Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'I do all these things AND work FT'

991 replies

Bumpitybumper · 15/11/2023 15:37

I see this on Mumsnet a lot but have just experienced it in real life. I have two friends (A&B). Friend A is a SAHM to school age kids and Friend B works FT in quite a stressful job. Friend B was just lamenting that they don't understand how Friend A fills her time as she manages to work FT AND do everything Friend A does.

The thing is, Friend B has a much smaller (yet lovely) house that is pretty chaotic in fun energetic way. It is never the tidiest or cleanest but it's not disgusting either. Friend A on the other hand has a much bigger house that is pretty immaculate most of the time. Friend A does all the school runs and volunteers at school. Friend B needs wraparound care in order to get to work so drops her kids of at 8 and collects around 17:30. Friend A cooks amazing meals for her family, has her children's friends round for fun playdates and activities and is generally incredibly on top of everything. Friend B is understandably more stretched and isn't in the position to cook lavish meals every day of the week or have friends round when she's at work. Friend B's husband does a lot (of course absolutely fair and right) so she doesn't have to attend every parents evening, sew all the badges for extracurricular clubs or assist with all the homework etc. Friend A does pretty much all of that as husband works such long hours.

I actually think both are amazing and very productive people that channel their energy, time and talent in different channels. I just struggle to understand though how Friend B can't appreciate that she isn't doing the same as Friend A or at least doing it to the same standard. Before people suggest I'm Friend A, I have my own business so don't really fit in either camp but used to be a SAHM so I guess can see Friend A's efforts more.

AIBU to think that Friend B is a bit deluded?

OP posts:
Mswest · 19/11/2023 10:32

Missamyp · 19/11/2023 10:12

It is important to acknowledge that not all women identify as feminists. For some women, prioritising their marriages and families takes precedence over political beliefs (Feminism) and materialistic values. Achieving true equality, wealth, and power is nothing but a fantasy. It is possible that the world functions the way it does because, honestly speaking, it works.
It isn't the patriarchy that undermines women, it's other women.

I'm not sure you understand what feminism is missyamp.

SeethroughDress · 19/11/2023 10:26

@Missamyp, if a woman thinks women should have equal status in law, continue to exist as a separate legal and financial entity after marriage, not automatically have to cede custody to her ex-husband on divorce, be able to vote, should be paid the same as men for the same job, have the same access to education and the workplace as boys and men, should not be assumed to have given blanket consent to sex on marriage etc, she is a feminist, regardless of what her own confused or ill-informed ideas about feminism are.

The family and marriage are not some apolitical private space. Without feminism, all the money and property she brought to a marriage would become her husband’s, she would be barred from many kinds of work after marriage, her husband could rape her legally, her children would stay with her husband after divorce, to mention only a few obvious issues.

If you know women who are so pitiably unaware of this, suggest they educate themselves.

Emi199 · 19/11/2023 10:21

Sorry I forgot who wrote what but in response to some replies that stood out

I would give up working if I won Euromillions but I must not have a career and be in a deprived area? Goodness me. I actually have a vocation and there’s a recruitment crisis and I’m a leader so have some influence. So would my husband who’s also a leader. I love my job and its “moral purpose” is undeniable but I struggle with how it has taken me away from my own children (and my husband who I often forget about!!) far too many times, despite having firm boundaries and always being very conscious to model balance to colleagues. Sorry if that makes me a bad feminist. (I don’t really care.)

There was also a reply about men being portrayed as useless on MN. This is obviously unacceptable but my concern is a more insidious form of this which starts when children are very young babies. It might be something as small as an otherwise very supportive and attentive father not feeling as confident as a mother bathing a newborn baby or perhaps the mother is better at settling them at bedtime, according to him. All these little things add up and the result is a tale as old as time: the mother is the main caregiver. So I would love to see fathers having an extended paternity which, if not taken up, is lost. This would help I’m sure.

Also some very valid points about feminism. I’m sure many women don’t set out to be a sahm and circumstances lead to it eg earning less than childcare costs for more than one child. I like to think I’m a feminist but if push came to shove and we had a tricky situation such as a financial one I’d have to be a not so good feminist. I’m aware it perpetuates a patriarchal set up which I’d be unhappy with. Life isn’t black or white.

