Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

30 hours free childcare- means tested?!

236 replies

bingbongbang23 · 14/11/2023 22:47

Sure I will get blasted, but I only just realised that the 30hr free childcare is means tested. I have paid full price for my child for past 2 years- at a whopping £1240 a month, but it is what it is.

Selfishly, i was so looking forward to her turning 3 and getting the free hours. Would be a massive help with mortgage going up. However I don't qualify. And it is not a sliding scale, I don't qualify for anything. So I would actually be better off reducing hours so I would qualify for the free hours- in what world should that be the case?! Makes no sense to me!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
wokbun · 15/11/2023 09:22

DinoDaddy · 15/11/2023 09:19

Actually no, we have private health care so we don't benefit from the NHS. I had a private midwife so they didn't even benefit from it then. I wouldn't send my children to state school as, sadly, they are shit. Same reason we don't use the NHS. I am happy to pay extra to get the level of education and health care I feel we deserve. I feel everyone deserves it tbf, just sadly not everyone has the means to provide it for their family.

Your choice then. You are able to use the NHS and the "shit" schools that you help fund if you really want to get what you pay for.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 15/11/2023 09:21

DinoDaddy · 15/11/2023 09:15

We both earn over 100k so we didn't get this either. Takes the piss a bit as we pay so much tax and then our children can't even benefit from any perks we pay towards. But, we have 4 in private school now, nursery fees are a drop in the ocean compared to that.

Send them to state then if you want to benefit. Mind you if you can afford four lots of fees you can suck up missing out the funded hours.

jupitermonket · 15/11/2023 09:21

Peablockfeathers · 15/11/2023 09:15

Well yes the shitty system we have, that's the point, people leave for a better one. Reality is people work for money, if you'd martyr yourself and happily lose out on tens of thousands of pounds just because then that's up to you, I don't judge those that find it unfair because I can empathise upwards as well as downwards.I think some people assume everyone in that tax bracket grew up with a silver spoon shrouded in generational wealth when it's no longer the case. And the point is people do already pay their share by paying a huge % of tax!

I don’t assume that at all. And neither do I martyr myself. It’s not a big personal sacrifice to earn a bit less to support a generally beneficial system.

How much money is enough?

I would like quite a bit more money to buy nice things, go to nice places. That would be lovely. But I don’t have it so I don’t sweat it. And if I earned more and got taxed more I wouldn’t sweat that either. I’d think how nice it was that I was still earning more!

I like the country in which I live, and it’s broader aims and values, more than I like money I guess.

DinoDaddy · 15/11/2023 09:19

Actually no, we have private health care so we don't benefit from the NHS. I had a private midwife so they didn't even benefit from it then. I wouldn't send my children to state school as, sadly, they are shit. Same reason we don't use the NHS. I am happy to pay extra to get the level of education and health care I feel we deserve. I feel everyone deserves it tbf, just sadly not everyone has the means to provide it for their family.

wokbun · 15/11/2023 09:19

Peablockfeathers · 15/11/2023 09:16

Indeed but high earners are also women and mums, it encourages them to drop hours or turn down promotions whilst their children are young as who wants to work harder for less money?

The government doesn't care about those women as they've already "made it".

kirbykirby · 15/11/2023 09:19

Anyone earning £100k is paying over £30k in tax so already heavily subsidising a system they don't benefit from.

You don't owe strangers your money or time OP, and if the system is unfair people will opt out by working less.

Peablockfeathers · 15/11/2023 09:16

wokbun · 15/11/2023 09:14

Everyone gets the 15 the extra 15 is to encourage those who would otherwise work part time to start to up their hours or even to look for work so that they don't fall further behind in their careers as a result of having to do more of the childcare. Lets be real this is usually mum. So it's a good way to help close the gender pay gap.

Indeed but high earners are also women and mums, it encourages them to drop hours or turn down promotions whilst their children are young as who wants to work harder for less money?

wokbun · 15/11/2023 09:16

DinoDaddy · 15/11/2023 09:15

We both earn over 100k so we didn't get this either. Takes the piss a bit as we pay so much tax and then our children can't even benefit from any perks we pay towards. But, we have 4 in private school now, nursery fees are a drop in the ocean compared to that.

Do they not benefit from the NHS? You could send them to a non-private school if you really cared about getting your money's worth.

Peablockfeathers · 15/11/2023 09:15

jupitermonket · 15/11/2023 09:07

If I had that much to tax in the first place then yes, I would. That’s the system I’m part of and it’s the system that I believe at least pays lip service to the aim of a better society for everyone. So I’m happy to pay my share.

I’m also happy not to be “clever”. Just stupid old me, dumb enough to only count my blessings, not my money. What an idiot I am. So stupid. Ho hum.

Edited

Well yes the shitty system we have, that's the point, people leave for a better one. Reality is people work for money, if you'd martyr yourself and happily lose out on tens of thousands of pounds just because then that's up to you, I don't judge those that find it unfair because I can empathise upwards as well as downwards.I think some people assume everyone in that tax bracket grew up with a silver spoon shrouded in generational wealth when it's no longer the case. And the point is people do already pay their share by paying a huge % of tax!

