Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

30 hours free childcare- means tested?!

236 replies

bingbongbang23 · 14/11/2023 22:47

Sure I will get blasted, but I only just realised that the 30hr free childcare is means tested. I have paid full price for my child for past 2 years- at a whopping £1240 a month, but it is what it is.

Selfishly, i was so looking forward to her turning 3 and getting the free hours. Would be a massive help with mortgage going up. However I don't qualify. And it is not a sliding scale, I don't qualify for anything. So I would actually be better off reducing hours so I would qualify for the free hours- in what world should that be the case?! Makes no sense to me!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
GoudaThunkIt · 15/11/2023 07:55

@TheWayTheLightFalls you're correct, that’s what the OP wants though

TheWayTheLightFalls · 15/11/2023 07:43

School nurseries are some of the most reasonable options for childcare out there.

Not sure about elsewhere but in my area school nurseries are term time only.

Nutellaonall · 15/11/2023 07:27

I think people that are on £110-120 kare the worst hit they actually end up taking home less than people on just under £100k. It’s ridiculous.

TookTheBook · 15/11/2023 07:24

Why do you say you don't get anything, but 15 hours is universal? A tad dramatic. You'll be entitled to 15 hours the term after your child turns 3 (no, not immediately).

We weren't entitled to the 30 hours as one of us was a student. But we got 15 hours.

In any case, 15 hours is term-time only. If you're looking for childcare to ensure you can work f/t a school nursery isn't much use as it's a school-length day and term -time only.

Peablockfeathers · 15/11/2023 07:23

Also what a lot of people are not appreciating is that the money you get back for childcare is an absolute drop in the ocean of the amount of tax you will contribute to the country as a higher earner. Why shouldn’t you have some of the benefits of this?! Is the solution to tax you less?

Yes more tax for less access to services sounds like a great deal, ita a real mystery why so many young people with great aspirations decide to leave this country. I'm sure we will all bask in the skill shortages nicely in the decades to come, can't wait.

GoudaThunkIt · 15/11/2023 07:19

School nurseries are some of the most reasonable options for childcare out there. If you’re eligible for 15 hours then you’re only paying for 15 hours a week on top of that.
The average price of a session by me is £15, so £30 a day.
You’re a high earner and you’re expected to pay maybe £75 a week for 38 weeks of the year to enable you to work.
I’ll bet my house your daily rate is much more than that and you are complaining!

(I appreciate the costs may vary by location but you take my point)

Peablockfeathers · 15/11/2023 07:17

lifehappens12 · 15/11/2023 07:12

Kind of agree with you, my manager once really excitedly told me my pay was going to be increased by £4000 to £101000.

What he didn't know was that after tax I was worse off. I lost my 30 free hours and tax free childcare and now the higher tax rate kicks in.

But I have to remember that being just under £100k I was getting all the help that people on much lower salaries are getting.

The issue exists for salaries just on the £100k mark really

It's not until someone earns £130k that they're 'better off'- I'd certainly drop hours or overpay into a pension until my children were out of the childcare years.

Mavissdaviss · 15/11/2023 07:17

I get your point. DH and I earn over £100k between us but will get the 30 free hours. It’s going to massively help us as at the moment we are spending over our wages every month and eating up savings. We have 3 children and a mortgage. Yes we are much much luckier than some and are extremely grateful. We have a house that houses all of us, we have one holiday a year (usually UK) but we don’t live extravagantly and we are always tight for money at the end of the month.

Also what a lot of people are not appreciating is that the money you get back for childcare is an absolute drop in the ocean of the amount of tax you will contribute to the country as a higher earner. Why shouldn’t you have some of the benefits of this?! Is the solution to tax you less?

lifehappens12 · 15/11/2023 07:12

Kind of agree with you, my manager once really excitedly told me my pay was going to be increased by £4000 to £101000.

What he didn't know was that after tax I was worse off. I lost my 30 free hours and tax free childcare and now the higher tax rate kicks in.

But I have to remember that being just under £100k I was getting all the help that people on much lower salaries are getting.

The issue exists for salaries just on the £100k mark really

Peablockfeathers · 15/11/2023 07:11

You won't get any sympathy on here OP as people are bitter towards high earners and because they're on crap wages hate the thought of anyone else moaning about anything even when it's unfair.

You should still get the 15 hours, but it's well known that there's a tipping point where you're better off cutting hours or paying more into your pension- have a Google it has been calculated where the area is that if you earn between x and y you're worse off. I think it should be universal, I'll never earn £100k plus but if you're a higher tax payer you pay more in than most. There's no real incentive anymore in this country to aspire to jobs that require a high level of education, responsibility and experience. Yes plenty of people on lower wages work hard too, but people can't be serious comparing someone who works in retail with a neurosurgeon for example (who ridiculously won't earn 100k plus for many years but still).

jupitermonket · 15/11/2023 07:11

bingbongbang23 · 15/11/2023 00:02

@jupitermonket ,rather harsh response :)

You will see a lot of people on this thread do see the point I am making and understand the frustration

Apologies @bingbongbang23 , I don’t mean to be unnecessarily harsh with you. But I do get frustrated when I hear very fortunate well off people complaining that they don’t get to use and benefit from the system that is really only meant to help those who absolutely need it.

You’re right, on paper there isn’t a parity between those who earn over £100k and those who earn much much less, or between households where the earnings are much higher on total, without either person breaking the £100k threshold individually. You’re right, on paper this isn’t “fair”.

but I think you need to realise that this is splitting hairs, and that neither you nor the households earning more than you but who are still able to claim are really the intended recipients of the vital help the free childcare system gives to those who really do need it.

so when you start to not only complain about that, but also try to make some wider point (using words usually used by very angry conservatives who resent the benefits system full stop, and equate earnings to talent and merit rather than a socio-political and education system that is rigged from birth and always has the same winners and losers in life) about you not being rewarded for working hard. Or punished because you work hard. Well, that’s hard for me to stay silent about.

I think you just need to have a little more humility about it, and a little more empathy for those for whom the childcare hours are a lifeline, and their ONLY opportunity to not only work and maintain some sort of work life, but in many cases their only ability to have children at all. Whether you want to reduce a few hours of your £100k a year job to be able to get “the same” is sort of neither here nor there.

In an ideal world everyone would universally have the same access to help, but since our benefits system is in dire straits, massively underfunded and being cut daily - mostly disadvantaging the poorest, the least physically able, the mentally unwell and the people who are unable to find decently paid stable work, then I think you calling for parity for those earning more than most of us will dream of, all To funded by extra taxes we all have to pay, is pretty tone deaf.

sorry.

WarningOfGails · 15/11/2023 07:06

It drives me mad that things like this aren’t assessed on household income, child benefit should be too.

I am not sure what I think though, is there a point where people should pay for their own childcare? I feel uncomfortable about the government supporting the wealthy in order for them to feather their nests a bit more while we have more families than ever living in temporary accommodation etc.

EveSix · 15/11/2023 06:55

The system is flawed in terms of the threshold for eligibility ‐that's annoying.
But I am astounded that any household where one partner earning 100k, even if the other earns nothing, would struggle, unless overextended on mortgage or other expenditure. Any family surely expects a few very lean years between the end of maternity leave and the start of school. 100k is still a really decent household income, whether shared between two earners or provided by a sole breadwinner.

RecycleMePlease · 15/11/2023 06:53

For those of us who like facts BTW (source HMRC), :

The 10% of income taxpayers with the largest incomes contribute over 60% of income tax receipts.

In the UK, the threshold for the top 10% of personal income before tax is £59,200

Median is about 30k, the 50th to 90th centiles pay 30% of total tax, and up to the 50th centile less than 10%

So actually half of people here really are barely contributing to OP's childcare anyway.

