Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS keeps being moved at school

261 replies

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 09:27

Ds has recently gone into year 2 and has had a brand new teacher. He previously had the same teacher from nursery to year 1 and he was doing so well in school. He was getting star pupil every week loved his teacher and he was progressing so well.

New teacher keeps moving him pretty much everyday and the reasons he is giving us seem petty unless he is lying but I have no reason not to believe him. She hasn’t contacted us to tell us he’s been messing around or everything and we see her everyday.

We paid £100 for him to go on a school trip and when we picked him up he looked so sad my heart broke for him. He eventually told us that she told him he was being rude for kicking a paper towel and made him sit at the front of the coach away from his friends.

He went into school this morning and she said hi “DS” and he just walked past her. We also seen her on bonfire night and he didn’t even want to say hi then either. I have never seen him like this before ever.

Something in my gut isn’t sitting right! Surely if he was misbehaving so badly we would have some kind of contact? He is a good kid never had any issues with him ever.

OP posts:
NightAndShiningArmour · 15/11/2023 11:50

One of our DS is a “poor me”. According to him, he’s a misunderstood borderline saint who is unfairly targeted. And at home, actually, he is really sweet, great company, a helpful and kind soul. But we are under ZERO illusions that at school he’s not a dickhead. He gets sucked into it with his friends and takes silliness too far. We know this from his teachers.

He wouldn’t be so rude as to blank people though.

Luxell934 · 15/11/2023 11:50

Elastica23 · 15/11/2023 11:35

What absolute nonsense about Star of the Week being only for badly behaved pupils. DDs used to get it for completing work particularly well and they were never badly behaved.

Not saying EVERY child who gets one is misbehaving. But it’s normally a behaviour tool. I’ve worked in schools for 10 years, a child who gets star of the week “every week” like OP said is not getting it because they’ve done good work or are well behaved.

Of course if your child received it a couple of times over the course of the year then it’s plausible they have actually done good work.

Tonia16 · 15/11/2023 11:44

UndertheCedartree · 15/11/2023 10:46

This absolutely. Telling DC that they should ignore their feelings and always be polite to adults is a breeding ground for a child being vulnerable to abuse.

A teacher saying good morning to a pupil hardly ranks as 'an adult being abusive or a bully.'
Teaching children basic good manners is certainly not laying the foundations for future abuse.
Another example of posters taking hold of a narrative and deducing the most exaggerated conclusion.

itsmyp4rty · 15/11/2023 11:43

Yr 2 is very different from a Reception/Yr 1 class. The playing ends and it's much more about sitting at your desk and working IME. Expectations are higher and your son might be struggling with all this. I've found that it's really not unusual for children to enjoy Yr 2 much less than the previous years.

It sounds like the teacher is also much stricter and that can be a big change if your son is used to a very warm, gentle teacher. Definitely speak to the teacher and say you're a bit worried that he's not enjoying school at the moment - I expect she'll put it down to the transition to 'top infants'. I would also encourage your son to make sur he is behaving really well at all times to avoid being split up from his friends again. I'd also encourage him to say good morning to his teacher - it doesn't have to mean he thinks she's wonderful.

amylou8 · 15/11/2023 11:41

It's sounds as though the expectations at home maybe quite different to at school. Your happy for him not to be forced to do things. School won't be quite so accommodating. The teacher won't have contacted you over low level disruption, I suspect she'd spend her whole evening on the phone reporting every misdemeanour of 30 6 year olds. Probably a good idea to have a chat to her.

Elastica23 · 15/11/2023 11:35

What absolute nonsense about Star of the Week being only for badly behaved pupils. DDs used to get it for completing work particularly well and they were never badly behaved.

SwingTheMonkey · 15/11/2023 11:32

Op why are you ignoring the questions pp have asked you about your last post on this exact issue?

How come you were aware of your son’s silly behaviour when you posted a couple of weeks ago but now he’s an angel who never misbehaves?!

Surely you’ve had time between this post and the last to contact the teacher and actually ask her what the issue is with your son in the classroom?

Elastica23 · 15/11/2023 11:31

You can ask the school to make reasonable adjustments for him, one of which could be certainty about where he will sit every day, if that is bothering him.

