Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disruptive kids in class

91 replies

Strangerfings1 · 15/11/2023 08:19

My DC year 4 hates school and it's because of the behaviour or a few kids in their class. At the end of year 2 the classes in the year were mixed. I think because all the "naughty" kids were in the same form. Now we have a bunch of disruptive kids, including 1 with SN who sometimes gets violent when he's wound up (which another kid Seems to enjoy doing) a couple who are sort of easily distracted and get "sucked in" to playing up and 1 particular child who's behaviour is frankly a nightmare. Now I assume this child has difficulties of some sort so this isn't a blame thing but is there anything I can ask the school to do? Some examples of the behaviour of this child include hitting / attacking other children (even in the classroom!) Getting up, shouting and running around, throwing things and he even ripped all the pages out of the books in the library corner. The whole class regularly miss break time as a punishment, often miss PE due to the threat of fighting in say, football, and end up not really doing any schoolwork because the teacher is having to deal with urgent behaviour issues.
Lots of the other children are either frightened, bored or just resentful for being punished for the behaviour of a few. And I really worry that they're falling behind because they can't get work done.
Is there anything I can ask the school to do, or is it just put up or try and move schools?
Thank you.

OP posts:
anon2134 · 15/11/2023 11:07

Where is the child supposed to go? I guarantee the parents have tried to get specialist provision to be told that their child is fine in mainstream and that there's no funding. There's no middle ground for kids with additional needs it's mainstream or specialist provision but the criteria for specialist provision is very high so kids who have outbursts a few times a day will not get a place.

Phineyj · 15/11/2023 10:54

Hi OP, I am dreadfully sorry but of course education misses out when behaviour has to be the focus.

I had a year 11 class (for an optional subject!) like that last year.

As well as the problems detailed on this thread, thanks to Michael Gove we have a really severe mismatch throughout large parts of the education system between what students are able to learn and what they're supposed to be taught.

By all means get involved but if you feel your child isn't learning what they should be you may need to take matters into your own hands (tutors or DIY).

That is the reality.

Strangerfings1 · 15/11/2023 10:39

Our teacher is very young and so probably (although lovely) does lack experience. Maybe that is part of the problem

OP posts:
eardefender · 15/11/2023 10:28

In a class of thirty a few children will need an EHCP to provide them with additional support but it is very very hard to get one and it takes about a year. It is a hugely beurocratic process with various stages and appeals processes. Parents that get through it then face schools not being able to provide even the funded support. I think the LA design the process to put parents off to be honest. Special schools are now few and far between and tend to be for the most severely disabled children. As a result schools are becoming very stressful environments for teachers and pupils and many parents are being forced to home school.

CoffeeWithCheese · 15/11/2023 10:20

I've been on both sides of it as the teacher struggling and as the parent (and Y4 in both cases - it seems to be where the issues really come to a head).

I'd start looking to move your kids to be honest - it was what we ended up doing when DD1 was in this situation, when what had always been a "lively" cohort suddenly seemed to tip over into concerning behaviour anarchy (Covid lockdowns played a huge role in our case - they came back into school and the kids who'd always been challenging had gone completely wild) and physical violence was common along with all sorts of unpleasantness verbally etc. We ended up moving both kids - and yes, the school we moved to isn't all rainbows and unicorns in terms of behaviour, but there's not that situation of behaviour snowballing so the teacher spends most of their day firefighting going on.

From what I gather from other parents who remained with that class - things did not improve with that year group and that core set of individuals were incredibly challenging and disruptive right the way up until they left primary. I'm not sure how they've panned out in Secondary as we made our secondary choices based at least partly on wanting to continue to keep DD away from them.

BlockadeRunner · 15/11/2023 10:17

It’s an issue because so many schools for children with additional needs were closed due to policy on inclusivity because of the Warnock report . What is interesting is the chair of this enquiry changed their mind on inclusivity after 25 years of the changes when they were clearly not working. There are some children who will thrive in mainstream but there are many who don’t and it’s a disservice to them and their classmates.

Aramist · 15/11/2023 10:16

If schools were given double the money they currently have, alot of these issues would be eradicated.

More support staff, more CPD for teachers, smaller class sizes. The list goes on.

