Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'I do all these things AND work FT'

991 replies

Bumpitybumper · 15/11/2023 15:37

I see this on Mumsnet a lot but have just experienced it in real life. I have two friends (A&B). Friend A is a SAHM to school age kids and Friend B works FT in quite a stressful job. Friend B was just lamenting that they don't understand how Friend A fills her time as she manages to work FT AND do everything Friend A does.

The thing is, Friend B has a much smaller (yet lovely) house that is pretty chaotic in fun energetic way. It is never the tidiest or cleanest but it's not disgusting either. Friend A on the other hand has a much bigger house that is pretty immaculate most of the time. Friend A does all the school runs and volunteers at school. Friend B needs wraparound care in order to get to work so drops her kids of at 8 and collects around 17:30. Friend A cooks amazing meals for her family, has her children's friends round for fun playdates and activities and is generally incredibly on top of everything. Friend B is understandably more stretched and isn't in the position to cook lavish meals every day of the week or have friends round when she's at work. Friend B's husband does a lot (of course absolutely fair and right) so she doesn't have to attend every parents evening, sew all the badges for extracurricular clubs or assist with all the homework etc. Friend A does pretty much all of that as husband works such long hours.

I actually think both are amazing and very productive people that channel their energy, time and talent in different channels. I just struggle to understand though how Friend B can't appreciate that she isn't doing the same as Friend A or at least doing it to the same standard. Before people suggest I'm Friend A, I have my own business so don't really fit in either camp but used to be a SAHM so I guess can see Friend A's efforts more.

AIBU to think that Friend B is a bit deluded?

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 18/11/2023 11:27

lizzy8230 · 18/11/2023 11:22

Extended paternity leave would be great, but I'd have given my right some of the legislation that's already in place now. Eg transferable parental leave. I would have loved to have eg 6 months leave or 9 months leave and then transferred the remainder to dh. I think it's best for all- it means the children get that 1:1 time with each parent, not just a couple of hours for bath and bed time but with both parents experiencing the reality of all day caring. If a father has spent several months doing that, it's bound to influence things going forward too. It's much more difficult for a dad to shrug off responsibility for looking after a baby or for doing domestic chores if he's had a period of time being solely in charge of those things.

Personally, I'd have a use it or lose it policy because my concern with transferable parental leave would be that it would actually just end up with mothers taking all or the majority of it and nothing would change.

I wouldn't force anyone to take it and I'd give the option of taking it together or one taking some leave and then the other taking some leave but to me, some leave needs to be available for fathers only which is longer than 2 weeks.

lizzy8230 · 18/11/2023 11:22

Extended paternity leave would be great, but I'd have given my right some of the legislation that's already in place now. Eg transferable parental leave. I would have loved to have eg 6 months leave or 9 months leave and then transferred the remainder to dh. I think it's best for all- it means the children get that 1:1 time with each parent, not just a couple of hours for bath and bed time but with both parents experiencing the reality of all day caring. If a father has spent several months doing that, it's bound to influence things going forward too. It's much more difficult for a dad to shrug off responsibility for looking after a baby or for doing domestic chores if he's had a period of time being solely in charge of those things.

SouthLondonMum22 · 18/11/2023 11:15

Mummymummy89 · 18/11/2023 10:43

It was me, I just wanted to share more thoughts on this now it's come round to pat leave again - the problem with the take-up of extended paternity leave is that it's become political. Counter-intuitively, it's considered in some radical-feminist viewpoints as anti-feminist to be in favour of extended paternity leave, as if it's a "men's rights" thing.

It really, really isn't. I'm a bit of a raging radfem but I see extended paternity leave as primarily benefiting the mum, and indirectly benefiting all childbearing-aged women in the workplace.

But when I've talked about this on twitter (I know, I know cesspit etc) I've been shut down by some of the radfems on there "who cares about the menz". (I don't particularly care about the menz. It's good for the womenz.)

But, looking at it in that light, it's less of a surprise that it's the more "woke" companies that do extended pat leave. For example, at my dh's company, they put he/him on his online profile (without asking him - what's the point eh) and little things like that are pointers about the political alignment of a company.

So you'll get little traction trying to campaign for this politically.

