Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'I do all these things AND work FT'

991 replies

Bumpitybumper · 15/11/2023 15:37

I see this on Mumsnet a lot but have just experienced it in real life. I have two friends (A&B). Friend A is a SAHM to school age kids and Friend B works FT in quite a stressful job. Friend B was just lamenting that they don't understand how Friend A fills her time as she manages to work FT AND do everything Friend A does.

The thing is, Friend B has a much smaller (yet lovely) house that is pretty chaotic in fun energetic way. It is never the tidiest or cleanest but it's not disgusting either. Friend A on the other hand has a much bigger house that is pretty immaculate most of the time. Friend A does all the school runs and volunteers at school. Friend B needs wraparound care in order to get to work so drops her kids of at 8 and collects around 17:30. Friend A cooks amazing meals for her family, has her children's friends round for fun playdates and activities and is generally incredibly on top of everything. Friend B is understandably more stretched and isn't in the position to cook lavish meals every day of the week or have friends round when she's at work. Friend B's husband does a lot (of course absolutely fair and right) so she doesn't have to attend every parents evening, sew all the badges for extracurricular clubs or assist with all the homework etc. Friend A does pretty much all of that as husband works such long hours.

I actually think both are amazing and very productive people that channel their energy, time and talent in different channels. I just struggle to understand though how Friend B can't appreciate that she isn't doing the same as Friend A or at least doing it to the same standard. Before people suggest I'm Friend A, I have my own business so don't really fit in either camp but used to be a SAHM so I guess can see Friend A's efforts more.

AIBU to think that Friend B is a bit deluded?

OP posts:
Fairtobefairohhhhhc · 16/11/2023 18:37

This is always a strange conversation and such competition. We all love differently and suited to our individual lifestyles surely. Just because one does something the other doesn't, doesn't mean one does more or less.

SisterHyster · 16/11/2023 18:37

Walkaround · 16/11/2023 18:28

So, the people doing your grunt work do not earn enough to pay others to do their grunt work, meaning huge numbers of people are just spending their time grunting for others or grunting at home…. Doesn’t sound like much fun to me.

My cleaner comes during the day, when her own children are at school. It’s her job - a proper job. She contributes to society and pays her taxes.

I don’t see why someone who is employed as a cleaner would employ a cleaner to do their cleaning. She’s very good at what she does.

Same for my window cleaner - he owns a business - a seemingly successful one.

I also pay for other services such as a hairdresser, waxing lady, a swim instructor for my eldest, and a dog walker for the dog. Yes, I could do all these things by myself, but I simply don’t want to, since someone else can do them better for me.

Technically, almost any job can be done by a non professional.

MightyMinestrone · 16/11/2023 18:34

Mummymummy89 · 16/11/2023 18:25

Being at home with the kids instead of working,

But friend A isn't. Her kids are at school.

The amount of extra time she spends with her kids compared to B is probably about 2 hours a day, maybe less depending on B's and Mr B's working hours.

Nb this is balanced against the much lower-quality involvement that Mr A has with his kids compared to Mr B.

This debate/question, as originally posited by op, is not about the very early years, it's about school years.

@Mummymummy89

5128gap · 16/11/2023 18:30

Hobbitfeet32 · 16/11/2023 17:39

What exactly do SAHMs do that WOHMs don’t do if you have school age children?
I’m yet to see a post that specifies anything that working parents don’t do.

There's no consensus. Because these threads are always divided between the SAHMs who want to recieve recognition for working as hard a WM just in a different way, and the SAHMs who want to deliberately evoke the jealousy they're convinced they're the objects of, by bragging about their husband's income and how it enables them to do hobbies and watch netflicks all day while other unfortunates have to work. The latter does nothing to help the case of the former, and leaves WMs none the wiser.

SisterHyster · 16/11/2023 18:29

Mummymummy89 · 16/11/2023 18:25

Being at home with the kids instead of working,

But friend A isn't. Her kids are at school.

The amount of extra time she spends with her kids compared to B is probably about 2 hours a day, maybe less depending on B's and Mr B's working hours.

Nb this is balanced against the much lower-quality involvement that Mr A has with his kids compared to Mr B.

This debate/question, as originally posited by op, is not about the very early years, it's about school years.

They also seem to miss out the role of the fathers. By the sounds of things, family A have a father who just dips into parenting together, whereas family B have a father who is truly an equal partner to his partner.

I bet the kids in family B get more parental contact hours than the kids in family A.

Nobody is talking about the benefits (for children) of having a very involved father. They should be.