DinoDaddy · 15/11/2023 09:15

We both earn over 100k so we didn't get this either. Takes the piss a bit as we pay so much tax and then our children can't even benefit from any perks we pay towards. But, we have 4 in private school now, nursery fees are a drop in the ocean compared to that.

wokbun · 15/11/2023 09:14

Everyone gets the 15 the extra 15 is to encourage those who would otherwise work part time to start to up their hours or even to look for work so that they don't fall further behind in their careers as a result of having to do more of the childcare. Lets be real this is usually mum. So it's a good way to help close the gender pay gap.

jupitermonket · 15/11/2023 09:12

TheSeasonalNameChange · 15/11/2023 00:13

@NorthernLights5 in this case they are the same thing though. Having more disposable income working for £80k for 4 days than £100k for 5 is literally being penalised for working harder.

How is that a penalty in anyone’s head? That sounds like a dream scenario!! I’d kill for a “problem” like that.

Why we’re all obsessed with working a “full” working week of five days, if we can live comfortably on less money but fewer days is a mystery to me. It doesn’t mean you work “harder” to work five days, or to earn a huge amount of money.

Perhaps if more people worked fewer hours overall there would actually be more work and more money to go around - job shares being a very successful example.

jupitermonket · 15/11/2023 09:07

Peablockfeathers · 15/11/2023 08:41

So you'd happily effectively be 30k worse off just by crossing an arbitrary threshold? Sure. I think tax scales are fair, but schemes like this aren't. We are a low wage economy with less prospects, people seeking a better life elsewhere where yes they pay tax but aren't penalised for earing a decent wage are the clever ones.

If I had that much to tax in the first place then yes, I would. That’s the system I’m part of and it’s the system that I believe at least pays lip service to the aim of a better society for everyone. So I’m happy to pay my share.

I’m also happy not to be “clever”. Just stupid old me, dumb enough to only count my blessings, not my money. What an idiot I am. So stupid. Ho hum.

BlueEyesGotMeLike · 15/11/2023 09:01

ToDamp0rNotToDamp

Its not whining to discuss it and want the system to be fair. If it’s not discussed, it’ll never change.

My kids are way past the age of needing childcare so it’s of no benefit to me and I was a SAHM who didn’t use childcare when they were young anyway. I still want it to be fair for others and for it to make sense. My partner earns over the £60k child benefit cut off and my youngest isn’t too far away from being an adult, but again, I still want it to be fair.

ToDamp0rNotToDamp · 15/11/2023 08:53

I’m a high earner, my husband is a ‘low’ earner. We don’t qualify for any help.

My sister and her husband both earn £80-90k EACH and are eligible for tax free childcare and free hours as individually both under £100k. On paper our total household incomes are similar, but their net take home is materially higher due to my tax.

Does this wind me up and seem unfair? Yes, sometimes but I don’t dwell on it.
Does it mean I should get some sort of child benefit or childcare allowance? OBVIOUSLY NOT!!!

It means they shouldn’t get any and the system needs changing to look at the combined household. But even that would have its own issues and be expensive to implement. So here we are. The one thing I can say for certain is, I have never felt the need to publically complain about this or expect the worlds smallest violin to play for me as I wipe away my tears with the +£100k that I earn. Christ.

As a side note (and I know this won’t be true for all high earners) - I’m a high earner because I work in private industry. With this comes a wealth of benefits: free private healthcare for my entire family, access to a 24hr private GP, generous leave to be used for dependents care (on top of usual annual leave), emergency childcare for 10 days a year, 10% discount on certain nursery chains, the list goes on. This isn’t intended to be a brag, but just to show that ultimately I, and others in my position, should not be whining.

Peablockfeathers · 15/11/2023 08:41

jupitermonket · 15/11/2023 08:14

Only the most selfish, thoughtless, “I’m alright Jack” people would leave the country of their birth just because they are asked to pay back some of the good fortune they have gained by living and working in it.

Only the most miserly, skinflinty, life-hardened Scrooges would complain bitterly about giving a few more of their precious gold tokens (proportionately much LESS overall than lower earners, by the way) to help those who earn only pennies wiping the arses, unclogging the veins, and cleaning the detritus from the gutters for all of us.

Only life’s coldest, meanest, grabbiest people would begrudge a system, imperfect though it is, that aims to elevate everyone to a quality of life that feels just about liveable and fulfilling.

Only those who believe their own hype, and inflate their own talents, believe that they are only where they are today because of those talents, and not because of a complex web of age-old socio-political and economic circumstances which gave them a head start before they were even born.

It you’d like to align yourself with that camp of people, go right ahead. But we see you.