There was actually a thread about this very thing a few months ago now I believe where OP was irritated that her ex (who wasn't involved, to be fair) was able to take a long paternity leave, I believe it was something like 3-4 months and obviously, the specific situation was wrong because he wasn't doing anything with his baby but it soon turned into a general discussion about longer paternity leave.

Many people (I'm assuming women) had the same view you are talking about. It was generally seen as a negative thing and something that should remain unchanged. I was surprised that so many women couldn't seem to understand how much it would benefit them, not only at home but should they go back to the work place too.

G5000 · 18/11/2023 11:01

I'm a bit of a raging radfem but I see extended paternity leave as primarily benefiting the mum, and indirectly benefiting all childbearing-aged women in the workplace.

Same here. Of course it benefits women.

Mummymummy89 · 18/11/2023 10:43

SouthLondonMum22 · 18/11/2023 10:09

I absolutely agree.

I discussed this with someone briefly a few pages ago, forgive me if it was you but a change I would make is a longer paternity leave. 2 weeks is woeful and also encourages fathers to be more hands off.

Some companies, usually tech ones, are now offering 3-4+ months of paternity leave and that should be standard across the board.

It was me, I just wanted to share more thoughts on this now it's come round to pat leave again - the problem with the take-up of extended paternity leave is that it's become political. Counter-intuitively, it's considered in some radical-feminist viewpoints as anti-feminist to be in favour of extended paternity leave, as if it's a "men's rights" thing.

It really, really isn't. I'm a bit of a raging radfem but I see extended paternity leave as primarily benefiting the mum, and indirectly benefiting all childbearing-aged women in the workplace.

But when I've talked about this on twitter (I know, I know cesspit etc) I've been shut down by some of the radfems on there "who cares about the menz". (I don't particularly care about the menz. It's good for the womenz.)

But, looking at it in that light, it's less of a surprise that it's the more "woke" companies that do extended pat leave. For example, at my dh's company, they put he/him on his online profile (without asking him - what's the point eh) and little things like that are pointers about the political alignment of a company.

So you'll get little traction trying to campaign for this politically.

5128gap · 18/11/2023 10:22

The way I see it, the reason many feminists take issue with the SAHM model is because feminism is not about applauding the choices of individual women who have found a way to make patriarchal systems work in their favour. Feminism is a political movement that centres the interests of women as a class, working to minimise our disadvantage and further our equality. Unfortunately there is no way (that I've found anyway) to squeeze the square peg of the SAHM into that round hole.
Sometimes individual women want to do things to benefit themselves and/or to benefit men that obstruct the progress of women as a class.
But most feminists get this. If you're a woman you understand that living in a world not geared up for you means you navigate it the best you can. You understand that emotional decisions, love for individual men and children, will often be prioritised over political ones, and self interest is most people's primary driver. Most feminists get this and in these discussions should not be attacking individual women for non feminist choices.
The criticism is of the model itself, with some challenge to the thinking that every choice made by a woman must be supported and applauded simply because a woman has made it.

SisterHyster · 18/11/2023 10:20

SouthLondonMum22 · 18/11/2023 09:27

I know someone (not fictitious before anyone says so!) whose avaricious husband forced her to go back to work once her maternity pay was no longer full pay at six months. She had been exclusively breastfeeding (no bottles even) until then and then had to pump round the clock, while juggling a Biggish Job and still being a new mother, to try to get enough milk for her baby to be in childcare fifty hours a week (8-6 x 5). I am notcriticising the fact that the baby was in childcare of course but she was really not happy about having to ‘make this decision’ which was never hers to make. Nothing feminist about that imo.

That's awful.

It should absolutely be a joint decision, no couple should be making the decision alone. Especially if we are talking about a longer term SAHM role because not everyone wants to be the sole provider financially which can often be stressful and put one person under a lot of pressure. I don't always think that is considered as men have been seen as the financial providers for a very long time.

It also means a discussion can be had about the father and if it's possible for him to request flexible working, go part time or even be the one to be a SAHP. I don't think that discussion currently happens enough because it is just assumed it's a decision for mothers to make.

Your last paragraph really resonated with me; mainly because my partner temporarily was a SAHD (he took redundancy and we used that as “income”) then went part-time, again temporarily. I think it all comes down to what kind of man the father is. In an ideal world, natural selection will weed out these types of sexist men, who expect parenting and housework to be done by women while they proceed with their normal life, because nobody will reproduce with them. We can dream!