SouthLondonMum22 · 19/11/2023 10:20

Missamyp · 19/11/2023 10:12

It is important to acknowledge that not all women identify as feminists. For some women, prioritising their marriages and families takes precedence over political beliefs (Feminism) and materialistic values. Achieving true equality, wealth, and power is nothing but a fantasy. It is possible that the world functions the way it does because, honestly speaking, it works.
It isn't the patriarchy that undermines women, it's other women.

How does it work?

lizzy8230 · 19/11/2023 10:17

@SouthLondonMum22 absolutely.

Missamyp · 19/11/2023 10:12

5128gap · 18/11/2023 10:22

The way I see it, the reason many feminists take issue with the SAHM model is because feminism is not about applauding the choices of individual women who have found a way to make patriarchal systems work in their favour. Feminism is a political movement that centres the interests of women as a class, working to minimise our disadvantage and further our equality. Unfortunately there is no way (that I've found anyway) to squeeze the square peg of the SAHM into that round hole.
Sometimes individual women want to do things to benefit themselves and/or to benefit men that obstruct the progress of women as a class.
But most feminists get this. If you're a woman you understand that living in a world not geared up for you means you navigate it the best you can. You understand that emotional decisions, love for individual men and children, will often be prioritised over political ones, and self interest is most people's primary driver. Most feminists get this and in these discussions should not be attacking individual women for non feminist choices.
The criticism is of the model itself, with some challenge to the thinking that every choice made by a woman must be supported and applauded simply because a woman has made it.

It is important to acknowledge that not all women identify as feminists. For some women, prioritising their marriages and families takes precedence over political beliefs (Feminism) and materialistic values. Achieving true equality, wealth, and power is nothing but a fantasy. It is possible that the world functions the way it does because, honestly speaking, it works.
It isn't the patriarchy that undermines women, it's other women.

SouthLondonMum22 · 19/11/2023 10:12

Singlespies · 19/11/2023 07:10

I don't think women should have to give maternity leave up for fathers. That is not women focussed. It would be better for women to have a properly supported year or more off work.

Also, as you can see on mumsnet, few fathers properly support a household. What I can see happening is fathers staying at home, doing no housework, and the mother coming back home from work to a tip of a house.

I don't think women should have to give up any of their maternity leave either but I do believe it is women focused to have a policy that offers men more than 2 weeks of paternity leave as well as benefiting men and children.

With the current setup, it is very difficult to prevent the woman becoming the default parent, naturally doing more around the house because she is home for up to a year if going back to work and it becomes difficult to move away from that setup once she does go back to work.

With a new setup which offers men anywhere up to 6 months off to take within the first year, it would encourage both parents to be hands on during the first year as well as workplaces now knowing that it is both parents that can now take some time off after the birth of a child which means it would be harder to discriminate against women in the workplace.

It would be beneficial all around including improving equality.

qizz · 19/11/2023 10:11

So many women on here falling over themselves to be 'worthier than thou' or to speak for all women. Just get over it, really. There is no such thing as 'what all women want,' or 'what all women should want.' If you're not maternal, you do you. If you love your job, you do you. If you want to be with your kids, you do you. If you don't want kids, you do you. Just stop labouring under a delusion that you are somehow 'the norm' or you know better. You really don't.

G5000 · 19/11/2023 10:08

Lizzy, see also: working mothers are abandoning their children and barely get to see them. It's just not possible to work and be an involved parent.
-What about your DH with Big Job then, who as you say is way too busy to even help out withone single school run or sick day?
-He's the most amazing involved father!

lizzy8230 · 19/11/2023 10:03

I agree that some level of employment is good on many levels (not just financially) and I believe there's quite a bit of evidence to support that.

