Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'I do all these things AND work FT'

991 replies

Bumpitybumper · 15/11/2023 15:37

I see this on Mumsnet a lot but have just experienced it in real life. I have two friends (A&B). Friend A is a SAHM to school age kids and Friend B works FT in quite a stressful job. Friend B was just lamenting that they don't understand how Friend A fills her time as she manages to work FT AND do everything Friend A does.

The thing is, Friend B has a much smaller (yet lovely) house that is pretty chaotic in fun energetic way. It is never the tidiest or cleanest but it's not disgusting either. Friend A on the other hand has a much bigger house that is pretty immaculate most of the time. Friend A does all the school runs and volunteers at school. Friend B needs wraparound care in order to get to work so drops her kids of at 8 and collects around 17:30. Friend A cooks amazing meals for her family, has her children's friends round for fun playdates and activities and is generally incredibly on top of everything. Friend B is understandably more stretched and isn't in the position to cook lavish meals every day of the week or have friends round when she's at work. Friend B's husband does a lot (of course absolutely fair and right) so she doesn't have to attend every parents evening, sew all the badges for extracurricular clubs or assist with all the homework etc. Friend A does pretty much all of that as husband works such long hours.

I actually think both are amazing and very productive people that channel their energy, time and talent in different channels. I just struggle to understand though how Friend B can't appreciate that she isn't doing the same as Friend A or at least doing it to the same standard. Before people suggest I'm Friend A, I have my own business so don't really fit in either camp but used to be a SAHM so I guess can see Friend A's efforts more.

AIBU to think that Friend B is a bit deluded?

OP posts:
Cinty6 · 16/11/2023 11:00

Boomboom22 · 16/11/2023 10:52

As a teacher, I qualified through having my first 2 18 months apart. Never had a problem. Worked pt then ft left just after the kids worked in the evening. Nursery was great. 3rd went back, by this time at another school ft, again no problems. Then my current school, 0.8 choose my frees so can do pick up etc, been promoted, never had an issue taking a day if kids are ill. Yes some men make out it's impossible but more like they never tried, asked or planned in the flexibility.

It sounds like you work in a great school that’s supportive of parents. I’m genuinely happy for you. It’s great when this happens. Among the friends I trained with, many of us have worked in schools that would never entertain choosing free periods or doing nice things like letting a parent go to see a school play during the working day. Indeed, in an academy, I am contracted until 5 and there’s not a chance I could miss the training and meetings that take place after school to pick my kids up.

SouthLondonMum22 · 16/11/2023 10:54

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2023 10:47

@Bumpitybumper

I think you are reading something into this paragraph that hasn't been written. I was writing the post in response to someone suggesting that the family didn't necessarily benefit from what A does. As A's DH desperately wants to maintain his career, then of course he is a direct beneficiary of her facilitating this. Whether the situation is right or equitable is a completely different question.

I get that and obviously yes the role that A plays undeniably makes life easier for the broader family. (Although I question the degree to which the children specifically benefit from having a SAHM as opposed to a working mum. It's a topic for another thread).

But I just find it so frustrating, as a woman who is forced to work, that these Big Job men invariably have a "facilitator" at home. It's not the job of women to facilitate other women in their careers and a SAHM should be a SAHM if she wants to. But it's hard to get across to people how hugely this setup disadvantages working mums like me. It makes our lives ten times harder at every step that we are constantly competing with "facilitated" men who basically never have to worry about anything other than their jobs.

But I just find it so frustrating, as a woman who is forced to work, that these Big Job men invariably have a "facilitator" at home. It's not the job of women to facilitate other women in their careers and a SAHM should be a SAHM if she wants to. But it's hard to get across to people how hugely this setup disadvantages working mums like me. It makes our lives ten times harder at every step that we are constantly competing with "facilitated" men who basically never have to worry about anything other than their jobs.