SouthLondonMum22 · 18/11/2023 10:09

lizzy8230 · 18/11/2023 10:02

Completely agree @SouthLondonMum22

I was referring to the extremes, where it really is abusive. Frankly any situation where one partner forces the other (whether that's forcing them into full time work or forcing them to be the sole provider) when there are alternatives available, well, that's abusive

As you say, between the extremes there's a whole range of nuances which perpetuate those ingrained attitudes: the fact that the vast majority of women are the default give up work/ go part time parent.

To me it seems strange that a woman and a man partner each other, make a commitment, set up home, decide to embark on a family and then once the child arrives, societal prejudices expect all that shared life experience and joint thinking to go out the window and for the couple to default into entirely separate roles. It's certainly not what dh and I wanted which is why we were determined (even while I was a breast feeding mum of a 3 month old) that we would both continue to work and both be hands on parents. Having achieved a good balance in raising our now adult children, it's rather depressing that despite all the wonderful provisions like long mat leave, shared parental leave, subsidised nursery fees, these ingrained prejudices still exist in society.

To me it all comes back to the child. It's not just about mum and dad both having a healthy balance of caring and providing in their life, imo it's actually beneficial to the child to have parents with this balance. I believe seeing both mum and dad in nurturing and providing roles is something that stays with them and will help them to not feel the pressure of societal prejudices and expectations.

I absolutely agree.

I discussed this with someone briefly a few pages ago, forgive me if it was you but a change I would make is a longer paternity leave. 2 weeks is woeful and also encourages fathers to be more hands off.

Some companies, usually tech ones, are now offering 3-4+ months of paternity leave and that should be standard across the board.

lizzy8230 · 18/11/2023 10:02

Completely agree @SouthLondonMum22

I was referring to the extremes, where it really is abusive. Frankly any situation where one partner forces the other (whether that's forcing them into full time work or forcing them to be the sole provider) when there are alternatives available, well, that's abusive

As you say, between the extremes there's a whole range of nuances which perpetuate those ingrained attitudes: the fact that the vast majority of women are the default give up work/ go part time parent.

To me it seems strange that a woman and a man partner each other, make a commitment, set up home, decide to embark on a family and then once the child arrives, societal prejudices expect all that shared life experience and joint thinking to go out the window and for the couple to default into entirely separate roles. It's certainly not what dh and I wanted which is why we were determined (even while I was a breast feeding mum of a 3 month old) that we would both continue to work and both be hands on parents. Having achieved a good balance in raising our now adult children, it's rather depressing that despite all the wonderful provisions like long mat leave, shared parental leave, subsidised nursery fees, these ingrained prejudices still exist in society.

To me it all comes back to the child. It's not just about mum and dad both having a healthy balance of caring and providing in their life, imo it's actually beneficial to the child to have parents with this balance. I believe seeing both mum and dad in nurturing and providing roles is something that stays with them and will help them to not feel the pressure of societal prejudices and expectations.

Cinty6 · 18/11/2023 09:54

Yes. It is a tremendous pressure on the sole earner. My husband earns well but in an industry where you can also get sacked at the drop of a hat, particularly if held to higher account as he is due to his position. Sure, he could always get a new job and has funds to fall back on on a rainy day but it would be insincere of me to not share that I often worried about this during my time off. So I feel more secure about myself and him now working again.

I wish threads about this debate contained more concrete advice for women and indeed men about the what ifs and, as you mention, solutions. Especially those that are a small step towards a more equitable future for our kids if not us, and result in women not feeling compelled to leave the workplace in the first case.

SouthLondonMum22 · 18/11/2023 09:48

lizzy8230 · 18/11/2023 09:33

Sadly there are always extreme situations - people in abusive relationships where one partner forces the other to behave in a certain way- whether that's forcing them back into work or forcing them to be sole provider. No amount of legislation about transferable leave or flexi working is going to be effective for people who are abusive, sadly.

We're talking about a minority though, and while we can all cite anecdotal examples, I like to operate on the basis that women and men fundamentally want similar things out of life, ie: a healthy work/life balance, the opportunity to experience different things.... and if they have children, the opportunity to nurture them as well as to provide.

