Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'I do all these things AND work FT'

991 replies

Bumpitybumper · 15/11/2023 15:37

I see this on Mumsnet a lot but have just experienced it in real life. I have two friends (A&B). Friend A is a SAHM to school age kids and Friend B works FT in quite a stressful job. Friend B was just lamenting that they don't understand how Friend A fills her time as she manages to work FT AND do everything Friend A does.

The thing is, Friend B has a much smaller (yet lovely) house that is pretty chaotic in fun energetic way. It is never the tidiest or cleanest but it's not disgusting either. Friend A on the other hand has a much bigger house that is pretty immaculate most of the time. Friend A does all the school runs and volunteers at school. Friend B needs wraparound care in order to get to work so drops her kids of at 8 and collects around 17:30. Friend A cooks amazing meals for her family, has her children's friends round for fun playdates and activities and is generally incredibly on top of everything. Friend B is understandably more stretched and isn't in the position to cook lavish meals every day of the week or have friends round when she's at work. Friend B's husband does a lot (of course absolutely fair and right) so she doesn't have to attend every parents evening, sew all the badges for extracurricular clubs or assist with all the homework etc. Friend A does pretty much all of that as husband works such long hours.

I actually think both are amazing and very productive people that channel their energy, time and talent in different channels. I just struggle to understand though how Friend B can't appreciate that she isn't doing the same as Friend A or at least doing it to the same standard. Before people suggest I'm Friend A, I have my own business so don't really fit in either camp but used to be a SAHM so I guess can see Friend A's efforts more.

AIBU to think that Friend B is a bit deluded?

OP posts:
Walkaround · 18/11/2023 05:43

K4tM · 17/11/2023 23:58

Bring a SAHM is undervalued because it is unpaid.

If my partner was willing pay the bills, plus cover my NI, plus pay a decent amount of money into my pension (e.g. a percentage of my assumed income like 14%) I might consider being a SAHM.

Else I wouldn’t put myself in this extremely vulnerable position.

You could argue, money is the biggest misogynist of them all and capitalism the most masculine of all inventions.

Ilovecleaning · 18/11/2023 05:06

SisterHyster · 17/11/2023 21:01

I just ignored that because I didn’t think that level of ignorance even warranted my time; but since someone else brought it up …

In Scotland, we track every single pupil on two indicators of wealth - one is by postcode (which uses census data to rank each postcode on 10 measures of “wealth” such as education, income, health, housing quality) and the other is free meal entitlement.

My school has one of the highest proportion of pupils living in the the least wealthy 10% in the country, and one of the highest free school meal entitlements. So much so that we get specialist funding from the government due to the deprivation.

When I say “deprived” I don’t mean that daddy only has one Range Rover and they only got to go to the villa four times last year; I mean that many of my pupils will only eat this weekend if they get food from the food bank.

I’m glad you added this information about deprived areas. Your final sentence is heartbreaking and disturbing in modern Britain.

Bumpitybumper · 18/11/2023 02:56

SisterHyster · 17/11/2023 22:18

Well, a SAHP’s job as a SAHP only impacts their own family. They may have other roles like a volunteering role which also values wider society, but wider society doesn’t gain any value from parent A having a very clean and tidy house, or sewing on her badges to her children’s brownies uniform, or her cooking fine dining meals for her own children.

My job (and millions of other peoples job) value wider society because there is a massive recruitment and retention crisis, particularly in my subject area, and staff within my subject area are predominantly male; so given the national drive to improve uptake in STEM subjects in girls, a positive female role model in this field is a huge advantage to thousands of children (of both genders)

I actually didn’t choose to work in this school, but I won’t get into the detail of how recruitment of teachers in my area works. But it certainly wouldn’t have been my choice - I actually nearly turned it down, but I didn’t because I realised I was more needed where I am.

I have already explained my reasoning behind my post - it was in direct response to “there is more to life than work”

Nobody who is involved in education would make a wild statement like “deprivation is subjective” because it’s quite frankly ignorant, at best.

