Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS keeps being moved at school

261 replies

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 09:27

Ds has recently gone into year 2 and has had a brand new teacher. He previously had the same teacher from nursery to year 1 and he was doing so well in school. He was getting star pupil every week loved his teacher and he was progressing so well.

New teacher keeps moving him pretty much everyday and the reasons he is giving us seem petty unless he is lying but I have no reason not to believe him. She hasn’t contacted us to tell us he’s been messing around or everything and we see her everyday.

We paid £100 for him to go on a school trip and when we picked him up he looked so sad my heart broke for him. He eventually told us that she told him he was being rude for kicking a paper towel and made him sit at the front of the coach away from his friends.

He went into school this morning and she said hi “DS” and he just walked past her. We also seen her on bonfire night and he didn’t even want to say hi then either. I have never seen him like this before ever.

Something in my gut isn’t sitting right! Surely if he was misbehaving so badly we would have some kind of contact? He is a good kid never had any issues with him ever.

OP posts:
Shakenkitty · 17/11/2023 14:27

T

Georgeandzippyzoo · 17/11/2023 13:32

I taught at a small school where teachers could have the same kids for 3yrs. The children become accustomed to how that teacher 'works' and build skills accordingly. Having a new teacher, who probably reacts differently can be quite distressing for young children because they don't know what to do. Their 'skills' they've built up no longer work and they become unsettled/unhappy.
We definitely had a few parents change schools because of their child's upset.

Personally I would speak with the teacher and say you've noticed a change in his demeanour and were wondering if you could have a chat. Don't be accusatory, why he's being moved etc. Ask about his behaviour in class, say he has said he's been moved, wondering if true and if so why, ask what would help etc.
I have a lot of school meetings now as a foster carer and I always say 'this is DC side of the story' because you ARE only getting 1 side and although you might believe him, he might be taking it in a completely different way as to how teacher meant. I do suggest ways of dealing with our DC in certain situations if i think the teacher has dealt with a child in the wrong way, but more on a educating about how this child processes/functions .

SWSarah · 17/11/2023 10:35

Right, I have just joined Mumsnet so I can reply to you. You are absolutely right to follow your gut instinct here, your child is only six, he is a really little boy and school can be hard, children have virtually no autonomy once through the doors, I am a teacher, it is unacceptable for a teacher or any adult to give what sounds like a sarcastic reply because they did not get a response from a child when they said good morning, the correct response is (internally in their own head) "this child was unable/unwilling to respond to my greeting today, I wonder what I can do to make this exchange easier for them". Remember, behaviour IS communication wether we like it or not it's a fact. I am deeply saddened by some of the responses you have received, your little boy needs support to allow him to work towards demonstrating the desired behaviours, not discipline or punishment and there is a HUGE amount of research showing this. Please go and speak to your son's teacher, depersonalise it, tell the teacher the facts regarding your son's change in demeanor and confidence since joining her class, if you are still not happy then speak to the school head. Children need to feel emotionally secure and safe at school, it's vital for them. Please don't wait until you have a child at school refusal stage, it can take years to repair that damage. Just surviving school went out with the arc, everyone should be aiming for children to thrive, good teachers make mistakes and take time to get to know their pupils so a conversation with his teacher is a must. I hope things get better for your son.

Julimia · 17/11/2023 09:07

You need to talk to teacher asap. But dont go in confrontation style,ask for her view , has she seen any changes etc and go from there. Having had the same teacher previously for so long the change becomes almost like a bereavement and no child should have 'star of the week' regularly. Good luck

Eskimal · 16/11/2023 22:54

I have an acquaintance who is a teacher. She’s an absolute bitch. She does it for the power trip (rather than a vocation) and regularly singles out kids.
she’s judgemental where she should be understanding. She has things about certain names eg Dylan. She never forgets and will hold grudges. She has no patience for kids with autism and deliberately misunderstands kids with ADHD.
I am sure she’s an complete exception because I’ve only ever met beautifully dedicated teachers. But horrid teachers do exist. She sucks up to the headteacher so any complaints would immediately be dismissed.

perhaps your child has had really bad luck getting a teacher like that.