I work by choice and I find it incredibly frustrating too. But you know, we have to put up and shut up because raising it means we aren't supporting other women with their choices. 🙄

It could at least be acknowledged that whilst it may be beneficial to the Indvidual family, it certainly isn't beneficial to equality within society or women who want or need to work.

Boomboom22 · 16/11/2023 10:52

As a teacher, I qualified through having my first 2 18 months apart. Never had a problem. Worked pt then ft left just after the kids worked in the evening. Nursery was great. 3rd went back, by this time at another school ft, again no problems. Then my current school, 0.8 choose my frees so can do pick up etc, been promoted, never had an issue taking a day if kids are ill. Yes some men make out it's impossible but more like they never tried, asked or planned in the flexibility.

Cinty6 · 16/11/2023 10:48

Bumpitybumper · 16/11/2023 10:44

Call BS all you like, this is the reality of his career. It won't move on from the 1950s whilst there are lots of childfree people willing to do what's required and desperate to fill his shoes.

There are actually quite a lot of roles that are difficult to manage with a family. My friend (not A or B) is an air stewardess and would not be able to do her job without her DH working for himself and being able to dictate his own hours. My other friend works for a maintenance firm and has to be on call one week out of four. These calls can be at anytime of day or night and it is expected that you just drop everything and go in. They ended moving the grandparents closer as they couldn't maintain both careers and family life when one of them basically couldn't be relied upon for a large chunk of each month.

Teaching can be too. Not always if you work in a school with sensible expectations and their priorities in the right order: teaching great lessons instead of pissing about with paperwork with zero impact on outcomes. But they’re increasingly rare.

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2023 10:47

@Bumpitybumper

I think you are reading something into this paragraph that hasn't been written. I was writing the post in response to someone suggesting that the family didn't necessarily benefit from what A does. As A's DH desperately wants to maintain his career, then of course he is a direct beneficiary of her facilitating this. Whether the situation is right or equitable is a completely different question.

I get that and obviously yes the role that A plays undeniably makes life easier for the broader family. (Although I question the degree to which the children specifically benefit from having a SAHM as opposed to a working mum. It's a topic for another thread).

But I just find it so frustrating, as a woman who is forced to work, that these Big Job men invariably have a "facilitator" at home. It's not the job of women to facilitate other women in their careers and a SAHM should be a SAHM if she wants to. But it's hard to get across to people how hugely this setup disadvantages working mums like me. It makes our lives ten times harder at every step that we are constantly competing with "facilitated" men who basically never have to worry about anything other than their jobs.

SeethroughDress · 16/11/2023 10:46

Boomboom22 · 16/11/2023 10:32

I'd bet thousands all the senior women manage to parent perfectly well. Outsourcing cleaning etc of course.

They do. I know senior academics, medical consultants, surgeons, architects, curators, who all manage to mother their children perfectly adequately.

Honestly, only a certain type of person thinks that sewing on Scout badges or doing your own cleaning is morally superior to the alternatives. Sure, living in a reasonably clean house is a good thing, but it matters not a jot how that is achieved, assuming you pay a cleaner fairly if you employ one.

Happilyobtuse · 16/11/2023 10:46

I am with you OP. I have been both A and B at different points in my life. A is probably lucky in that A has some choices on when she can do what but it doesn’t make her lazy or not as busy as B. In my experience when a woman is not in full time work then the lion’s share of all the chores, childcare, holiday planning, investments, grocery shopping, other life admin land on her. So while B might have a cleaner, after school childcare etc. A would be doing it all herself. These things take time and I find it idiotic how people think those things have no value when you do them yourself but if you outsourced it you would have to pay minimum of £10 per hour to get the work done. Also if A’s partner is a high earner he probably puts in very long hours and has a stressful job which means A would end up doing everything other than going to work. While in B’s case her partner would be splitting chores with her since they both work full time. So NO, B is definitely not doing the same as A and working full time. Both are lifestyle choices and both are fine. We need to learn to respect and appreciate each other. Women need to lift each other up and not put each other down!

