Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS keeps being moved at school

261 replies

Cupsoftea2 · 15/11/2023 09:27

Ds has recently gone into year 2 and has had a brand new teacher. He previously had the same teacher from nursery to year 1 and he was doing so well in school. He was getting star pupil every week loved his teacher and he was progressing so well.

New teacher keeps moving him pretty much everyday and the reasons he is giving us seem petty unless he is lying but I have no reason not to believe him. She hasn’t contacted us to tell us he’s been messing around or everything and we see her everyday.

We paid £100 for him to go on a school trip and when we picked him up he looked so sad my heart broke for him. He eventually told us that she told him he was being rude for kicking a paper towel and made him sit at the front of the coach away from his friends.

He went into school this morning and she said hi “DS” and he just walked past her. We also seen her on bonfire night and he didn’t even want to say hi then either. I have never seen him like this before ever.

Something in my gut isn’t sitting right! Surely if he was misbehaving so badly we would have some kind of contact? He is a good kid never had any issues with him ever.

OP posts:
Rubyphoebetina · 18/11/2023 11:17

I would trust your guy. If you’ve had no problems in the past and he is clearly unhappy I would ask for a meeting with the teacher to get her side of the story and take it from there

SENDintheClowns101 · 18/11/2023 08:55

OP it sound like you have difficulty believing your “dear” child is incapable of being disruptive or rude or non-compliant or any of the other negative behaviours child can construe. Herein lies your issue. The sooner you realise that you child is probably not behaving in an acceptable manner for one reason or another the easier things will get. I say this from experience - our children are very good at pulling the wool over our eyes and us wearing rose tinted glasses. I imagine if you were a fly on the wall at school you’d realise why he’s being moved. Try supporting the teacher and telling him that if his behaviour doesn’t improve he will keep being removed from his friends. He needs to learn to toe the line.

bruffin · 18/11/2023 08:02

Champers66 · 18/11/2023 07:05

You rude rude person. You have made a huge assumption here.

Who are you talking to?

However everyone is making assumptions here just as you are, as nobody really knows what is going on. OP posted about same a few weeks back, but her child wasnt so much an angel then and admitted he can be silly, not sure why she had to post again under a nc.
I

Champers66 · 18/11/2023 07:05

You rude rude person. You have made a huge assumption here.

Champers66 · 18/11/2023 07:03

Call the school and ask to speak with her. Unlike some of the comments here suggesting you dismiss his feelings, and that the teacher ‘deserves respect’, find out what’s going on, because if she is victimising him- I don’t blame him for his reaction. You know your son, and if something isn’t feeling right, it probably isn’t.

all you commenters acting like teachers are god and he shouldn’t be ‘rude’ and ‘walk past an adult’.. if she’s singling him out, that’s an obvious reaction to ignore her. I would never force my son to be kind to someone who’s made him feel sad, teacher or no teacher!

thirdfiddle · 18/11/2023 03:52

Imagine how uncivilised it would be if all the children were kicking paper towels around?

I'd like to know more because paper towels aren't really expected in a bus queue.
If OP's son somehow fetched a pile of towels and decided to play footie with them yes. Or: there is something on the ground, kid toes it to see what it is, yuck it's a soggy paper towel. Teacher descends.

nocciola · 17/11/2023 21:32

Why ever are you posting here? Stop second guessing and speak with her.

Northernladdette · 17/11/2023 21:13

brokenhearted2 · 17/11/2023 19:33

So he missed out on the trip and started behaving so was allowed to go with the new school the following year? That sounds like the sanction of not being allowed to go worked to get him to understand there are consequences

I don’t believe his behaviour changed at all. His behaviour wasn’t that bad in the first place, the teacher took a dislike to him.
I worked in education for 25 years, believe me, it does happen 🤔

Puffling235 · 17/11/2023 21:01

Pliudev · 17/11/2023 19:31

Sorry to all those who seem to think teachers are always reasonable and right but I disagree. When my son was 7 he changed from a happy, outgoing child to one who lacked confidence and self esteem. I found out that other children had told their parents that Miss X 'was being unkind' to my DS. For example: one day she said his work was dirty and disgusting. This was two boys on his table had been kicking it about on the floor but it was my DS who she told off and humiliated. That is just one incident. I also learned that this teacher had caused another boy in a previous year to have a breakdown by treating him similarly. She simply did not like certain boys. She made my DS self conscious about his size (he was tall and well built but not fat) and he became a vegetarian, which was fine but I wish I knew what it was in reaction to.

When I complained to the head she said I had 'given her the ammunition' she needed to 'do something that had needed doing for a long time'. But that teacher stayed in place until the end of the year before she left. In my opinion she spoiled my DS's experience of primary school and effected him significantly in lasting ways.
OP, you need to find out what is happening and act accordingly.