Baba197 · 16/11/2023 21:45

I would make an app to go in and speak to the teacher. I used to look after a child who was being targeted daily by her current teacher, she turned from a lively happy child to an emotional wreck. I was also bullied by a teacher for a year which totally ruined my life. For all those saying you are allowing him to be rude- this could be happening to him. If it isn’t and he just doesn’t like her then you need to speak to him about his behaviour and being respectful to others even if you aren’t keen on them but 1st of all go in
and get her take on the situation. If there is something happening then you need to be your child’s voice

shieley · 16/11/2023 19:16

Hi we had this with our son when he was in year 2. After a few week he told me on a weekend that he was fed up of his teacher calling him names now this shocked me as my husband was the site service officer at the school and we had lived on school site since our son was 18mths old. But she was a new teacher just out of uni and every night when i picked him up there was always something wrong eg he walked the long way back to his seat he put his book in wrong pile. The nights she didnt tell me she would tell my husband any way after our son told me this i rang my friend who worked in the office and told her what had been said she told me to ask him about another name. He said yes she has made all the class call him by this name all morning that was the day i had a call from school saying he was crying and could i nip down, but when i got there the teacher would not leave me on my own even thought it was lunch time and our son would not say what was wrong the teacher said it was because it was spelling test that afternoon and he was worried but that was the morning she had all the class doing this. Monday morning both me and his day were there to see the head she asked our son what had been happening he told her every thing she got the teacher in who straight away admitted it her reason was that she was bulled as a child and didnt see any think wrong in what she had done so please look into this and dont leave it best wishes

KillerTomato7 · 16/11/2023 18:23

It's interesting. Many teachers talk about not getting the "respect" they deserve, and for the most part I think this complaint is justified. But I can't help noticing that some of the more vocal teachers on this website seem to have trouble understanding how respect is earned.

If your main approach to communicating with concerned parents is the condescending sneer followed by the direct insult, you may want to reconsider whether you are representing your profession in a good light. We evidently expect 6 year olds to play well with other children. So it's not too much to ask you to play well with other adults.

In the words of one particularly eloquent poster from this thread: "Do better."

BusyMum47 · 16/11/2023 16:45

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 15:43

Spoke to the teacher she said no issues he just likes a little chat with his friends now and again. She gives him a warning first but if he carrries on chatting she moves him.

She did declare she only moved him once then me and DH listed all the other days he told us and she said yeah that’s true. If we didn’t bring up the other days though she wouldn’t have mentioned it.

So he needs to stop talking then. 🤷‍♀️

Parryotter · 16/11/2023 13:41

He was getting star pupil every week?! This doesn’t seem believable. And if it is true then it isn’t right or fair.

It is obvious that you need to have a meeting with the teacher and (calmly and politely) talk about your concerns re:your child. If it is true that he is doing nothing wrong and being moved for no reason then you need to get to the bottom of it. If there is a very good reason that he is getting moved (which is more likely) then you need to know so that you can help steer your child towards better behaviour.

re:ignoring his teacher twice, and at the age of 6/7!! This is incredibly rude and unacceptable behaviour. You need to talk to your son and make sure he understands manners and respect otherwise he will grow up to be an entitled & rude person.

re: kicking a paper towel. It sounds like the children were being asked to be on their best behaviour (as per any school trip outside of school where there are more risks etc). He wasn’t behaving. You seem to think that this is minor but you weren’t there. Maybe him kicking the paper towel meant the line of children was disrupted and potentially placed some of the children in danger near a road or vehicles, perhaps he was close to kicking other children, perhaps he had already been asked to stop and was deliberately ignoring his teacher. It was clearly bad behaviour and he was rightly punished for it. I think you need to stop making excuses for him and maybe not believe everything he says.

But the main point here is that if you are concerned about your son and his teacher then you need to speak to the teacher - don’t ask a load of internet ransoms on mumsnet!

Drpawpawspaw · 16/11/2023 13:41

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 10:29

Well he said yesterday his friend put a ruler on his eye lids and everyone was giggling but he was only one to be moved.

Always someone else’s fault…

Yalta · 16/11/2023 11:59

*Luxell934 · Yesterday 15:53

What an awful teacher wanting your son to actually learn and reach his full potential rather than have a nice chat with his friends! This cold woman needs to be sacked immediately*

But he isn’t learning

Moving around causes disruption and why isn’t anyone else being moved around. Why is it always him.

Not all teachers are benevolent and want to teach every pupil in their class
I found out when ds was in year 1 he was spending most of the day outside the classroom. I didn’t know a thing about it until ds refused to get out of the car one day and a classmate who was passing the car said it was because the teacher sent him out of the class and refused to have him in the classroom because ds
was coughing
I had explained to teacher and TA when he started back at school on the Monday that he would have a cough for 6 weeks but wasn’t infectious
The TA had looked a little embarrassed when the teacher walked off whilst I was mid sentence.