Walkaround · 16/11/2023 18:28

SisterHyster · 16/11/2023 18:21

You are making a lot of assumptions about what workings parents do.

We are both full time as of Monday. We use no childcare whatsoever, our kids are either in education or with a parent.

We have just as much quality time as a SAHP because we prioritise earning enough money so someone else can do the grunt work (like cleaning and gardening) allowing us to have a lot of quality time with our kids.

My children quite like the luxuries that being a dual income home affords them. Plus, we will never rely on a single income, so we are better protected against unforeseen issues such as redundancies, illness, relationship breakdowns.

So, the people doing your grunt work do not earn enough to pay others to do their grunt work, meaning huge numbers of people are just spending their time grunting for others or grunting at home…. Doesn’t sound like much fun to me.

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2023 18:26

@Walkaround

And there is no more logic in claiming it is better to earn more money than you need or want than there is in claiming it is better to have more time and less stress than to feel the satisfaction of working for money

I don’t have more money than I need or want and I don’t work for fun or “pocket money” or to buy shoes or handbags (which is the usual canard which people come up with to level at working mums). I work to support my child. I happen to enjoy my job (usually), but that doesn’t change the fact that I have to do it.

Nor is it to do with any “satisfaction” in earning money. It’s pure financial necessity.

I’m not worried about this particular woman and I have said until I am blue in the face that it’s up to each woman to make choices that suit her circumstances.

But I stand by the fact that making a lifetime career out of financial dependence on one other person is very risky.

Mummymummy89 · 16/11/2023 18:25

Brakken · 16/11/2023 18:01

@lizzy8230 right, this is laughable, come on now, you can't be serious that's what you think the average SAHM spends their time doing 😄🙄 It's telling seeing some working mothers on here desperately trying to assuage their guilt of being away from their kids by trying to belittle mothers who stay home with their kids. If you were truly secure and happy about your choices, you wouldn't feel the need to do that. Which also goes for "mother B" in the OP's example.

Being at home with the kids instead of working, naturally means you're able to spend much more quality time with your child. It's nothing about denigrating working mothers, it's just stating a simple fact and acknowledging the rules of our Earth that no parent is (yet!) able to bilocate and be in two places at once. And what do you think the children themsleves prefer - the vast majority of course would prefer their own parent looking after them and this is what is best for them.

Even if your child is in school while you're at home, you're able to be there for your child to pick them up from school each day and can spend that time while they're in school catching up on running household/errands/cooking etc and therefore when they're actually home from school, you can use the time to focus on spending quality time with them instead of being side tracked by having to all these other tasks at the same time, that you would have to do if you're a working parent.

Being at home with the kids instead of working,

But friend A isn't. Her kids are at school.

The amount of extra time she spends with her kids compared to B is probably about 2 hours a day, maybe less depending on B's and Mr B's working hours.

Nb this is balanced against the much lower-quality involvement that Mr A has with his kids compared to Mr B.

This debate/question, as originally posited by op, is not about the very early years, it's about school years.

SecondUsername4me · 16/11/2023 18:21

Forge not forget.

SisterHyster · 16/11/2023 18:21

Brakken · 16/11/2023 18:01

@lizzy8230 right, this is laughable, come on now, you can't be serious that's what you think the average SAHM spends their time doing 😄🙄 It's telling seeing some working mothers on here desperately trying to assuage their guilt of being away from their kids by trying to belittle mothers who stay home with their kids. If you were truly secure and happy about your choices, you wouldn't feel the need to do that. Which also goes for "mother B" in the OP's example.

Being at home with the kids instead of working, naturally means you're able to spend much more quality time with your child. It's nothing about denigrating working mothers, it's just stating a simple fact and acknowledging the rules of our Earth that no parent is (yet!) able to bilocate and be in two places at once. And what do you think the children themsleves prefer - the vast majority of course would prefer their own parent looking after them and this is what is best for them.

Even if your child is in school while you're at home, you're able to be there for your child to pick them up from school each day and can spend that time while they're in school catching up on running household/errands/cooking etc and therefore when they're actually home from school, you can use the time to focus on spending quality time with them instead of being side tracked by having to all these other tasks at the same time, that you would have to do if you're a working parent.

You are making a lot of assumptions about what workings parents do.

We are both full time as of Monday. We use no childcare whatsoever, our kids are either in education or with a parent.

We have just as much quality time as a SAHP because we prioritise earning enough money so someone else can do the grunt work (like cleaning and gardening) allowing us to have a lot of quality time with our kids.

My children quite like the luxuries that being a dual income home affords them. Plus, we will never rely on a single income, so we are better protected against unforeseen issues such as redundancies, illness, relationship breakdowns.

SecondUsername4me · 16/11/2023 18:21

Aramist · 16/11/2023 18:19

Thing is you can be just as busy as someone who works full time. You fill the time.
It's what you fill the time with that's being judged. It's just jealousy.

Isn't saying "it's jealousy" quite a lazy argument? I tried being a SAHM. I hated it. I'm not jealous at all of how a SAHP fills their day. As long as they are happy, as long as all women can forget a set of circumstances that gives them satisfaction - that's the ideal.

HolyGuacamole28 · 16/11/2023 18:20

Ha!! I am B. Work full time in a stressful city job, no cleaner, husband who also works all hours (self employed) 2 kids in nursery. Our house is always a mess (not dirty) and we live for weekends. I am very jealous of SAHP but we couldn’t afford to live on one salary. I try and just get on with it but recognise that life just isn’t really fair.

Aramist · 16/11/2023 18:19

Thing is you can be just as busy as someone who works full time. You fill the time.
It's what you fill the time with that's being judged. It's just jealousy.

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2023 18:18

@Brakken

It's nothing about denigrating working mothers

(Goes on to spend four long paragraphs denigrating working mothers).

Course you’re not, love.

Walkaround · 16/11/2023 18:16

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2023 17:57

@Walkaround

A woman may work but still be told it’s just a pocket-money job which is deeply unimportant and really doesn’t make up for the time and freedom lost by being at the beck and call of both her partner and an employer. I’ve seen plenty of women kick other women for that. It’s a bit of a cop out and does not ring true to claim the only thing you really have a problem with is someone who does no paid work outside the home and that this is the Russian roulette situation that concerns you, whilst carefully avoiding saying how much money you think a woman needs access to and what she is allowed to count as “her own” money.

You're projecting your own perspective on the work women do. The picture you're presented here is a particularly bleak and twisted view on paid work by women which I don't recognise from my life or most of my female friends and your logic seems warped.

I'm a lone female breadwinner and I'm wholly responsible for my family's financial wellbeing so this is completely inaccurate with respect to my life. That may not be the norm on the national basis, but it's not as unusual as you suggest. Even if you aren't able to support your own family and you're contributing to a wider family "pot", I'm struggling to understand why not earning money is better than earning money? There's no logic to that position at all.

The more your financial contribution to the family, the higher your autonomy. I'm not saying that this is the only way to have autonomy in a family, there are plenty of women who don't work but who have high status in their families, but anyone bringing some money in is automatically in a stronger position.

Meanwhile you reference the Friend A in this scenario as being in the best possible position. That may or may not be true, depending on her husband's job, their relationship and myriad other factors. If she's married and he has a lot of money and treats her well she may indeed be set up for life and good luck to her. But it is by definition a gamble. It's a gamble that he will make good on his promise to support and protect her. It might work, but she has no control over it. Yes she would probably get a decent payout in a divorce (and she's welcome to it). But not without several years of pain and almost certainly involving uprooting her children in the process. And with roughly half of marriages ending in divorce, why would you want to hand that level of risk to someone else?

You assume I am taking sides in this, @Thepeopleversuswork . The only person who can decide whether they are in the best position for them is the person in that position. Not you, not me - but I am not the one claiming to worry about women you have no proof you need to worry about. Life is by definition a gamble. Don’t pretend you can protect yourself from taking gambles. And there is no more logic in claiming it is better to earn more money than you need or want than there is in claiming it is better to have more time and less stress than to feel the satisfaction of working for money. There are trade offs to be made in all decisions anyone ever makes and money is one factor, not the only factor. How you feel about what you do and what motivates you are also important, particularly when you already have enough money.

Lelophants · 16/11/2023 18:14

MrsSchrute · 16/11/2023 18:01

I don't get this argument.

Are your kids happy and well looked after? Are you happy with the choice you've made? Then crack on!

Exactly

MrsSchrute · 16/11/2023 18:01

I don't get this argument.

Are your kids happy and well looked after? Are you happy with the choice you've made? Then crack on!

Brakken · 16/11/2023 18:01

lizzy8230 · 16/11/2023 08:06

@Mummymummy89 exactly. Having an immaculate lounge rather than a reasonably tidy one, or spending an hour of the afternoon sewing badges on a brownie uniform rather than sewing them on after work make zero difference to the child. It may be that the mother prefers the former, but that's for her own satisfaction rather than for anyone else's and certainly doesn't make a jot of difference to wider society.

That's not a judgement whatsoever; simply stating facts.