Gosh, this is heartbreaking!

boqq · 17/11/2023 20:42

Sometimes I wonder if most ppl on mums net are teachers. Authority figures? Come on, get a grip. Like everyone else teachers need to earn respect and if they’re being unfair kids are not stupid… Support your son and show him you’ll always be there for him. That way he’ll feel comfortable opening up.

BooBooDoodle · 17/11/2023 20:30

My kids were moved daily. It’s to socialise and build resilience. They want everyone in their classes to get to know each other and build friendships. I get it can be uncomfortable for a lot of children but this helps to break down any social barriers and get them involved. Teachers find it easier to identify those who struggle with social times so more help can be put in to remedy this and build confidence.
One of my sons has also been moved a few times because he’s a chatterbox and was disruptive. This is fair enough and the school had our backing on doing so. Both of mine were also taught to respect adults and behave accordingly.

Heresapickle · 17/11/2023 20:08

Some people are dicks, ergo some teachers are dicks. You won’t know what is happening until you go in and ask.

I once rang my son’s head teacher because he was refusing to go to school because he had pe and he said the pe teacher shouted, laughed at him and teased him for being rubbish (he has dyspraxia as well as asd and adhd).

I rang thinking this can’t be right, he has probably misunderstood… I told the head what he said and she said “ yep, the pe teacher is from an agency and she is horrible” apparently the head had heard her shouting and laughing at the children.

She said they weren’t going to have her back next year and until then my son could just not do pe… which suited him but didn’t actually sort it for the rest of the kids.

Tortycatlover · 17/11/2023 19:49

Do you really think such behaviour is ok? Imagine how uncivilised it would be if all the children were kicking paper towels around? The queue would not be a queue at all! Please try to view your DS’s behaviour from the point of view of the teacher and the other children, some of whom may find his behaviour stressful.

AnxieteaAndBiscuits · 17/11/2023 19:33

Hi OP, I haven't read all of the comments but just wanted to say that my DS is moved most days or he's removed from the classroom. He's in year 3 (7y/o) and is currently awaiting an ASD assessment. However, it's been the same since he was in reception and while it's not ideal I can appreciate the reasons for it and what may appear trivial reasons if he was at home in a class of 30 children it becomes problematic.
I've always built up a good rapport with his teachers. His y 3 teacher is new to the school so I let him settle for a couple of weeks before I approached her. You need to make it clear that your willing to talk about his behaviours and how best to manage them for example reward charts, raffle tickets for good behaviour etc. You could also give her a small exercise book and ask her to briefly log his behaviour just so you can recognise patterns.
Is he bored? Struggling with the work being set? Is the work too easy? Does he need short breaks during his lessons? These are all questions you could ask and really she should be happy to discuss them.

brokenhearted2 · 17/11/2023 19:33

Northernladdette · 15/11/2023 18:22

In Year 5 my son wasn’t allowed to go on a residential, which was right up his street, due to his behaviour.
We moved house and he went to a new school where they did the same trip in Year 6. He went, he loved it, and was good as gold.
I think sometimes some teachers just take a dislike to some kids. I’d raise it with the Head, they won’t be happy and will have a word with the teacher concerned.

So he missed out on the trip and started behaving so was allowed to go with the new school the following year? That sounds like the sanction of not being allowed to go worked to get him to understand there are consequences

AcadeMama · 17/11/2023 19:33

I am picking up that the teacher may be treating him unfairly. One of my daughters was bullied by a teacher and she was a pretty well behaved child. If his character has changed there may be a reason. Dont be so quick to blame OPs parenting. She sounds very concerned and wants solutions, not blame. The teacher might have taken a dislike to him for whatever reason. I would ask other parents subtly about how their kids are fitting in and raise it with the head of year if it continues. He may be being victimised and its an awful situation to be in.

Pliudev · 17/11/2023 19:31

Sorry to all those who seem to think teachers are always reasonable and right but I disagree. When my son was 7 he changed from a happy, outgoing child to one who lacked confidence and self esteem. I found out that other children had told their parents that Miss X 'was being unkind' to my DS. For example: one day she said his work was dirty and disgusting. This was two boys on his table had been kicking it about on the floor but it was my DS who she told off and humiliated. That is just one incident. I also learned that this teacher had caused another boy in a previous year to have a breakdown by treating him similarly. She simply did not like certain boys. She made my DS self conscious about his size (he was tall and well built but not fat) and he became a vegetarian, which was fine but I wish I knew what it was in reaction to.

When I complained to the head she said I had 'given her the ammunition' she needed to 'do something that had needed doing for a long time'. But that teacher stayed in place until the end of the year before she left. In my opinion she spoiled my DS's experience of primary school and effected him significantly in lasting ways.
OP, you need to find out what is happening and act accordingly.

Ilovetravelling · 17/11/2023 19:30

Maybe you should go & have a chat to the teacher & tell her how unhappy he seems. If you get no joy go to the head teacher.

brokenhearted2 · 17/11/2023 19:30

donnaelle · 15/11/2023 17:51

why should the child be forced to speak to someone they dont want to? does a child have less rights than an adult because i wouldnt be polite and talk to someone who i felt was making my life a misery so why should a child.

If you didn't like your manager would you ignore them?

grownuplefthome · 17/11/2023 19:26

When I was the same age as your son, I had a teacher who was truly evil to me, my mum noticed the change in my behaviour. One day I was a little late for school but my mum explained that it was her fault and how sorry she was. The teacher seemed to accept it and told me to go into the classroom. Mum left. As soon as she had gone the teacher brought me to the front of class and began to yell at me for bringing my mum in and not accepting I was in the wrong. However my mum was still in the corridor because she had seen another teacher and was catching up with her, so she heard everything. She walked straight into the room and took me out straight to the head, needless to say I was moved classes and the teacher left the school quite quickly after. Check in with your son and ask other parents and kids what happens in the classroom.

Mrshawshouse · 17/11/2023 19:08

If your DS has changed and is now anxious about school, it is only right you do all you can to help him. Respecting adults, based solely on the fact they are adults makes no sense. There is every possibility that she hasn't warmed to your son for some reason and he senses it, especially if he had such a lovely relationship with his previous teacher. As the professional adult in the situation, she needs to treat him in a way that doesn't make him feel so anxious that he doesn't want to go to school! You have drawn her attention to it now, and she was either lying about moving him so often, or was a bit oblivious to it. Either way, now she knows and it's up to her to try and rebuild the relationship

SpeakEasy2311 · 17/11/2023 19:06

@PennyFleck this infuriated me, if you've raised your child to be polite and they stop behaving in that manner to someone never ever force them to act a certain way in front of that person. You question them after! This is why there are children who are abused and molested because of people like you! Who fail to read the room, think outside the box and see the bigger picture.

sarahd29 · 17/11/2023 18:47

My son is yr3 and has had several teachers (don't ask) but all of them have moved the children around. It's not necessarily been him that's the issue, sometimes someone he is sat near has an issue with someone else, 7 year
old personalities can be strong, he's quite steady and not easily distracted so he tends to get put by those who are..there have been a couple with bad eyesight who needed to be nearer the front. He's quite needy so it's helped to have him
near the front but can do the work so
sometimes he goes
to
the back..I asked the head once and she said it's incorporated into their plan to move them round to ensure people learn to get along and don't fall into cliques and all depends on the dynamics of the whole room.

Starjacks · 17/11/2023 16:47

Wow you sound lovely. Adults won't say hi to people they dislike, why should we force children? Op should arrange a meeting with the teacher hear them out and express concern at them singling their son out. Kicking a paper towel on the floor on a bus is hardly disruptive and if it was happening so often why weren't the parents notified? It sounds fishy and like the teacher has taken and unnecessary dislike to the child

Fluffybunniesandkittens · 17/11/2023 14:30

I have not read all of the comments but I just had to set up an account especially for this one.
Transitioning to year 2 is difficult for a lot of children. There are more expectations placed upon them, they have a new teacher and the work is harder.
Your child has gone from getting rewarded every week despite him being a bit chatty, to being what he sees as being punished and picked on for something that is not always under his control, ie his friends laughing. He is always the 1 to get moved and to him it's not fair.
He has told you, as his mum, his support and safe person about the problem from his perspective in the hope that you can help him to deal with the situation.
He is experiencing something that he hasn't been through before with a person that is practically a stranger to him, whom he doesn't know or trust. This person in his mind is not very nice to him. When she then said good morning to him, his only way to communicate his feelings about her to her, is to ignore her. This is rude behaviour but doesn't automatically mean that a 7 yo child is a rude child. You are correct not to force him to acknowledge her at that moment as that would make him feel like his trusted person is taking the side of the person that is upsetting him and invalidating his feelings towards her. This will slowly erode his trust.
The rude behaviour needs to be dealt with at home where he feels safe with time for a proper conversation about it being polite to acknowledge someone speaking to you. Including an explanation to him about how things have changed and why there are different expectations of him now.
Being well behaved but chatty isn't a big deal before y2 but as y2 is more work focused, being chatty is more of a problem. He needs to understand that he isn't doing anything that is bad behaviour but why being less chatty in class is now important. If he doesn't have this understanding then he will continue to think that he is being picked on and it's not fair and this will affect his confidence and make him feel like there is no point in trying to behave any more because no matter what he does, he can't do right for doing wrong.

Swipe left for the next trending thread