Behaviour is a communication, and his acting out when he doesn't normally needs to be explored further. I would at first speak to the teacher and see how you find her.

UndertheCedartree · 15/11/2023 11:29

cardibach · 15/11/2023 11:11

There’s a big difference between ‘always be polite’ and basic manners in greeting someone. I’m a bit concerned you don’t seem to know what it is.

Edited

I'm very concerned you don't seem to understand that that moment wasn't the one to be 'teaching' manners. Manners are mainly learned through imitation not by 'hauling' DC around and lecturing them.

Dramatic · 15/11/2023 11:21

MNCrazies · 15/11/2023 10:41

I bloody well hope she didn’t, what kind of message is that setting?!

That an adult outranks him because what, they’re older?
Doesn’t work that way, perhaps you need to grow up and join us in the real world. Respect is earned, relationships are built and he does not owe anyone anything by default.

This fucking website, I swear…

To be fair I'd even tell my child it's rude to ignore another child too, doesn't matter if it's an adult or a child it's basic manners.

Myfabby · 15/11/2023 11:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You can just flounce off without announcing your departure! Drama queen.🙄

OP, yes speak to teacher, something has unsettled your son and it's best to be open minded to make sure this doesn't escalate.

Your son should have responded to teacher's greeting. It's poor manners not to. Don't set a precedent for him , that he will be allowed to choose when he can behave. It will be difficult for him to navigate the world based on 'feelings'.

Good luck. I'm sure it will be resolved with a conversation,. Be open minded and ready to cooperate with teacher.

cardibach · 15/11/2023 11:11

UndertheCedartree · 15/11/2023 10:46

This absolutely. Telling DC that they should ignore their feelings and always be polite to adults is a breeding ground for a child being vulnerable to abuse.

There’s a big difference between ‘always be polite’ and basic manners in greeting someone. I’m a bit concerned you don’t seem to know what it is.

cardibach · 15/11/2023 11:10

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 15/11/2023 10:41

OP I could have written your post many years ago. It turned out the teacher was in fact low level bullying my DD to the point her personality changed and she became very withdrawn. It happened over the school year and it took us all that time to realise that all the minor things DD was coming home and telling us about were building up in her head as her just not being good enough. I pulled her out of the school after witnessing the teacher bully DD in front of other staff including the HT and he denied it happened.

I'm not saying this is happening with your DS but when a teacher takes a dislike to a student then they will punish something minor (like kicking a paper towel) which for any other student would just be a "please don't do that again". Your DS does not sound rude or like a spoilt brat. He sounds like a 6 year old who's struggling to deal with being punished for things that aren't really that big of a deal.

Good luck speaking to the teacher

The only ‘punishment’ the OP mentions is being moved. That’s not. Punishment. It’s about safety and giving everyone (including OP’s son) the opportunity to work and learn properly. You know, the thing they go to school to do.

cardibach · 15/11/2023 11:08

MNCrazies · 15/11/2023 10:41

I bloody well hope she didn’t, what kind of message is that setting?!

That an adult outranks him because what, they’re older?
Doesn’t work that way, perhaps you need to grow up and join us in the real world. Respect is earned, relationships are built and he does not owe anyone anything by default.

This fucking website, I swear…

No. It gives the message that if someone greets you, you return the greeting - especially if it’s someone you work with. Why does being polite mean you only speak to those who ‘outrank’ you? In which case why did the teacher speak to him?
Respect sometimes comes with position. The teacher has earned that by working hard for her qualifications and then getting a job. It’s not always personal - or would you not be polite to your boss if you didn’t respect them on a personal level?

VisionsOfSplendour · 15/11/2023 11:07

It's only part way through November, there hasn't been time for every child to be star of the week, you can't complain about that

Primary school children aren't the best at fully explaining the facts, the teacher may well be treating him unfairly but you need to here her said before making any conclusions

cardibach · 15/11/2023 11:05

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 10:34

No I’m not defensive I think it’s difficult as a parent you send them to school and you don’t know what is happening during the day. It has come as a shock these last couple of months because no one has ever told us that he has been misbehaving at school. Him having the same teacher for all them years probably isn’t great either. But his new teacher doesn’t give me that nice friendly feeling either almost feels very cold.

Cold? The only info we have about her is that she said hi to your son, greeting him by his name!

TheGreatATuin · 15/11/2023 11:04

There are a few aspects here. Firstly, OP needs to talk to the teacher in the first respect and make sure she has the whole story.
But it can happen that teachers take a dislike to one child or a group of them, and when it's that young, the child will struggle to know how to deal with it. Some may become more withdrawn but others may start acting up and being the 'naughty' child that they're expected to be. You can't expect an adult response from a 6 year old.
DS had this in Y2. He went from loving school in R/Y1 and to hating it. He'd never had problems but suddenly we were constantly being called in for his behaviour. At first, we were very keen to work with the school to get to the bottom of it and were implementing everything she suggested.
DS was terribly distressed by it. Was constantly in tears about not wanting to be 'bad'.
But then we had a meeting with this teacher and the head, and she said a few things about DS that were just bizarre things to say about any 6yo, and it suddenly became clear where the problems were coming from. I remember the head looking very uncomfortable too.
xH was still trying to be conciliatory at that point but I was furious.
The teacher left not long after and I suspect she was managed out in some way.
DS suddenly stopped having 'behaviour problems' under the new teacher and hasn't had any problems since, but I still feel guilty because my child was in so much distress and it took me far too long to identify the cause.
Most teachers are lovely, but there are some who can't cope with young children and shouldn't be anywhere near them.

cardibach · 15/11/2023 11:02

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 10:29

Well he said yesterday his friend put a ruler on his eye lids and everyone was giggling but he was only one to be moved.

Any other examples?

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 11:00

luckylavender · 15/11/2023 10:55

He was getting star pupil every week? That doesn't seem right or fair

Wasn’t just him though they gave it to quite a few kids. My point is he’s never had one since he’s had his new teacher. So either his previous teacher was giving them out just to give them out I don’t know. But I have seen his friends taking them home with new teacher. It’s not a huge issue it’s just one of the things in my head.

OP posts:
RoomOfRequirement · 15/11/2023 10:58

You're allowing his rude behaviour, ignoring when he does it in front of you and defending it on here. I think we all know the parent you are. His poor teachers.

Luxell934 · 15/11/2023 10:57

In your other thread you admit he’s poorly behaved and winds up his sister etc so can you not see how this silly behaviour in a class of 30 kids could be a big issue for the teacher? Teachers have to manage the class, they have to apply behaviour techniques otherwise they can’t teach.

It’s no wonder teachers are leaving the profession.

luckylavender · 15/11/2023 10:55

He was getting star pupil every week? That doesn't seem right or fair

Cordeliathecat · 15/11/2023 10:53

Also, another thought OP, is your son a particularly popular child?

I ask because my teen daughter is and she is always getting pulled up for low level behaviour that her peers tend to get away with.
We have spoken to the school about this and they have said that when the popular kids start chatting or messing around in class they need to nip it in the bud pretty quickly and dish out sanctions otherwise the risk of further class wide disruption is much greater than if other kids do it which I do understand.

InTheRainOnATrain · 15/11/2023 10:52

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 10:34

No I’m not defensive I think it’s difficult as a parent you send them to school and you don’t know what is happening during the day. It has come as a shock these last couple of months because no one has ever told us that he has been misbehaving at school. Him having the same teacher for all them years probably isn’t great either. But his new teacher doesn’t give me that nice friendly feeling either almost feels very cold.

But it probably wasn’t classed as bad behaviour when he was younger. No one would be surprised if a nursery child didn’t want to sit for circle time, or if a reception child didn’t have a particularly long attention span but this is expected to improve as they get older. Hopefully you can have a productive conversation with the teacher and get on the same page about how to help him.

Celticliving · 15/11/2023 10:50

UndertheCedartree · 15/11/2023 10:40

The OP has explained how sad and upset her DS is and him not responding to the teacher was a symptom of that. I fail to see how 'hauling' him back and speaking to him harshly would help. The OP rightly wants to get to the bottom of the issue and solve the cause.

Doesn't need to be 'hauled back' but I would simply say "Mrs Xxx just said good morning.." and wait for him to respond to her.