Experienced senior teachers are becoming too expensive nowadays. Younger, fresher teachers are brought in who are thrown in the deep end. No wonder so many leave within 3 years of qualifying.

sollenwir · 15/11/2023 10:06

Baldieheid · 15/11/2023 10:00

Ah, it's PE that's being spoken about. I thought it was playtime/break time.

Difficult situation.

To be fair, I think both PE and break were mentioned by OP.

Baldieheid · 15/11/2023 10:00

sollenwir · 15/11/2023 08:56

If they are highly disruptive in class then they may also be disruptive in PE - this may involve more dangerous disruption (eg throwing PE equipment) and be even harder to manage over a larger (potentially outside) area.

Ah, it's PE that's being spoken about. I thought it was playtime/break time.

Difficult situation.

Djimm · 15/11/2023 09:48

Keep it about your child, and lead with what is making her feel less safe in school. I think PPs are right, missing PE and breaks are unfair and an ineffective punishment. If it was going to work it would have done so already and would no longer be needed. It is only going to exacerbate the situation because it will further break down the relationship between this lad and his peers.

It's not your job to fix this - it would be patronising to go in with a list of solutions. But you stating the impact on your child formally might actually be quite helpful because it's evidence of the detriment to classmates, which will support the case for the child getting more support. Focus on detriment to your own child. Safety they have to take most seriously but of course you can include impact on their learning time.

Don't go in railing that the child needs to be removed so the good kids can concentrate. Acknowledge how much the teacher is already doing but say that despite this the detriment to your child is significant.

rainbowstardrops · 15/11/2023 09:37

Unfortunately, this seems almost the norm these days. There's not enough money for extra support staff and no where near enough specialist school places.

I've recently left the education sector because of this.

Go to the head teacher and explain all your worries for your child. The class teacher will probably be so thankful for you raising it. Mind you, support for teaching staff relies on an effective SLT ....... hence why I left!

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/11/2023 09:37

Tumbleweed101 · 15/11/2023 09:18

There definitely needs to be a major overhaul of the education system as a whole. So many children even from preschool age are incredibly disruptive and stop the rest of the children getting the education they deserve.

Far more specialist education provision needs to be available, for both SEN and behavioural needs. Only children who can sit and learn in main stream with minor support should be there so the other children can concentrate and learn.

Children who can't do this may need support outside of mainstream with teachers who have a passion for certain SEN or behaviour therapies and are able to give those children education in a way that caters for their needs. For many it may be outdoor learning, or active, sensory learning that can't be offered in mainstream with 30 other children. I think all children are being failed by the current system and EHCPs are going to appeal that should really be approved. It should also be much easier to move between the two. A child who can't self regulate and cope in a class room at 5yo may be able to do so and cope at 8yo.

As a parent to 'good' children I find it frustrating they are losing out on possible exam grades that could impact their future choices by disruptive or aggressive classmates. On the other hand I have seen parents of such children at breaking point because they can't get the support their child needs to do the best they can educationally because they system doesn't cater for their needs.

I'm a parent to a 'good' child as you put it who needs significant support. I totally disagree with your assertion that they shouldn't be in mainstream and indeed find it rather ableist.

Many thousands of kids with significant needs thrive in mainstream when the correct support is in place. They shouldn't be relegated to schools that don't provide the range of curriculum that they aspire to and be unable to reach their potential just because they need extra support. SEN is a huge spectrum and many SEN kids are highly intelligent.

Gymrabbit · 15/11/2023 09:34

And just to add the vast majority of disruptive kids are just disobedient little shits with shitty parenting so more SEN provision won’t help them.
More PRU schools would though.

Gymrabbit · 15/11/2023 09:31

As others have said, focus on the effect on your child.
It is completely unacceptable that well behaved children are missing out on PE and breaks because other children cannot behave. This issue should be fixed easily with no whole class detention and the kids who are too badly behaved to play team games sitting with the head while the others play.

Unfortunately a lot of schools pander to the kids who can’t behave and it’s the others who suffer. Moving schools won’t help as you may well find the same situation there.

The more of you who complain the better though. There were lots of complains about the poor behaviour of kids in my daughters class last year (only one of whom has SEN) and they have given them a senior teacher this year and it’s much better.

