Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'I do all these things AND work FT'

991 replies

Bumpitybumper · 15/11/2023 15:37

I see this on Mumsnet a lot but have just experienced it in real life. I have two friends (A&B). Friend A is a SAHM to school age kids and Friend B works FT in quite a stressful job. Friend B was just lamenting that they don't understand how Friend A fills her time as she manages to work FT AND do everything Friend A does.

The thing is, Friend B has a much smaller (yet lovely) house that is pretty chaotic in fun energetic way. It is never the tidiest or cleanest but it's not disgusting either. Friend A on the other hand has a much bigger house that is pretty immaculate most of the time. Friend A does all the school runs and volunteers at school. Friend B needs wraparound care in order to get to work so drops her kids of at 8 and collects around 17:30. Friend A cooks amazing meals for her family, has her children's friends round for fun playdates and activities and is generally incredibly on top of everything. Friend B is understandably more stretched and isn't in the position to cook lavish meals every day of the week or have friends round when she's at work. Friend B's husband does a lot (of course absolutely fair and right) so she doesn't have to attend every parents evening, sew all the badges for extracurricular clubs or assist with all the homework etc. Friend A does pretty much all of that as husband works such long hours.

I actually think both are amazing and very productive people that channel their energy, time and talent in different channels. I just struggle to understand though how Friend B can't appreciate that she isn't doing the same as Friend A or at least doing it to the same standard. Before people suggest I'm Friend A, I have my own business so don't really fit in either camp but used to be a SAHM so I guess can see Friend A's efforts more.

AIBU to think that Friend B is a bit deluded?

OP posts:
lizzy8230 · 16/11/2023 07:01

Also, every good parent I know absolutely prioritises their children - they come first, whether the parent works or not. I love my job- it's stimulating and rewarding and pays me a good income and pension - but hell, of course my children are the most important thing. No compromise there.

Of course, if you're bad parents, you're bad parents whether one, both or neither of you has a job, hardly rocket science.

Beezknees · 16/11/2023 06:58

MightyMinestrone · 16/11/2023 03:42

@Alana1983 No normal woman would be 'banging the drum' to her daughters about being a stay at home mother specifically in that guilt tripping tone you're describing - that's just your own prejudices talking.

The pressure on women is actually overwhelmingly the other way, so it's good their daughters would be hearing conversations to provide at least a little balance against the current societal propaganda in the West which is trying to devalue motherhood and give the impression women are only worthy if they're in the workforce (which is complete rubbish; there's arguably nothing more important than forming the next generation).

I've been working all my adult life in a field I need a high degree of education for, and currently still am in the workforce, but I'm not of more value than a mother forming the next generation who stays at home to do so. And who cares if they choose never to return to the workforce, this was the norm for many women for many generations and is still the norm now in many other countries/cultures.

My experience of having a working mother made me realise that I wouldn't want the same for my own children. I would want to stay at home to look after my kids, I'd be proud to do so, and I couldn't care less what anyone else thinks.

I've had my time already to happily prioritise my education and career which I've enjoyed and I want to spend the next stage of my life prioritising my children instead. I won't be brainwashed into thinking i have to "do it all" at the same time and i'd be encouraging any future daughter to put her and her family's wellbeing first and not empty societal mantras.

There's not enough hours in the day for anyone, whether you're a man or woman, to properly do it all, something or someone is always compromised, and I don't want that to be precious time with my kids while they're young. 🙂

As more and more women burn out trying to "do it all at the same time" and realise it's not ultimaely worth it, I expect the tide in time will actually swing back to more traditional gender roles in future generations down the line.

I don't think the tide will turn to that honestly. I think more people will just not bother having kids. It's already happening.

lizzy8230 · 16/11/2023 06:37

@Wonderously exactly.

I really don't get why a minority of women see this issue in such a binary way, as a woman is only a SAHM if they don't like/ can't cope with working, or is only a WOHM if they couldn't cope with being at home.