I went to see the HT and asked if ds should just not bother coming back to school for 6 weeks as it was pointless sending him to school to learn anything if he was going to be just sitting on his own all day.

Apparently found out from a friend who worked in the school that my complaint was the final straw and they had a substitute teacher brought in a few hours later

Talking to a friend whose dd had similar issues with this teacher the year before and a few others mums on hearing what had happened that day joined the conversation about how this teacher would pick on random children and make their life a misery
We noticed our children had one distinct thing in common. Our children had the same very distinct hair coloured.

Katiesaidthat · 16/11/2023 11:32

I commend you for trying to get to the bottom of this. When I was 7 i had this awful teacher who disliked me intensely. She never said it, but it was implied in her attitude, I would get flack and my toy taken away when 6 others in same situation right beside me didn´t. So much so, that one of the kids actually GAVE me her toy because she thought it was unfair. I was one of those quiet kids, no disruption or being difficult or answering back or being an ass. Years later I saw her at the bus stop, I was 15 by then, she greeted my mother and looked me up and down and our eyes locked and we knew. When we took our bus, my mum turned to me and said, "I never liked her either. She used to give me the creeps". I never had a problem with a teacher before, nor after right up to finishing uni. SHE was the problem. She was hostile to me, why? God knows. And I picked up on it. Children know.
Speak to her, see what she says.

Charlotte120221 · 16/11/2023 10:45

OP you're getting a bit of a bashing on here when all you really want is the best for your ds?

The key thing is that kids that age don't always tell the whole truth? He might perceive being moved/told off as the end of the world but really it isn't. The teacher is just trying to keep everything on track.

If he's no quite himself then out of school activities/sports/playdates can help improve his mood - and he does gently need to be reminded to the school rules and encouraged to follow them.

Am sure it will all even out in the longer term.

user1471600850 · 16/11/2023 10:45

I think most of you are spectacularly missing the point of this thread - I hope you sort things out for your poor DS

Wherearemykeysagain · 16/11/2023 10:39

I’m a teacher and a psychotherapist. I still teach primary part time. I’ve found children do tend to live up to what you say or expect of them. There is also research about this where teachers were given at random pre-judgements about children. The children where the teacher was told ‘bad’ things about them all behaved worse than the same children with a different teacher who had been told “good” things about them.

This is why as parents you will often see children have a whole year of children struggling and then miraculously a new teacher or school and the child is suddenly doing really well (or vice versa).

It’s very often totally subconscious by the teacher and is why we should all be encourage to self reflect. I remember having a little girl in my class who seemed to constantly in bother. On reflecting I realised she look physically very similar to a child who bullied me when I was little. I had not made the connection but I was unconsciously hostile to her. When I realised (and was horrified) I made an effort to notice her, catch her being kind or helpful. Within a week she was transformed. It was entirely my projection that she was responding to, when we feel disliked we respond accordingly.

Guard your child’s self image. Move school if needed. But a good teacher, if you tell her little James thinks you don’t like him, will reflect on that and try to build the relationship.

Cupofteaandpacketofbiscuits · 16/11/2023 10:34

You won't know anything more unless you raise it with the teacher/school, ideally starting from a neutral stance where you lay out the information and the issues as you understand it so far, and then listen to what their take is on the situation, or what other information they have. Then put them together, see where you are and work out how the situation can get to the point where both DS and teachers can get on a more positive footing.

But do try and start off with a neutral stance so the tone is not confrontational from the start, which doesn't often follow to good, open collaborative conversation and action. The end result it's about helping your DS be happy and productive in class rather than airing grievances. I would ask your DS meanwhile why he didn't say hello and explore his feelings in that moment rather than focussing on the action of saying hello to an adult etc and whether you should force it or not in future. That doesn't get to the heart of the matter, it just papers over the crack.

Myfabby · 16/11/2023 10:27

viques · 16/11/2023 08:14

Sorry OP. I lost this one at £100 for a school trip in Y2.

try harder.

What are you implying? That she's making up how much the trip cost? Why on earth would she do that?

My youngest is 17, and I remember paying about £130 for his Y3 trip. His Y7 (residential) trip was almost £1k.

Red0 · 16/11/2023 10:16

I feel like this post is the reason there are so many disrespectful kids these days and shows what we should expect for the future generation. Excuses for shitty behaviour! Honestly why are so many parents in denial?! Seems like the teacher probably couldn’t be honest with OP about this kids behaviours because the OP wouldn’t accept it. Is it not possible that this is actually your child’s fault, not the teachers?! You are doing him no favours by the sounds of it.

