Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know I partially am... But I think DH is too

258 replies

feelingstucktoday · 15/11/2023 10:17

Without a massive drip feed my DH hasn't historically shown to "be there for me" it was not until an ultimatum that he started to change. He HAS improved but ultimately him being s completely different person has been fairly recent (from late June this year).

So I have to travel abroad to finally collect my inheritance. Due to local laws I have to go and do it myself. It's worth £200k and will pay the mortgage. I have to wait on my own while the bank transfer is cleared and I really don't want to be on my own while that is processing.

So my DH first reply was "No" that's his usual reply to most requests (in the past) and then I have to convince him about why it's a good idea or not.... As always he eventually came around and said that he'll come with me.

He however doesn't understand that I shouldn't have to convince him to do things with me if there's no direct benefit to him.

Bottom line, given its exceptional circumstances surely his work would just let him come with me? I get they might say no. If somebody died it wouldn't be as questionable, but I have nobody else to die - hence the inheritance. It's just that it was stuck in limbo for many many years

OP posts:
TayeuxBapestry · 15/11/2023 12:54

2jacqi · 15/11/2023 12:38

@feelingstucktoday what country do you have to go to?? most solicitors, even foreign ones, pay things via bank transfer nowadays!! I have been paid without solicitor setting eyes on me and my husband is paid via bank transfer from foreign solicitors to his legal business in uk! there is no reason why you cant do this without travelling abroad and if they refuse to do it without sight of you then they have to change the date to accomodate you. There is also no reason for you not to do this on your own!!!! I would also advise NOT paying off the mortgage with your inheritance!!!!!!

Edited

I wonder if it’s Spain? My parents still had money in Spain after they left and it was complicated to get it sorted out and they had to be there in person.

TayeuxBapestry · 15/11/2023 12:49

This may not be the point, but I’d kill to ditch my DH and toddler for a week away by myself! Especially to pick up £200k, I’d be chomping at the bit. I’d relax, sleep, read, sightsee, it would be lush. Unfortunately this would never happen for me, so I can only dream 😂

from your posts I think it sounds like he has been shit in the past but I think YABU this time. Also, if he put the work in and changed after you gave him an ultimatum you have to forgive and forget. You can’t keep battering him with old wounds. Have you had therapy at all to help you both move forward?

billy1966 · 15/11/2023 12:46

Thedm · 15/11/2023 11:53

It doesn’t matter where the money is. The money itself is a marital asset and would still be split however they decided in mediation or by a judge.

I honestly thought if an inheritance WASN'T ploughed into a shared asset like a morgage etc., it could be protected.

If I was the OP, I would still be putting it into a sole account and getting legal advice.

I wouldn't be paying off a shared morgage with someone who treats me poorly.

StrictlyComeSnoozing · 15/11/2023 12:44

You aren't unreasonable to expect your husband to be more supportive.

You are being unreasonable to have expectations of his employer to just let him go abroad for something he doesn't especially need to be there for. It isn't akin to a death, it is admin which doesn't require him to be there. I have a pretty laid back employer and couldn't foresee them being overly enthusiastic or positive if I requested this. If he's using annual leave, and he's not requesting it outside of policy then its nobodies business.

LogicVoid · 15/11/2023 12:41

You realise you don't have to put your inheritance into the marital pot..? As your relationship isn't stable, it might be wise to take advice on this.

Baffledandalarmed · 15/11/2023 12:41

Oh, you are so V unreasonable.

You want him there to be an emotional dumping ground for you because you don't want to be alone. That's fine. But you guilt tripped him into it when he didn't have any annual leave left to take and now you're complaining about him not jumping for joy at being asked to be your emotional dumping ground for a week.

We've all had to do horrible things alone before. Most of us manage to do it without needing someone there.

Your past issues with your DP and hurt over your bereavement (for which you have my condolences) is probably clouding your judgment here.

Edit: Just seen your update about telling him you spoke to your friend about him and him being upset! I'd have been really hurt if that was my DP slagging me off to a mate and then telling me about it. Tbh the more you post the more unreasonable I think you are. You're coming across as whiny and manipulative - it appears to be 'I want this and my DP must do it.'

feelingstucktoday · 15/11/2023 12:40

And yes I thought if treating it like a business trip too! I even thought of waiting in a 3rd country and having a "mini break".

Considering how costly it is to bring him, I thought eff it I might as well buy a neverfull/ go to the spa every day, etc... but ultimately with my ex husband it was the same. In 8-9 years together he wouldn't go unless we were doing something apart from visiting family and even then he wouldn't come, because he didn't like them that much (he did come twice in all of those years). When I met my now husband I did tell him how unsupported by my ex I felt, and he said he understood.

I also had a chat with a friend (that he knows) that I only used as a reference that he didn't immediately changed his mind (because he claimed it was almost instant and didn't need persuading) and then he started going on about how he needed to talk to her because "I was misrepresenting his character".

OP posts:
TheClitterati · 15/11/2023 12:39

you could always seperate from him before you collect the inheritence and use the ££ to buy a new house on your own without him.

Just saying ....

wildlifeobserver1 · 15/11/2023 12:38

YABU. Your husband has no AL left, and I would not be granting an employee unpaid leave for a reason such as this. I understand he does not want to ask his employer, as taking unpaid leave for something like that, is quite far reaching and does not leave a good impression.

I think your judgement on this situation is clouded because of previous issues in your relationship.

2jacqi · 15/11/2023 12:38

feelingstucktoday · 15/11/2023 10:49

I'm fine with flying on my own. But it's more of being a foreigner in the city that I was raised in but have nothing left there

@feelingstucktoday what country do you have to go to?? most solicitors, even foreign ones, pay things via bank transfer nowadays!! I have been paid without solicitor setting eyes on me and my husband is paid via bank transfer from foreign solicitors to his legal business in uk! there is no reason why you cant do this without travelling abroad and if they refuse to do it without sight of you then they have to change the date to accomodate you. There is also no reason for you not to do this on your own!!!! I would also advise NOT paying off the mortgage with your inheritance!!!!!!

Lochness1975 · 15/11/2023 12:37

I was going to vote unreasonable but seeing your update a week off is a big ask, I know my employer would say no- to much would needed to be cancelled/rearranged.

I do know that my dp would not make me go by myself, he would come with me- he’s even taken days off to drive me to interviews (he’s self employed and I drive long distances for my job so not as I’m in scared of driving anywhere) as he likes to support me in what I’m doing and be there for me.

steppemum · 15/11/2023 12:36

I understand why you want emotional support, but he has no AL left and you want him to take a week!

Sometimes life just doesn't allow for us to have what we want.

Obviously there is some communication between you that you can both work on.
It seems as if he doesn't really understand when you need emotional support, but also you seem to want him to understand without explaining.
He could learn to say - I understand that this is important to you, let me think about it.
You could learn to ask him in a way that let's him know that it matters without manipulating or expecting him to mind read.
My dh is pragmatic, 'no need for both of us to go' type of person. I have learnt to ask without drama - actually I would like you to come for emotional support - would that be possible?

I would say that you need to plan something to give the week a purpose. You grew up there but you ds won't, and by the sounds of it he might never visit. So why not make a project of documenting the city/country for him? Make a photo book? Mummy's life in Otherland. Here is the house I grew up in, and this is the local park. Look in Otherland we have wild monkeys in the park, I used to feed them buts when I was a kid and one time.....

Or whatever. Come home with a camera full of memories and stories to make into a book to share with your kids.

Alopeciabop · 15/11/2023 12:36

Aw this is sad. Of course you’re feeling vulnerable and would like someone with you to hold your hand for emotional support. It sounds like you’ve lost the last real connection to the place you were raised and that must be a very odd and disconcerting feeling.

you want someone to understand and care about that - this should be your husband but it sounds like he is generally quite unsympathetic towards you anyway.

It sounds like you need to reconsider the marriage - plenty of me would support you - this man is not. And it isn’t the actual physical going with you that’s really the issue, it’s the fact he doesn’t really want to - he can’t be bothered and it would make his life harder.

sometimes someone can’t be physically there for us, but the intent to help means the world.

💐

GarlicMaybeNot · 15/11/2023 12:31

you've been unable to let go what happened in the past because you don't think he's really changed - and that's because he hasn't. Maybe before you go abroad, have a meeting with a solicitor and a financial advisor to see if you can ringfence the inheritance in some way

Strongly agree.

InSpainTheRain · 15/11/2023 12:30

I can't see any work just giving time off to wait in another country for paperwork that isn't their own. If you don't feel unsafe then I do t see the issue to be honest.

However you don't seem to value your husband and if he is not the right one for you then I assume you won't be paying off the mortgage if it's in joint names?

MrsHarrisAParis · 15/11/2023 12:27

It's not really that he said 'no' because that's understandable if he has no AL. The problem is what you've shared in your last post - once you mentioned a nice hotel and a beach, he became motivated to ask his work for extra leave. That would make me unhappy.
As I said earlier, I wouldn't expect my DH to go with me. But if he said no then suddenly became more amenable if I bribed him with a hotel and a pool - I'd be really pissed off. Either he can't go or he can. But if anything is going to motivate him to ask for more leave, it should be supporting his DW not the lure of a fancy holiday.
I think OP you've been unable to let go what happened in the past because you don't think he's really changed - and that's because he hasn't. Maybe before you go abroad, have a meeting with a solicitor and a financial advisor to see if you can ringfence the inheritance in some way eg putting it into a trust for your DC.

anotherweek · 15/11/2023 12:26

If you were raised there then surely (even if you've nothing left in terms of living relatives or friends) you are familiar with the place, know your way around, the language and customs. You are not a complete stranger in what you have called your country and say you feel safe enough there.
Sure, there's some emotion around feeling it's closing a chapter in your life but it's all doable. As the saying goes....get your big girl pants on! Your DH doesn't have to come for this one if he's out of AL. The other stuff about you having to twist his arm all the time to do what you want is a bigger issue.

category12 · 15/11/2023 12:25

If you don't feel like your relationship is particularly great or that he's supportive to you generally, maybe you should think twice about paying off the mortgage or at least get legal advice before you do so.

I don't think he'd automatically have a claim on your inheritance as it is, but putting it into a shared marital asset like the family home would change that. I'd think about whether you se this marriage going the distance, or whether you might someday be glad if you ringfenced your inheritance.

LAMPS1 · 15/11/2023 12:24

Does your DH know how you feel about going back there for a final time…how sad and bereft that makes you feel ? Or are you just expecting him to instinctively know and be feeling your grief with you, without talking about it properly ?
A lot of men just can’t automatically relate to this sort of complicated deep emotion.

If he does know, and if he just doesn’t care about your feelings, then I would think hard about my future with him anyway.
If he really can’t get time off work then at least he tried. You surely wouldn’t want him to lose his job over your fear of facing this sadness alone.

OP I think you may well have to gather your strength and courage to go alone anyway and it would be much better to actively plan yourself a leisurely week in a nice hotel than to drag your uncaring/unwilling husband there if he can’t/doesn’t want to understand why you need him. That would be worse.
Maybe the city has changed and you can discover new things?
Keep yourself busy and hopefully the time will soon fly by. Good luck !

RB68 · 15/11/2023 12:24

I think his approach to the discussion is unreasonable esp comment re no direct benefit!!! HOWEVER sometimes holiday runs out, we have to be grown up s and do stull we don't like or make us feel emotionally drained and we just have to get on with it. Expecting him to take an absence from work when he has no annual leave left is unreasonable, but I get the emotional upheaval of it all and whilst it would be nice to have a hand hold, it just doesn't sound possible here. There is your Son to consider as well, if DH comes with you what happens with him?

Mymilkshakebringsallthepapstomycar · 15/11/2023 12:21

I would spend the time thinking about whether I wanted to shackle myself for the rest of my life to someone who isn't there for me emotionally. Is your marriage otherwise what you want and what you envisaged your life would be like? Don't be too quick to put that money into the mortgage if the need is not urgent. Inheritances are not necessarily "family money". It would provide a lifeline for you to make changes if you want to.

DisquietintheRanks · 15/11/2023 12:19

feelingstucktoday · 15/11/2023 12:07

So I had to persuade him... So said things like "maybe if we go to the beach while we wait" or "I'll get a nice hotel with a pool" then he started considering it.

The whole point is that instead of saying "no, because of X,Hz" he could have just said "I'll ask my boss, you know how he is, but also I understand how important/difficult it is for you so I'll try my best"

If you insist on scripting other people's responses you are always going to be disappointed in them.

GarlicMaybeNot · 15/11/2023 12:18

AliasGrape · 15/11/2023 10:53

I think that's understandable and people are being a bit harsh calling you ridiculous - it WILL feel strange and sad I'm sure.

How long will you need to be there?

He's said he will come now, and if that's really what you feel like you need then take him up on it.

Practically/ logically it would make far more sense for him to stay home though - but sometimes these things bring up big emotions and there's nothing wrong with that. Do you feel supported emotionally by him/ able to talk about how this is all making you feel/ like he's concerned and caring about what this might be bringing up for you - I wonder if he could show a bit more of that side you wouldn't feel so much like he needs to physically be there on the day.

Agree with this. You aren't really being unreasonable, just a bit fragile in a very specific situation. I think a husband would ideally want to make things easier for you at such a time.

This is a tad confusing, @feelingstucktoday: It's worth £200k and will pay the mortgage. ... I shouldn't have to convince him to do things with me if there's no direct benefit to him

Clearing the mortgage isn't a direct benefit to him? I'd think holding your wife's hand for a day in exchange for becoming mortgage-free is a good deal!

I'm sorry about his failure to support you with the cancer, too; that must have felt like a body blow. All told, your DH sounds like a selfish arsehole to me, but that isn't what you asked.

Luxell934 · 15/11/2023 12:15

I can understand why you would want your family there for support.

but if your husband has no annual leave left then what do you want him to do? Can you afford to have him take it unpaid? What if he can’t take it unpaid? Risk losing his job? Call in sick?

Ebee19 · 15/11/2023 12:14

I think here is nothing wrong with you wanting emotional support, that is understandable. I also think this hurts more because of his history in behaviour. However, it sounds like practicalities might make this one impossible (whether that is his motive or not). I would say for you to go on your own and try to have a nice time - bar picking up the inheritance, treat it like a nice trip away. It's a shame he can't be there with you but it is probably a long time since you had a trip to yourself. I would however say a major aspect in this, if your marriage is going badly - why would you be putting this money into paying off your mortgage? I would say to put it into savings so that you have a way to leave your husband if you are really not happy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread