Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know I partially am... But I think DH is too

258 replies

feelingstucktoday · 15/11/2023 10:17

Without a massive drip feed my DH hasn't historically shown to "be there for me" it was not until an ultimatum that he started to change. He HAS improved but ultimately him being s completely different person has been fairly recent (from late June this year).

So I have to travel abroad to finally collect my inheritance. Due to local laws I have to go and do it myself. It's worth £200k and will pay the mortgage. I have to wait on my own while the bank transfer is cleared and I really don't want to be on my own while that is processing.

So my DH first reply was "No" that's his usual reply to most requests (in the past) and then I have to convince him about why it's a good idea or not.... As always he eventually came around and said that he'll come with me.

He however doesn't understand that I shouldn't have to convince him to do things with me if there's no direct benefit to him.

Bottom line, given its exceptional circumstances surely his work would just let him come with me? I get they might say no. If somebody died it wouldn't be as questionable, but I have nobody else to die - hence the inheritance. It's just that it was stuck in limbo for many many years

OP posts:
feelingstucktoday · 16/11/2023 07:14

Cnidarian · 16/11/2023 05:00

If not having enough leave remaining due to his workplace policy and it is directly impacting the family regularly he should consider another role. However in this scenario he has no leave, of course he can't just take a day off to come with you.

And we have talked about this ad nauseam but it's an OK job for his skills and we don't think he could get anything better.

He asked his workplace and they've agreed for that week off as long as he pays is back before Christmas.

OP posts:
Cnidarian · 16/11/2023 05:00

If not having enough leave remaining due to his workplace policy and it is directly impacting the family regularly he should consider another role. However in this scenario he has no leave, of course he can't just take a day off to come with you.

Hibiscrubbed · 16/11/2023 04:47

So this inheritance will pay off his mortgage and his default is still ‘no’ to any help you ask for?

He sounds like a prick to be honest if his default to anything you ask or say is no. It’s weird.

Somewhereoverthersinbowweighapie · 16/11/2023 00:55

That’s awful. I can understand why you would want support. Pay to take a friend. Then keep the money separate, from the families money. Just keep a little next egg as you will probably want it in the future.

Rufusroo · 15/11/2023 22:47

He sounds just like my DH! His default answer is always ‘No’. Unless, of course, it was HIS idea. Eventually I got really fed up with his negativity - my sister invited us to their new house in France and we had planned a special trip to the Battlefields to trace the story of where our grandfather was killed in WW1. I really wanted to go but he said no and put so many obstacles in the way. He was totally shocked when I said “Fine! I’ll go on my own” and proceeded to make all the arrangements for just myself. He then had to plead and wheedle to be allowed to accompany us🤣🤣. I understand how frustrating it is to always have to cajole them

babyproblems · 15/11/2023 21:46

the only thing I can think of is that he could ask for unpaid leave. I don’t see why they’d refuse that unless his workload is something really totally essential and no cover whatsoever. He should be more prepared to support you in things that life brings; you say this wouldn’t benefit him but erm if you’re married it is both of yours so it is beneficial to him also..

AcrossthePond55 · 15/11/2023 19:58

feelingstucktoday · 15/11/2023 18:07

No, no. He's al ays have had a broad idea of it...

And I have stayed with him because overall if I don't have to ask for any special help these days, we live a happy loving life. He's definitely changed over time

Actually, you aren't living a 'happy, loving life'. You're living a life of walking on eggshells and knowing that the one person who is supposed to be there for you absolutely isn't. Unless, of course, there's 'something in it for him'. To me that's living a 'lonely, unloved life'.

Of course we can't expect our spouse to run at our beck and call for every little thing. For example, I wouldn't expect my DH to attend my routine doctor visits, tests, and the like. But I'm currently undergoing treatment for a blood disorder. DH was with me through every Dr's appt from the initial 'what's wrong with me' visit up through the first three treatment sessions. Why? Because he wanted to be there because he knew I was frightened and because the treatment can have side effects that might have left me unable to drive home (I'm fine with driving). I didn't have to ask, I didn't have to promise him a 'treat' like he was a fucking 2 year old child! I've told him that now I'm good to drive but I know if I need him to drive me, he'll do it with no complaint. As I did for him during his cancer treatment and will do again if need be.

When my parents died, he was my rock. He kept the home fires burning through those last days and was always there with 'What do you need?'. That's what a good spouse does.

Remember, you can be far lonelier living with the wrong person than you'll ever feel actually on your own. I'm not telling you to leave, just telling you to think about the rest of your life. What is going to happen when you get old and your health fails, your mobility starts to go, your memory fades. Is this a man who will care for you tenderly?

76evie · 15/11/2023 19:00

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable, sounds like you want/need emotional support from your husband. I think he is being unreasonable to be honest, he could at least speak to work and see if he could sort something out. Hope you’re ok.

batsandeggs · 15/11/2023 18:36

It sounds like your initial question has kind of been misrepresented. It sounds like you’re upset that he’s not coming, yes, but more so that he’s not showing you any emotional support or making any sort of effort to seek a resolution to this that would be helpful to you. He doesn’t seem to recognise that this is going to be an incredibly difficult experience for you and that you need some support. Even his response to you asking seems emotionless - even if it’s impossible for him to go from a work perspective, it’s how this is communicated and how he supports you DESPITE not being able to physically go that makes the difference. He doesn’t seem capable of giving you what you need, despite any recent changes he might have shown you. You can’t change who someone fundamentally is.

billy1966 · 15/11/2023 18:21

feelingstucktoday · 15/11/2023 18:07

No, no. He's al ays have had a broad idea of it...

And I have stayed with him because overall if I don't have to ask for any special help these days, we live a happy loving life. He's definitely changed over time

So if you behave yourself and ask NOTHING of him?

Arsehole.

billy1966 · 15/11/2023 18:20

OP, clearly you have tolerated very poor behaviour from him and have bent yourself out of shape trying forgive and move on.

Why?

He's an arsehole.

Is his 5 month effort connected to your inheritance?

He's an arsehole to his core.

That mask he is trying to maintain will always slip because at his core he is a selfish man that is primarily focused on himself.

You have had a child with an arsehole, that won't change.

Protect yourself and protect your inheritance.

You are being spectacular naive if you don't.

Get legal advice and lodge that money into YOUR account only.

Cornettoninja · 15/11/2023 18:10

Ever since I told him he had to be the "best boy"

is that the actual language you used? That’s incredibly patronising and infantile imho.

Look, you can’t change someone from who they are into who you’d like them to be. On that note you should just arrange this trip for yourself and use the time to consider whether you’re in a marriage or a project. It sounds to me like you’d be happier out of this relationship.

feelingstucktoday · 15/11/2023 18:07

No, no. He's al ays have had a broad idea of it...

And I have stayed with him because overall if I don't have to ask for any special help these days, we live a happy loving life. He's definitely changed over time

OP posts:
Ktime · 15/11/2023 17:36

But yes for almost 5 months now his behaviour has been I would say exceptional. And even up to this point I would just have been annoyed but not taken 20 steps back if he had just shown actual empathy from day one.

Did this exceptional behaviour start around the time he found out how much your inheritance is going to be?

TayeuxBapestry · 15/11/2023 17:16

Fifth and final time of asking; OP why are you with your husband?

Shodan · 15/11/2023 17:02

I think, OP, that you have to accept that you haven't forgiven him for his past poor behaviour (and it sounds like it was pretty awful), and that this brief period of behaving like a decent husband (and human being) is just a pretence.

Let's face it, if he didn't have a history of basically refusing your requests for his support ( and it's pretty sad that you even had to ask for it in the first place, rather than it being freely given), you probably would have been mildly irked, at most, by his inability to accompany you this time.

As it is, it is just a reminder that at any moment he will behave boorishly , as he did 'before', when he sees no direct benefit to him.

I would suggest giving the future of this marriage a serious think.

feelingstucktoday · 15/11/2023 16:56

But he never has any AL left! Part of the problem is that his company makes them use 10 days of AL around Christmas as that's their policy.

Around 10 are to be used around the DC holidays and the 5 left over are for random needs.

We have exactly the same number of days if AL, but my company doesn't close so don't have the same issues

OP posts:
Loverofoxbowlakes · 15/11/2023 16:51

feelingstucktoday · 15/11/2023 15:10

But I CANNOT go any time... The date has been given by that court I have zero say over it.

And unfortunately your dp has ZERO say in his employer giving him ADDITIONAL leave (paid or unpaid).

You travel alone 'all the time'. So do it again this time, and go back to visit to say your proper goodbyes when your dh IS available. Don't be pissed off that he can't go due to work commitments. I'd get sacked if I took off unauthorised time (teacher, set holidays, no unpaid leave for this sort of thing).

feelingstucktoday · 15/11/2023 16:50

Well this is VERY minor in terms of what he's done in the past. He still went on in ways that I didn't appreciate instead of either trying to yes work something out or saying "Wel I understand it's important but my hands are tied". He showed zero empathy when he first said no.

But yes for almost 5 months now his behaviour has been I would say exceptional. And even up to this point I would just have been annoyed but not taken 20 steps back if he had just shown actual empathy from day one.

Because to ME his behaviour was still the same as before - not interested unless I get something back- .

Even a couple of weeks ago, I figured out that during his "bad boy" days he did something I would have thought unforgivable at the time, but it's in the past. So as much as I was sad and disappointed I didn't make a big deal out if it.

OP posts:
PortalooSunset · 15/11/2023 16:44

feelingstucktoday · 15/11/2023 12:07

So I had to persuade him... So said things like "maybe if we go to the beach while we wait" or "I'll get a nice hotel with a pool" then he started considering it.

The whole point is that instead of saying "no, because of X,Hz" he could have just said "I'll ask my boss, you know how he is, but also I understand how important/difficult it is for you so I'll try my best"

Are you saying that if he'd used the weasel words of "I'll see what I can do" but ultimately the answer was no and the situation was as is, with you going alone, you'd actually have been happy? Even though there's realistically no difference and he might have just told you that without even bothering to check with work because he knew he had no leave left?

Ffsnotaconference · 15/11/2023 16:42

feelingstucktoday · 15/11/2023 16:19

I've never said that he can't say "no" to me. He can say it plenty of times. And he does.

What I'm asking of him is to not just give a straight "no" as the first answer for any special request that I might have... He can still say no but phrase it differently that's all. At least so I can feel that he cares, and not that he's doing things because he'll get something in exchange

But he can’t. You said above you want the answer to be ‘let me look into it’.

But that’s beside the point. You didn’t answer the question. You told him he needed to be perfect. There must have been an ultimatum attached to it. ‘Be the best boy or things will carry in exactly the same and I will do nothing’ doesn’t mean anything. There’s got to have been a consequence to him not behaving how you feel is ‘best’.

Are you willing to do whatever the ‘or else’ and carry out what you said would happen? You feel he hasn’t been the ‘best boy’. So what’s happens now?

Do you think you maybe don’t want to with him. His efforts are too little to late and you have been (subconsciously) waiting for him to do something that means he isn’t the ‘best boy’, so you can follow through with the ultimatum?

SophieStew · 15/11/2023 16:41

NoSquirrels · 15/11/2023 15:30

I understand you feel unsupported. But you are being unreasonable, you know this. Most people can’t just take time off work unpaid on a fixed date for a week or more at short-ish notice if they have no annual leave left.

I think you should work on changing your own mindset on this, rather than feeling upset that your DH cannot come. Make it a ‘proper goodbye’ - enjoy your week in your home country, treat yourself to whatever you need to make good, happy memories rather than dwelling on the grief of a ‘final goodbye’. In time you can take your DS to visit and that will create more happy memories too.

This is good advice.

I get the impression OP just wants DH to cave to her demands as some kind of recompense for past sins, or to evidence that he’s a “changed man”

TayeuxBapestry · 15/11/2023 16:37

Asking again OP - why are you with your husband?

tenterden · 15/11/2023 16:37

feelingstucktoday · 15/11/2023 16:19

I've never said that he can't say "no" to me. He can say it plenty of times. And he does.

What I'm asking of him is to not just give a straight "no" as the first answer for any special request that I might have... He can still say no but phrase it differently that's all. At least so I can feel that he cares, and not that he's doing things because he'll get something in exchange

This sounds ridiculous.

He is either a crap husband who has let you down dreadfully when you needed him most. Or he’s so wonderful you want to renew your vows?

Which is it?

MidnightOnceMore · 15/11/2023 16:37

I understand @feelingstucktoday

This is a big emotional thing you have to do, and you'd like some support, you'd like to not be alone.

My DH would go with me if he could, no question. And I'd go with him if I could, no question. Because we just support each other if we can. If work said no, we'd understand and rethink.

You've hit a deep vein of empathy-free posters here for some reason.