Sadly there are always extreme situations - people in abusive relationships where one partner forces the other to behave in a certain way- whether that's forcing them back into work or forcing them to be sole provider. No amount of legislation about transferable leave or flexi working is going to be effective for people who are abusive, sadly.

I wasn't talking about abusive situations personally, though I would agree that pp's example would be classed as abusive. I was more talking generally about how ingrained it is in society for men to be providers and women to be the default parent. I think changing attitudes within society could address some of this. Such as reframing it as a choice both men and women need to make together once they become parents, not just a choice that women need to make about if they go back to work full time, part time or not at all. Men need to consider this too.

I agree that there will always be extreme situations but language is also important and doing simple things such as stop using 'help' when it comes to men parenting their own children would go a long way.

lizzy8230 · 18/11/2023 09:33

Sadly there are always extreme situations - people in abusive relationships where one partner forces the other to behave in a certain way- whether that's forcing them back into work or forcing them to be sole provider. No amount of legislation about transferable leave or flexi working is going to be effective for people who are abusive, sadly.

We're talking about a minority though, and while we can all cite anecdotal examples, I like to operate on the basis that women and men fundamentally want similar things out of life, ie: a healthy work/life balance, the opportunity to experience different things.... and if they have children, the opportunity to nurture them as well as to provide.

SouthLondonMum22 · 18/11/2023 09:27

Cinty6 · 18/11/2023 09:05

My type of feminism is women having a choice, the only women I feel sorry for are those who don't have a choice and have to either work or stay at home due to circumstances when they'd love to do the other. @Peablockfeathers

This is my view of it too.

I know someone (not fictitious before anyone says so!) whose avaricious husband forced her to go back to work once her maternity pay was no longer full pay at six months. She had been exclusively breastfeeding (no bottles even) until then and then had to pump round the clock, while juggling a Biggish Job and still being a new mother, to try to get enough milk for her baby to be in childcare fifty hours a week (8-6 x 5). I am not criticising the fact that the baby was in childcare of course but she was really not happy about having to ‘make this decision’ which was never hers to make. Nothing feminist about that imo.

Meanwhile, I decided to take some time out when I had babies fairly close. It was important for me to be at home when they were so young, although I also wanted them to see us both working when they were older. I know my choice won’t be for everyone. There were also several practical reasons which meant we would have had to have them with a nanny for wraparound, after pick up from two different nurseries too. We didn’t want this personally and for many reasons again. I had savings and had a decent pension already due to always being financially responsible and my husband and I discussed at length all the risks and what would be done to minimise them. I appreciate my privilege in being able to do this.

I’m sure my decision, certainly at face value, would be criticised on here. But my own experience of wondering how the hell we were going to make it work and the experience of someone we know above is why I try not to judge too quickly about a decision a woman seemingly makes, whether it’s to go back to work or stay at home.

I know someone (not fictitious before anyone says so!) whose avaricious husband forced her to go back to work once her maternity pay was no longer full pay at six months. She had been exclusively breastfeeding (no bottles even) until then and then had to pump round the clock, while juggling a Biggish Job and still being a new mother, to try to get enough milk for her baby to be in childcare fifty hours a week (8-6 x 5). I am notcriticising the fact that the baby was in childcare of course but she was really not happy about having to ‘make this decision’ which was never hers to make. Nothing feminist about that imo.

That's awful.

It should absolutely be a joint decision, no couple should be making the decision alone. Especially if we are talking about a longer term SAHM role because not everyone wants to be the sole provider financially which can often be stressful and put one person under a lot of pressure. I don't always think that is considered as men have been seen as the financial providers for a very long time.

It also means a discussion can be had about the father and if it's possible for him to request flexible working, go part time or even be the one to be a SAHP. I don't think that discussion currently happens enough because it is just assumed it's a decision for mothers to make.

SouthLondonMum22 · 18/11/2023 09:11

lizzy8230 · 18/11/2023 08:06

@Walkaround, thanks for replying: I understand what you're saying and I entirely concur that trolling either way is just a waste of space - whether it's calling SAHM lazy, or telling WOHM they aren't raising their children.