Catsfrontbum · 16/11/2023 09:46

Teachers want to work with parents and usually they will be delighted with a parent who engages.

Ask for a meeting-
Explain how withdrawn your son is, ask her about his behaviours and the expectations of behaviours in the lessons. Do they match?
What can be done to align them? What measures for communication can be taken going forward. Do you need something like a home link book where you both make short comments on how his day went the positives and the things to work on?

Ultimately schools are places for learning and the children learn best when they feel safe and contented. You need to support your son in working out a way to meet the behaviour expectations of the classroom and being respectful of his learning and her teaching. The teacher must support you in this so it’s all consistent.

Low level minor annoyances really disrupt the flow of lessons. Bear that in mind with your son.

Kindly, this defensive/minimising attitude won’t serve him or you well going forward.

Possumzilla · 16/11/2023 09:45

I would speak to the school. The massive change in demeanor is a big red flag. It happened with my DD (although the issue was other kids, not the teacher). It's awful when they feel anxious about school. I hated making her go when she wasn't happy there.

It sounds like she might just be a normal teacher, but after a couple of years of having an extra positive relationship with his old teacher, the change is tough on him. My DD was devastated at the end of Y2 because she had such a lovely bond with her teacher. The first few weeks of Y3 were a bit of a struggle because she didn't immediately have the same bond with her new teacher and therefore felt a bit apprehensive.

Ignore everyone telling you that you should have made him respond to the teacher. Parenting is knowing which battles to pick, and that one instance just doesn't matter in the long run.

SwingTheMonkey · 16/11/2023 09:32

TiredParentAlways · 16/11/2023 07:23

I don't understand why so many comments are criticising the parent here.
Are those people all totally ignoring the bit where the child has withdrawn into themselves and is acting differently and anxious? Forcing an upset and anxious child to interact with an adult they are nervous of is just wrong no matter how rude you think it is. That boy is obviously anxious to talk to the teacher and his mum forcing it will not help the situation!

Basically you need to talk to the teacher and discuss how you DS is feeling at home now compared to how he was in reception and hopefully you can get to the bottom of the issue and find a solution so your DS loves school again. Good luck and I hope you get it sorted out xx

P.s. ignore the hateful comments- they do not have enough information to make such ridiculous and unhelpful judgements.

Yeah we do. Op posted about this exact situation a couple of weeks ago where she admitted that she knew her child’s behaviour wasn’t great. All of a sudden, now he’s an angel…

Luxell934 · 16/11/2023 09:31

All the year 2 classes I’ve ever known don’t have assigned seats anyway. They sit on the carpet for the introduction, then half go off to do enhanced provision while the teacher and TA take small groups to do the work. There’s not even enough chairs or tables in the class for each child to have their own seat as they never all work at the same time.

SwingTheMonkey · 16/11/2023 09:27

Oblomov23 · 16/11/2023 03:41

I agree with Otter. I disagree with all on this thread. He doesn't want to say hello to teacher and now we all know why. She's dismissive, saying she's only moved him once, but when op listed all the times, she's now admitted this was true.
How did it end op? Because if no resolution I'd ring back. Ask her what she suggests to improve the situation.

Why didn't she ring you, if all this was going on. I'll tell you why, because dismissive of the damage that's been done here. She's the teacher, the adult. She should've addressed it. Any low level rudeness or not behaving could've been reported to you at the end of the day.... Mrs op we've had a couple of issues this week ..... but no. She's had a number of punishments and sanctions, unbeknown to you, and now he's pissed off. Rightly so. I wouldn't have said hello to her either.

In fact her arrogance at her jolly hello Billy at a firework display where he isn't required to say hello, trying to cover her ass. It now turns out she can't even remember how many times she's moved him. She's emotionally inept. She's all jolly. He doesn't like her. Now we all know why.

I'd definitely be ring again. Putting her right in her place. Telling her 'I've had another think about it' and asking her how she intends to compensate ds for her bad handling of the whole situation.

Jesus wept.

Thats a cracking story you’ve written there.

No wonder people don’t want to teach.

TinyTear · 16/11/2023 09:23

johnd2 · 15/11/2023 19:50

Not really on topic but ignore all the people saying your child owes people a greeting, it's good to get the principle solid in your children that they don't owe anyone conversation, no matter who they are, whether a well meaning teacher or in twenty years time a pervy boss or whatever.
Don't forget that good old fashioned manners prepared the ground for the abuse that resulted in the meToo movement.

you might not owe anyone conversation (true) but a good morning is polite

even to the most annoying colleagues I saw good morning even if I then shut down and grey rock any attempts at personal conversation