Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS keeps being moved at school

261 replies

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 09:27

Ds has recently gone into year 2 and has had a brand new teacher. He previously had the same teacher from nursery to year 1 and he was doing so well in school. He was getting star pupil every week loved his teacher and he was progressing so well.

New teacher keeps moving him pretty much everyday and the reasons he is giving us seem petty unless he is lying but I have no reason not to believe him. She hasn’t contacted us to tell us he’s been messing around or everything and we see her everyday.

We paid £100 for him to go on a school trip and when we picked him up he looked so sad my heart broke for him. He eventually told us that she told him he was being rude for kicking a paper towel and made him sit at the front of the coach away from his friends.

He went into school this morning and she said hi “DS” and he just walked past her. We also seen her on bonfire night and he didn’t even want to say hi then either. I have never seen him like this before ever.

Something in my gut isn’t sitting right! Surely if he was misbehaving so badly we would have some kind of contact? He is a good kid never had any issues with him ever.

OP posts:
tinytemper66 · 15/11/2023 18:14

You need to speak to the teacher.

Heatherbell1978 · 15/11/2023 18:12

In my experience the kids that get 'star pupil' every week are the most poorly behaved as it's used as a bribe in the classroom. My DS's P2 teacher admitted this to me when I asked the direct question as it seemed like he was always missing out to the disruptive kids. Sounds like this teacher is enforcing some rules and your DS doesn't like it.

caringcarer · 15/11/2023 18:09

Star of the week is more often than not given to naughty children as a way to try to control their behaviour. Good well behaved DC often get overlooked as the teacher thinks they are already motivated.

PatchworkElmer · 15/11/2023 18:08

I would also encourage (but not force) him to say hello in the morning, because it is polite. I’d model it by brightly saying hello yourself. Some of my DC’s friends (also Y2) will not greet the teacher in the morning, but they have always been painfully shy. It doesn’t sound like your child is like that by nature.

caringcarer · 15/11/2023 18:07

Mariposista · 15/11/2023 09:46

There you have it - too much choice.
He will have plenty of time in life where he has to be polite whether he likes it or not. He will soon find himself in deep water if he is rude to a boss he doesn’t see eye to eye with. You suck it up - teacher is in charge.

He sounds a rude boy tbh. It's very rude to ignore someone saying good morning. You should have picked him up on it.

PatchworkElmer · 15/11/2023 18:05

I think you’re right to speak to the school, but you’ve gone about it in the wrong way by zeroing in on the being moved thing. Often the thing they say they’re upset about isn’t actually the thing they’re upset about.

I would speak to the teacher again, say you’ve noticed a real change in DS’s mood at home and you’re wondering if they’ve noticed anything in school. One of my friends went in really hard on the school because her son was going in crying every morning, but when the child was spoken to by pastoral care about ‘worries’, they said they were unhappy about their toddler sibling having more time at home than them.

I also think Y2 (at our school at least) is a big step up in terms of academic and behavioural expectations. Ask the teacher about how they feel the transition has gone for your DS. I’d mention that last year DS was getting various awards and you’re wondering why they’ve not this year- does it indicate a change in their behaviour at school etc. Basically don’t assume the worst of the teacher and approach this as a collaborative process initially- I’m not saying that some teachers aren’t horrible people, but most are decent and won’t be torturing your child for kicks. If you don’t get anywhere, then think again.

StarlightLime · 15/11/2023 18:05

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 15:43

Spoke to the teacher she said no issues he just likes a little chat with his friends now and again. She gives him a warning first but if he carrries on chatting she moves him.

She did declare she only moved him once then me and DH listed all the other days he told us and she said yeah that’s true. If we didn’t bring up the other days though she wouldn’t have mentioned it.

So he refused to stop chatting on quite a number of occasions, then.

Are you still supporting his decision to refuse to speak to his teacher because he feels hard done by?

StarlightLime · 15/11/2023 18:02

donnaelle · 15/11/2023 17:51

why should the child be forced to speak to someone they dont want to? does a child have less rights than an adult because i wouldnt be polite and talk to someone who i felt was making my life a misery so why should a child.

She's his teacher, of course he can't just decide to stop talking to her.
Can you even be serious? 🤦🏼‍♀️

donnaelle · 15/11/2023 17:51

why should the child be forced to speak to someone they dont want to? does a child have less rights than an adult because i wouldnt be polite and talk to someone who i felt was making my life a misery so why should a child.

beanii · 15/11/2023 17:45

If you're honest is he as well behaved as you make out?

The teacher saying hello and him ignoring her speaks volumes and I would've pulled one of mine up on it - it's rude. Your excuse - I don't want to force him 🤦‍♀️ raise him to have manners!

Maybe he's acting like that in class?

In school he needs to get used to being moved, working with different children, different teachers/ta's etc.

I very much imagine he's not the angel you think.

nutsnutspistachionuts · 15/11/2023 16:27

Our Y3's teachers move them around a lot for minor chatting and it's not always the kid who is getting moved's fault. The school does mixed ability tables and it's like The Breakfast Club: you can clearly work out who they think is the resident brainy kid, naughty kid, clown, quirky kid, middling chatterbox, etc. Every table seems to have one of each "type", so when they move the kids it's not always about the individual, sometimes about keeping the balance. (I have mixed feelings about this and its tendency to encourage labelling but that's another story!)