When I look at my own children (and I have sons and a daughter) I just hope that in their life time it becomes more the norm that roles are shared. It was far tougher for my own generation: like I said, when you're an avid breastfeeder and have just a 12 week mat leave, it takes a huge effort to get back to work and continue feeding. The easier option would definitely have been to jack in my job! Definitely with the fact dh had no paternity leave entitlement back then, and certainly none of the shared parental leave available now. I think despite these obstacles, we made a pretty good fist of getting a balance. We've both always worked and we've both shared the child and home stuff. Society has made progress - option of transferable leave, right to request flexi working - BUT there is so much further to go.

Ultimately to me it's about the children. Children deserve time with both parents, I believe they benefit from seeing mum and dad as providers and nurturers, it sets a pattern with hopefully they take forward themselves. I would have hated my sons growing up feeling pressure that one day they have to have that fat cat high flying job because they've got to be sole provider. Neither would I want my dd to excel at school and university, go into a good job and then feel pressure to jack it in because she 'ought' to be at home if she has kids.

Well said. This is almost exactly how I feel.

I don't blame Indvidual SAHM's (well, unless they talk about working mums paying for someone else to raise their children), I blame the sexist society we live in that hold mothers and fathers to a different standard and put far too much pressure on mothers yet nowhere near enough pressure on fathers.

I just want to live in a world where women aren't automatically seen as the default parent and men just 'help'. I want it to be more equal.

I'm pregnant with twin girls and I don't want them growing up in a world where society thinks something is wrong with them if they become mothers themselves one day and want to work full time. It wouldn't make them 'wired' incorrectly or not 'maternal', it would simply make them working parents.

It isn't too much to ask.

Cinty6 · 18/11/2023 09:05

My type of feminism is women having a choice, the only women I feel sorry for are those who don't have a choice and have to either work or stay at home due to circumstances when they'd love to do the other. @Peablockfeathers

This is my view of it too.

I know someone (not fictitious before anyone says so!) whose avaricious husband forced her to go back to work once her maternity pay was no longer full pay at six months. She had been exclusively breastfeeding (no bottles even) until then and then had to pump round the clock, while juggling a Biggish Job and still being a new mother, to try to get enough milk for her baby to be in childcare fifty hours a week (8-6 x 5). I am not criticising the fact that the baby was in childcare of course but she was really not happy about having to ‘make this decision’ which was never hers to make. Nothing feminist about that imo.

Meanwhile, I decided to take some time out when I had babies fairly close. It was important for me to be at home when they were so young, although I also wanted them to see us both working when they were older. I know my choice won’t be for everyone. There were also several practical reasons which meant we would have had to have them with a nanny for wraparound, after pick up from two different nurseries too. We didn’t want this personally and for many reasons again. I had savings and had a decent pension already due to always being financially responsible and my husband and I discussed at length all the risks and what would be done to minimise them. I appreciate my privilege in being able to do this.

I’m sure my decision, certainly at face value, would be criticised on here. But my own experience of wondering how the hell we were going to make it work and the experience of someone we know above is why I try not to judge too quickly about a decision a woman seemingly makes, whether it’s to go back to work or stay at home.

Walkaround · 18/11/2023 09:04

Kids care about feeling loved and secure. There are multiple ways of showing that to them, including working to provide an income, making the wider world seem an interesting and worthwhile place to grow up in (whether by volunteering or doing paid work), taking an interest in their lives, sharing the things you love with them. Not everyone looks constantly for external validation, or sees others’ actions only in that light. I wouldn’t automatically assume the serving of “amazing meals,” ensuring playdates are frequent and fun, or sewing on badges was for external display purposes only - these are all ways, among many potential ways, of showing love and interest and providing a secure, stable environment. It’s not so much what a person does, but the way in which they do it that is meaningful - one person’s spotless home is cold and sterile and resentful, another’s is the creation of a safe, comfortable, happy space.

Mummymummy89 · 18/11/2023 08:52

Just coming back to this thread to say I've got a lot of food for thought from it and I'm glad op started it.

On a lighthearted note, my mum is visiting at the moment and I gave her a summary of the thread and about friend A and B. For context my mum is in her 60s, has been a single mum throughout my life, always working FT until she retired recently, and has always lived in an East Asian country where I grew up.

Her reaction (she interrupted me to rant):

"Ugh, A sounds like a busybody(+). Of COURSE she's on the PTA. I know the type. Don't tell me, always baking for the cake sales? I bet her house is really tidy?! I'm so glad you're not that type!!"