The thing that makes me Hmmis the lack of consistency with posters who claim not working is preferable for a mum:

'I'm a SAHM and it's the best thing in the world; I'm so lucky my dh can support me'

'What about your dh? If it's the best thing in the world, doesn't he want a slice of it?'
*
'Oh no, he's far too busy with his Big Job, and he's really really happy working all hours in his Big Job'*

Grin
Boomboom22 · 19/11/2023 10:02

You wouldn't find being of huge use to society, educating children in the subject you love and know very well,very fulfilling. Ok then. I guess you also wouldn't find being a nurse or Dr fulfilling. Or any job that makes a real difference. Social worker?
Maybe you'd prefer to be a banker?

notahappybunny7 · 19/11/2023 09:57

SisterHyster · 19/11/2023 09:34

You obviously don’t know people with fulfilling careers then?

On a basic level, I think every human would like to not have to work, regardless of their gender. But that would only be if they could still have the same income and level of satisfaction. For example, if I was still paid my monthly salary and pension contribution whether I turned up for work or not, no questions asked, I wouldn’t work. But I would still contribute to society in other ways, I’d offer free tutoring (which I can normally charge up to £35/hour for) to people who can’t normally afford tutoring. I’d possibly set up my own business related to this, so I could set my own hours and work as much or little as I wanted.
However, I wouldn’t do any of this without my own income stream.

differ strokes for different folks. You’re a teacher aren’t you? I wouldn’t find that fulfilling at all.

SisterHyster · 19/11/2023 09:45

Boomboom22 · 19/11/2023 08:42

That seems extremely unlikely, are you in a deprived area with jobs like retail and caring not careers?
I think maybe 1 in 10 women I know would give up work completely if they could. Most teachers I know would go pt if they won the lottery, because their job is meaningful to them.
Unless seriously ill I highly doubt most people would want to stop entirely, they might go to 2 or 3 days.

We have a frequent discussion in the staff room as to what we would do if we won the lottery (we are teachers)

Consensus is that we would all go down to two or three days. None of us actually want to quit, despite the fact that we fantasise about quitting most days.

Our team is fairly young (I’d imagine our average age is mid 30s) and fairly evenly split between men and women. Roughly even numbers of people with no kids, people with young kids, and people with grown up kids.

SisterHyster · 19/11/2023 09:37

G5000 · 19/11/2023 09:05

Giving up work when you're independently wealthy is a totally different from giving up work with the hope that another person (who in the vast majority of cases is just living paycheck to paycheck) will support you for the rest of your life.

My perspective is definitely that most people I know who are SAHP are not particularly wealthy, their partners earn a low to average wage, and universal credit funds the rest.
Although they tend to enragingly call themselves “full time mummies” rather that SAHM’s.

SisterHyster · 19/11/2023 09:34

notahappybunny7 · 19/11/2023 08:35

Not really. Most of the women I know would give up work tomorrow if they could.

You obviously don’t know people with fulfilling careers then?

On a basic level, I think every human would like to not have to work, regardless of their gender. But that would only be if they could still have the same income and level of satisfaction. For example, if I was still paid my monthly salary and pension contribution whether I turned up for work or not, no questions asked, I wouldn’t work. But I would still contribute to society in other ways, I’d offer free tutoring (which I can normally charge up to £35/hour for) to people who can’t normally afford tutoring. I’d possibly set up my own business related to this, so I could set my own hours and work as much or little as I wanted.
However, I wouldn’t do any of this without my own income stream.

G5000 · 19/11/2023 09:05

Giving up work when you're independently wealthy is a totally different from giving up work with the hope that another person (who in the vast majority of cases is just living paycheck to paycheck) will support you for the rest of your life.

lizzy8230 · 19/11/2023 09:02

I wasn't asking about you, I was referring to all the women you know and claim want to give up work tomorrow, and wondering if the men you know feel the same

notahappybunny7 · 19/11/2023 08:59

lizzy8230 · 19/11/2023 08:52

@notahappybunny7* *
"Not really. Most of the women I know would give up work tomorrow if they could."

And the men? Do they all want to give up work too? Or are they are totally different species? Grin

Quite frankly if working is that horrendous, it makes sense for both partners in a couple to work part time... at least it shares out the awfulness equally, rather than one partner suffering it full time to facilitate the other doing none of it!

Of course, the other thing is to aim for interesting and stimulating work, which is what I always encouraged my dd and ds' to do. Working is a fact of life, most people will spend a chunk of their adult life doing it so it makes sense to do something that's interesting as well as providing economic independence

My work isn’t horrendous but I wouldn’t do it if I won the lottery no way.
Im a business owner, I have been for 2 decades, I’m very lucky I can work mostly when I want but than I did carve it out to be that way.

lizzy8230 · 19/11/2023 08:52

@notahappybunny7* *
"Not really. Most of the women I know would give up work tomorrow if they could."

And the men? Do they all want to give up work too? Or are they are totally different species? Grin

Quite frankly if working is that horrendous, it makes sense for both partners in a couple to work part time... at least it shares out the awfulness equally, rather than one partner suffering it full time to facilitate the other doing none of it!

Of course, the other thing is to aim for interesting and stimulating work, which is what I always encouraged my dd and ds' to do. Working is a fact of life, most people will spend a chunk of their adult life doing it so it makes sense to do something that's interesting as well as providing economic independence

Starsalign · 19/11/2023 08:52

I mean lots of people, men and women, those with children and those without would love to give up work if they could afford to. I don't think that means most have a burning desire particularly to be a SAHM.

Boomboom22 · 19/11/2023 08:52

It's quite normal for people to value their work, usually linked to years of learning and cpd. I don't recognise this negative idea of work being something you'd just give up asap.

notahappybunny7 · 19/11/2023 08:47

Boomboom22 · 19/11/2023 08:42

That seems extremely unlikely, are you in a deprived area with jobs like retail and caring not careers?
I think maybe 1 in 10 women I know would give up work completely if they could. Most teachers I know would go pt if they won the lottery, because their job is meaningful to them.
Unless seriously ill I highly doubt most people would want to stop entirely, they might go to 2 or 3 days.

No, not deprived at all, just people who’s career isn’t the centre of their lives.

Mirabai · 19/11/2023 08:47

@Boomboom22 That seems extremely unlikely, are you in a deprived area with jobs like retail and caring not careers?

What you really mean is - you must be working class.

Boomboom22 · 19/11/2023 08:42

notahappybunny7 · 19/11/2023 08:35

Not really. Most of the women I know would give up work tomorrow if they could.

That seems extremely unlikely, are you in a deprived area with jobs like retail and caring not careers?
I think maybe 1 in 10 women I know would give up work completely if they could. Most teachers I know would go pt if they won the lottery, because their job is meaningful to them.
Unless seriously ill I highly doubt most people would want to stop entirely, they might go to 2 or 3 days.

lizzy8230 · 19/11/2023 08:40

@Peablockfeathers I agree 100% with that and it was exactly what dh and I did. We both worked and split other stuff between us.

I also think that could be some value in having a certain amount of leave which could only be taken by the father. It wouldn't mean reducing any of the paid leave available to mums, but introducing an element of leave on a use it or lose it basis. I know there is the option of transferable leave now but the take up rate it pitiful - barely any mums transfer some of their leave to the dad. It's a shame - we would definitely have taken advantage of it had it been around in the 1980s. It would be beneficial for the child, and also it would mean dads are far more likely to continue being hands-on if they're had a period of time as sole carer. It seems a big problem nowadays is that mums usually have a long mat leave - up to a year - but dad hasn't had any time as sole carer so when mum returns to work, it becomes the default that she Carries on doing more child and domestic chores.

Dh and I were always determined to share things as much as possible as we both wanted a good balance for ourselves and our dc. But the above suggestion would be helpful for couples where perhaps they're more ambivalent, and could slip into polarised roles by default. You see it a lot on MN; mums several years down the line bemoaning the fact the dad doesn't lift a finger round the house, or doesn't do nursery drop offs because his job is 'too important' etc Sad that in 2023 this persists. Sometimes it takes a new policy or legislation to shift peoples' mindsets and behaviours. Anything which promotes equality and helps to give children the parenting and role models they deserve is a positive thing imo