UndertheCedartree · 15/11/2023 16:23

That's good you've spoken to the teacher and know what is happening in the classroom so you can support your DS with it. Did you mention to the teacher how unhappy he has been?

UndertheCedartree · 15/11/2023 16:20

Tonia16 · 15/11/2023 11:44

A teacher saying good morning to a pupil hardly ranks as 'an adult being abusive or a bully.'
Teaching children basic good manners is certainly not laying the foundations for future abuse.
Another example of posters taking hold of a narrative and deducing the most exaggerated conclusion.

It's clear you've not understood my post. I said nothing about the teacher being a bully or abusive. I think your conclusion could definitely be called exaggerated! 🙄

UndertheCedartree · 15/11/2023 16:17

Elastica23 · 15/11/2023 11:35

What absolute nonsense about Star of the Week being only for badly behaved pupils. DDs used to get it for completing work particularly well and they were never badly behaved.

Apparently 'star of the week' meant the little boy was badly behaved last year, he's not been the 'star' this term...which means he's badly behaved! Which is it?

Malbecfan · 15/11/2023 16:11

FFS, should a y2 teacher have to remember every bloody time she moved a disruptive chatty kid? Does she not have more important things to remember, like how to get these kids to the ridiculous standards that St Michael of Gove decreed? Your DS is disrupting the learning of other kids, however many times he has been Star of the Week. The teacher is warning him, but he is making poor choices and needs to learn the consequences of those choices. You could reinforce this at home, but I'm not convinced that will happen, sadly.

You should be encouraging your DS to say good morning to his teacher, especially if she greets him by name. It's rude not to. He's going to have to learn to deal with people he doesn't particularly like, so better to start now. And in the nicest possible way, does it matter if you don't have a "warm feeling" about the teacher? You'd probably hate me because I am very strict and have high standards of behaviour. But every lesson in my secondary school has moments of laughter and in almost every lesson, kids thank me unprompted at the end of the lesson. I also get good results and feedback but I spend time establishing routines and boundaries with each new class so everyone knows what to expect. Parents who attempt to undermine me get very short shrift.

Luxell934 · 15/11/2023 15:53

What an awful teacher wanting your son to actually learn and reach his full potential rather than have a nice chat with his friends! This cold woman needs to be sacked immediately!

You do know the teacher decides where the children sit in her classroom and she is responsible for classroom management. Maybe you should become a teacher if you think you could do a better job, we are crying out for teachers!!

sendismylife · 15/11/2023 15:48

As I said, moving a child is neither a punishment nor a big deal. She probably didn’t recall under pressure until you mentioned it. it’s not surprising when she has someone demanding to know why she is doing her job properly as if she is in the wrong!

if he chooses to ignore a warning, his choice. It’s not as though he didn’t know what would happen after the first couple of times. He just decided that chatting was more important than being moved.

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 15:43

Spoke to the teacher she said no issues he just likes a little chat with his friends now and again. She gives him a warning first but if he carrries on chatting she moves him.

She did declare she only moved him once then me and DH listed all the other days he told us and she said yeah that’s true. If we didn’t bring up the other days though she wouldn’t have mentioned it.

OP posts:
iloveherons · 15/11/2023 15:32

no pupil is ever chosen as a star pupil every week. the reward is always rotated around so that every kid gets a turn. 🤔

StarlightLime · 15/11/2023 15:32

MNCrazies · 15/11/2023 10:41

I bloody well hope she didn’t, what kind of message is that setting?!

That an adult outranks him because what, they’re older?
Doesn’t work that way, perhaps you need to grow up and join us in the real world. Respect is earned, relationships are built and he does not owe anyone anything by default.

This fucking website, I swear…

I'll bet your kids are a delight. Much like their Mum, in fact.

StarlightLime · 15/11/2023 15:28

brokenhearted2 · 15/11/2023 09:54

Maybe. But then again if an adult were being a bully or abusive you wouldn't surely tell your child to 'be nice'. That's how kids, esp girls end up abused. Invalidating their experience and demanding that they are nice to the perpetrators is very very unhealthy

Whataboutery nonsense. It's his teacher, not an abuser.

SwingTheMonkey · 15/11/2023 15:22

@PollyPut It was an overnight residential. Op posted about this exact situation a couple of weeks ago but apparently hasn’t managed to speak to the teacher in the interim.

PollyPut · 15/11/2023 13:59

£100 for a school trip? For one day? where did they go?

It must have been a long journey - no wonder she wanted to keep an eye on him on the coach if he'd been misbehaving

bruffin · 15/11/2023 12:31

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 10:23

When he was getting star of week it was for his maths and reading not for behaviour.

It could be that other children have caught him up and surpassed him. I know my DS made huge strides in year 2 with his reading and caught up the children who were reading fluently in reception

TooBusyGazingAtStarss · 15/11/2023 11:57

grapesandplums · 15/11/2023 09:59

I don't think you should force your child to be polite if previously they were and it is only directed at one person. I think you're right in asking yourself, if a previously polite and happy child is now stressed and anxious, why is that? Keep asking those questions OP, you'll never regret trying to understand your child before you go ahead and force or punish them. I think those that do & are reprimanding you here for trying to understand will regret this in later life when their children reflect on their childhoods.
There are such things as bad teachers, bad adults, bad colleagues etc.

Totally agree with this

Swipe left for the next trending thread