Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'I do all these things AND work FT'

991 replies

Bumpitybumper · 15/11/2023 15:37

I see this on Mumsnet a lot but have just experienced it in real life. I have two friends (A&B). Friend A is a SAHM to school age kids and Friend B works FT in quite a stressful job. Friend B was just lamenting that they don't understand how Friend A fills her time as she manages to work FT AND do everything Friend A does.

The thing is, Friend B has a much smaller (yet lovely) house that is pretty chaotic in fun energetic way. It is never the tidiest or cleanest but it's not disgusting either. Friend A on the other hand has a much bigger house that is pretty immaculate most of the time. Friend A does all the school runs and volunteers at school. Friend B needs wraparound care in order to get to work so drops her kids of at 8 and collects around 17:30. Friend A cooks amazing meals for her family, has her children's friends round for fun playdates and activities and is generally incredibly on top of everything. Friend B is understandably more stretched and isn't in the position to cook lavish meals every day of the week or have friends round when she's at work. Friend B's husband does a lot (of course absolutely fair and right) so she doesn't have to attend every parents evening, sew all the badges for extracurricular clubs or assist with all the homework etc. Friend A does pretty much all of that as husband works such long hours.

I actually think both are amazing and very productive people that channel their energy, time and talent in different channels. I just struggle to understand though how Friend B can't appreciate that she isn't doing the same as Friend A or at least doing it to the same standard. Before people suggest I'm Friend A, I have my own business so don't really fit in either camp but used to be a SAHM so I guess can see Friend A's efforts more.

AIBU to think that Friend B is a bit deluded?

OP posts:
G5000 · 19/11/2023 17:31

If you're with a man who thinks in terms of 'his money' or who believes in any type of separate finances or who doesn't see the benefits to his children of having their mum more available then obviously, don't be a SAHM.

Also remember that the man you divorce is not the same you married. So many men who made all the right noises and were happy for the woman to save nursery fees and facilitate his career will do a full 180 when they no longer want to be with that woman. Suddenly, when division of assets and support is concerned, the agreements and discussions never happened.

Mummymummy89 · 19/11/2023 17:21

If there were not a power imbalance between men and women, would power imbalances disappear?

This is like imagining what the oceans would be like if water wasn't wet.

Sorry to be facetious. But that power imbalance is the one constant that transcends culture, race, country, era. It was there in the stone ages and the bronze age and with the ancient Egyptians and in dynastic China and it's still here in the UK in 2023 and will remain so.

SouthLondonMum22 · 19/11/2023 17:17

lizzy8230 · 19/11/2023 16:40

@janetjupiter I don't think anyone has disagreed with that. There are upsides and downsides to every scenario and of course people are individuals with different views.

The point though it the inequalities at a structural level which impact on all of us. It's an inequality that mothers' careers, earnings and pensions are affected far more than fathers. It's a structural inequality that it's more socially 'unacceptable' for a father to go part time or jack his career in than for a mother.

That's the real debate here. And many of us strive for a society which works to overcome these inequalities

That's it.

It all comes back to micro vs macro level. I don't care what people do at a micro level but I do care about the impact some of those choices have on all of us at a macro level which includes things such as the gender pay gap and the double standards we see when it comes to expectations of mothers and fathers as well as many other things that enable our unequal society.

Walkaround · 19/11/2023 17:14

If there were not a power imbalance between men and women, would power imbalances disappear? Would those being paid to help provide otherwise unmet care and domestic needs have more power than they currently do if both sexes did them equally, or would these services always attract low levels of pay and power? If the latter, are we happy that the quality of the care and domestic services offered would be adequate for all, or would there be insufficient numbers of people attracted to doing them, due to the abuse of power, low pay and low prestige they would be subject to if they actively chose to do them? Or would there be plenty of desperate people queueing up to do it, however badly, because any scrap is better than nothing?

Is domestic and caring work more appealing if done for your own loved ones, or if done for strangers? How do we guarantee the level of care we all want for those we love if we are not able to provide it ourselves and not able to pay much for others to provide it either?

janetjupiter · 19/11/2023 16:55

Yes of course. Personally, I'm all for equality of opportunity, but I am uncomfortable when people try to dictate equality of 'outcome' - ie. dictate how other couples in society should relate to each other or how they should organise themselves in their personal spheres. Some (many) couples will always prefer to have different focuses and different roles and this is absolutely fine. If people can't relate to that, it's their issue. They don't have to relate and they can live how they want.

lizzy8230 · 19/11/2023 16:40

@janetjupiter I don't think anyone has disagreed with that. There are upsides and downsides to every scenario and of course people are individuals with different views.

The point though it the inequalities at a structural level which impact on all of us. It's an inequality that mothers' careers, earnings and pensions are affected far more than fathers. It's a structural inequality that it's more socially 'unacceptable' for a father to go part time or jack his career in than for a mother.

That's the real debate here. And many of us strive for a society which works to overcome these inequalities

janetjupiter · 19/11/2023 16:30

Everything involves compromise though. If you SAH, you miss out on the benefits of working. The more you work, you miss out on time with children - this goes for men too. But people are all different and one persons' compromise is another persons ideal.

I don't think a society in which two parents both working and only spending evenings and weekends with their children is necessarily more 'enlightened.' It depends what people actually want, what makes them happier and what they value. For some, two parents working full time is a necessity. For some it's preferable. For some it's a less than ideal way to live. Again, it depends. One person's 'enlightened ideal' would be another person's nightmare.

SouthLondonMum22 · 19/11/2023 16:23

lizzy8230 · 19/11/2023 16:13

I read @SouthLondonMum22's post more as a general point of the power imbalance between the sexes. There is a power imbalance in society which is reflected in many ways:

  • men earning more than women
-women's careers being impacted more than men's if they have kids -women taking on more domestic/ caring/mental load by default -women having far less financial security in older age

Of course at a micro level there will be exceptions to the rule: the woman who out earns her husband. The dad who does the lion's share of nursery pick ups and domestic work. Etc.

But at a macro level it absolutely cannot be denied that there are inequalities which isn't good for anyone imo: not for women, mothers or the children we're raising to become the adults in a hopefully more enlightened society.

Exactly.

Well said.

lizzy8230 · 19/11/2023 16:13

I read @SouthLondonMum22's post more as a general point of the power imbalance between the sexes. There is a power imbalance in society which is reflected in many ways:

  • men earning more than women
-women's careers being impacted more than men's if they have kids -women taking on more domestic/ caring/mental load by default -women having far less financial security in older age

Of course at a micro level there will be exceptions to the rule: the woman who out earns her husband. The dad who does the lion's share of nursery pick ups and domestic work. Etc.

But at a macro level it absolutely cannot be denied that there are inequalities which isn't good for anyone imo: not for women, mothers or the children we're raising to become the adults in a hopefully more enlightened society.

janetjupiter · 19/11/2023 15:30

I can understand why you might think it would be a power imbalance and, in many cases it would be. In many other cases though, it really is not.

If you're with a man who thinks in terms of 'his money' or who believes in any type of separate finances or who doesn't see the benefits to his children of having their mum more available then obviously, don't be a SAHM.

SouthLondonMum22 · 19/11/2023 15:23

janetjupiter · 19/11/2023 14:59

I don't think it's so much 'allow' it as 'prefer' it because in some circumstances, everyone benefits. It really is dependent on so many individual factors.

The point is though that if they don’t prefer it then ultimately he will have the final say because he is the one providing the money.

It’s a power imbalance.

SouthLondonMum22 · 19/11/2023 15:20

janetjupiter · 19/11/2023 14:43

'Risk' is obviously relative though. If you are couple who invest together, or have various income streams, joint investments, etc, this makes SAHP much more viable. For many people, SAHP is not a viable choice these days because families need two incomes to survive. But that's not to say there aren't many ways to mitigate against 'risk' if you are fortunate enough to have a choice and SAHP is something you feel happier doing overall.

Of course but I’d say that those situations are exceptions. Generally, it means the SAHM is financially vulnerable.

The majority of time when there’s a thread about a woman trapped in a relationship she can’t afford to leave, she’s a SAHM.

TheHoover · 19/11/2023 15:04

I am convinced that the OP is not real and is instead an allegory of the lamentable prevalence of women scorning one another for their choice of either staying at home to look after children or choosing to continue their career.
There is no friend A or friend B.

janetjupiter · 19/11/2023 14:59

I don't think it's so much 'allow' it as 'prefer' it because in some circumstances, everyone benefits. It really is dependent on so many individual factors.

5128gap · 19/11/2023 14:53

Mirabai · 19/11/2023 14:28

Many working women do a chunk of SAHPing when the kids are small - I don’t recognise that as being limited to a “tiny minority” and certainly not “independently” wealthy.

I didn't say a tiny minority of women spend some time as a SAHP. I said that a tiny minority will be able to do so because its their choice. The choice belongs to the person agreeing to fund them to SAH.
People have talked about the 'main thing' being women having the right to choose. I'm saying that in the absence of state funding to SAH, only the independently wealthy really get that choice. The others are reliant on their partner choosing to allow it.

janetjupiter · 19/11/2023 14:43

'Risk' is obviously relative though. If you are couple who invest together, or have various income streams, joint investments, etc, this makes SAHP much more viable. For many people, SAHP is not a viable choice these days because families need two incomes to survive. But that's not to say there aren't many ways to mitigate against 'risk' if you are fortunate enough to have a choice and SAHP is something you feel happier doing overall.

lizzy8230 · 19/11/2023 14:42

@Mirabai stress comes in all sorts of forms. Being busy doesn't necessarily equate with stress. Of course, having too many demands on one's time can be a cause of stress, but so can lots of other things, such as feeling isolated or money worries

SouthLondonMum22 · 19/11/2023 14:34

Mememe9898 · 19/11/2023 13:59

It’s not mutually exclusive. You can depend on your partner whilst the kids are young but still have savings if s* hit the fan and also keep your skills so you could find work.
If someone prefers to look after their kids than going to work and prepared to make that sacrifice it doesn’t make prioritising working better.