@lizzy8230 right, this is laughable, come on now, you can't be serious that's what you think the average SAHM spends their time doing 😄🙄 It's telling seeing some working mothers on here desperately trying to assuage their guilt of being away from their kids by trying to belittle mothers who stay home with their kids. If you were truly secure and happy about your choices, you wouldn't feel the need to do that. Which also goes for "mother B" in the OP's example.

Being at home with the kids instead of working, naturally means you're able to spend much more quality time with your child. It's nothing about denigrating working mothers, it's just stating a simple fact and acknowledging the rules of our Earth that no parent is (yet!) able to bilocate and be in two places at once. And what do you think the children themsleves prefer - the vast majority of course would prefer their own parent looking after them and this is what is best for them.

Even if your child is in school while you're at home, you're able to be there for your child to pick them up from school each day and can spend that time while they're in school catching up on running household/errands/cooking etc and therefore when they're actually home from school, you can use the time to focus on spending quality time with them instead of being side tracked by having to all these other tasks at the same time, that you would have to do if you're a working parent.

MrsSchrute · 16/11/2023 17:58

Hobbitfeet32 · 16/11/2023 17:57

@MrsSchrute I work 30 hours per week. In the last week I have volunteered on : occasions, twice at events my children have taken part in and once for a charity. I will be volunteering to help at a school sports event in a couple of weeks and volunteer at most PTA events.

That's great!

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2023 17:57

@Walkaround

A woman may work but still be told it’s just a pocket-money job which is deeply unimportant and really doesn’t make up for the time and freedom lost by being at the beck and call of both her partner and an employer. I’ve seen plenty of women kick other women for that. It’s a bit of a cop out and does not ring true to claim the only thing you really have a problem with is someone who does no paid work outside the home and that this is the Russian roulette situation that concerns you, whilst carefully avoiding saying how much money you think a woman needs access to and what she is allowed to count as “her own” money.

You're projecting your own perspective on the work women do. The picture you're presented here is a particularly bleak and twisted view on paid work by women which I don't recognise from my life or most of my female friends and your logic seems warped.

I'm a lone female breadwinner and I'm wholly responsible for my family's financial wellbeing so this is completely inaccurate with respect to my life. That may not be the norm on the national basis, but it's not as unusual as you suggest. Even if you aren't able to support your own family and you're contributing to a wider family "pot", I'm struggling to understand why not earning money is better than earning money? There's no logic to that position at all.

The more your financial contribution to the family, the higher your autonomy. I'm not saying that this is the only way to have autonomy in a family, there are plenty of women who don't work but who have high status in their families, but anyone bringing some money in is automatically in a stronger position.

Meanwhile you reference the Friend A in this scenario as being in the best possible position. That may or may not be true, depending on her husband's job, their relationship and myriad other factors. If she's married and he has a lot of money and treats her well she may indeed be set up for life and good luck to her. But it is by definition a gamble. It's a gamble that he will make good on his promise to support and protect her. It might work, but she has no control over it. Yes she would probably get a decent payout in a divorce (and she's welcome to it). But not without several years of pain and almost certainly involving uprooting her children in the process. And with roughly half of marriages ending in divorce, why would you want to hand that level of risk to someone else?

Hobbitfeet32 · 16/11/2023 17:57

@MrsSchrute I work 30 hours per week. In the last week I have volunteered on : occasions, twice at events my children have taken part in and once for a charity. I will be volunteering to help at a school sports event in a couple of weeks and volunteer at most PTA events.

Walkaround · 16/11/2023 17:57

It’s not what you do, it’s the way that you do it 😂.

MrsSchrute · 16/11/2023 17:54

Hobbitfeet32 · 16/11/2023 17:39

What exactly do SAHMs do that WOHMs don’t do if you have school age children?
I’m yet to see a post that specifies anything that working parents don’t do.

I used to be a SAHM, now I'm a WOHM.
When I was a SAHM I helped to run a weekly toddler group, went into school every week to hear children read, volunteered time for a number of charities, was a school governor etc.
Now I'm a WOHM I volunteer a little bit, but I don't do the other things.

That is the answer to your question in my case.

Lelophants · 16/11/2023 17:54

SisterHyster · 16/11/2023 17:50

You, evidently.

Yes, when someone’s nasty. Who gives a crap about someone else’s work status. So thankful my friends are nice people and we actually respect each other.

SisterHyster · 16/11/2023 17:50

Lelophants · 16/11/2023 17:47

When they go on about how much better they are than mum A and how much they do, they come across as over invested and jealous. Who gives a crap .

You, evidently.