And before we tell people with children that that's their choice, take into account that single workers in the UK are taxed a little less than EU average, and those with children are taxed a fair whack more than EU average (source OECD)

In the United Kingdom, the average single worker faced a net average tax rate of 23.6% in 2022, compared with the OECD average of 24.6%

Taking into account child related benefits and tax provisions, the employee net average tax rate for an average married worker with two children in the United Kingdom was 18.8% in 2022, which is the 11th highest in the OECD, and compares with 14.1% for the OECD average.

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 15/11/2023 06:48

And it is not a sliding scale, I don't qualify for anything.

You get 15 free hours.

Pleaseletitbebedtime · 15/11/2023 06:47

Orangeteddy · 14/11/2023 22:54

I thought 15 hours free was universal for all 3 & 4 year olds?

For the other 15 hours to take you up to 30 free hours, depends how far over the threshold your pay is vs the cost of nursery? With losing the tax allowance too you may be better off dropping a day at work or paying more into your pension - only relevant though if you’re slightly over £100k

It is. I think it’s called 15 hours of education but it’s free.

RecycleMePlease · 15/11/2023 06:43

I bet, like child benefit, and so many other means tested benefits, that the amount it costs to do the means testing is the same or more than the amount they would spend to just give it to everyone.

The cost/benefit analysis of means testing is rarely justifiable (unless you want popular votes or to create entire departments to do it)

TheCurtainQueen · 15/11/2023 06:24

I agree OP. The system is ridiculous. My best friend and her partner earn a combined £140k (£70k each) and get the 30 free hours. My husband and I earn a combined £135k (£100k and £35k) and only get 15 free hours. It’s baffling that it is not calculated on household income.

Have a look at tax free childcare instead.

pinkfondu · 15/11/2023 05:03

And arent you in such a fortunate position be able to have such choices. For some those hours is the difference between being able to keep a roof over their heads or work at all.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 15/11/2023 04:57

UsingChangeofName · 14/11/2023 23:00

Why do you think every tax payer should subsidise your childcare, when you are such high earners ? Confused That would make no sense to me.

Because they are probably paying a large amount of tax and should be able to get something in return during those tougher years

mimi0708 · 15/11/2023 01:53

bingbongbang23 · 14/11/2023 23:14

It is done on individual salary and not on household income. So you could have couple each earning £80k and qualify; then have a couple where one doesn't work and the other earns £101k and they don't qualify. That for me is madness

We encourage people to work, and yet it would be more lucrative for me to drop a day and take the 30hrs vs work full time as I do today

There is something flawed in this...

And yes, I can divert money to pension and/or offset bonus to stock options. But it's the principle of system that I don't agree with

Yup completely agree with you OP that it is madness that it is based on individual salary and not household income! We had the same thing and people who are earning more than us as a household qualified because their individual salaries are below the threshold!

Confusion101 · 15/11/2023 01:51

OP I'd love to see your calculations. How much money would it actually save you to reduce your working week by 1 day to receive this payment?

whosaidtha · 15/11/2023 01:41

I think you are wrong about it being beneficial going part time. 15 hours where I live is about £90 but let's be generous and say it's £135. If your wage is over 100k you definitely earn more than £135 a day so you wouldn't be better off. And remember that its term time only so even less than you think.

DonnaBanana · 15/11/2023 00:56

Reduce your hours. You’re paying 60% tax between 100-125k now so it’s hardly worth it. Might as well have the time and keep the full 30 hours

PestilencialCrisis · 15/11/2023 00:29

bingbongbang23 · 14/11/2023 23:14

It is done on individual salary and not on household income. So you could have couple each earning £80k and qualify; then have a couple where one doesn't work and the other earns £101k and they don't qualify. That for me is madness

We encourage people to work, and yet it would be more lucrative for me to drop a day and take the 30hrs vs work full time as I do today

There is something flawed in this...

And yes, I can divert money to pension and/or offset bonus to stock options. But it's the principle of system that I don't agree with

Read the room

Swipe left for the next trending thread