It involves depending on someone else financially which naturally comes with risks. Even if it’s just whilst the kids are young, that’s why I wouldn’t consider it the ‘lucky’ option or a ‘blessing’.

Mirabai · 19/11/2023 14:28

5128gap · 19/11/2023 14:22

Other than a tiny minority of independently wealthy people, no one really has the privilege of that choice. The choice to allow an adult to live without an income is a choice of the person financially supporting them. However much its couched in 'we' language, however much in times of cordiality its framed as a joint decision between equal partners, the wage earner really gets to decide as just as they give they may take away, as the fancy takes them.
The only way women would have a choice is through state funding to be a SAHP, which i inagine very few people would support.

Many working women do a chunk of SAHPing when the kids are small - I don’t recognise that as being limited to a “tiny minority” and certainly not “independently” wealthy.

5128gap · 19/11/2023 14:22

Mememe9898 · 19/11/2023 14:06

If I wanted to look after my kids full time instead of working I’d do it in a heartbeat. The problem is too many women are trying to make SAHM feel bad for their choices.
I’m a full time working mum and can totally see the benefit in both lifestyles. The privilege comes from having choices which some people don’t and have to work regardless. Im sure that a lot of parents not just moms but dads too would quit work if they could maintain their levels of income.

Other than a tiny minority of independently wealthy people, no one really has the privilege of that choice. The choice to allow an adult to live without an income is a choice of the person financially supporting them. However much its couched in 'we' language, however much in times of cordiality its framed as a joint decision between equal partners, the wage earner really gets to decide as just as they give they may take away, as the fancy takes them.
The only way women would have a choice is through state funding to be a SAHP, which i inagine very few people would support.

Mirabai · 19/11/2023 14:20

TheKeatingFive · 19/11/2023 12:19

Depends on the level and type of job, and circumstances, but a lot of people do and put a brave face on it.

I'm not sure you can speak for 'a lot of people' here. Speak for yourself.

There are different levels of stress tolerance out there. We manage our household pretty well and I can't say we'd welcome less stress overall. Both DH love our jobs and the hustle that goes with them. We have a brilliant after school and the kids adore that. Our income means we have bandwidth to cut stress in other ways

I’m not actually in that situation, I’m just observing what I see around me and online.

If you wouldn’t “welcome” less stress there seem to be plenty of people who would.

SisterHyster · 19/11/2023 14:15

janetjupiter · 19/11/2023 13:19

It's not 'for some reason' 😆- these repetitive threads with the whole WOHM / SAHM are tedious because it's just defensive, anecdotal mud-slinging both ways. As I said, it goes nowhere and bears no relevance to actual reality. But some people love to engage in this to and fro ad infinitum - only they know why.

Edited

And yet here you are, engaging in the to-and-fro. Irony.

Mirabai · 19/11/2023 14:14

SisterHyster · 19/11/2023 12:03

It depends. Being dual income means we can afford to pay people to do a lot of the tasks we would have to do ourselves if we had a SAHP. I find housework utterly boring and quite stressful tbh, it’s nice to know I don’t really have to do much of it. Same with cooking - we eat out a lot because it’s a nice family experience and everyone can eat whatever they like: whereas at home it’s someone stuck in the kitchen cooking and then cleaning up, whilst the other person single handedly manages the kids.

Which is why I said it depends on the level and type of job.

Two people in finance who can afford FT nanny, cleaners, eating out, even a housekeeper, staff in other words to cover a SAHP’s tasks, are fine.

But the reality for many couples is that FT work involves covering domestic work in the evenings and the weekends.

lizzy8230 · 19/11/2023 14:07

@SouthLondonMum22 agree.

This is a public forum so unfortunately there'll always be a few crack pot or goady posts but that shouldn't detract from the hugely important issue of gender equalities of opportunity and the societal constructs which work against that.

Mememe9898 · 19/11/2023 14:06

If I wanted to look after my kids full time instead of working I’d do it in a heartbeat. The problem is too many women are trying to make SAHM feel bad for their choices.
I’m a full time working mum and can totally see the benefit in both lifestyles. The privilege comes from having choices which some people don’t and have to work regardless. Im sure that a lot of parents not just moms but dads too would quit work if they could maintain their levels of income.

Swipe left for the next trending thread