Pooooochi · 15/11/2023 09:26

It won't be missing pe due to fighting.

I will bet £1m it is that the issues mean the teacher cannot physically keep the children safe to do PE.

The person you need to advocate to is the SENCO & the head. Something is badly wrong in sen provision if its like this.

Tumbleweed101 · 15/11/2023 09:18

There definitely needs to be a major overhaul of the education system as a whole. So many children even from preschool age are incredibly disruptive and stop the rest of the children getting the education they deserve.

Far more specialist education provision needs to be available, for both SEN and behavioural needs. Only children who can sit and learn in main stream with minor support should be there so the other children can concentrate and learn.

Children who can't do this may need support outside of mainstream with teachers who have a passion for certain SEN or behaviour therapies and are able to give those children education in a way that caters for their needs. For many it may be outdoor learning, or active, sensory learning that can't be offered in mainstream with 30 other children. I think all children are being failed by the current system and EHCPs are going to appeal that should really be approved. It should also be much easier to move between the two. A child who can't self regulate and cope in a class room at 5yo may be able to do so and cope at 8yo.

As a parent to 'good' children I find it frustrating they are losing out on possible exam grades that could impact their future choices by disruptive or aggressive classmates. On the other hand I have seen parents of such children at breaking point because they can't get the support their child needs to do the best they can educationally because they system doesn't cater for their needs.

Themostimportantpart · 15/11/2023 09:18

Strangerfings1 · 15/11/2023 09:08

I can't band up.with other parents. That feels awful, like bullying the kid with issues or their family :(

By complaining you might help the child in need get help which will benefit everyone.

sollenwir · 15/11/2023 09:15

bombastix · 15/11/2023 09:10

Your child gets one crack at this. One go. Think carefully if you don't do this. Who suffers in the end? It's your child and other children.

What do you think is going to happen though? The school cannot magically fund more support staff. Something would be happening to improve things if it was possible.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 15/11/2023 09:14

I don't think getting other parents on board with this is bullying of the child. You need to go at it from the "what can be done for OUR children who are missing out on their education " perspective rather than "what is being done about this child". As another poster said, you going to the HT may be just what the teacher hopes someone does. Having a disruptive class with no TA is hell on Earth. How is a teacher supposed to cope in those circumstances?

JSMill · 15/11/2023 09:12

Is this a school in the UK? They can't miss PE as a punishment. It's part of the curriculum!

bombastix · 15/11/2023 09:10

Strangerfings1 · 15/11/2023 09:08

I can't band up.with other parents. That feels awful, like bullying the kid with issues or their family :(

Your child gets one crack at this. One go. Think carefully if you don't do this. Who suffers in the end? It's your child and other children.

Strangerfings1 · 15/11/2023 09:08

I can't band up.with other parents. That feels awful, like bullying the kid with issues or their family :(

OP posts:
bombastix · 15/11/2023 09:07

Strangerfings1 · 15/11/2023 09:01

It's the lack of education that worries me the most. It's like everyone has to focus on keeping everyone safe and there isn't time for learning

Just complain. It is unreasonable to have class punishment. The disruptive child can have the punishment and perhaps enough of this conduct and it will help them to get better help. SEN may be a factor, or simply the child had crappy parenting or indeed both. It's your child's education and class punishment is totally unreasonable. I would still look at other schools

sollenwir · 15/11/2023 09:07

shockeditellyou · 15/11/2023 09:04

Moving schools will not solve issues- this is run of the mill for most primaries at the moment.

It seems to get somewhat better at a good, large secondary where they can separate out the children more.

My son had most of his primary time disrupted by these issues, but at secondary it was much better (still a few issues with different people, but not constant). Now he's higher up the school most of them are not in his class/have left, so it's not really a concern. I don't know what some of them are up to, but I do know a couple of them have apprenticeships/college and are actually doing ok/well, which reinforces my belief that it wasn't inability to learn but more the wrong learning environment/support for them.

Strangerfings1 · 15/11/2023 09:06

Moving schools is complicated as well as I have twins in the class. Didn't mention that but BC I worry about being identified (although I think it's unlikely from what I've said here!) So I'd need a school with 2 spaces.

OP posts: