Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's my loss too.....

153 replies

Purpleturtle45 · 16/11/2023 06:01

Looking for options on my situation with relationship with my Mum. I am one of three siblings and have sister and brother. Sister and I had children around about the same time. I have never been very close to my Mum, she was pretty awful to sister and I in teens but became closer in 20's and then again when we had kids in 30's. She was supportive with grandkids initially however made it clear she was there to be a fun gran and spoil them and was not up for any regular childcare (absolutely her prerogative and no hard feelings about that) and would only have one grandchild at a time (from a sibling group) so she could give them her undivided attention.

Fast forward a few years and after my sister and I completed our family's my brother (always been the golden child) went on to have kids and low and behold all the boundaries she had in place went out the window and she is all of a sudden quite happy to do regular child care for him and has taken his kids together from baby/toddler stage.

Her attitude towards his family is night and day compared to ours and she is willing to go above and beyond to help him in any way she can but will continually put obstacles in the way any time I (very rarely) ask for a bit of help with something important. She has made it clear (for my sister and I) that they are our kids and we shouldn't be asking anyone else for help. All family gatherings are spent with her entertaining my brother's kids while ours are more or less ignored.

She thinks it's ridiculous when my sister and I spend any time away from our families for the odd weekend away and has no problem expressing this despite her opinion despite not being asked for it and never asking her to help out with childcare. Yet when my brother and SIL do the same age thinks it's great they are getting a break.

I feel so sad when I hear how close my friends are to their Mums and how they see them all the time. I have tried to include my Mum in our family life loads over the years (by spending time with us as a family, not just wanting help) and it's always met with reluctance and (sometimes ridiculous) excuses. I have put a lot of effort into our relationship over the years, regularly host the family gatherings such a Christmas, helped her a lot when she has broken bones and not been able to drive etc. When I talk to my friends about it they are all very sympathetic and say it's her loss but I very much feel it's my loss as well as I would love a great relationship with my Mum.

I have tried to talk to her a couple of times over the years but she completely denies any if it. I have accepted the situation for what it is now but struggling not to become bitter about it.

OP posts:
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 16/11/2023 08:48

I wouldn't try and address it with her. She won't change. As others say you need to start to distance yourself from her.

If you don't, I've seen quite a few posts on here over the years where it's expected by everyone in the family that the non golden child(ren) look after their parent in old age. Because the golden child is too important and caring is 'women's work '. And they get nothing but abuse for it while the golden child gets loads of praise for visiting for an hour twice a year. And they end up with a load of resentment and realising after years and years and years that whatever they do, their efforts won't make their mum change her feelings towards them

TheresaOfAvila · 16/11/2023 08:46

sorrynotathome · 16/11/2023 06:16

OP has literally said that she tried to talk to her Mum about it!

OP the problem is that you have tried to engage with her about being a shit Mum. She isn’t going to voluntarily go there.

However, that doesn’t mean you have to accept her narrative or give her an easy ride about it.
” I see you have prioritised X again, as he’s more important to you, and it doesn’t bother you that I am upset.”
”Do not ask me to deny what I can see with my own eyes. I am not prepared to pretend I can’t see the choices you make, and I will draw my own conclusions as to why you do that without asking your permission.”
and the very powerful “Well, we’ll have to agree to differ on that. I’m capable of making my own mind up.”
You could even say “We both know you’re comfortable lying to me and [sis], but can you at least stop lying to yourself”

I would also make the comment to your brother and SIL.

Finally, and to hep you have compassion for your mother, maybe she fears ‘losing’ your brother to your SIL and her side of the family, so feels compelled to work hard against that, especially if she feels that her bond to her daughters is secure (enough).

junebirthdaygirl · 16/11/2023 08:44

Just thinking of your mil collecting your children. Sounds very supportive but does she have dds who are not being supported as much. You are gaining by your mil choosing to support her sons family. Sometimes that's easier as you don't have the baggage you have with your own mother.
I would just accept your mom is who she is and as others have said plan accordingly. Sometimes we can have this fantasy of what a mother is to us as adults but it's best to actually deal with the reality as it causes less pain and constant disappointment. She won't change but you can. Let your brother be the one who cares for her in her old age!

DoubleTime · 16/11/2023 08:40

Tell her you won't be hosting at Christmas because your children are getting old enough to notice the difference in the way your M treats their cousins.

DisquietintheRanks · 16/11/2023 08:30

You could just ditch her OP. Might make you feel better.

UnRavellingFast · 16/11/2023 08:29

user1492757084 · 16/11/2023 07:42

Your children are older now and will only know and rememeber their own experiences.
Help them look back with happiness about the special times they spend with your mother - even though they spend time alone with her.
I hope you don't voice comparisons and expess displeasure that your brother's children go as a pair.

It seems that your mother does her best and has always had a special rapport with your brother. Unfortunate for you but he can't help it.

Many grandparents focus on the younger children in a group so that is not odd.

Edited

Seriously. Are you the OP’s mum?

WildflowersInAMasonJar · 16/11/2023 08:28

Is that you OP’s mother ?

Yes. I was thinking that. Certainly someone who has done this themselves. 🙄

caringcarer · 16/11/2023 08:27

ZekeZeke · 16/11/2023 06:18

Your brother is the golden child, its that simple.

Sadly this. She will always put your brother and his children first. It must hurt very much. I'd lean towards my sister and try to be close with her if you can.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 16/11/2023 08:23

user1492757084 · 16/11/2023 07:42

Your children are older now and will only know and rememeber their own experiences.
Help them look back with happiness about the special times they spend with your mother - even though they spend time alone with her.
I hope you don't voice comparisons and expess displeasure that your brother's children go as a pair.

It seems that your mother does her best and has always had a special rapport with your brother. Unfortunate for you but he can't help it.

Many grandparents focus on the younger children in a group so that is not odd.

Edited

Have you actually read the OP’s post. Vile behaviour towards her daughters, overt favouritism towards golden child son, and sowing the seeds of division with the grandchildren. And you think she’s doing her best ? Words fail me.

susiedaisy1912 · 16/11/2023 08:23

cloverleafy · 16/11/2023 06:51

Not having a "mum", in the way that most people interpret the word, is a huge loss and you will feel grief. Having it rubbed in that she can "mother" and "grandparent", just not for you or your children, is painful.

This.

Bookworm1111 · 16/11/2023 08:23

My children have never mentioned it, which I find odd as the kids go to the same school so see their Gran picking up their cousins every week and not them. I never say anything about it in front of them as I am glad they haven't picked up on it. I guess they just accept it for what it is and they probably don't remember a time it wasn't this way. My nephew is very aware though sadly and feels very let down.

This is awful. Your mum's behaviour is spiteful and, I'd wager, intentional. She must know what she's doing when she sees your DC in the playground and doesn't go near them. For my own sanity I would have to withdraw from the relationship - no helping her out with anything, no pressing her for visits, no phone calls checking how she is. I'd stop engaging completely and concentrate on the fabulous relationship you have with your MIL. You say she does the grunt work – TELL your kids how lucky they are to have her and don't mention their other gran in any context. She doesn't deserve it.

Rosscameasdoody · 16/11/2023 08:19

user1492757084 · 16/11/2023 07:42

Your children are older now and will only know and rememeber their own experiences.
Help them look back with happiness about the special times they spend with your mother - even though they spend time alone with her.
I hope you don't voice comparisons and expess displeasure that your brother's children go as a pair.

It seems that your mother does her best and has always had a special rapport with your brother. Unfortunate for you but he can't help it.

Many grandparents focus on the younger children in a group so that is not odd.

Edited

Is that you OP’s mother ?

cerisepanther73 · 16/11/2023 08:18

@PriOn1 totally nailed this on the head with that good remark...

cerisepanther73 · 16/11/2023 08:17

Totally agree with @nibblessquibbles very good advice there,

i am not susprised you and your sister feel the way you do Op, !

anyone in your situation would feel Totally the same too.

PegasusReturns · 16/11/2023 08:13

It seems that your mother does her best and has always had a special rapport with your brother. Unfortunate for you but he can't help it

What crap, a decent mother doesn’t behave like that. It’s the very opposite of doing her best.

OP I’m sorry. I have a similar relationship with my mother. My young adult DC have nothing to do with her, a situation entirely of her own making and I and the younger DC are very low contact, which was best thing I ever did.

wesurecouldstandgladioli · 16/11/2023 08:12

SauronsArsehole · 16/11/2023 07:42

I meant to add.

by taking your kids separately she is instilling division in them.

that they are not good enough ‘together’ but their uncles kids are.

these are tiny seeds that grow as the years go by. Don’t let this happen to your kids.

Yep, I’d also wonder what she’s whispering in their ears when she has each one alone.

WildflowersInAMasonJar · 16/11/2023 08:07

Your mum is a fucked up person. Having been through it, my advice would be to keep your kids away from her. Don’t let her damage their self esteem over time, don’t let them see you be treating as lesser. She’s the issue, stop trying to please her because you never will.

ThenKatyFainted · 16/11/2023 08:02

I have some experience of this, too. But why do they do it? I really, really would like to understand. I can't imagine doing this to my own children, I love them all equally.

SunshineAutumnday · 16/11/2023 07:58

I had counselling due to the bitterness and anger I felt towards my mum for how I was treated in childhood and adulthood. My DM is very cold, controlling nacarrisit.

Through counselling the anger has creased - I can't change the past but I have let it go. Which has stopped the anger. It also taught me to think about the RELATIONSHIP I want with my DM and on my terms.

You can't change your DM (sorry) but YOU can decide how her actions affect you. My DM refused to do childcare for my children - even in an emergency she refused - my lovely dad stepped in, he took a day off work to help me. 15 years on the story in my DMs head has changed to her saving the day. I used be angry but now I laugh.

good luck.

MsRosley · 16/11/2023 07:57

Walk away. Put precisely as much effort into the relationship and she does with you. Cultivate love and affection from those able to give it, and look on the bright side. She's released you. You now owe her nothing. When she's old and frail, you and your sister don't have to worry - her golden boy can take care of her.

Purpleturtle45 · 16/11/2023 07:57

Lastchancechica · 16/11/2023 07:48

You sound like ops mother…

Was just thinking the same 🤣

OP posts:
Girlsjustwannahavefundamentalrights · 16/11/2023 07:50

Your brother is the golden child. I saw my cousins being treated as the golden children when i was growing up. Boys had different rules to the girls. By the time the youngest boy grandchild came along, the entire family joined in and elevated him to golden child status. It seriously damaged my self esteem. I wish my mum had stood up to protect us from the toxicity because i don't think i will ever see myself as any thing other than unworthy of positive attention.

Lastchancechica · 16/11/2023 07:48

user1492757084 · 16/11/2023 07:42

Your children are older now and will only know and rememeber their own experiences.
Help them look back with happiness about the special times they spend with your mother - even though they spend time alone with her.
I hope you don't voice comparisons and expess displeasure that your brother's children go as a pair.

It seems that your mother does her best and has always had a special rapport with your brother. Unfortunate for you but he can't help it.

Many grandparents focus on the younger children in a group so that is not odd.

Edited

You sound like ops mother…

user1492757084 · 16/11/2023 07:42

Your children are older now and will only know and rememeber their own experiences.
Help them look back with happiness about the special times they spend with your mother - even though they spend time alone with her.
I hope you don't voice comparisons and expess displeasure that your brother's children go as a pair.

It seems that your mother does her best and has always had a special rapport with your brother. Unfortunate for you but he can't help it.

Many grandparents focus on the younger children in a group so that is not odd.

Night409 · 16/11/2023 07:42

YANBU obviously but I wouldn’t talk to her about it and I would just pull back from the relationship.

My brother is definitely the golden child and his DCs were always put above mine and my sisters.

But my mum said once that he’s the boy and his new wife will take him away from her, so she has to make more of an effort to keep him in her life, whereas me and my sisters will always be there.
She said we need to see her and help her but he doesn’t.
I think a lot of mums think like this actually and that’s why MILs get such a bad name because they blame the new wife for trying to take their son away.

I decided to pull back from my relationship with her and made a lot less effort.
I would have days out with my brother and his family or invite them round for dinner. My mum would kick off about it (never cared when it was my sister coming round) and I’d say I didn’t invite her because she never wants to come to my home.

I’ve definitely noticed since I’ve pulled back that she’s made more effort.
Its also made me realise how bad her behaviour actually was towards me and my sisters (especially me) and that it’s really important to put those boundaries in before she gets too old.