I would absolutely never work in the private sector, but if I did, then yes, I’d view my role as less important. Children of parents who can send their children to a private school already have a positive role model. They probably get breakfast, whether I bring it in or not. They probably have a safe place to do homework, whether I provide it or not, and they probably can afford a tutor if they need extra help.

So yes, some jobs are more important to society than others, like medical jobs, education, food supply, garbage disposal and such. SAHP may have a wider role which benefits society; but most of Parent A’s role is primarily only of benefit to those in her close circle.

I have said many times on this thread that it's very difficult to assign 'worth' to roles. We live in a society where salaries and social status often don't match perceived moral worthiness. Arguably in our hyper capitalist society, money talks and put simply, our society doesn't value you and your role as much as you seem to think they should.

You seem to be a strong believer in public duty and 'making a difference'. The reality is that most people I know don't have jobs that fit so neatly into your definition of worthwhile. They work in retail selling ethically questionable, unsustainable goods for tax dodgy corporations, they are no win no fee lawyers, they are marketing managers trying to persuade already cash strapped people to part with more money or they own restaurants selling delicious yet pretty unhealthy food. Most people are doing what they think is in the best interest of themselves and their family. Few people are as selfless and publicly minded as you. Being in employment or a SAHM doesn't really change that or automatically make one person more laudable than the other.

OP posts:
K4tM · 17/11/2023 23:58

Bring a SAHM is undervalued because it is unpaid.

If my partner was willing pay the bills, plus cover my NI, plus pay a decent amount of money into my pension (e.g. a percentage of my assumed income like 14%) I might consider being a SAHM.

Else I wouldn’t put myself in this extremely vulnerable position.

lizzy8230 · 17/11/2023 23:57

@TheKeatingFive
We need to understand the reasons why men (mostly) end up in these kinds of jobs and why women end up giving up their careers in these kinds of circumstances. And the first step in that process is acknowledging the reality of what's happening

Agree, it's all very well to talk about the world as we'd like it to be - and personally I'd like a world where it's absolutely the norm for men to do the nursery drop, or cook dinner or take a day off for a sick child as much as it's the norm for women. But we need to start from where we now which is that even in 2023 there's a woeful imbalance. I had my babies years ago, in the bad old days before there was paternity leave never mind shared parental leave, but despite this, dh worked hard at aiming for a balance so we both did child related and domestic stuff and also both worked. Children have two parents after all, and imo it's great for them to see both parents as carers and providers. But we certainly do need to understand the reason such vast gender inequality still exists when people become parents

Cubic · 17/11/2023 23:23

SisterHyster · 17/11/2023 22:18

Well, a SAHP’s job as a SAHP only impacts their own family. They may have other roles like a volunteering role which also values wider society, but wider society doesn’t gain any value from parent A having a very clean and tidy house, or sewing on her badges to her children’s brownies uniform, or her cooking fine dining meals for her own children.

My job (and millions of other peoples job) value wider society because there is a massive recruitment and retention crisis, particularly in my subject area, and staff within my subject area are predominantly male; so given the national drive to improve uptake in STEM subjects in girls, a positive female role model in this field is a huge advantage to thousands of children (of both genders)

I actually didn’t choose to work in this school, but I won’t get into the detail of how recruitment of teachers in my area works. But it certainly wouldn’t have been my choice - I actually nearly turned it down, but I didn’t because I realised I was more needed where I am.

I have already explained my reasoning behind my post - it was in direct response to “there is more to life than work”

Nobody who is involved in education would make a wild statement like “deprivation is subjective” because it’s quite frankly ignorant, at best.

I would absolutely never work in the private sector, but if I did, then yes, I’d view my role as less important. Children of parents who can send their children to a private school already have a positive role model. They probably get breakfast, whether I bring it in or not. They probably have a safe place to do homework, whether I provide it or not, and they probably can afford a tutor if they need extra help.

So yes, some jobs are more important to society than others, like medical jobs, education, food supply, garbage disposal and such. SAHP may have a wider role which benefits society; but most of Parent A’s role is primarily only of benefit to those in her close circle.

Your list of important roles in society misses the means by which they ate funded, the admin positions which facilitate the workforce, settings and equipment, the legal professionals which draw up the contracts, the bankers that handle the funds, the managers which make the decisions etc the roles you view as valuable to society wouldn't be viable without other roles which are less public facing. They are all valuable and all needed.

A society benefits in many different ways and requires a multi faceted approach to function. Whatever value you place on your job you shouldn't belittle someone else's choice. You write of children going without breakfast but berate parent A in the OP for ensuring her children have decent meals. If more parents did this you may not need to provide breakfast.

Allowing her husband to do whatever his job is may be more vital in your own scale of worth (long shot I know). He could have any number of roles which could possibly eclipse yours. This is her choice and his as a couple/ team. It works for them. If his role is deemed more vital or even critical in some way, their choice to split responsibilities in this way shouldn't demish her worth in the same way others who support your work shouldn't have their worth diminished.

She may be raising decent children who don't devalue others. You do not know.

I won't polish your halo and I'm grateful you don't teach my children. I'd hate for them to have a teacher who self idolises.

I wonder if for some women the need to justify their choices of either sah or woh is so great that they can't be open to the possibility that there are benefits to opposing views. They can't acknowledge the merits of alternative ways of doing things incase it diminishes in their mind what they choose and possibly what they've sacrificed.

TheKeatingFive · 17/11/2023 22:26

Yes but it shouldn’t, should it? By surrounding our language around men earning and women not, it perpetuates the stereotypes on both genders.

Increasingly I feel it's important to acknowledge the world as it is, rather than the world as we want it to be. I believe that is fundamental to effective change.

We need to understand the reasons why men (mostly) end up in these kinds of jobs and why women end up giving up their careers in these kinds of circumstances. And the first step in that process is acknowledging the reality of what's happening

SisterHyster · 17/11/2023 22:18

Cubic · 17/11/2023 21:58

You still haven't addressed why your job is more valuable to society than sahm and who has deemed it so.

You have chosen to work in your profession and applied to work in that school. I wonder if for you and part of the appeal is to appear more valuable in society whereas for some sahm their priorities are different.

Deprivation can be subjective while i appreciate there are quantifiers you can quote your wording read with the intention of highlighting your own importance. If you had the same position in an inde school would you have less impact on society and if so still more than sahm? You have no idea of the impact some sahm make on society. Many are unpaid carers and volunteers. Making statements about your own importance in comparison to strangers is ignorant "There is also more to life than being the best at scrubbing a toilet and sewing on Brownies badges. I do a job that actually matters to wider society.".

Well, a SAHP’s job as a SAHP only impacts their own family. They may have other roles like a volunteering role which also values wider society, but wider society doesn’t gain any value from parent A having a very clean and tidy house, or sewing on her badges to her children’s brownies uniform, or her cooking fine dining meals for her own children.

My job (and millions of other peoples job) value wider society because there is a massive recruitment and retention crisis, particularly in my subject area, and staff within my subject area are predominantly male; so given the national drive to improve uptake in STEM subjects in girls, a positive female role model in this field is a huge advantage to thousands of children (of both genders)

I actually didn’t choose to work in this school, but I won’t get into the detail of how recruitment of teachers in my area works. But it certainly wouldn’t have been my choice - I actually nearly turned it down, but I didn’t because I realised I was more needed where I am.

I have already explained my reasoning behind my post - it was in direct response to “there is more to life than work”

Nobody who is involved in education would make a wild statement like “deprivation is subjective” because it’s quite frankly ignorant, at best.

I would absolutely never work in the private sector, but if I did, then yes, I’d view my role as less important. Children of parents who can send their children to a private school already have a positive role model. They probably get breakfast, whether I bring it in or not. They probably have a safe place to do homework, whether I provide it or not, and they probably can afford a tutor if they need extra help.

So yes, some jobs are more important to society than others, like medical jobs, education, food supply, garbage disposal and such. SAHP may have a wider role which benefits society; but most of Parent A’s role is primarily only of benefit to those in her close circle.

lizzy8230 · 17/11/2023 22:06

@Cubic it's pointless to try to compare value between individuals because there are so many variables.

Like I said in my previous post, surely we can agree that good parenting is valuable (not being a parent per se, because sadly there are shit parents who don't nurture their children or worse, abuse them) Good parenting is done by WOHP and SAHP. Imo that's where the focus should be, not on whether a parent is working or not, but whether they are raising their children to become well adjusted, positive adults who will in turn be a valuable member of society.

And surely it also goes without saying (as a separate issue) that working is valuable in many ways too: tax payers benefit everyone by contributing to health, education and other services. And if on top of that a job has a wider social benefit (eg teacher, medic) then that's another layer of value.

Cubic · 17/11/2023 21:58

SisterHyster · 17/11/2023 21:01

I just ignored that because I didn’t think that level of ignorance even warranted my time; but since someone else brought it up …

In Scotland, we track every single pupil on two indicators of wealth - one is by postcode (which uses census data to rank each postcode on 10 measures of “wealth” such as education, income, health, housing quality) and the other is free meal entitlement.

My school has one of the highest proportion of pupils living in the the least wealthy 10% in the country, and one of the highest free school meal entitlements. So much so that we get specialist funding from the government due to the deprivation.

When I say “deprived” I don’t mean that daddy only has one Range Rover and they only got to go to the villa four times last year; I mean that many of my pupils will only eat this weekend if they get food from the food bank.

You still haven't addressed why your job is more valuable to society than sahm and who has deemed it so.

You have chosen to work in your profession and applied to work in that school. I wonder if for you and part of the appeal is to appear more valuable in society whereas for some sahm their priorities are different.

Deprivation can be subjective while i appreciate there are quantifiers you can quote your wording read with the intention of highlighting your own importance. If you had the same position in an inde school would you have less impact on society and if so still more than sahm? You have no idea of the impact some sahm make on society. Many are unpaid carers and volunteers. Making statements about your own importance in comparison to strangers is ignorant "There is also more to life than being the best at scrubbing a toilet and sewing on Brownies badges. I do a job that actually matters to wider society.".

lizzy8230 · 17/11/2023 21:06

If we're talking about value, surely what's valuable to society is children being raised well. Children being fed healthily, kept safe, in homes where education is valued, where decent principles are imparted etc.

It's good parenting that matters. Poor parenting is actually very damaging to society - it's damned expensive aside from anything else when you look at the consequences of anti social behaviour, poor mental health etc

The fact is, children can be raised well by WOHP and by SAHP. There is no one blueprint for how to raise children well. Let's value good parenting. And of course work is valuable too, particularly when it's something which has a direct social value - hats off to anyone who teaches an important subject in a deprived area.

SisterHyster · 17/11/2023 21:05

TheKeatingFive · 17/11/2023 20:49

That might be the case, but I think it’s important that we should take gender out of the discussion around wages.

I don't agree with you as gender plays a huge part in how this plays out. Overwhelmingly it is men who earn this kind of money and I don't think it helps the cause to pretend it's not happening.

From my own pov I'm pleased that the economic norms of where I am now encourage women staying in the workforce. We need to look at this holistically.

Yes but it shouldn’t, should it? By surrounding our language around men earning and women not, it perpetuates the stereotypes on both genders.

Instead, I prefer to say that where one partner is a high earner, the other may choose to stay at home.

It doesn’t even need to be about really high earners. I consider myself a high earner (49k) because in relation to cost of living in my area, that is pretty high. My partner earns more in line with the average salary here (a lot less than me) - yet there was still an assumption that I’d be the one to drop hours; purely because I have a vagina.

SisterHyster · 17/11/2023 21:01

Ilovecleaning · 17/11/2023 20:48

‘A deprived area’ is not a subjective opinion. Deprived areas are defined by unemployment, crime rate, amount of social housing, children on free school meals…
To say nothing of the number of boarded up shops, charity shops, kebab shops, betting shops, lack of parks and libraries - definitely not a subjective opinion.

I just ignored that because I didn’t think that level of ignorance even warranted my time; but since someone else brought it up …

In Scotland, we track every single pupil on two indicators of wealth - one is by postcode (which uses census data to rank each postcode on 10 measures of “wealth” such as education, income, health, housing quality) and the other is free meal entitlement.

My school has one of the highest proportion of pupils living in the the least wealthy 10% in the country, and one of the highest free school meal entitlements. So much so that we get specialist funding from the government due to the deprivation.

When I say “deprived” I don’t mean that daddy only has one Range Rover and they only got to go to the villa four times last year; I mean that many of my pupils will only eat this weekend if they get food from the food bank.

TheKeatingFive · 17/11/2023 20:49

That might be the case, but I think it’s important that we should take gender out of the discussion around wages.

I don't agree with you as gender plays a huge part in how this plays out. Overwhelmingly it is men who earn this kind of money and I don't think it helps the cause to pretend it's not happening.

From my own pov I'm pleased that the economic norms of where I am now encourage women staying in the workforce. We need to look at this holistically.

Ilovecleaning · 17/11/2023 20:48

Cubic · 17/11/2023 19:42

Is there a hierarchy of of what careers/ jobs which are more valuable to society? Furthermore is it only certain people who a debt to society or is it everyone?

Should we all fawn over the stem teacher above who in her eyes teaches in a deprived area (a subjective opinion)? A job I'm guessing she had to agree to take and can leave? Is part of the appeal of these jobs that you may be viewed in a saintly way?

Ultimately especially when discussing careers where you need a specialist qualification to work these people have chosen to do that job, train to do it. Why are their choices more valid than a sahm?

We all have choices and make decisions based on our situations. I certainly wouldn't hold someone in higher regard because of their career as opposed to their morality/ personality.

‘A deprived area’ is not a subjective opinion. Deprived areas are defined by unemployment, crime rate, amount of social housing, children on free school meals…
To say nothing of the number of boarded up shops, charity shops, kebab shops, betting shops, lack of parks and libraries - definitely not a subjective opinion.

Walkaround · 17/11/2023 20:42

SouthLondonMum22 · 17/11/2023 19:37

It is true though. Men aren't held to the same standard as women and it's a reason why it is women who often give up their careers or go part time when they become parents.

Men simply aren't expected to.

Yes, of course it is true that men are not held to the same standard, but women also need to take some responsibility for the harm they cause when they undermine and shame each other and then try to blame it all on men. I don’t have to reference men or fathers every single time I tell the world what I enjoy and want to do with my life. After all, men aren’t expected to do so…

SisterHyster · 17/11/2023 20:35

TheKeatingFive · 17/11/2023 20:23

Do they check for a penis at job interviews in London? High flying careers aren’t exclusive to men, and average careers aren’t exclusive to wives.

Totally agree with you in terms of how it should be, but in my experience this overwhelmingly how it works out.

I know of plenty of couples where they earn around the same, or one earns a bit more than the other. But if the pay differential is substantial (millions versus 40k for example) I've only ever seen that one way.

I'm only reporting only my own experience here, btw.

That might be the case, but I think it’s important that we should take gender out of the discussion around wages. Instead, I think it would be better to frame this around one parent earning more than the other. It just perpetuates stereotypes about important men with wives who might work for a little bit pocket money, but in the grand scheme of things they aren’t really valuable in the workforce.

Cinty6 · 17/11/2023 20:26

SisterHyster · 17/11/2023 20:17

Do they check for a penis at job interviews in London? High flying careers aren’t exclusive to men, and average careers aren’t exclusive to wives.

Apparently so in my husband’s firm and profession since there are chronically few women sadly!