I must admit I cracked up. The WOHM/SAHM schism transcends space and time. There are mum-aliens on a distant moon griping about each other and the immaculate tidiness of their moon-caves.

In fairness to my mum she always contributed her signature gingerbread men to the cake sale - we had to stay up late to help make them after dinner.

(+)Actually she used a word in her own language which is more hilarious but roughly translates to busybody

WinchSparkle80 · 18/11/2023 08:52

@lizzy8230 exactly, better articulated than me! I definitely get self worth as a parent and being a good role model but also working.

lizzy8230 · 18/11/2023 08:35

@WinchSparkle80 agree. The whole premise of the thread was quite judgey really.

Also part of the problem is the moment a WOHM says they get self worth from working, some people interpret that as 'oh so you're saying mums don't have self worth unless they work, which is nonsense. It's a different kind of self worth. I've always felt self worth as a parent because I feel dh and I have given our best to raise them well. I feel self worth in the workplace because I've worked hard to gain skills and experience and I've achieved things that I wouldn't have if i didn't work.

It's entirely normal to feel validation for a range of reasons.

WinchSparkle80 · 18/11/2023 08:25

It all just sounds really judgmental.

I am Friend B, I love being Friend B because I get a lot of my self worth from working because I love it. I also WFH so get stuff done and my DH helps

I have lots of friends who are Friend A. I wouldn’t like their lives but I don’t judge them for it. It doesn’t occur to me to comment on them being better at parenting than me because they are not. Just a different set up.

Kids don’t care about huge immaculate homes or amazing meals- people do that for other parents to show the world they are successful/better or because it’s very important to them.

Kids want attention and as a Friend B my kids have lots of quality attention and have lots of fun.

lizzy8230 · 18/11/2023 08:06

@Walkaround, thanks for replying: I understand what you're saying and I entirely concur that trolling either way is just a waste of space - whether it's calling SAHM lazy, or telling WOHM they aren't raising their children.

When I look at my own children (and I have sons and a daughter) I just hope that in their life time it becomes more the norm that roles are shared. It was far tougher for my own generation: like I said, when you're an avid breastfeeder and have just a 12 week mat leave, it takes a huge effort to get back to work and continue feeding. The easier option would definitely have been to jack in my job! Definitely with the fact dh had no paternity leave entitlement back then, and certainly none of the shared parental leave available now. I think despite these obstacles, we made a pretty good fist of getting a balance. We've both always worked and we've both shared the child and home stuff. Society has made progress - option of transferable leave, right to request flexi working - BUT there is so much further to go.

Ultimately to me it's about the children. Children deserve time with both parents, I believe they benefit from seeing mum and dad as providers and nurturers, it sets a pattern with hopefully they take forward themselves. I would have hated my sons growing up feeling pressure that one day they have to have that fat cat high flying job because they've got to be sole provider. Neither would I want my dd to excel at school and university, go into a good job and then feel pressure to jack it in because she 'ought' to be at home if she has kids.

Walkaround · 18/11/2023 07:51

@lizzy8230 - I agree with everything you are saying. My post was not my thoughts on the way things are now so much as a response to those people (probably mostly trolls), who definitely have appeared on this thread, who have used the language you are now objecting to in my post, and one or two who have said that SAHMs are lazy. I am not going to tolerate being told I do not see my own “misogyny” when, quite frankly, it seems to me that some people simply do not understand the difference between misogyny and despising anything that was traditionally done by women in the past. I don’t want to be trapped at home, stuck in a traditional role, being denied an education, being refused access to some parts of society, but nor do I want a society which tells people they are weak and pathetic if their version of teamwork and family life does not fit a rather selfish narrative. If we achieve equality with men simply by using an unrespected underclass to so the “grunt work” for us, I won’t see that as a fantastic achievement of humanity, just a rearrangement of disrespect.

Peablockfeathers · 18/11/2023 07:42

Walkaround · 18/11/2023 06:00

So, it’s kind of funny how so many feminists don’t recognise the misogyny in pushing and pushing for women to protect themselves by opting out of more and more unpaid work, which is now just reclassified as unimportant existing on this planet or silly little hobby stuff, and focusing instead on making money. Then they go further and start to call any woman not joining in with money making a weak, lazy, pathetic waste of space who sponges off the important people who do the valuable work. Then everyone faux-wonders why on earth men don’t want to join in with being called lazy, pathetic wastes of space who do the grunt work.