Personally I've always worked, as has dh, and it's been great and we've raised our children into wonderful adults. I never found being at home with the children while on maternity leaves a chore or boring (can't say I'm so keen on housework or sewing on badges but hey Grin) I'm sure our kids would be equally fine if I or dh had stayed home too. But we both had good jobs, we were both equally skilled both in and out of the home and wanted to both do both!

Wonderously · 16/11/2023 06:15

One is not better then the other. They are just different.

Wonderously · 16/11/2023 06:13

i think it would be very easy to fill time as a SAHP, she’s only really free 9.10 to 3pm so cleaning, shopping, food prep, gardening, exercise, errands, seeing friends for socials, helping school or PTA.

I'm c (work part time) but can see that both are equally valid life style choices. It potentially boils down to different interests, stamina, resilience, values, cleanliness/tidiness levels,

1AngelicFruitCake · 16/11/2023 05:55

Slightly off the topic but I know of many Mums doing a B job and striving to be A (myself included!) and maybe not getting there but doing a great job of trying to achieve it!

Ive got a friend who is A and they are lovely but tell be how tired they are whenever they see me! I grit my teeth because no matter how tired I am, I’m also working a very busy day!

Maybe B is being unreasonable and not appreciating A and the effort she goes to but the effort required to be B is a lot! It’s exhausting!

meatbaseddessert · 16/11/2023 05:51

In with friend B. Friend A 'work' sounds like busy work to me where she can personally affirm her reason for being and polish her perfect parent halo.

Who gives a toss if a kids badges are sewed on by hand by a mother with shiny hair and a serene look clad in a perfectly pressed frock over two hours or wonderwebbed in 10 seconds by a mother in her pants and bra in between ironing a work shirt. I know who is making best use of their time.

Or indeed it's delegated to another functional member of the household. When I was a Brownie I was expected to sew the fuckers on myself.

lizzy8230 · 16/11/2023 05:28

@MightyMinestrone fabulous that you found what works for you Smile

We're not all the same though. Many of us don't feel that we're 'superior' or 'naturally better' at being at home than our partners are, not that they are 'better' at having a career and earning. We like to raise our children while also working.

Ultimately what matters is raising children into happy, well adjusted, successful adults. I can't see anyone disagreeing with that! My 'babies' are now adults with their own partners, working lives and their own families. They're fabulous people and I'm proud that dh and I have raised them. And yes, we've both always been WOHP. No doubt our kids would also have grown into happy successful adults if dh or I hadn't worked too! It's not a case of one thing - either WOH or SAH being 'better' than the other!

RantyAnty · 16/11/2023 04:37

No man would ever be competitive about these things or say them, but they're all to happy to sit back and laugh at the women doing backflips for him while he does exactly what he wants to do.

MightyMinestrone · 16/11/2023 03:42

Alana1983 · 15/11/2023 22:21

It's not about what the daughters want, that wasn't my question. It was more about what the mothers who choose to SAH want for their own daughters and grandchildren?

i accept its rare and I'm not talking about people who take a career break - I'm talk of about people who have children and never return to work and specifically those that bang the drum loudly about what that means for them, the career they could have had and would have had but they chose instead to raise children - these conversations are occurring in front of daughters and I wonder what pressure that might add when that same daughter is making her choices as a mother in a few years?

@Alana1983 No normal woman would be 'banging the drum' to her daughters about being a stay at home mother specifically in that guilt tripping tone you're describing - that's just your own prejudices talking.

The pressure on women is actually overwhelmingly the other way, so it's good their daughters would be hearing conversations to provide at least a little balance against the current societal propaganda in the West which is trying to devalue motherhood and give the impression women are only worthy if they're in the workforce (which is complete rubbish; there's arguably nothing more important than forming the next generation).

I've been working all my adult life in a field I need a high degree of education for, and currently still am in the workforce, but I'm not of more value than a mother forming the next generation who stays at home to do so. And who cares if they choose never to return to the workforce, this was the norm for many women for many generations and is still the norm now in many other countries/cultures.

My experience of having a working mother made me realise that I wouldn't want the same for my own children. I would want to stay at home to look after my kids, I'd be proud to do so, and I couldn't care less what anyone else thinks.

