Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'I do all these things AND work FT'

991 replies

Bumpitybumper · 15/11/2023 15:37

I see this on Mumsnet a lot but have just experienced it in real life. I have two friends (A&B). Friend A is a SAHM to school age kids and Friend B works FT in quite a stressful job. Friend B was just lamenting that they don't understand how Friend A fills her time as she manages to work FT AND do everything Friend A does.

The thing is, Friend B has a much smaller (yet lovely) house that is pretty chaotic in fun energetic way. It is never the tidiest or cleanest but it's not disgusting either. Friend A on the other hand has a much bigger house that is pretty immaculate most of the time. Friend A does all the school runs and volunteers at school. Friend B needs wraparound care in order to get to work so drops her kids of at 8 and collects around 17:30. Friend A cooks amazing meals for her family, has her children's friends round for fun playdates and activities and is generally incredibly on top of everything. Friend B is understandably more stretched and isn't in the position to cook lavish meals every day of the week or have friends round when she's at work. Friend B's husband does a lot (of course absolutely fair and right) so she doesn't have to attend every parents evening, sew all the badges for extracurricular clubs or assist with all the homework etc. Friend A does pretty much all of that as husband works such long hours.

I actually think both are amazing and very productive people that channel their energy, time and talent in different channels. I just struggle to understand though how Friend B can't appreciate that she isn't doing the same as Friend A or at least doing it to the same standard. Before people suggest I'm Friend A, I have my own business so don't really fit in either camp but used to be a SAHM so I guess can see Friend A's efforts more.

AIBU to think that Friend B is a bit deluded?

OP posts:
Lelophants · 16/11/2023 17:47

SisterHyster · 16/11/2023 17:28

We are not jealous that you get to clean your toilet or sew badges on 😂don’t flatter yourself!
From,
Every working mum ever.

When they go on about how much better they are than mum A and how much they do, they come across as over invested and jealous. Who gives a crap .

SisterHyster · 16/11/2023 17:47

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2023 17:32

@SisterHyster

We are not jealous that you get to clean your toilet or sew badges on 😂don’t flatter yourself!
From,
Every working mum ever

This. It's perfectly possible to disagree with another person's position without being jealous of them. It's called critical thinking - you should try it.

It is indeed not a competition but it is a social issue which affects mothers and this is a site for debate by mothers so it's entirely legitimate to raise this without being accused of bitterness.

I work full time, and I don’t see the value in cleaning. I make just over £40 per hour. I pay someone £20/hour to clean for me. They do it better than I would. Similarly, I can get a meal out for us all for £60, and it would take me way more than an hour and a half to cook and clean up a similar meal.

Anything that I can outsource for less than my hourly rate, I’ll outsource. Gardening, washing the car, I even send my laundry off sometimes. We eat out a lot.

Just because someone is a working mum does not necessarily mean they are run ragged, feeding their kids chicken nuggets and neglecting them whilst they cram a full days admin into a few hours before bed.

Hobbitfeet32 · 16/11/2023 17:39

What exactly do SAHMs do that WOHMs don’t do if you have school age children?
I’m yet to see a post that specifies anything that working parents don’t do.

Walkaround · 16/11/2023 17:39

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2023 16:10

@Walkaround

all you are doing is accepting, agreeing with and positively going along with abuses of power. You are minimising the fact the vast majority of women with children will never earn enough that they can go it completely alone and sod their abusive partner/husband. You are creating a fantasy for women where the reality is, women are just making other women suffer with their abusive rhetoric towards each other

How the hell am I "going along with abuses of power" or "creating a fantasy for women"? Completely OTT reaction to my post.

I'm saying women need some access to their own money. I've never said they need to be totally self-sustaining and own everything in their own right. I'm simply saying its very risky to be wholly dependent on the whims of one other person for your financial security and to build an entire life around that person without a get-out clause.

Except it is a fantasy, @Thepeopleversuswork. A woman may work but still be told it’s just a pocket-money job which is deeply unimportant and really doesn’t make up for the time and freedom lost by being at the beck and call of both her partner and an employer. I’ve seen plenty of women kick other women for that. It’s a bit of a cop out and does not ring true to claim the only thing you really have a problem with is someone who does no paid work outside the home and that this is the Russian roulette situation that concerns you, whilst carefully avoiding saying how much money you think a woman needs access to and what she is allowed to count as “her own” money.

The reality is, Friend A is likely to be in a far, far less vulnerable position than a great many women despite not working, as she is patently highly competent and in a financially comfortable position. She does not sound like a victim, or someone playing Russian roulette in any meaningful sense, albeit of course she could be hiding an abusive relationship (which would also be the case if she were doing paid work - either her partner is abusive or he isn’t…). I suspect she is married and has access to pooled finances which she no doubt views as hers as much as it is his. You should save your fears for people who are actually being abused, not people capable of looking after themselves and making informed decisions. Paid work is not a panacea.

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2023 17:32

@SisterHyster

We are not jealous that you get to clean your toilet or sew badges on 😂don’t flatter yourself!
From,
Every working mum ever

This. It's perfectly possible to disagree with another person's position without being jealous of them. It's called critical thinking - you should try it.

It is indeed not a competition but it is a social issue which affects mothers and this is a site for debate by mothers so it's entirely legitimate to raise this without being accused of bitterness.

SisterHyster · 16/11/2023 17:28

Chipsahoyagain · 16/11/2023 11:08

This. I'm friend A and I steer clear of people like B. Always undertone of jealous and bitterness. It's not a competition but so many women make it into one .

We are not jealous that you get to clean your toilet or sew badges on 😂don’t flatter yourself!
From,
Every working mum ever.

Comtesse · 16/11/2023 17:26

B is doing the same as A. She is raising her children, feeding them, doing household jobs. Yes the standards and methods differ but she is doing the same. I like the analogy of the jumper that PP made - if your kid is clothed and warm, then there are many many ways of achieving that outcome.

We can talk about “busy work” or “slapdash” if we want to use judgemental language about how other people organise their time - but they are (we are all) raising our children, feeding them, doing household jobs.

Mummymummy89 · 16/11/2023 17:15

SouthLondonMum22 · 16/11/2023 16:26

Maybe in some tiny pockets but within society as a whole? I don't think so.

I still experience it myself all of the time. I'm pregnant with twins and I've had more than one person question how I will 'manage' working full time, no one has asked my husband that or if he will cut his hours down/take a career break.

I can't even go outside alone without someone asking where my son is if I bump into someone I know. Again, my husband is never asked where his son is if the same thing happens.

I'm sorry to hear that people say that stuff...I don't get that much from the people I know (maybe I'm too prickly?!)

When people see me out and about without DD they ask how she is rather than where she is if that makes sense. They definitely ask DH the same if they see him.

If anything, because my dh wfh, seeing him outside the house without dd is a rare event lol.

If I see a dad from dd's nursery my first question is how is his kid, same as if I see a mum.

With the twins thing, (congratulations btw! Hope all is well with the pregnancy! I'm PG atm too but just a singleton) I'm honestly amazed they don't ask your dh the same, or at least whether he's taking extended pat leave. It's my first question to any expectant dad (that I know well enough to ask this kind of question), let alone of twins.

I just find it boggling how hands-on dads manage with just two weeks' paternity leave. My male colleague at work is up a lot of the night with his poorly newborn and it's taking its toll on him and his wife for sure.

Extended paternity leave (without reducing maternity leave) is the answer to all these problems imo.

Bumpitybumper · 16/11/2023 16:56

Janeandme · 16/11/2023 16:01

I’m not sure she is saying that, as she also, as a parent. Will sew badges and make meals, it’s her very point, she’s doing that and a day job. It’s what the op is about.

shes not saying there is no value, she’s saying she doesn’t understand how it’s a full time job,

i think if many stay at home parents are honest, that unless you live in a massive house with a large amount of pre school children or ones with additional needs then it isn’t a full time job unless you class basic parenting like bath time or homework or dinner time and feeding yourself as a job.

tnat doesn’t mean it is not valuable. But being valuable to your family and a full time job are very different things.

And yet nobody has said that A is doing the equivalent of a FT job, least of all A herself. B is literally saying she does ALL that A does and a FT job. My observation is that this simply isn't true.