We could try reclassifying what people do in a less misogynistic way if we really wanted a more fair share of work to be done, rather than telling people there is all this crappy, worthless stuff that we all have to share and then this amazingly brilliant power-trip called money, which we earn for ourselves and shouldn’t have to share with anyone, because it represents our own over-inflated egos and that’s what’s important and gets things done around here.

That's quite some reaching and wild interpretation. The reality is we live in a society where you require money in order to have a roof over your head, food on the table and whatever else. We also live in a country that doesn't provide an adequate safety net anymore- as in there are children who's parents who are on benefits who can't afford to eat. Society doesn't value unpaid work, but it's not ridiculous for people to suggest women who actively choose to remove themselves from paid work to being solely reliant on a man for money (this excludes those with generational wealth or those with existing assets as they'd be fine) to really think about it because in the society we live in this does make them, and their children, vulnerable.

I don't think women generally view being a mother and associated duties of as 'silly little hobby stuff' but have pointed out that in this capitalist society you should make an informed decision and balance the risk of doing so. This is sad in itself but not the fault of women. There are some who say they would hate to be a SAHM as for them they'd find it unfulfilling which is fine; I'm sure many SAHMs feel the same about paid employment. My type of feminism is women having a choice, the only women I feel sorry for are those who don't have a choice and have to either work or stay at home due to circumstances when they'd love to do the other.

lizzy8230 · 18/11/2023 07:33

@Walkaround you've constructed a narrative completely of your own there! I haven't seen a single person say that unless all women join in 'money making' then they're a 'weak, lazy pathetic waste of space.' Using emotive, strident language doesn't make what you're writing true!

IMO the reality is far more straightforward. People tend to partner someone with similar levels of education and ability. There are often shared life goals with the person you set up home with, whether to have children etc. I don't see this massive divide between men and women based simply on their sex. Ime most women are equally capable as their male partners in the workplace. That was certainly true of dh and me: we met at university, we set off on career paths of similar status and incomes. From being students we were both equally competent at cooking and cleaning. When we decided to embark on a family, it was a joint decision, and when the dcs arrived, he loved them just as much as me. He was always equally capable at nappy changing, playing with the kids, doing nursery runs etc etc It was much harder to create a balance of earning and caring when we had our babies because this was in the era of 3 month maternity leave and zero for paternity. However, we strived to achieve a balance as far as possible; we both worked and we shared everything like nursery drop off, child sickness days, cooking, as much as possible.

No one is saying being a SAHM is wrong. If a couple both agree that they prefer the idea of one earner and the other taking on all child and home related stuff then that's their business. But should it honestly surprise us that many couples don't want to separate the roles out like this?

The caveat I'd add is that however much anyone bangs on about capitalism, it's a simple fact that having one's own money does give choices, and choice is a powerful and positive thing. Again, it's a fact that women as a group are far more financially vulnerable, are far more likely to live in poverty in older age etc And that's not just in the case of divorce. The happiest marriages can be struck with illness or the husband can predecease the wife and suddenly she's stuck without his income or without his full pension. These are real issues facing women which shouldn't be ignored.

Anyway, like a say, I think all this frothing just results in the core issue becoming lost: Partners often have similar levels of capability and similar shared goals in life and want balance: not being sole earner with all the responsibility, and often the hours that go with it taking them away from time with their children, but neither wanting to completely give up their work life with the consequences that often go along with that.

Walkaround · 18/11/2023 06:00

So, it’s kind of funny how so many feminists don’t recognise the misogyny in pushing and pushing for women to protect themselves by opting out of more and more unpaid work, which is now just reclassified as unimportant existing on this planet or silly little hobby stuff, and focusing instead on making money. Then they go further and start to call any woman not joining in with money making a weak, lazy, pathetic waste of space who sponges off the important people who do the valuable work. Then everyone faux-wonders why on earth men don’t want to join in with being called lazy, pathetic wastes of space who do the grunt work.

We could try reclassifying what people do in a less misogynistic way if we really wanted a more fair share of work to be done, rather than telling people there is all this crappy, worthless stuff that we all have to share and then this amazingly brilliant power-trip called money, which we earn for ourselves and shouldn’t have to share with anyone, because it represents our own over-inflated egos and that’s what’s important and gets things done around here.