I've had my time already to happily prioritise my education and career which I've enjoyed and I want to spend the next stage of my life prioritising my children instead. I won't be brainwashed into thinking i have to "do it all" at the same time and i'd be encouraging any future daughter to put her and her family's wellbeing first and not empty societal mantras.

There's not enough hours in the day for anyone, whether you're a man or woman, to properly do it all, something or someone is always compromised, and I don't want that to be precious time with my kids while they're young. 🙂

As more and more women burn out trying to "do it all at the same time" and realise it's not ultimaely worth it, I expect the tide in time will actually swing back to more traditional gender roles in future generations down the line.

TheKeatingFive · 16/11/2023 03:33

B's house just simply isn't that clean or tidy. Nothing crazy, but normal household mess and things like the oven could do with a good clean and the shower screen could do with a bit of a scrub

But who cares about this really?

I can understand why B would think that areas where she is 'falling short' of A's performance are not of much importance in the overall scheme of things.

Bumpitybumper · 16/11/2023 03:20

notreallyme2023 · 15/11/2023 22:25

OP you are very over invested in both A and B's life

You said A hasn't said anything negative about A despite your first post and are very insistent B should "acknowledge" A does more. Both fees there children. Why does A need extra acknowledgement because her meals are so lavish

You seem to worship A in your posts. Both fa.iles function differently why do you need B to acknowledge it if she has never said anything negative

B saying that she does all that A does and work FT is negative in my view. She isn't saying that they both focus their time and energy on different things or that the families function differently, she is saying she is capable of doing exactly the same as A in much less time. My point is that she isn't doing the exact same and I feel that it's undermining and insulting to A to suggest that she is. It implies B is somehow super human and capable of doing everything twice as quickly as A or that A is lazy or incapable. Neither is true.

I admire both A and B to be honest. The nature of this thread means I have found myself listing all the great things that A does that B doesn't, but B is absolutely amazing too. She is fantastic at her job, makes a real difference with her work and is a great mum. Her children are happy and healthy and she has a lovely home. As I find myself working more, my respect for B grows as I see that she is balancing things brilliantly and that part of this is understanding you can't do it all and you don't necessarily need to either. That's why it's strange that although she is xeemingly really good at prioritising and letting the right things slide, she doesn't seem to acknowledge that this is what she has done and there will be some stuff that just doesn't get done as a result of this. I differ from her as I obviously can't do it all either but I am often acutely aware of what has been dropped in order to facilitate me doing other stuff.

OP posts:
Meandermoanda · 16/11/2023 01:28

Honeychickpea · 16/11/2023 01:06

You forgot about the bullshit bit where they "gave up their career to facilitate their husbands career".

This is not me by a long mile but in some circumstances free childcare to let the other half work honestly can't be underestimated. I've seen it happen a lot'

Meandermoanda · 16/11/2023 01:25

This division annoys me so much

I encountered it first of all when my child started school five years ago. I have always worked from home because I am successful in my career. Because of this I was able to move to a nice village

I got so many digs and comments about how they work and their lives are hard

They had no idea I work till midnight to pick kids up from school

Their cognitive dissonance couldn't realise that the fact their job allowed them to do pick up meant others worked too

It still happens

I just don't care any more the one who accused me most let her mum pat for her kid to go to private school

Honeychickpea · 16/11/2023 01:06

Alana1983 · 15/11/2023 22:21

It's not about what the daughters want, that wasn't my question. It was more about what the mothers who choose to SAH want for their own daughters and grandchildren?

i accept its rare and I'm not talking about people who take a career break - I'm talk of about people who have children and never return to work and specifically those that bang the drum loudly about what that means for them, the career they could have had and would have had but they chose instead to raise children - these conversations are occurring in front of daughters and I wonder what pressure that might add when that same daughter is making her choices as a mother in a few years?

You forgot about the bullshit bit where they "gave up their career to facilitate their husbands career".

Honeychickpea · 16/11/2023 01:00

Lelophants · 15/11/2023 19:06

In all honestly I’ve never known a sahm to be nasty about working mums. Theyre more admiring of them if anything and have their own reasons for doing what they do (often never had the best career, low self esteem etc). Yet it’s the working mums who like to take up time being incredibly nasty about them.

