fixed’ and ‘just process faster’ answers just aren’t feasible at all

cardibach · 16/11/2023 21:18

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 21:15

How many do you think is the capacity?

Edited

Like I’ve said - I don’t know. Do you?
What’s your solution for the growing number of genuine asylum seekers in the world?

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 21:15

cardibach · 16/11/2023 21:07

I think thats possibly true - if you define capacity as ‘how many asylum seekers people think we should accept’. I think the actual capacity is much higher.

How many do you think is the capacity?

SerendipityJane · 16/11/2023 21:14

TangerineNeonLight · 16/11/2023 20:10

But the government can't circumnavigate the law by making new ones. The supreme court exists to keep them in check. There seem to be posters on here genuinely arguing for a government to be able to do anything they like because 'they make the laws'. What if they decide they'd like to make a law preventing any more elections taking place? There are, and should be, limits to their power and no one should be so blase about ignoring that because in this case they like the proposed legislation.

This is where the US constitution makes a point. It is a US citizens protection from the power of the state. Based on the Magna Carta which successive parliaments have diluted.

What protections do UK citizens have from the power of the state ? Protections that aren't fine words.

cardibach · 16/11/2023 21:07

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 16:40

Well you’ve noticed the issue at least.

Your proposal won’t work. Demand would far exceed capacity and the reason why it’s a difficult question is because wishing it could be done doesn’t resolve the basic problem faced.

Not just here, but in many countries. Which is why new systems will start to emerge.

I think thats possibly true - if you define capacity as ‘how many asylum seekers people think we should accept’. I think the actual capacity is much higher.

TangerineNeonLight · 16/11/2023 20:10

But the government can't circumnavigate the law by making new ones. The supreme court exists to keep them in check. There seem to be posters on here genuinely arguing for a government to be able to do anything they like because 'they make the laws'. What if they decide they'd like to make a law preventing any more elections taking place? There are, and should be, limits to their power and no one should be so blase about ignoring that because in this case they like the proposed legislation.

Ballsbaill · 16/11/2023 20:05

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 19:40

Why a dictatorship?

MPs vote and it goes through the process

People vote in GEs

Exactly the public elect the government. The government then make the laws. Or are people seriously suggesting the public should vote on each law?!