Edited

So you'd happily effectively be 30k worse off just by crossing an arbitrary threshold? Sure. I think tax scales are fair, but schemes like this aren't. We are a low wage economy with less prospects, people seeking a better life elsewhere where yes they pay tax but aren't penalised for earing a decent wage are the clever ones.

daffodilandtulip · 15/11/2023 08:39

Absolutely agree, and if we were staying in private nursery it would be a different story. I want to put her to the school nursery. She would then share the wrap around care that I already have in place for her sister- and so she would effectively go to having nil childcare costs (as I already pay for her sisters).

You may well find that you have fees to pay to the school nursery, if you aren't entitled to funding.

BlueEyesGotMeLike · 15/11/2023 08:36

Read the room

The ‘room’ is mumsnet where there are people on various salaries. Should only people up to a certain income be able to post? 🙄

OP points out the obvious flaw in the system and is right to. The fact that 2 people can earn more than one person but get this benefit is wrong. Just like the flaw in the child benefit model too.

kirbykirby · 15/11/2023 08:33

I would reduce my hours. You'll have more money and more time for yourself- no brainer. You need to do what's best for your family.

LTBarbara · 15/11/2023 08:25

QueenOfWeeds · 14/11/2023 23:01

I agree that this is not the place for you to find a sympathetic audience. What I find ridiculous is that it is tested per adult, not per household. DH just edges over the threshold so, despite my poorly paid, public service job, we don’t qualify. Fine. But we have friends where both people in the couple earn just below the threshold so, despite their household income being £50-80K higher than ours, they are able to claim free hours. It absolutely should be there for people who need it, but in some of the households we know, they definitely don’t need it - it just enables them to have a slightly easier lifestyle. The government should fund childcare properly, and this in turn should encourage, facilitate, and support people returning to work.

Yes, same for two earners with each on 99K. That’s a massive loophole obviously.

They should also be paying for childcare.

jupitermonket · 15/11/2023 08:14

Peablockfeathers · 15/11/2023 07:23

Also what a lot of people are not appreciating is that the money you get back for childcare is an absolute drop in the ocean of the amount of tax you will contribute to the country as a higher earner. Why shouldn’t you have some of the benefits of this?! Is the solution to tax you less?

Yes more tax for less access to services sounds like a great deal, ita a real mystery why so many young people with great aspirations decide to leave this country. I'm sure we will all bask in the skill shortages nicely in the decades to come, can't wait.

Only the most selfish, thoughtless, “I’m alright Jack” people would leave the country of their birth just because they are asked to pay back some of the good fortune they have gained by living and working in it.

Only the most miserly, skinflinty, life-hardened Scrooges would complain bitterly about giving a few more of their precious gold tokens (proportionately much LESS overall than lower earners, by the way) to help those who earn only pennies wiping the arses, unclogging the veins, and cleaning the detritus from the gutters for all of us.

Only life’s coldest, meanest, grabbiest people would begrudge a system, imperfect though it is, that aims to elevate everyone to a quality of life that feels just about liveable and fulfilling.

Only those who believe their own hype, and inflate their own talents, believe that they are only where they are today because of those talents, and not because of a complex web of age-old socio-political and economic circumstances which gave them a head start before they were even born.

It you’d like to align yourself with that camp of people, go right ahead. But we see you.

CherryBlossoms88 · 15/11/2023 08:10

I think you’ve forgotten that you can get 15hrs free that is not means tested!

SeatonCarew · 15/11/2023 08:02

Note to all earning between £100,000 and £125,140 pa.

For those whose incomes fall within this bracket,* *in my opinion it's crazy not to put all earnings over £100,000 into a pension, due to the loss of your personal tax allowance in this bracket at a rate of £1 loss for every £2 earned. This means you are effectively taxed and pay NI at a marginal rate of 62% in the pound on this income. If you put this chunk of income into your pension, you are effectively only paying 38p for every pound of contribution, and you can retain your free childcare hours as you are keeping your relevant income under £100,000.

More information here:

https://taxscouts.com/high-earner-tax-returns/what-are-the-tax-implications-of-earning-over-100k/

What are the tax implications of earning over £100K? – TaxScouts

One of the major tax implications of earning over £100k is that you can get taxed 60%. Learn more about the implications to stay as tax-efficient as possible.

https://taxscouts.com/high-earner-tax-returns/what-are-the-tax-implications-of-earning-over-100k/

diefledermaus · 15/11/2023 08:00

What I think is ridiculous is two parents can earn 99k each and qualify.
But a single parent making 100k doesn't qualify. It should be by household income, not individual.

TheCave · 15/11/2023 07:59

Agree with other posters who say that it only makes sense to drop hours if you earn slightly above £100k. Do the maths on your actual salary OP and you can work out if it makes sense for you or not. I tried but it didn't make sense for me. You still get 15 hours (which personally I don't think makes sense for people earning over £100k, so I think high earners should be very grateful for it). If your child is going to school nursery, they may allow you to pay the extra to get a full time place - our school nursery does and they charge £60/week for it, which is pretty reasonable frankly (especially when on over £100k and if you are using to monthly costs of £1200 for nursery).