I have known that situation. It's usually because the SAHM is terrified that her husband will choose a working co-worker over her. She needs to try to convince herself that she, as SAHM, is so much better.

Honeychickpea · 16/11/2023 00:55

WineAndFireside · 15/11/2023 16:41

Because she has plenty of time and money. She has no boss. She has a large, immaculate home. She can have coffee in bed after the school run. She can manage her chores and errands and school admin without feeling like she's drowning. She probably has plenty of energy left over for her kids. She doesnt have to worry about childcare issues. Maybe she feels less torn and less guilty. Maybe she's delighted to be out of the rat race. She probably has time for hobbies. God, so many reasons!

She also has a husband that could leave at any moment, and her situation might be rather precarious.

Walkaround · 15/11/2023 23:58

Mummymummy89 · 15/11/2023 23:12

So many of op's examples aren't parenting. Bake sales, being on the PTA - these are school community busywork, not parenting.

If you're on the PTA, that's not for your specific child's benefit. If we did a straw poll of kids with parents on the PTA vs kids whose parents are not on the PTA, you wouldn't see better happiness levels, academic results, whatever.

Similarly, having an "immaculate" home vs an acceptably clean and tidy-ish home: again, you will not find a demonstrable improvement in children's well-being, academic results or other attributes from living in an immaculate home. Some might even argue it's more likely the other way.

So doing those things does not mean "parenting to a higher standard". It just means doing stuff, useful stuff sure, but it's not parenting.

So yes, B does all the parenting A does plus works full time. Friend A fills the rest of her time with other activities that she chooses to do: useful and meaningful ones, maybe, but not directly parenting (not least because her kids are at school most of the day...!)

The OP never said parent A spent more time parenting, though, that’s just lots of people with weird chips on their shoulders interpreting it all as examples of parenting, rather than just descriptions of what parent A is doing with their time and why it is taking them longer than it takes B. To pretend that different people do not have different standards for housework or cooking or voluntary work is just ridiculous - of course we all have different standards for these things and spend different amounts of time on them, and if, for example, we were paying someone to clean our houses, we would definitely notice if their standards did not live up to our expectations, so it is deliberately demeaning not to notice standards when something is done for free.

When it comes to parenting, you simply cannot grade parenting by a set of standards, as parenting is something experienced as a whole, not a sum of parts. It is not the OP who made the mistake of trying to turn parenting into a list of chores, it was just some of the people responding to her who did that.

anonimoxyz · 15/11/2023 23:20

OP are you actually friend A and upset that friend B said what they did?

Mummymummy89 · 15/11/2023 23:12

So many of op's examples aren't parenting. Bake sales, being on the PTA - these are school community busywork, not parenting.

If you're on the PTA, that's not for your specific child's benefit. If we did a straw poll of kids with parents on the PTA vs kids whose parents are not on the PTA, you wouldn't see better happiness levels, academic results, whatever.

Similarly, having an "immaculate" home vs an acceptably clean and tidy-ish home: again, you will not find a demonstrable improvement in children's well-being, academic results or other attributes from living in an immaculate home. Some might even argue it's more likely the other way.

So doing those things does not mean "parenting to a higher standard". It just means doing stuff, useful stuff sure, but it's not parenting.

So yes, B does all the parenting A does plus works full time. Friend A fills the rest of her time with other activities that she chooses to do: useful and meaningful ones, maybe, but not directly parenting (not least because her kids are at school most of the day...!)

CocoC · 15/11/2023 23:10

Friend B must see it as she does the 80% 'that matter', as well as a FT job. So she does '180%'.
There is an additional 20% that friend A does which is very time consuming but not critical (eg the fetes etc).
I am friend B and I think I match friend A on certain things which I think are priorities (eg the children's clubs and sports), but totally don't compete on things I think are less important (volunteering and tidy house at all times). That is probably what B means.

Walkaround · 15/11/2023 23:09

SisterHyster · 15/11/2023 22:38

Well, childless couples are happier than couples with children, and have happier marriages, soooo … maybe we should be.

And let’s not twist things. Do you really believe that parents (specifically mothers, since nobody has a problem with “working dads”) working is responsible for poor mental or physical health in children? No, it isn’t. Social media, sedentary lifestyles, pollution rates, and a million other factors are at play here. Correlation does not equal causation (and actually, with specific reference to mental health, I’m not sure it even is worse - I think that it’s just discussed more)

No, I don’t believe mothers working is responsible. I do think threads like this demonstrate a lot of the problems, though - there are far too many patently stressed and unhappy people in the world wasting time publicly passing judgement on the lives of others as a means of trying to feel better about themselves and their own lives. There are far too many people who interpret pretty much any comment anyone makes as a personal criticism of their own choices and instantly go on the attack about it. These are not the behaviours of people who are actually happy with their lot, they are the behaviours of people who feel under permanent attack and chronic stress. As for sedentary lifestyles, pollution, etc - that is the upbringing we are giving our children, it didn’t happen to us, we all contributed to it, yet we are still focusing on who does or does not do paid work, as though this is the most important question and everything else would be solved if everyone did paid work.

Yesyoucant · 15/11/2023 23:03

Bumpitybumper · 15/11/2023 19:47

I think my analogies have been unhelpful so I'll be more direct.

B simply does not do what A does and a lot of what A does is driven by her own high standards.

A's house is very clean and tidy, imagine a show home with some kids stuff and that is pretty much her house. B's house just simply isn't that clean or tidy. Nothing crazy, but normal household mess and things like the oven could do with a good clean and the shower screen could do with a bit of a scrub. Objectively the houses aren't cleaned to the same standard. The cars are the same as is the garden. Meals are more elaborate at A's house whereas B does a mix of basic cooking from scratch and some convenience foods. A sits with their child to listen to them read whilst B listens to their child whilst dashing around doing other stuff. I know this sounds like I'm putting B down, but honestly I find myself doing many of the same things because there simply aren't enough hours in the day.

A has the children until 8:30 and collects them again at 3. B drops off the children earlier and collects them much later. This isn't a standards thing but just a fact that B isn't looking after her children for the same amount of time. A probably has the children for around 4 hours a day more during a school day and obviously a lot more than that in the school holidays when B has to rely on clubs. Again, B simply isn't doing what A does.

B combined with her husband manage to get most things done but I think the husband is a red herring. B was saying that SHE did everything that A did, not that B and her husband achieved this together. A's husband is away a lot and works very long hours so she can't rely on him to contribute in the same way.

Won't someone think of the manky shower screens!

SisterHyster · 15/11/2023 22:56

Juni11 · 15/11/2023 22:40

@SisterHyster I agree. I guess my view is there are different types of SAHP - the ones who chose/need to not work but do lots of community orientated duties which many (not all) working mums don’t have time to do. Then there are the ones who complain that they have been so busy whilst doing all the same things as someone working 40 hours/week. I guess I view it as a privilege for parents to be able to get their parenting/house ‘jobs’ done in the day and actually sit down or be able to get to bed before 10pm. Or to go to the gym or food shop in the day, or maintain an ultra tidy home etc.

Yeah, as the higher earner (40% tax payer) it’s always made sense for me to work. I cook a proper meal for my kids every day, they are with a parent or in education almost 24/7 (grandparents take them out for a few hours at the weekend, but not as childcare) my house is clean (I’d argue cleaner than most - but it’s not me who cleans it!) and in terms of my kids experience, I can’t see any negatives to them having a dual income household. I do see a lot of positives though - such as having money to do what we like at the weekend with little thought of budget, and also the expectation that both of them will also contribute financially as adults. I’d be really concerned if either of them became a SAHP.

Cupcakekiller · 15/11/2023 22:55

It's not about providing children with an A* service, it's about the outcome and how the children feel. Can you raise happy, healthy well rounded children with a FT working mother? Of course you can. That's what's important, not how immaculate the house in or how many hours you spend in your children's company.