Bumpitybumper · 16/11/2023 10:44

Boomboom22 · 16/11/2023 10:32

Then his industry needs to move on from the 50s. I call bs that any profession is so incompatible with family life.

Call BS all you like, this is the reality of his career. It won't move on from the 1950s whilst there are lots of childfree people willing to do what's required and desperate to fill his shoes.

There are actually quite a lot of roles that are difficult to manage with a family. My friend (not A or B) is an air stewardess and would not be able to do her job without her DH working for himself and being able to dictate his own hours. My other friend works for a maintenance firm and has to be on call one week out of four. These calls can be at anytime of day or night and it is expected that you just drop everything and go in. They ended moving the grandparents closer as they couldn't maintain both careers and family life when one of them basically couldn't be relied upon for a large chunk of each month.

OP posts:
Cinty6 · 16/11/2023 10:44

Boomboom22 · 16/11/2023 10:32

Then his industry needs to move on from the 50s. I call bs that any profession is so incompatible with family life.

On this, the stats around women in their thirties leaving teaching are telling. I wonder what tends to happen when women are this age… 🧐 I have worked with many a talented teacher who secured great outcomes for hundreds of kids to then find themselves on capability measures or a step towards it after becoming a mother. After the evening and bedtime routine, they planned lessons and marked books and did all the family admin. No wonder they were frazzled and didn’t have time to do all the bureaucracy that comes with working in far too many schools.

I will be using my next vote wisely for many reasons.

SouthLondonMum22 · 16/11/2023 10:43

Boomboom22 · 16/11/2023 10:32

I'd bet thousands all the senior women manage to parent perfectly well. Outsourcing cleaning etc of course.

Exactly.

Like I've already said, I work in a male dominated industry in a senior role and several of them have wives at home facilitating their career because it is a ''big job''.

It can be flexible, especially in a senior role but those men aren't expected to be flexible because society expects mothers to be the default parent.

Boomboom22 · 16/11/2023 10:32

I'd bet thousands all the senior women manage to parent perfectly well. Outsourcing cleaning etc of course.

Boomboom22 · 16/11/2023 10:32

Then his industry needs to move on from the 50s. I call bs that any profession is so incompatible with family life.

Bumpitybumper · 16/11/2023 10:25

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2023 09:58

@Bumpitybumper

The husband gets the obvious benefit of being able to focus on his career in the knowledge that the house and children are being well managed. He has a career that simply couldn't be done in a more 50:50 setup and as much as you can argue the rights and wrongs of this, he trained very hard and worked many years to get where he is and it would be a huge sacrifice for him to give this up because more was expected of him at home.

I'm sorry.... and let me be very clear at the outset that I have no problem with women choosing to take a step back from their careers....

But can you not see how inherently sexist that paragraph is? Why is it assumed that its always a "terrible sacrifice" for the man to give up a career he's trained for but not a woman? And why should his career be facilitated by a woman making this life as frictionless as possible?

I work 60+ hours a week and there is no one who stays at home to "facilitate" me focusing on my career. Why should it be taken as read that this man and his enormously important job gets that perk?

Of course there will be families where that role falls to the man and it suits the woman to choose not to work. And fair enough. But no one bemoans the fact that the children of this man are not getting to see him because he works 80 hours a week. Why the disparity?

This, I would suggest, is what people like Friend B find so irritating. That a man with a Big Job always seems incapable of running his life without a woman flapping around to make everything as comfortable as possible for him. No such advantage is ever handed to women with Big Jobs.

I think you are reading something into this paragraph that hasn't been written. I was writing the post in response to someone suggesting that the family didn't necessarily benefit from what A does. As A's DH desperately wants to maintain his career, then of course he is a direct beneficiary of her facilitating this. Whether the situation is right or equitable is a completely different question.

Of course it would be a huge sacrifice for anyone (man or woman) to give up the kind of career that A's DH has. The reality is though that the career isn't very family friendly and requires extremely long hours, lots of travel and he needs to be extremely flexible to go into work at the drop of a hat. All of these things are completely incompatible with family life so he just wouldn't be able to do his share at home and maintain this career. Put simply, if A did what B does then A's DH would have to change careers. You can argue about whether he should anyway and if this would be a better situation overall, but that doesn't change the facts of the matter.

OP posts:
janetjupiter · 16/11/2023 10:18

Well you can look at it on a macro or micro level or whatever you want, but ultimately, people will do what they want. It is a fact that women - not all, but in general - feel differently to men after children come along. Some of this will be societal conditioning, but it's also biological. Some women do not feel a maternal urge. That's fine too, what are you going to do about it anyway? Just do what you feel you need to do - why did people need everyone to feel the same as them. Just accept variation and different priorities.

Boomboom22 · 16/11/2023 10:12

Your second to last post I find sexist, insulting and utterly wrong in premise. I think parents who can prioritise are better employees so if a man or woman is so focused on their career I think this will adversely affect it.
I also think the higher paid and more professional you are the more freedom you have. Male headteachers do leave early and pick up primary schools kids. Male lawyers do the morning school run. Dr's organise their shifts around childcare and them dropping off.
I'd think if they can't focus on both they are just less competent tbh.

Mirabai · 16/11/2023 10:11

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 16/11/2023 09:49

I wouldn’t say this out loud, but as an exhausted working mum, I think it’s potentially a very smart decision to marry a rich man and give up work. As long as you’re married, and you’ve got your own cash to pay for a lawyer, he’s going to have a tough time screwing you over without paying for it - you can pull all the ‘I sacrificed my career’ stuff, which is rubbish as this thread shows how many women were chomping at the bit to give up work, but it works.

Ironically I know a woman who’s been absolutely stung on divorce as a result of slogging her guts out to maintain a high-flying career.

I will say this out loud - as an exhausted working mum I’d love to have a SAHW to do all the life admin, shopping, cooking, cleaning, maintenance, gardening and general wifework so I didn’t have to think about any of it. I think it would be lovely.

SouthLondonMum22 · 16/11/2023 10:01

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 16/11/2023 09:55

I can't support something I don't believe benefits society, though I suspect I would feel differently if it was just as likely for a man to be a SAHP or go part time. The problem I have is the pressure it puts on women who don't want to give up their careers.

It’s true. The most unsupportive men I work with all have SAHWs. They’re terrible to work with as a working mum - they’re bitter because of a life spent at the corporate grindstone funding a family they don’t get to participate in, and they don’t like working mums because they don’t see why you should get any flexibility to see your children when they don’t.

But I guess we all look out for number one and from the perspective of the mum I think it’s potentially a winner.

I understand it's a decision made largely because it is believed it benefits the individual family which I could absolutely get behind if we all lived on individual islands and our choices had no effects on society.

I have no issues with it on a micro level, my concern is looking at it on a macro level.

I hear you about unsupportive men with SAHM's. I work in a male dominated industry and it is incredibly hard competing with men who have a woman at home facilitating their career.

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2023 09:58

@Bumpitybumper

The husband gets the obvious benefit of being able to focus on his career in the knowledge that the house and children are being well managed. He has a career that simply couldn't be done in a more 50:50 setup and as much as you can argue the rights and wrongs of this, he trained very hard and worked many years to get where he is and it would be a huge sacrifice for him to give this up because more was expected of him at home.

I'm sorry.... and let me be very clear at the outset that I have no problem with women choosing to take a step back from their careers....

But can you not see how inherently sexist that paragraph is? Why is it assumed that its always a "terrible sacrifice" for the man to give up a career he's trained for but not a woman? And why should his career be facilitated by a woman making this life as frictionless as possible?

I work 60+ hours a week and there is no one who stays at home to "facilitate" me focusing on my career. Why should it be taken as read that this man and his enormously important job gets that perk?

Of course there will be families where that role falls to the man and it suits the woman to choose not to work. And fair enough. But no one bemoans the fact that the children of this man are not getting to see him because he works 80 hours a week. Why the disparity?

This, I would suggest, is what people like Friend B find so irritating. That a man with a Big Job always seems incapable of running his life without a woman flapping around to make everything as comfortable as possible for him. No such advantage is ever handed to women with Big Jobs.

downdowndowndowndown · 16/11/2023 09:55

This thought hit me yesterday after a friend sent me a TikTok video of a craft thing she was doing for Christmas
'Half of us are running around so busy that we can't eat, can't go to the toilet, drink coffee like no tomorrow, throw ourselves at the doors of public transport because we can't miss another morning meeting, and the other half are turning dried orange slices into tiny festive fox faces to put into Christmas pot pouri trays'

Basically neither sides are happy. Side one (which I am a member of) are stressed, drink too much, feel guilty, feel not present, constantly apologise and feel like we're losing all the time. Side two feel the same guilt, shame, frustration but because society doesn't value them and they've lost power in their relationships. Society values me as a working mother but not if I don't hit all the other unrealistic targets set for me. Society wants me to have time to make fox faces whilst also progressing in my career, having a healthy marriage, be a loving ever present mother. No one can do all of this!

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 16/11/2023 09:55

I can't support something I don't believe benefits society, though I suspect I would feel differently if it was just as likely for a man to be a SAHP or go part time. The problem I have is the pressure it puts on women who don't want to give up their careers.

It’s true. The most unsupportive men I work with all have SAHWs. They’re terrible to work with as a working mum - they’re bitter because of a life spent at the corporate grindstone funding a family they don’t get to participate in, and they don’t like working mums because they don’t see why you should get any flexibility to see your children when they don’t.

But I guess we all look out for number one and from the perspective of the mum I think it’s potentially a winner.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 16/11/2023 09:49

I wouldn’t say this out loud, but as an exhausted working mum, I think it’s potentially a very smart decision to marry a rich man and give up work. As long as you’re married, and you’ve got your own cash to pay for a lawyer, he’s going to have a tough time screwing you over without paying for it - you can pull all the ‘I sacrificed my career’ stuff, which is rubbish as this thread shows how many women were chomping at the bit to give up work, but it works.

Ironically I know a woman who’s been absolutely stung on divorce as a result of slogging her guts out to maintain a high-flying career.

SouthLondonMum22 · 16/11/2023 09:44

Whatafustercluck · 16/11/2023 09:33

I completely agree. But with all of that context, women should be better at supporting one another's decisions, precisely because they are under more pressure than fathers.

I don't think anything will change without societal change as a whole.

I can't support something I don't believe benefits society, though I suspect I would feel differently if it was just as likely for a man to be a SAHP or go part time. The problem I have is the pressure it puts on women who don't want to give up their careers.

Whatafustercluck · 16/11/2023 09:33

SouthLondonMum22 · 16/11/2023 09:27

To be fair, it doesn't happen with men because they are largely expected to continue as normal when they become fathers which isn't the same at all when a woman becomes a mother.

It's there because of the pressure women are put under in society when they become mothers which men simply don't experience.

No one asked my husband if he was going to back to work after becoming a father
No one judged my husband for going back to work after becoming a father
No one says that my husband doesn't raise his child because he works full time
No one calls my husband selfish for working full time as a father

etc

I completely agree. But with all of that context, women should be better at supporting one another's decisions, precisely because they are under more pressure than fathers.

Mummymummy89 · 16/11/2023 09:31

Bumpitybumper · 16/11/2023 09:21

I understand your point and agree to a certain extent but if I'm honest the family does benefit from the majority of what she does in quite tangible ways.