TheKeatingFive · 17/11/2023 20:23

Do they check for a penis at job interviews in London? High flying careers aren’t exclusive to men, and average careers aren’t exclusive to wives.

Totally agree with you in terms of how it should be, but in my experience this overwhelmingly how it works out.

I know of plenty of couples where they earn around the same, or one earns a bit more than the other. But if the pay differential is substantial (millions versus 40k for example) I've only ever seen that one way.

I'm only reporting only my own experience here, btw.

TheKeatingFive · 17/11/2023 20:18

This is what I find to be problematic. I'm in London, I have the higher salary (though, to be fair, my husband has a higher than average salary) but it never occurred to my husband to 'make the case' to keep working. He just carried on working.

Yes agreed. This is a different conversation for men and women.

SisterHyster · 17/11/2023 20:17

TheKeatingFive · 17/11/2023 19:59

agree, a lot comes down to the men we decide to procreate with

It also depends on the economic norms of where you live.

I knew of more SAHM in London, because there are more husbands with huge salaries and therefore it's challenging for wives on average salaries to make the case to keep working.

Im now in Dublin. The big massive jobs exist, but there are fewer of them. Housing is still very expensive, so two incomes are generally needed to pay the mortgage. In my social circle, men know they have to facilitate their wives jobs for the sake of family finances. So they step up.

Do they check for a penis at job interviews in London? High flying careers aren’t exclusive to men, and average careers aren’t exclusive to wives.

SouthLondonMum22 · 17/11/2023 20:11

TheKeatingFive · 17/11/2023 19:59

agree, a lot comes down to the men we decide to procreate with

It also depends on the economic norms of where you live.

I knew of more SAHM in London, because there are more husbands with huge salaries and therefore it's challenging for wives on average salaries to make the case to keep working.

Im now in Dublin. The big massive jobs exist, but there are fewer of them. Housing is still very expensive, so two incomes are generally needed to pay the mortgage. In my social circle, men know they have to facilitate their wives jobs for the sake of family finances. So they step up.

I knew of more SAHM in London, because there are more husbands with huge salaries and therefore it's challenging for wives on average salaries to make the case to keep working.

This is what I find to be problematic. I'm in London, I have the higher salary (though, to be fair, my husband has a higher than average salary) but it never occurred to my husband to 'make the case' to keep working. He just carried on working.

Cinty6 · 17/11/2023 20:05

TheKeatingFive · 17/11/2023 19:59

agree, a lot comes down to the men we decide to procreate with

It also depends on the economic norms of where you live.

I knew of more SAHM in London, because there are more husbands with huge salaries and therefore it's challenging for wives on average salaries to make the case to keep working.

Im now in Dublin. The big massive jobs exist, but there are fewer of them. Housing is still very expensive, so two incomes are generally needed to pay the mortgage. In my social circle, men know they have to facilitate their wives jobs for the sake of family finances. So they step up.

I knew of more SAHM in London, because there are more husbands with huge salaries and therefore it's challenging for wives on average salaries to make the case to keep working.

My experience of London too. Also, many Londoners don’t have family around to help out with pick ups and things as they may be up North or abroad for two people in a couple which is the case with us.

TheKeatingFive · 17/11/2023 19:59

agree, a lot comes down to the men we decide to procreate with

It also depends on the economic norms of where you live.

I knew of more SAHM in London, because there are more husbands with huge salaries and therefore it's challenging for wives on average salaries to make the case to keep working.

Im now in Dublin. The big massive jobs exist, but there are fewer of them. Housing is still very expensive, so two incomes are generally needed to pay the mortgage. In my social circle, men know they have to facilitate their wives jobs for the sake of family finances. So they step up.

lizzy8230 · 17/11/2023 19:47

@SisterHyster agree, a lot comes down to the men we decide to procreate with. My dh enjoyed being with our children as much as I did, he was also equally good at domestic chores. We met at university; I was as well qualified as him and just as competent in the workplace. Worked for us to both have a great balance rather than one being sole earner and one taking on all the children and home responsibilities