OP posts:
Bumpitybumper · 16/11/2023 16:51

lizzy8230 · 16/11/2023 16:39

@Bumpitybumper you're overly invested in the detail of the infinite different detail of how parents organise their lives. Some people will have both parents working, some neither, and every possible permutation between: part time/ flexi, using proper regulated childcare, not using childcare, using relatives for informal childminding... you also seem obsessed with quantifying the basic tasks of caring for children and running a home.

Ultimately, does it matter if a child wears a lovely hand knitted jumper bought from a shop or a lovely jumper hand knitted by a SAHM? Does it matter if a SAHM changes 5000 nappies or whether some of the thousands of nappy changes happen at the childminder or nursery?

As I keep saying, surely what's important is raising happy well rounded children to adulthood. That can be done (or not!) by SAHM or WOHM. Raising children is about imparting values, not simply a quantifiable sum of tasks. There is no 'right' way to do it. Tbh I find it slightly odd that you felt so invested as to begin a thread about how other mums spend their time.

This is Mumsnet. Unbelievably the forum is populated with all kinds of threads about motherhood and the details around it. Starting a thread doesn't make me overly invested. I don't lay awake at night thinking about this or really think about it much in general life. It's as simple as B making a comment and that triggering a thought process that I shared on here. I think the 'over invested' line is trotted out on MN when people would rather not discuss a topic. It's the equivalent of a kid calling another 'weird' for questioning something. There is absolutely nothing wrong with discussing this and the amount of replies including your own, show that many people are interested in this too.

The nappy changes and jumper might not matter to you but they might matter to someone else who will organise their life accordingly. I could list a million things that other people care about that I don't but I don't automatically assume that they are wrong to care about those things. I'm sure our lists of priorities in terms of motherhood and every other aspect of our lives would differ and that is absolutely fine. There isn't a 'right' way of doing it but there are different ways that require different levels of effort and time. As I have said a million times, I have no quarrel with anyone saying that they don't think that devoting so much time and effort into something isn't worth it for them or they think it's unnecessary. What I don't think is ok is pretending that it's all exactly the same anyway and that your shop bought is the exact same as someone's hand made one.

OP posts:
Mirabai · 16/11/2023 16:41

Walkaround · 16/11/2023 15:58

@Thepeopleversuswork - all you are doing is accepting, agreeing with and positively going along with abuses of power. You are minimising the fact the vast majority of women with children will never earn enough that they can go it completely alone and sod their abusive partner/husband. You are creating a fantasy for women where the reality is, women are just making other women suffer with their abusive rhetoric towards each other and the men no longer even have to get involved in it to get the boot in, because it’s the women gleefully behaving like shits towards each other with their “told you sos,” either when the working mother can’t cope with all the demands and feels like a failure at everything, or when the sahm is left without any money and told she is an absolute failure at everything. The reality is, a huge number of women have the absolute worst of all worlds, working inside and outside the home, paid and unpaid, and trapped in poverty with abusive partners, due to the obstinate refusal of some women to accept the real problem is abuse of power, not whether or not women do paid work.

Agree with this.

lizzy8230 · 16/11/2023 16:39

@Bumpitybumper you're overly invested in the detail of the infinite different detail of how parents organise their lives. Some people will have both parents working, some neither, and every possible permutation between: part time/ flexi, using proper regulated childcare, not using childcare, using relatives for informal childminding... you also seem obsessed with quantifying the basic tasks of caring for children and running a home.

Ultimately, does it matter if a child wears a lovely hand knitted jumper bought from a shop or a lovely jumper hand knitted by a SAHM? Does it matter if a SAHM changes 5000 nappies or whether some of the thousands of nappy changes happen at the childminder or nursery?

As I keep saying, surely what's important is raising happy well rounded children to adulthood. That can be done (or not!) by SAHM or WOHM. Raising children is about imparting values, not simply a quantifiable sum of tasks. There is no 'right' way to do it. Tbh I find it slightly odd that you felt so invested as to begin a thread about how other mums spend their time.

SouthLondonMum22 · 16/11/2023 16:26

Mummymummy89 · 16/11/2023 13:53

I think this is changing though, at least in the families I see, which is maybe a similar demographic to yours (I'm also in South London as it happens, professional careers etc).

For example at dd's nursery, a good proportion of the pickups and drop offs are done by the dads (maybe not half but close).

And I have a male friend whose gf has recently got pregnant; the male friend has a high earning job where he has to go abroad quite often for a week or two, at least ten times a year, and people have already asked him whether he's going to change job or role now because he's going to be a father. He'd be getting judgement if he just carried on and was frequently absent, rather than praise for "providing".

Incidentally he's my dh's closest friend and I think he and everyone around him see my dh's level of "presence" as a father as preferable (wfh, doing most of the nursery runs, braiding hair etc) and would be sheepish about continuing to go abroad all the time as a father.

So expectations on dads I think are increasing, and are no longer as you describe.

Maybe in some tiny pockets but within society as a whole? I don't think so.

I still experience it myself all of the time. I'm pregnant with twins and I've had more than one person question how I will 'manage' working full time, no one has asked my husband that or if he will cut his hours down/take a career break.

I can't even go outside alone without someone asking where my son is if I bump into someone I know. Again, my husband is never asked where his son is if the same thing happens.

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2023 16:10

@Walkaround

all you are doing is accepting, agreeing with and positively going along with abuses of power. You are minimising the fact the vast majority of women with children will never earn enough that they can go it completely alone and sod their abusive partner/husband. You are creating a fantasy for women where the reality is, women are just making other women suffer with their abusive rhetoric towards each other

How the hell am I "going along with abuses of power" or "creating a fantasy for women"? Completely OTT reaction to my post.

I'm saying women need some access to their own money. I've never said they need to be totally self-sustaining and own everything in their own right. I'm simply saying its very risky to be wholly dependent on the whims of one other person for your financial security and to build an entire life around that person without a get-out clause.

SeethroughDress · 16/11/2023 16:06

Are you feeling ok, @Walkaround ? Because @Thepeopleversuswork didn't say anything like that.

Janeandme · 16/11/2023 16:01

Ponderingwindow · 16/11/2023 15:36

Friend B in some ways is saying she does not see value in sewing on badges or cooking meals.

I think both approaches to parenting have value. Showing your children the importance of work is valuable. Being there to volunteer in class or sew a costume, also valuable. We can’t possibly do it all, so we just have to play to our strengths.

I’m not sure she is saying that, as she also, as a parent. Will sew badges and make meals, it’s her very point, she’s doing that and a day job. It’s what the op is about.

shes not saying there is no value, she’s saying she doesn’t understand how it’s a full time job,

i think if many stay at home parents are honest, that unless you live in a massive house with a large amount of pre school children or ones with additional needs then it isn’t a full time job unless you class basic parenting like bath time or homework or dinner time and feeding yourself as a job.

tnat doesn’t mean it is not valuable. But being valuable to your family and a full time job are very different things.

Walkaround · 16/11/2023 15:58

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2023 08:28

@Walkaround

I certainly agree that the argy-barby about this topic on here is not constructive and it's true that working parents to some extent have to work together, even if they're no longer together.

But you're minimising the importance of a woman having access to some money on her own terms and which she doesn't rely on her husband's goodwill for. That's really really critical.

There's a big difference between a couple who are both working and have joint bank accounts and have a lot of give and take on childcare and a scenario with a working father and a career SAHM who will be up shit creek if the father decides to trade her in. It's an incredibly precarious position to put yourself and your children in and in my view the marginal trade off of being able to be at home facilitating things and making the home look nice without paying for childcare doesn't compensate for the financial and emotional risk.

Of course there's a sliding scale: not every working mum needs to berate themselves for not being a CEO or a surgeon. There are plenty of women who justifiably take the early years of their kids lives off and then slowly reenter the world of work once the children are at school. There are women who work part time all their lives in order to make life easier for their children. There are women who are independently wealthy who don't rely on their husbands and choose to volunteer. And that's all fine.

But the bare fact is that throwing all your eggs in the traditional basket of "I'll facilitate his career and raise his kids and he'll support me" is like playing Russian Roulette.

@Thepeopleversuswork - all you are doing is accepting, agreeing with and positively going along with abuses of power. You are minimising the fact the vast majority of women with children will never earn enough that they can go it completely alone and sod their abusive partner/husband. You are creating a fantasy for women where the reality is, women are just making other women suffer with their abusive rhetoric towards each other and the men no longer even have to get involved in it to get the boot in, because it’s the women gleefully behaving like shits towards each other with their “told you sos,” either when the working mother can’t cope with all the demands and feels like a failure at everything, or when the sahm is left without any money and told she is an absolute failure at everything. The reality is, a huge number of women have the absolute worst of all worlds, working inside and outside the home, paid and unpaid, and trapped in poverty with abusive partners, due to the obstinate refusal of some women to accept the real problem is abuse of power, not whether or not women do paid work.

Mirabai · 16/11/2023 15:52

I think everyone’s insecurities are coming out on the thread, this is not confined to the OP.

illbeinthegarden · 16/11/2023 15:51

Friend B doesn't sound particularly a good friend but tbf if she's 'doing all that' and working full time she's probably absolutely knackered. Women being told they can do everything is ridiculous why the fuck should we.

Bumpitybumper · 16/11/2023 15:44

WitcheryDivine · 16/11/2023 15:28

I've actually really enjoyed reading this thread and all the different perspectives, so thanks for starting it.

But I do think OP that your own anxieties perhaps about what a woman should ideally do are coming out quite strongly. Even in your last post you've put "B is doing something important during the majority of the waking day (i.e. working!) so why on earth should she feel like she has to match A?" While you're being respectful the implication is that she doesn't "match" A, presumably in terms of fulfilling her role as wife/mother. I'm sorry if you feel that now you have your own business you are somehow failing to live up to an ideal, that must be stressful.

More widely I think there's a slight confusion on the thread about what "doing all these things" means. If you look at it literally timewise (which I think is your approach), B is clearly not spending X hours on cooking, X hours on volunteering, X hours on whatever that A does. But the way I read it (and maybe others too), "doing all these things" means "fulfilling these roles and getting stuff done". She is making sure the household income is kept up, as is A apparently by supporting high earning Mr A. She is feeding the kids by doing it herself, getting takeaway or having a husband who does his part - as is A by cooking lavish meals. She is making sure the kids are looked after and get to school and have a social life - as is A by being at home with the kids in her case. And so on. So I think she is right to think that she is doing "all these things" and working full time (although boasting about it/doing A down - if that's what she's doing - sound irritating).

It's a bit like if my friend and I each had kids who both needed new jumpers, and she got her own wool from her flock of sheep and then spun it and eventually knitted it into a jumper, and I went out and bought a similar jumper (or even had a hand me down from a friend or sibling) - we have both done the same thing in terms of providing the clothing that our child needs. She has spent hours and hours on it and I have spent 30 minutes on it, but we have both done it. And there isn't necessarily any real difference in the outcome, quality or anything else. What is different is the amount of "home made-iness" which I think is probably what the OP here values.

You are probably right that my own insecurities and issues are evident on this thread, both in terms of how I am managing as working parent but also how I felt judged as a SAHP. It's a weird dichotomy I admit. To be honest though, I feel like most posters have a complex and interesting relationship with this topic hence why there are so many responses and things have got quite animated at times.

Your jumper example is a good one. I have no problem with you saying that you have provided a jumper for your child the same as your friend. I would just expect you to acknowledge if asked that their jumper was handmade and took more time and effort. I wouldn't expect you to think this made the jumper better, more valuable or more fit for purpose. In the case of the wraparound care, I think this is the same as allowing someone else lend your child a jumper for a while. Again, your child still has a jumper but it's not the same as you making one for them yourself and will be different than the handmade jumper. Ultimately the children in all scenarios have jumpers and won't feel cold which is the most important thing.

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 16/11/2023 15:36

Friend B in some ways is saying she does not see value in sewing on badges or cooking meals.

I think both approaches to parenting have value. Showing your children the importance of work is valuable. Being there to volunteer in class or sew a costume, also valuable. We can’t possibly do it all, so we just have to play to our strengths.

LTBarbara · 16/11/2023 15:29

KatharinaRosalie · 16/11/2023 13:44

Just accept that families will always do what works for them, regardless of whether anyone else likes that or not.
What works really depends on the society where we live though. How many women have said on MN they can't afford to go back to work due to childcare? How abot dads who would like to spend more time with their babies, but nobody in their company has ever taken parental leave, and their flexible working requests are denied, but female colleagues get theirs approved. Dads who are excluded from 'mum and baby' groups. Women who have to swim against the current and justify daily why they are working, and their bosses assuming they are not interested in any career development now they have kids. And so on. Those decisions are not taken in vaccuum. (Believe me, I've tried - I'm the main earner, DH was the one who stayed home.)

To be fair, the baby groups in my area welcome dads, not that they really go though, generally speaking. The only one that doesn’t is a breastfeeding one and rightly so if you ask me.

WitcheryDivine · 16/11/2023 15:28

I've actually really enjoyed reading this thread and all the different perspectives, so thanks for starting it.

But I do think OP that your own anxieties perhaps about what a woman should ideally do are coming out quite strongly. Even in your last post you've put "B is doing something important during the majority of the waking day (i.e. working!) so why on earth should she feel like she has to match A?" While you're being respectful the implication is that she doesn't "match" A, presumably in terms of fulfilling her role as wife/mother. I'm sorry if you feel that now you have your own business you are somehow failing to live up to an ideal, that must be stressful.

More widely I think there's a slight confusion on the thread about what "doing all these things" means. If you look at it literally timewise (which I think is your approach), B is clearly not spending X hours on cooking, X hours on volunteering, X hours on whatever that A does. But the way I read it (and maybe others too), "doing all these things" means "fulfilling these roles and getting stuff done". She is making sure the household income is kept up, as is A apparently by supporting high earning Mr A. She is feeding the kids by doing it herself, getting takeaway or having a husband who does his part - as is A by cooking lavish meals. She is making sure the kids are looked after and get to school and have a social life - as is A by being at home with the kids in her case. And so on. So I think she is right to think that she is doing "all these things" and working full time (although boasting about it/doing A down - if that's what she's doing - sound irritating).

It's a bit like if my friend and I each had kids who both needed new jumpers, and she got her own wool from her flock of sheep and then spun it and eventually knitted it into a jumper, and I went out and bought a similar jumper (or even had a hand me down from a friend or sibling) - we have both done the same thing in terms of providing the clothing that our child needs. She has spent hours and hours on it and I have spent 30 minutes on it, but we have both done it. And there isn't necessarily any real difference in the outcome, quality or anything else. What is different is the amount of "home made-iness" which I think is probably what the OP here values.

cannaecookrisotto · 16/11/2023 14:15

I have a "big job".

I have friends who are SAHMs.

We don't even consider this shite, we just crack on. Sometimes we even help each other out 😱.

Mummymummy89 · 16/11/2023 13:53

SouthLondonMum22 · 16/11/2023 13:31

Which is part of the problem, the double standards.

I said it before on this thread but it’s the same when it comes to a father working vs a mother working too.

The father is a big hero working hard (long hours) providing for his family

The mother prioritises her career over her children, she’s part of the rat race who will clearly regret working on her death bed and she shoves her children in nursery for other people to raise.

I think this is changing though, at least in the families I see, which is maybe a similar demographic to yours (I'm also in South London as it happens, professional careers etc).

For example at dd's nursery, a good proportion of the pickups and drop offs are done by the dads (maybe not half but close).

And I have a male friend whose gf has recently got pregnant; the male friend has a high earning job where he has to go abroad quite often for a week or two, at least ten times a year, and people have already asked him whether he's going to change job or role now because he's going to be a father. He'd be getting judgement if he just carried on and was frequently absent, rather than praise for "providing".

Incidentally he's my dh's closest friend and I think he and everyone around him see my dh's level of "presence" as a father as preferable (wfh, doing most of the nursery runs, braiding hair etc) and would be sheepish about continuing to go abroad all the time as a father.

So expectations on dads I think are increasing, and are no longer as you describe.