The husband gets the obvious benefit of being able to focus on his career in the knowledge that the house and children are being well managed. He has a career that simply couldn't be done in a more 50:50 setup and as much as you can argue the rights and wrongs of this, he trained very hard and worked many years to get where he is and it would be a huge sacrifice for him to give this up because more was expected of him at home. B's DH is not able to pursue their careers in such a focussed manner because they are having to drop things to pick up poorly children or make sure they're available by a certain to collect the kids. I would say that this has certainly impacted B's earning potential as he had the opportunity to work in London with a hefty pay rise but couldn't take the job as he couldn't make the hours and commute work with his family commitments. Again, I must reiterate that I'm not saying that it is great that father's can pursue career completed unencumbered by children but it is hard to argue that A's husband hasn't benefited from her being at home.

Her kids also don't have to go to wraparound care and holiday clubs when they don't want to. I have dragged my kids to clubs because I NEED them there and I'm sure B has done the same. A has the time to facilitate extracurricular activities that require high levels of commitment to take seriously. B has a child into the same hobby as one of A's kids but A is able to take her child to proper accredited classes in the evenings whilst B simply can't do this. I don't know if anything will come of this hobby and whether it will make a difference in the long terms, but B's child has told my child that they are envious of A's child going to these classes. A also has the time to thoroughly go through homework with each of her children and I would say it does make a difference as her kids are in the top groups for everything and seem to have mastered things like timestables and reading in a way that is hard to achieve without parental input. If course they could just be naturally super intelligent but I think her input has certainly helped.

I could elaborate further but my point is that the family definitely do directly benefit from what A does. I know not everything she does is objectively beneficial for the family but I think it's misleading to ignore the advantages of what she does.

I do get what you're saying and I think our viewpoints are beginning to converge (good outcome to a thread!) And in particular I'm glad that you mentioned the benefit to A's dh first. Because he's the main beneficiary in A's setup.

But personally I really, really wouldn't want such an imbalance in my marriage. It's true that my dh now earns more than me and I work PT (two jobs totalling 3.5/4 days pw). He's "fortunate" that his skills are more lucrative than mine although we have the same degree - he's in software, I'm in teaching.

But would I want to have less of a career so he can have a better one? Would I want him to do none of the pickups and drop offs, none of the home made curries, none of the sewing, none of the braiding of dd's hair (my dh does the best French braids)?? No.

I'm of the very strong opinion that my dd, and B's children, benefit hugely from having a dad who sews their badges and braid their hair and does nursery/school drop offs.

I think the benefit of an all-rounded, present, father figure absolutely outweighs the benefit of an immaculate living room or even an extra-curricular activity and I will die on this hill lol...! (And this is coming from someone who had a single mum myself and no dad at all.)

Bumpitybumper · 16/11/2023 09:31

G5000 · 16/11/2023 07:47

but I'm not of more value than a mother forming the next generation who stays at home

What do you mean here? Yes I agree that morally a working mother is not necessarily a nicer person than a SAHM, but surely most jobs create some value? Otherwise they wouldn't exist, if there was really no difference if they are done or not.
My own mother has done something that has affected thousands of children, she has received numerous awards and recognitions for what she has done outside of home. How can this be nothing, just as same as if she was a lifelong SAHM?

I think this is a bit of a tricky argument.

There are definitely people that work in roles that unequivocally greatly benefit society. There are very many other people though that work in roles that don't really add much value to society and on some cases actively harm it.

For example, take the vape stores that have opened up and down the country. The people that work there may well work hard but is what they are doing benefitting society in anyway? What about the people that work for tax evading companies like Amazon? They have decimated the high street and have a questionable environmental impact so are they good for society? What about ambulance chaser lawyers or those working for Klarna? The list is literally endless. My own business is serving a purpose and helping to grow the economy but many don't like it and consider it detrimental to society in some ways. I imagine some would argue that they would rather I stayed as SAHM than expand an industry they are not hugely comfortable with.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread